Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 5th January 1881 (cont.).

Mr. William Crozier sworn.

4,083. (The Coroner.) What are you, Crozier? — A miner.

4,084. A miner of what class; hewer, stoneman, or what? — Coal hewer.

4,085. Were you in the pit at the time of the explosion? — No.

4,086. What district do you work in — which seam? — In No. 2.

4,087. In No. 2 seam? — Yes.

4,088. In what portion there? — "The East Way" or "The Second North." It goes by those names.

4,089. (Mr. A. Jones.) You have examined the mine, have not you? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) When?

(Mr. A. Jones.) I am coming to that, sir. I ask him generally if he has inspected it.

4,090. You have inspected the men? — Yes.

4,091. You have worked at Seaham for four years at the colliery? — Nearly five.

4,092. And you have worked at No. 2 pit for the past nine months? — Yes.

4,093. How long have you inspected for the men? — It is about six months ago since I inspected. We have inspected again just a short time since.

4,094. Since the explosion? — Yes.

4,095. When would that be, before the explosion — what month would that be in? — Before the explosion.

4,096. When before it? — In July.

4,097. What part of the colliery did you examine? — Well, I examined the No. 3 Hutton seam.

4,098. And any other part? — Yes; the main coal.

4,099. Any other part? — The No. 1 Hutton, the 3rd east way.

4,100. Did you examine the No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

4,101. Any other part? — The Maudlin seam.

4,102. Anywhere else? — No; not before the accident.

4,103. Now, I will just take you, in the first place, if you please, to No. 3 Hutton — in July, when you examined it — do you remember the date? — Yes.

4,104. You have entries in your book — what is the first? — July 1st.

(The Coroner.) Let us have the entry then; that will be the shortest way.

4,105. (Mr. A. Jones.) Will you turn to your entries in relation to No. 3 Hutton, and tell us what you found as far as your entries go? — Well, sir, we commenced at the furnace and we went up the return — that is, the south side return, up to what they call the west point up to the top of the bank — and we examined the working places and the air-ways at the top of the bank, and came down by the south return to the furnace in the No. 3 Hutton seam. We found it all right there.

4,106. You found it all right there? — Yes.

4,107. Did you find any gas? — No.

4,108. Nowhere? — Not in that seam.

4,109. I am speaking of that. I want to confine your attention to that seam, if you please. You found no gas at all in that seam? — Not in that part.

4,110. (Mr. R. Wright.) That would be No. 3 west, would not it? — Yes.

4,111. (Mr. A. Jones.) Then your report was an absence of gas? — Yes.

4,112. No gas to be found anywhere in there? — Yes.

4,113. How did you find the ventilation? — It was very good.

(Mr. Edge.) No gas; ventilation good — that is No. 3. Then are you going to the main coal next?

(Mr. A. Jones.) I will take the Maudlin, if you please.

4,114. On what date did you go over the Maudlin? — On the 6th of July.

4,115. Did you go all over the Maudlin? — Yes; on the 6th July.

4,116. The in-takes and the working places? — On the 6th of July I examined all the returns.

4,117. Did you find any gas? — There was a small quantity in a new return. That was in course of preparation.

4,118. Where would that be — in what part of the Maudlin? — It was in the east way, I think, as far as I can recollect.

4,119. Would that be near the goaf? — No.

4,120. Can you state on the plan where it was you found the gas? — I could not tell exactly the spot where it was. It is a new return they are making to be ready by — the other ones —

4,121. Can you at all say near where it was?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) This is not the part that is sealed up.

4,122. (Mr. Bell.) Tell us somewhere near the part, and I will find it for you? — I could not tell the exact spot.

4,123. Was it on the long wall side? — I would not like to say — not exactly.

4,124. Was it on the right hand side as you went down the east way? — No; it was on the left side as we were coming out.

4,125. As you left by? — As we were coming out.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Was that coming out by the in-take?

(Mr. Bell.) By the return, he says.

(The Witness.) We went in by the right side return, and came out by the left.

4,126. (Mr. A. Jones.) You came out by the left side return? — Yes.

4,127. Then it would be this one (pointing). It is the side north-east? — Yes.

4,128. On towards the goaf? — Yes.

4,129. (Mr. Bell.) And was by that piece of goaf — how far were you from the goaf? — Well, we were a long way from the goaf.

4,130. (Mr. A. Jones.) Which way — more in-bye than the goaf? — Out-bye.

4,131. Would it be near where the crossings are, or the north way return? — I would not exactly like to say whether it was near the crossings or not.

4,132. I am afraid I cannot carry it further with you. You know it was a good way in by the east way of the Maudlin? — Yes.

4,133. And it was where they were making a fresh return? — Yes.

4,134. How was the gas coming up — in what form? — It was in the top.

4,135. In the roof? — Yes ; but of course the master wasteman ordered them to put a canvas further up towards the top.

Never mind what he did ; I will come to that directly,

(The Coroner.) We may as well take it now.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Very well, just say — ordered what?

(The Coroner.) Ordered bratticing?

(The Witness.) Ordered canvass to be put near the top to clear it away.

4,136. (Mr. A. Jones.) Was it coming in in the form of a blower, or was it a small leakage? — It would be a small leakage from the top. The stone was falling.

4,137. Was there any noise with it? — No.

4,138. Was there any water coming off with it? — No; at least, I saw none.

4,139. What is the roof made of? — It is a sort of blue stone — slatey.

4,140. On any other occasion have you found gas in the Maudlin? — No; not in the Maudlin seam.

4,141. How did you find the ventilation in the Maudlin? — Well, sir, it was pretty fair.

4,142. When you say pretty fair, do you mean it was as good as you found in No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

4,143. As a rule, going as far in-bye as you can in the returns, which seam do you find the ventilation the best in? — I would scarcely like to say, but if I had to give an opinion, I would say the No. 2.

4,144. You found the ventilation better in No. 2 than you do in any other seam? — Yes.

4,145. That is the Harvey No. 2, is not it? — Yes.

4,146. I will take you now to No. 1 Hutton seam, it being more convenient, being on the plan, that we should take those on the plan first. Take the No. 1 Hutton — when did you go into that last, before the explosion, I mean? — On the 9th of July.

4,147. What did you find then? — We went in the north way and up into the first west flat. The first place we went into was James Wonder's place, but, of course, it was laid off through gas.

4,148. What part of the No. 1 Hutton would that be? — Up the incline to the left.

4,149. Would that be near the big goaf — not the biggest goaf — is that near the Polka goaf? — No; it was nearest to the north side return.

4,150. Was it far east in No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

4,151. Far east? — Yes; right down east, and then went into the north side and up to the west, and then came back over to the left side to the south side again.

4,152. Perhaps I had better put it this way — how far would it be in-bye from the shaft? — I think it would be about a mile and a half, as near as could be.

4,153. It would be about a mile and a half in-bye? — Yes; as near as I could guess.

4,154. In what quantities was gas coming off? — It was like a roll that had come down from the roof.

4,155. Do you mean a blower? — No; a fall of stone that had come down from the roof; like as if a gullet had gone up.

4,156. Do you know whether the gas had brought out the stone, or whether it had been a blower which had brought out the stone? — It was a roll that had fallen out with it; a roll of stone that had fallen out.

4,157. (The Coroner.) I suppose it is a gullet behind a fall of stones? — No, the stones were cleared away.

4,158. (Mr. A. Jones.) Do you know whether it was the gas that brought out the stones, or was it a fall independent of the gas. You do not know, I suppose? — No, I would not like to say.

4,159. In what quantities did the gas come off? — When we went in there was a canvas drawn across the place. Of course the foreman, George Care, asked me to try it, and I told him to try it and to put his lamp up, and it immediately put it out.

4,160. It put it out? — Yes, it put his lamp out.

4,161. Put it out at once? — Yes.

4,162. What lamp did he use? — The Clanny.

4,163. Did it make a great noise? — No, not a great noise; just an ordinary noise.

4,164. Can you give us an idea. Would it make a noise like steam blowing off from an engine; as much as that? — Just like a puff. Just the way it generally is whenever they try gas.

4,165. You know what a blower is, do not you? — Yes.

4,166. Would you call this a blower? — No.

4,167. You would not call it a blower? — No. Of course I say a blower some had in another place.

4,168. I will come to that. Means were taken to carry it off, where was the gas taken to? — The gas was taken into the return.

4,169. Was this in a working place where you found the gas? — Yes, it was taken into the air-way, and from the air-way into the return — the north side return.

4,170. It was taken straight into the returns? — Yes, of course there were two men working behind, and they were preparing the air-ways behind the canvas.

4,171. In the same day in the same seam in No. 1 Hutton, did you find any gas coming off from the blower? — Yes.

4,172. Where? — In Cleghorn's place, the second west flat, a flat that goes by the name of Belcher's flat.

4,173. Whereabouts is that? — The second west flat.

4,174. That would be north of where you saw the gas coming off — north of that? — Yes.

4,175. How far away? — Well, I would not like to exactly say, but as nigh as I can guess it would be about 200 yards, or rather more.

(The Coroner.) From what point?

4,176. (Mr. A. Jones.) From where the gas was coming off before. (To witness.) That was a blower you say? — Yes.

4,177. Was any water, or soil, or stone coming off with the blower? — No, it was coming out with the coal.

4,178. Was it the big blower? — Yes.

4,179. Did it make a great noise? — Yes.

4,180. Did it make a noise as loud as a steam engine? — No.

4,181. Have you ever heard a blower in the No. 1 which did make a noise as loud as a steam engine? — No.

4,182. You never have? — No.

4,183. Could you hear it some distance off? — We could hear it a few yards off, perhaps four or five.

4,184. Was there a large quantity of gas coming off? — There was a good quantity of gas coming.

4,185. How far was that from the nearest in-takes, should you say? — Of course you know the air was regulated round that way.

4,186. But this was in a return where it was coming off? — In a working place.

4,187. But next to a return? — There was a brattice up the place, and the air went in one side of the brattice and came out the other; of course one was the in-take and the other the return for that place.

4,198. Then how far would it be from the in-take? — From the main in-take do you mean?

4,189. Yes? — It was about 150 yards perhaps from the west side, the first west flat, and the air went round that way from the first west.

4,190. Had you heard of any other blowers in No. 1 Hutton? — Well, the same day Thomas Burt examined straight down east along with me, and he told me he found gas.

4,191. (The Coroner.) You did not see the place? — No.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Of course taking this strictly as evidence, I submit what he heard is not evidence; but generally the course that has been pursued by us hitherto is to gain as much information as we possibly could without having the strictest evidence.

(The Coroner.) Yes, but we try to keep hearsay as much out of it as possible.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Mr. Wright's question, of which he gave me intimation this morning, that he proposed to ask all my witnesses, was a question entirely based upon hearsay.

(The Coroner.) No, no, decidedly not ; — "have you heard any complaint of the ventilation?" — that is quite a fair question.

(Mr. A. Jones.) That is equally a matter of hearsay with the question I am now putting — "Have you heard any mention made of gas?" — he is now giving a certain definite statement as to what he has heard.

(The Coroner.) You can go on; you will spend more time in discussing the question.

4,192. (Mr. A. Jones.) I think we ought to put this question. You say you heard of gas being found by two other men; who were they? — I mentioned one man. Of course I heard after that by other men.

4,193. Who was the man? — It was Thomas Burt that was examining the east way.

(The Coroner.) Is he still here?

4,194. (Mr. A. Jones.) Burt is going to be called, then I need not pursue this. Now I will take you to the main coal. When did you examine the main coal? — On the 2nd July.

4,195. Did you find any gas? — No.

4,196. You found no gas? — No.

4,197. Now, speaking generally of the pit and the whole colliery, how have you found the ventilation? Going as far as possible in-bye in the working places, have you found it sluggish in some parts? — In the whole places it has generally been good, but I have found it bad betimes in the broken places in the juds.

4,198. When you say "bad" you mean the air came in sluggishly? — I mean it was rather hot, warm to work in.

4,199. Do you specify any particular parts of the colliery in which you found it more so than in others, any particular seam? — Mostly in the far off way in the juds.

4,200. (The Coroner.) What seam? — No. 1 seam; generally when the juds were about taken off.

4,201. (Mr. A. Jones.) Did they work long wall in that part at all? — No.

4,202. It was all pillar and stall? — Yes.

4,203. Now, with regard to gas, have you found frequently or heard frequently of gas being found in the colliery — I am not speaking of any particular seam, but generally speaking of the colliery? — Well, not very frequently in the juds, but I remember about four years ago down this dilly way there was one of the men that had charge; he examined the gas in one of the twins, and be found the gas upon one of the twins coming down the dilly way.

4,204. Going down the dilly way; that was far east? — No, that was in the far-off way.

4,205. You are speaking of No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

4,206. Would that be near the big goaf? — Yes, it was taking the pillars off up the edge of the goaf.

4,207. When would that be — about four years ago? — Yes.

4,208. Was there much gas then? — It was just a small quantity.

4,209. (The Coroner.) Was it on one occasion or more than one? — Just on one occasion.

4,210. (Mr. Jones.) You have large experience of this colliery? — Yes, I have.

4,211. Five years experience of it? — Yes.

4,212. Speaking about it, do you think it is a colliery which contains a good deal of gas? — Well, there is gas in the colliery.

4,213. (Mr. Edge.) Do you know any colliery in the Durham coal field in which there is not gas more or less? — Well I have never seen but one that I have never seen any gas in.

4,214. Were was that? — The Black Prince.

4,215. Where abouts is the Black Prince? — At Towlaw.

(Mr. Jones.) That is just at the edge of the seam.

4,216. (The Coroner.) Looking at the intake or the returns proper, did you ever find either the intake or the returns foul? — No, neither the main in-takes nor the returns.

4,217. (Mr. Wright.) How long have you been an examiner? — It is about six months since I was first appointed.

4,218. July was the first inspection which you made as examiner? — Yes.

4,219. You never seemed to have gone into the far-off at all in the No. 1 Hutton? — No.

4,220. Why not? — Because Thomas Burt examined that portion ; there were two of us.

4,221. You did not go into No. 3 south of the No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

4,222. You did not describe going along the No. 3 south of the No. 3 Hutton? — No, but of course I had been there before. We went up for a turn. I missed that out.

4,223. You missed that out? — Yes.

4,224. You did go over it? — Yes.

4,225. And it was satisfactory? — Yes.

4,226. Did you do the No. 2 Hutton? — No.

4,227. Nor the Harvey? — No, not at that time.

4,228. Burt did those? — Yes.

4,229. Who did the water standage? — I did.

4,230. Was that all right? — Yes.

4,231. Has it always been right when you have seen it? — Yes.

4,232. There is always a great deal of gas in the far-off of this No. 1 Hutton? — I would not like to say, but about four years ago there were two men watching at what they call the inclined way.

4,233. That would be at the end of 1876? — Yes.

4,234. I see a report here signed by Richard Hall, about gas in the far-off way at the end of 1876; do you know anything about that? — No; it was Edward Hall and James Brown watching at that time.

This is signed "Richard Hall?"

4,235. (Mr. Willis.) They examined it? — They were the two men that examined.

4,236. (Mr. Wright.) You, as examiner of the mine on the part of the men, think it your duty to make yourself acquainted with every part of the management of the colliery? — Yes, as far as possible.

4,237. And you have in fact done so? — Yes.

4,238. At the time when the explosion happened, I suppose you were pretty well acquainted with the condition of other parts of it? — Yes, with the part we had looked to.

4,239. Either you or Mr. Burt had made every inspection that according to your judgment it was requisite or proper to make of every part of the colliery? — Yes.

4,240. You saw no reason at that time to apprehend anything wrong or any danger? — No. Of course we reported all right, with the exception of the places I have just mentioned.

4,241. According to your own judgment, is the system on which the mine is worked good? — Yes.

4,242. No false economy in the management anywhere? — Well, no, as far as I have seen.

4,243. Is the discipline good? Are the rules properly observed — the rules of the mine? — I know that the manager was very stringent.

4,244. So far as you know, the rules are enforced? — Yes, on the part of the manager.

4,245. But on the part of the men — do the men always make reports when they ought to? — I do not know that.

4,246. Did it ever come to your notice that they have not? — No.

4,247. You have never known a man, for instance, finding gas in the main and failing to report it? — No.

4,248. Have you ever known of a case? — Well, about three weeks before the explosion, there were some men who made a great deal of noise about gas in the third east at our meeting.

4,249. That is in No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

4,250. Were you present at the meeting? — Yes.

4,251. Who were the men who made complaints? — Robert Greener was one.

4,252. Who were the others? — I do not know who the others were.

4,253. Could he tell us? — Perhaps he could.

4,254. You were present when the complaints were made? — Yes, of course they were finding fault with us; I said that was rather strange, because I had just examined it about three weeks ago.

4,255. What were the complaints? — He was complaining that the men had to work about five yards from the face.

4,256. Why should he complain of that? — Because it is too far from the face. He said the gas would not allow them to take the lamps into the place.

4,257. You mean that they could not take their lamps in because of the gas? — Yes, that was the report.

4,258. Did he say anything else? — They told us about one of the deputies being dismissed for allowing men to work with their lamps so far back by Mr. Stratton.

4,259. Greener complained to Mr. Stratton? — Complained about the gas being in the place.

4,260. That I know ; but about dismissing the overman? — That was one of the deputies who had got his notice for allowing his men to work where it was not workable, and he immediately sold off and went to America.

4,261. Who was that deputy? — Thomas Foster.

4,262. Was he dismissed in point of fact or not? Do you know of your own knowledge? — I do not know of a fact, but I know he sold off and went to America within a fortnight.

4,263. (The Coroner.) Within a fortnight of the complaint, Foster sold off and went to America? — Yes.

4,264. (Mr. Wright.) After Greener made this complaint to you, as mine examiner, what steps did you take to find out if it was true? — We took none. None of us went in, of course, because we were not appointed by the men.

4,265, I thought you said you were the mine examiner? — Not to go in then; they did not send us the second time.

4,266. (The Coroner.) The meeting passed the complaint by? — Passed it by for the time being.

4,267. (Mr. Wright.) They gave you no instructions? — No.

4,268. And nothing was done to see whether the miners' complaint was true or false? — Not that I am aware of.

4,269. (Mr. Jones.) You are appointed for the purpose of making a general examination, but you were not appointed for this special examination? — No ; we only have to go when we are sent.

4,270. (Mr. Wright.) As examiner do you take any particular notice of the way the blasting is done — shot firing? — I have not seen any firing lately.

4,271. It is no part of your duty to see that the rules of the colliery are observed with respect to firing? — Well, you know, we went round on the day shift and we came in contact with no shot firing, or else if we had come in contact with it we should have had to examine it.

4,272. What I want to know is, whether you consider it any part of your duty as mine examiner to take care that shots are fired at proper times and under proper regulations? — No.

4,273. (Mr. Jones.) You are appointed about once a month by the men to go round and examine — is that so? — Once in six months, or once in three months.

4,274. And you have got no power to go round and examine until your next appointment? — No.

4,275. You are only just an ordinary workman until that time? — Yes.

4,276. You had already made your inspection shortly before the miner made this complaint? — About three weeks.

4,277. Do you know whether Greener is here? — I do not know whether he is here at present.

4,278. Have you asked him to come? — I have not seen him lately.

4,279. Do you know he has declined to come? — Well, I think he has been asked, both him and the other man.

(Mr. Wright.) If you wish him brought, it is very easy to bring him.

(Mr. Jones.) Quite so. We very likely shall have resort to that process.

(The Witness.) I have never heard of Greener declining. I have heard tell of the other men.

4,280. (Mr. Jones.) I want to ask you this — can you speak as to the presence of coal dust in the colliery? — Yes. I have seen dust sometimes.

4,281. What do they do with the dust; is it taken away? — Well, there are generally men cleaning, and the way is generally kept clean.

4,282. That is the main-way? — Yes, and the trollyway.

4,283. That is the part they keep clean? — Yes.

4,284. They do not clean the other parts? — There are always men in the returns keeping them right.

4,285. Of course, there are the shifters and those kind of people in the returns keeping them right, and there would be dust on the timber, I suppose? — Yes.

4,286. But what do they do with the dust when they clean it up? — They generally send it to bank as rubbish.

4,287. Do they ever throw it aside? — I have never seen any — it is just raked up in heaps until they get it put into the tub and send it to bank; that is when they have been cleaning it.

4,288. I suppose when the tubs are travelling you have seen the dust flying? — Yes.

4,289. How long after the explosion did you go round? — The first day I went down at 12 o'clock at night as soon as I could get there.

4,290. What part did you go to? — Well, we went down into the Maudlin and the travelling ways.

4,291. Did you go into the No. 3? — Yes.

4,292. From your observations that you made on the first day and subsequently, what conclusions do you arrive at as to where the explosion took place? — Where we had gone we came to the conclusion that it had gone in-bye over.

4,293. Where from? — From No. 3 — came down from the No. 3 gone in-bye over.

4,294. When you say from No. 3, do you mean come from No. 3 as opposed to having come from the Maudlin, or might it have come from the Maudlin or No. 3? — No. It went into the Maudlin. I mean coming from the No. 3 shaft to the Maudlin coming down the in-take.

4,295. You know where the curve is? — Yes.

4,296. And where the doors are? — Yes.

4,297. Did you notice the doors on the other side of the curve going into the Maudlin? — There is none going into the Maudlin; it is the main in-take.

4,298. There are separation doors as you go into the Maudlin? — No, they come away from the No. 3 shaft.

(Mr. Bell.) Just at this point the dip is right down into the Maudlin below the Maudlin seam.

(Mr. Jones.) You saw indications of the blasting having come from No. 3?

(The Coroner.) I think you would get it quicker if you asked him where he thought the explosion came from, and then give his reasons for so thinking.

(Mr. Jones.) He says from No. 3 Hutton.

4,299. (The Coroner.) Give us your reasons why you do not think it came from the Maudlin, and why you think it come from No. 3 Hutton? — Simply because everything was leaning that way towards the Maudlin. For instance, the sheaves going down towards the Maudlin seam were leaning inwards.

4,300. You mean from the direction of No. 3? — Yes.

4,301. Now, again with regard to No. 1 Hutton, in what direction were the things lying there? — Going inwards.

4,302. Can you form any idea as to what part in No. 3 Hutton the explosion took place? — I would scarcely like to say, but when I was standing at Venner's shot I saw it had gone in every direction from that. There is the way-end going up the back, and there is the way-end that goes at the back of the staple, and the way-end that goes to the south, and the way-end that goes back to the shaft, and there is the travelling way, and it had spread in every direction from that way.

4,303. (The Coroner.) You say you think the explosion took place where Venner's shot was fired? — I would not like to say, but from there it spread in every direction.

4,304. (Mr. Jones.) What things did you see thrown in-bye where Venner's shot was; do you remember? — Yes.

4,305. What? — The tubs were blown in-bye, in past the staple, straight on.

4,306. What tubs were those — were they full tubs? — There were both full tubs and empty tubs.

4,307. These were blown in-bye from Venner's shot? — Yes.

4,308. What did you see out-bye from Venner's shot? — Tubs and timber was blown into the way going down to the High Pit shaft, and going down to the Maudlin, engine — that is the in-take. The end was almost blocked up.

4,309. And they were blown out-bye? — Yes.

4,310. On one side of Venner's shot you found the tubs blown in-bye — that is, in-bye side of Venner's shot, and out-bye side of Venner's shot you saw the tubs blown out-bye? — Yes.

4,311. Did you see, besides out-bye and in-bye, anything blown in any other direction? — No; but across from Venner's shot there was a table and such like standing there, and they were all blown to bits.

4,312. (The Coroner.) You have fixed the locality of the explosion, and it occurred at Venner's shot. Will you go further, and tell us where, in your idea, the gas came from and it fired? — Well, I could not say that it was in the main in-take. I could not say where any gas that collected there came from — that is where the mystery lies. I would not like to say it did explode there.

4,313. (Mr. Wright.) Might it, according to your view, have exploded about the bottom of the staple? — No.

4,314. Venner's shot is not very far from the staple? — No.

4,315. But you do not think it could have been from the bottom of the staple that it exploded? — I do not think it was the bottom of the staple.

4,316. You stick to Venner's shot as the most likely place? — Yes, because the tubs on the outside of the staple were all blown in past the staple.

4,317. Would Hindson's shot account for it? — I could not say anything about it. I do not know exactly where Hindson was.

4,318. Assume it to have been, say, 20 yards outbye from Venner's? — As far as I understand, Hindson was the inside-bye of Venner; I would not like to say exactly where he was; I just go from what I have heard.

4,319. Brown's shot would not do for it? — For what.

4,320. If the explosion had happened where Brown's shot was fired, in your judgment that would not explain the way the things were blown cut? — I could not say if it had happened at Brown's shot that they would not have been blown in the same way.

4,321. It might have been Brown's shot so far as you can say? — Yes.

4,322. Did you notice amongst the other things blown in-bye into the No. 3 Hutton a 10-cwt. wheel? — That was at the back; that was up the old Hutton, and, of course, I have never been up that way.

4,323. You have not seen it? — I have not seen it since the explosion.

4,324. Would the situation of the Maudlin engine do? Supposing it had taken place there, would that be consistent with what you observed? — No.

4,325. You think it cannot have taken place at the Maudlin engine? — No.

4,326. (Mr. Edge.) What indications did you find between where the road goes, the main coal staple down the in-take, and the Maudlin engine? — From the main coal staple?

4,327. Between the main coal staple and the Maudlin engine did you see any indications? — I have taken a point of division before we get to the staple.

4,328. Between the main coal stable and the Maudlin engine did you see any indications? — From the switches to the staple everything was blown in.

4,329. Where are the switches? — The out-bye side of the staple.

4,330. Therefore, the explosion was going westward? — Yes.

4,331. As you travelled along did you find still that the explosion was still going westward? — Yes, from the switches.

4,332. From the switches right away, where to where? — In past the staple from the switches outside everything had gone over the other way.

4,333. In-bye or out? — Out-bye over.

4,334. What did you see that had gone out-bye over from the switches? — The tubs.

4,335. Where did you see the tubs? — The tubs was lying in the two bye ends — the way the air comes in and the way it goes to No. 3 shaft, where the Hutton seam and the main coal coals goes down to the No. 3 shaft.

4,336. Was it in that rolly-way down to No. 3 that you say the tubs were blown over? — Blown into that way.

4,337. Did you see anything in the main in-take — any indication of which way the blast had gone? — Yes, there were tubs in there too.

4,338. Tell me where? — Just going into the intake.

4,339. Do you know the Maudlin dock? — Yes.

4,340. Did you see any indications there? — I would not like to say exactly just there.

4,341. Where were the tubs — the tubs which you say were in the main in-take — were they between the crossing here and the way into No. 3? — There is a crossing just going into the in-take, and that crossing was blown out.

4,342. Tubs, you say, were in the main in-take; can you tell me where they were? — They were blown into the main in-take just within the main in-take way end; in fact, they were all blown against the point where the two points are.

4,343. Do you know where these tubs had been before they were blown? — Yes, they would be standing in the siding.

4,344. Do you mean to say they were blown out of the siding? — Yes.

4,345. In which direction? — Out-bye over.

4,346. Out-bye; do you mean towards the Maudlin engine? — Towards the Maudlin engine and towards the No. 3 pit.

4,347. They were blown in towards No. 3 pit? — Out over — that is out over.

4,348. How soon after the explosion did you go up into No. 3? — I would not like to exactly say the day, but it was within a few days after the explosion.

4,349. Were you there when a man's body was found opposite where Venner's shot was fired? — I was there when Smith was found; that was in-bye — Smith and Rawlins at the staple bottom.

4,350. Were you there when young Venner was found? — Yes.

4,351. Where was it? — As we went down the pit shaft we found him lying across the way.

4,352. Was not one of the Venners found about 20 yards straight opposite where Venner's shot was? Yes; but that was found the shift after I was in.

4,353. You were not there when the body was found? — No.

4,354. As you came along, did you notice any of the wheels of any of the sheaves coming from the Maudlin seam? — That is from the Maudlin engine.

4,355. Did you notice any of the wheels of the sheaves? — I took no notice between the Maudlin engine and the Maudlin coal; I took no notice of them from the coal down the drift.

4,356. Did you know there was any wrapper rope down the tail rope? — Yes.

4,357. Did you notice it curled round the tail rope? — No.

4,358. How long were you down when you made this exploration? — Do you mean the first time?

4,359. Yes? — I would scarcely like to say how long I was down the first time; but I was down about nine hours the second.

4,360. How far did you go into No. 1 after the explosion? — I have been into the far-off way, and I have been into the far east.

4,361. Shortly after the explosion, in going into the No. 1, did you notice the brick arch had come down? — I noticed it had been propped in some places.

4,362. Do you remember coming to the first overcast? — Yes.

4,363. Did you notice that that had been blown away? — Yes.

4,364. Did you notice some of the bricks belonging to the over-cast had been blown out by it? — No, I did not take any notice.

4,365. Did you see a block of coal that had been blown out of its place by one of the refuge holes in No. 1? — No.

4,366. Did you notice any hay as you went along by No. 1? — Yes.

4,367. Did you notice the hay was out-bye of the stables? — There was hay the in-bye side of the stables.

4,368. Was not there hay the out-bye side? — I did not notice any on the out-bye side of the first stables.

4,369. Where did you notice it? — On the left side of the first stables; and when we got into the No. 2. in-take, there was hay from there right up 60 yards past the second west stables.

4,370. That is, in the travelling way? — Yes.

4,371. Between the first stables you came to going in and the No. 1 stables, you did not notice any hay? — No.

4,372. I suppose you would not undertake to say there was no hay there? — No, I would not undertake to say there was no hay there.

4,373. Do you know, going along the engine-plane of No. 1, where the caution-board was, just at the junction of No. 1 with the second in-take, the junction where the second in-take takes off, there was a notice board? — I never saw one.

4,374. The gate was up some distance, up the second in-take? — A few yards in the second in-take.

4,375. But beyond and between that and the pit shaft, did you notice no notice board? — No, not before the explosion.

4,376. Do you know where the Polka way is? — Yes.

4,377. Beyond the Polka way were not the indications in-bye? — Yes, all in-bye.

4,378. What indications did you see between the Polka way and the No. 1 shaft that showed you that the blast had gone in-bye there? — At the bottom of the shaft the tubs all seemed to be blown in-bye over.

4,379. That is close to the bottom? — Yes.

4,380. The travelling way a little distance from the bottom of the shaft. Tell me what the next indication was? — Timber seemed to be all blown in over.

4,381. Where did you see any timber blown in over. Up above the first staples.

4,382. Was that above the second in-take? — No, below the second in-take.

4,383. Was that in the engine plane the timber appeared to be blown in over? — In the engine plane between the first west staples and the in-take.

4,384. What you call the second in-take? — Yes; the travelling way.

4,385. What timber was it you saw blown in over? — The sheave stands; there was not much timber set there any further than the sheave stands.

4,386. Is this timber that you are speaking of in the engine plane? — Yes.

4,387. Of No. 1? — Yes.

4,388. (Mr. Jones.) How far is Venner's shot from the old Hutton way? — I would not like to say.

4,389. Is it close to it? — Perhaps about a quarter of a mile.

4,390. You know where the staple is? — Yes.

4,391. Do you know the way into the old Hutton workings? — Yes, straight up the bank.

4,392. Now you know the way end? — Yes.

4,393. How far is the staple from the way end? — Well, about 30 or 40 yards.

4,394. How far was Venner's shot from the staple? — About 50 or 60 yards, as near as I can tell.

4,395. Was Venner's shot nearer to the staple, or nearer to the old Hutton way? — Nearer the old Hutton way end.

4,396. Then it would be about 20 or 30 yards from the old Hutton way, or less? — Somewhere about that.

4,397. Do you know the self-acting doors at the out-bye end of No. 3? — They are between the No. 3 shaft and the staple — the self-acting doors.

4,398. That is what I want — which way were they blown? — I would not like to say, everything seemed to be in confusion — in fact, I never saw the doors, they were all blown to pieces, as far as I know.

Adjourned for a short time.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print