1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 5th January 1881 (cont.).
Mr. Spence recalled.
4,775. (Mr. Wright.) You mentioned an occasion when I found gas in the return about 60 yards from the furnace? — Yes.
4,776. Did you put the furnace out when you found that? — No.
4,777. Would not it have been a proper thing to do? — I did not think it was necessary.
4,778. Supposing the same mixture of gas and air that you found 60 yards off had gone through the furnace, would not there have been some danger of an explosion? — No; I think not.
4,779. You think it would have been quite safe? — The furnace was damped at the time.
4,780. (Mr. Bell.) How long had the furnace been damped? — Three hours.
4,781. Does she always go out after being damped three hours? — No.
4,782. Do the strata work very much in this mine? — In some parts they do — in the Maudlin.
4,783. (The Coroner.) It is a mere upheaval of the bottom, is it?
4,784. (Mr. Wright.) Is there much creep? Why I ask the question is, that it has been sometimes suggested, where you get a large goaf like this, if the strata work at all over it, they may force it down unevenly, and squeeze out gas from the interstices in the goaf into the working. Is there enough movement in the strata here to produce much effect in that way? — If the goaf has been standing long enough it will come together.
4,784a. I mean to distinguish the steady pressure of the land weight, which, of course, would be always forcing out a little gas here and there, from the sudden movement of the strata over it, which somewhat suddenly forces out an exceptionally large quantity of gas from the goaf. In your judgment, likely to happen in these goafs? — I do not think so.
4,785. Have you accounted for the gas working out of the goaf behind the No. 3 Hutton down the dip into the working? — It never does come unless the barometer falls.
4,786. That is your observation — that when the barometer falls gas will come down the dip into the working? — Yes.
4,787. But not at other times? — No.
4,788. Had you observed the barometer just before the explosion? — Yes, it had been working pretty steadily.
Mr. Hales Harrison sworn.
4,789. (Mr. A. Jones.) Are you a stoneman? — Yes.
4,790. You reside at Hall Street, Seaham Colliery? — Yes.
4,791. Have you been employed for 36 years at Seaham Colliery? — Yes, it is 36 years since I first came to it.
4,792. I believe, with the exception of about six years' interval, you have worked there ever since? — Yes.
4,793. And for about seven years you have been now working consecutively at the colliery? — Yes.
4,794. On the morning of the 11th September did you go into the colliery? — Yes.
4,795. At what time? — About 11 o'clock.
4,796. What did you go down for? — I came home then.
4,797. You did not go down? — No.
4,798. When did you go down again? — I had to go down at 5 o'clock in the morning.
4,799. After the explosion? — Yes.
4,800. What part of the colliery did you go to; did you get down? — No, I was getting ready to go to work when it happened.
4,801. When did you first go down after the explosion? — It would be about a week, I think, afterwards. I was a week out of the pit.
4,802. Generally speaking, what conclusion do you draw as to the spot where the explosion took place? In what part of the colliery do you believe the explosion occurred? — If I had to give my opinion, I would give my opinion for No. 1 fire-hole.
4,803. Where is that? — In No. 1 Hutton seam.
4,804. Where are the fire holes? (The position was pointed out on the plan.)
(Mr. Wright.) Just turn to the curve at No. 1 engine.
4,805. (Mr. Jones.) What leads you to come to the conclusion? — The force of the explosion was as heavy there as anywhere.
4,806. Did you see any indications of the way in which the things were blown, whether blown in-bye or out-bye? — All was blown in-bye that I have seen, going in-bye to No. 1 shaft.
4,807. Going in-bye to No. 1 pit? — On the Maudlin side of No. 1 shaft the timber is blown towards No. 1 shaft.
4,808. How was it in No. 1 Hutton? — Going into No. 1 Hutton, where I have been working, it is blown in-bye.
4,809. From what point is it blown in-bye from the shaft; as you start from the shaft, did you find everything blown in-bye in No. 1? — Yes.
4,810. In the Maudlin, how do you find it? — I was not much there; I did not notice how it was blown there.
4,811. Do you know whether there is much coal dust in the mine? — Yes: there are places where there is coal dust.
4,812. You find it in the travelling ways? — On the engine plane and things. The dust must fly, and it must get somewhere.
4,813. Do you remember, about 20 years ago, anything happening to the coal dust? — Yes, I was working at the time at the bottom of No. 1 shaft.
4,814. In what seam? — In the No. 1 seam.
4,815. No. 1 Hutton? — Yes; I took the torch in my hand to make the torch burn, and a snuff flew from the torch and got into the coal dust; it set fire to the coal dust, and we had to go and get water to put it out.
4,816. How far did this fire extend? — It may be two or three yards.
4,817. Did it extend rapidly, flame along? — It just burned like sawdust.
4,818. When it first fired, did it fire suddenly, blaze out?
4,819. (The Coroner.) Did it spread anything like a sprinkling of gunpowder? — No, it did not give any flash that I saw.
(Mr. Wright.) But you would not expect it to light in a heap on the ground?
4,820. (Mr. Jones.) Of course not. (To witness.) How long did it burn? — It might burn three-quarters of an hour or an hour before it was put out.
4,821. Do you remember, in 1871, anything happening to the dust — the man named Peart? — Yes.
4,822. What was that? — It was just after last explosion ; he was shooting stone up against where Brown lost his life. That was in No. 3 Hutton. He was shooting stone there, and he put a heavy charge in, and set the dust on fire all about the timber, and caused a lot of bother.
4,823. How far did the fire extend on that occasion? — When I went there were three or four baulks, and the baulks may be six feet apart, and the coal dust was burning on the top of them all. I had to send two into the shaft to get a tub of water to put it out.
4,824. Was the fire going along the timber? — Along the top of the baulks.
4,825. And it was burning freely? — Yes.
4,826. Did he tell you how it caught fire? — No, he did not tell me.
4,827. Did you hear how it caught fire? — It was from his shot that set it on fire.
4,828. And they sent for you? — Yes.
4,829. What for? — I was master stoneman.
4,830. Well now, those two occasions you have known the coal dust catch fire ; once you say through a shot, and the other time while you were using a torch? — Yes.
4,831. Is the coal dust every day in this colliery? — In places.
4,832. When the tubs are travelling I suppose it flies? — Yes.
4,833. I have heard that measures are taken to remove it as it accumulates; do you know how often the coal dust is sent to bank? — No.
4,834. It is sent to bank, you know, as a matter of fact? — Yes, occasionally. Oh yes, they keep clearing it out, and wheeling it away at the week's end.
4,835. Have you ever known coal dust put away in the refuge holes? — Not that I can recollect.
4,836. Would it be thrown into the worked out places sometimes? — There would be muck holes made, and they put it in there when they clean it out, and carry it away when they have a chance.
4,837. The dust will light, of course, upon the floor of the mine; where else do you find it lodged, on the baulks? — Yes.
4,838. And along the props, I suppose? — Yes, about the props and all.
4,839. I suppose in some parts of the mine it will be thicker than others? — Oh, yes.
4,840. I mean, in some of the travelling way it is thicker than in some of the travelling ways? — Oh, yes.
4,841. Is the mine of uniform dryness? — Is it a dry mine all through? — There are places where it is rather dampish.
4,842. Take No. 3 Hutton, is that very dry? — No. 3 is dry in the Hutton.
4,843. Is No. 1 Hutton dry? — Yes, in one part — up east way. I believe there is some damp, but I do not know much about that.
4,844. Have you ever known them water the coal dust to keep it laid? — I have seen water on the travelling ways in No. 1.
4,845. That has been to lay the coal dust, I suppose? I never went into No. 1 until just lately.
4,846. You have never seen them water the coal dust in the travelling ways of No. 3? — I have seen them water on the banks.
4,847. (Mr. Edge.) Did you notice which way the doors leading into the fire-holes were blown? — No.
4,848. Did you notice that the doors were blown in towards the pillars? — I was not in at it.
4,849. The only reason why you suggest the neighbourhood of the fire-holes as the origin of the explosion is that there was a great deal of damage done in the neighbourhood? — Yes.
4,850. (Mr. Wright.) Have you been asked about the explosion of 1871, the misfortune that happened ten years ago, in 1871. Do you remember that explosion? — Yes.
4,851. Was it ever found out what caused it? — No.
4,852. Where the gas came from? — There were different opinions; it did get the blame for having happened at the top of No. 2 bank.
4,853. What is the top of No. 2 bank? — It was in No. 5 Hutton: it was supposed it happened there.
4,854. That is a part that is worked out; it is all in the goaf now? — Yes.
4,855. Did the coal dust on the second time that you speak of make anything of an explosion? — I never saw any.
4,856. No flash? — I saw the fire, but I have not seen any explosion that I can recollect.
Adjourned until to-morrow at half-past ten o'clock.