Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 5th January 1881 (cont.).

Mr. Joseph Spence sworn.

4,399. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A master wasteman.

4,400. (Mr. Edge.) Were you master wasteman at the Seaham Colliery at the time of the last explosion on the 7th September? — Yes.

4,401. I believe you had been in that position for some five years? — Yes.

4,402. What are your duties as master wasteman? — My duty is to travel in the returns, and take charge of the ventilation, the regulators, and the separation doors, and so forth.

4,403. You have, I think, the charge of the whole ventilation of the mine? — To the out--bye side of all landings.

4,404. How many men have you under your charge? — Something like 30 at the time.

4,405. On the 7th September last what time did you go down the pit? — Three o'clock in the morning.

4,406. Which district did you go into? — I went into No. 2. Before I went into No. 2 I examined the furnaces, and the out-comes of the several returns before going into No. 2.

4,407. How did you find the furnaces and the outcomes of the returns? — They were all right.

4,408. Did you find any indication on the 7th September which would lead you to the conclusion that there was any accumulation of gas in any part of the works? — Not in the least.

4,409. I suppose you know the place near the returns — the approach to the main coal staple? — Yes.

4,410. Where is the furnace situated which draws the air along those returns? — Near to No. 3 shaft. There is No. 1 (describing), and No. 3 is here.

4,411. Do you know the plan? — A little.

4,412. I do not want to trouble you with the plan if you do not understand it. You understand the plan? — Yes.

4,413. Just go and put your finger so that the jury may see it, on the main coal staple on the plan.

(Mr. Wright.) It is somewhere there (pointing on the plan.)

4,414. (Mr. Edge.) How far from that do you say the furnace is? (The witness pointed on the plan.) Can you tell me this: In the neighbourhood, close on to where the main coal staple is, is there not a strong draught along that return? — Yes.

4,415. The pressure of air is into the return, and not from the return outwards? — It is in the return.

4,416. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Have you ever known the gas get into the in-takes? — No.

4,417. Never in any part of the mine? — No.

4,418. Never heard a suggestion of such a thing happening? — No.

4,419. Can you form any theory at all of any way in which the gas could have got into the in-take — we will say, first of all, the in-take of No. 1 Hutton about the Polka? — No.

4,420. Take, secondly, the in-take to No. 3 Hutton, anywhere about the point where the Maudlin engine is, or between Venner's shot and Brown's shot. Can you form any idea of how gas could have got there? — No.

4,421. Nor into the in-takes of the Maudlin itself? — No.

4,422. Have you never heard any report of gas getting into the in-takes? — No.

4,423. What means do you take to ascertain how much gas there is in the air of the returns of the mine? — Well, I have taken no means to ascertain the quantity of gas in the air.

4,424. It is your special duty to see to the ventilation out by the working faces? — Yes.

4,425. And to see that the travelling roads and the in-takes and returns are free from noxious gases? — Yes.

4,426. Have you ever taken any means to ascertain what quantity of gas is contained in the return air of this mine? — I have not taken any means to try it.

4,427. I ask you the question. I do not impute any blame to you. I simply want to know if any means to your knowledge have been taken to ascertain it? — No.

4,428. I want your particular attention, please, to this part of the mine. (Pointing on the plan.) There is a curve near No. 1 pit — almost round No. 1 pit, a curve in the in-take; do you see that? — Yes.

4,429. A little to the eastward of that, there are some returns commencing near this fault. That is a fault, is it? — That is a fault.

4,430. Near the nearest fault to that curve, commencing there, and communicating ultimately with the in-take into No. 1 Hutton near the first crossing. Do you understand what I mean? — Yes, I understand it.

4,431. Sometimes the effect of one of the furnaces upon the other is that there is no strong current between these two; there is a kind of balance of air if I may say so? — There is not a great deal, but there is always a little air passing.

4,432. Still, sometimes there is not I suppose. You must tell me what the effect is. Is it ever stagnant? — It is never quite stagnant.

4,433. It is never quite stagnant, you think? — No.

4,434. Is no part of this ever stagnant? — No.

4,435. The furnaces balance each other, do not they? — There is always a little air passing.

4,436. What is the term you use for furnaces burning? — Drawing.

4,437. That does happen, that the furnaces balance? — The ventilation is all connected together. Of course if one furnace is slack and the other is not, it affects all alike.

4,438. So there is then no strong draw through these airways? — No.

4,439. Does that often happen? — What?

4,440. That there is a suspension of the draught through these airways? — There is always air passing.

4,441. A slackening of it, I say? — There is no particular difference.

4,442. Is there, or is there not a considerable slackening there? — No.

4,443. You told me just now there was? — No.

4,444. I understood you to say that sometimes when one furnace drew upon another, air slackened? — I say, it affected the mine altogether, all the way up.

4,445. You mean not this specially (pointing on the plan)? — No.

4,446. (Mr. Bell to the witness.) What I apprehend Mr. Wright wants to be at is this, when the No. 3 furnace is slackened, can the air through this east side come through here, this way, and go round to No. 1 furnace (describing on the plan)? — I have never seen it do it.

4,447-8. (Mr. Wright.) Can it do it? — It can do it, but I have never seen it do it.

4,449. If No. 3 furnace was slack and No. 1 furnace was going, must it not necessarily do that? — I have never seen it do it.

4,450. That is not the question. If No. 1 furnace is going, and No. 3 furnace is slack, must it not do that? — No.

4,451. (Mr. Bell.) Coming from the Maudlin side this way, and coming over this crossing, and coming over to this furnace, that is what Mr. Wright says? — No.

4,452. (Mr. Wright.) Then how does it pass? — It passes down — a portion of it — this way, and comes round this way, and comes round to No. 3. That is always the route.

4,453. That is, it comes along the nearest return of the east side of the No. 1 Hutton in-take, immediately to the north of the first crossing. Have you ever paid special attention to this part of the question? — Yes.

4,454. Whether there might not be an amount of slack air all about these returns which you have been speaking of? — Yes.

4,455. And have you ever found any slacking? — I have never found any slacking.

4,456. (The Coroner.) You never have found any slacking? — No.

4,457. (Mr. Bell.) Can the air come round this way (pointing on the plan) and then go away? — It can go this way,

4,458. Can the return air come over this way, and come the other way here; what I mean is, that the way being open, it may come through No. 1 furnaces or No. 3 furnaces? — It might do.

4,459. (The Coroner.) Your answer is, it might do so, but you have never seen it do so? — No.

4,460. You have never seen the special circumstances to cause it to do so? — No.

4,461. (Mr. Wright.) Supposing it did so, gas would accumulate in the parts of the returns that you are speaking of, would it not? — It might do if there was no ventilation.

4,462. If there was a greatly retarded current for a few hours? — Well ; it might be, but I have never seen it.

4,463. If it did, I ask you. Do not be afraid. I am not leading you into anything that you need be afraid of answering. If it did accumulate there, then, supposing the ventilation was again restored, would that gassy, foul air get into the in-take? — No.

4,464. It could not possibly? — I do not know of it.

4,465. Could you suggest any way in which it might by chance get into the in-take? — No.

4,466. If it could not get into the in-take it must go to the furnace fires? — What, the gas?

4,467. Yes? — Yes, if there was any.

4,468. Quite so, if there was gas there; and if it could not get into the in-take it must go to the furnace fire? — Yes.

4,469. What is the nearest point to the furnace that gas has ever been seen in any of the returns, to your knowledge? — About 60 to 70 yards from the No. 3 furnace, I have seen a slight indication.

4,470. Just point on the plan whereabouts you saw it? — Here (pointing).

4,471. How would you describe that return? — That is No. 3, north side.

4,472. No. 3, north side, No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

4,473. In what form did you find the gas there — issuing or what? — Simply a dullness in the air, or a slight indication of gas.

4,474. A slight indication? — Yes, very little, small.

4,475. A small blue cap? — It is a long time since.

4,476. How long? — I am sure I could not say.

4,477. Five or six years? — Yes, since that.

4,478. Two years? — A little over.

4,479. Where did that come from, did you ever find out? — A long way from here, from the north side, return No. 3 Hutton.

4,480. It would come out of the goaf in No. 3 Hutton, north side? — Yes.

4,481. Get into the returns there, and be carried in the returns to the furnaces? — I have never seen it carried to the furnaces.

4,482. You lost it at a distance of about 50 yards from the furnaces? — Yes.

4,483. Did you trace it back at all on that occasion? — Yes, further in.

4,484. To try to find where it came from? — I went so far (pointing on the plan). It seemed to be mixed all alike.

4,485. Was it explosive? — No.

4,486. Was it near the explosive point of mixture? — No.

4,487. You did identify the particular part of the goaf it came from? — I think it came from no place else than there.

4,488. There was no blower? — I had no barometer at the time.

4,489. Have you ever known an explosion take place in your experience on account of blower gas? — No.

4,490. You never heard of such a thing happening? — No.

4,491. Where are the Geordie bank doors? — Just near the bottom of that curve, No. 1 pit, are they not? — Yes.

4,492. Has gas ever been seen in the return there? — No, I never have.

4,493. What is it that is called? — The dock?

(Mr. Edge.) The Maudlin dock.

4,494. (Mr. Wright.) Do you know where that is, the dock? — It is here (pointing).

4,495. What is it? — It is where the tub goes on to a skip on the travelling road.

4,496. Is there a kind of lift there? — The carriages nearly touch the top there.

4,497. Has gas ever accumulated? — No, it is too low.

4,498. How is it ventilated? — There is a ventilator at the in end of the brick-work.

4,499. What air comes through that ventilator? — There is something like 8,000 goes through there and the doors together.

4,500. And passes through that dock? — No, about 4,000.

4,501. There is about 4,000 passes through the dock? — Yes.

4,502. Were you at Seaham in 1871? — Yes.

4,503. When the explosion happened there? — Yes.

4,504. Whereabouts did it happen? — I do not know.

4,505. We have been told the cause of that, but I am sorry to say I have forgotten it. What was the cause of that in your judgment? — I do not know.

4,506. You have never troubled to ask? — I had never been on that side. I have never been at it before.

4,507. You never had the curiosity to find out. Did anybody else find out, do you know? — I heard what was said.

4,508. Have you any theory of your own as to how this explosion happened? — No.

4,509. Or where it happened? — No.

4,510. Nor how the gas got there? — No.

4,511. Do you mean to say you have not? — I do not remember any gas being near the place.

4,512. I am talking of the 7th September this last year. Have you no view whatever, first of all, as to what part of the mine the explosion happened in? — No.

4,513. Do you mean to say it is all one in your judgment whether it happened in the far-off or in the Maudlin, or in the No. 3 Hutton; do you think it more likely to happen in the one than in the other? — I do not think it happened in the far-off, or in the Maudlin, or in the in-bye No. 1.

4,514. Do you think it happened in the No. 3 Hutton? — I cannot say.

4,515. What do you think; give us the best of your judgment? — Really I cannot say.

4,516. You are clear it did not happen in the inbye in No. 1? — Yes.

4,517. That you think, at least? — Yes.

4,518. Have you any opinion whether it happened in the Maudlin? — No, I do not think it did happen there.

4,519. You do not think it did happen there — not in the part that is sealed- up, or in the other part? — I think not ; no.

4,520. May I ask you your reason for thinking it did not happen in the Maudlin or in the part sealed up? — It has always been right, so far as I know.

4,521. That is your only reason? — Yes.

4,522. What is your reason for saying it did not happen in No. 1 Hutton? — Because it was always right there.

4,523. For the same reason, I suppose, it was wrong in the others? — There were men burnt there.

4,524. When you told me that you thought it did not happen in No. 1 because there was nothing wrong there, it was because the men were not burnt there? — Yes.

4,525. Were they burnt in No. 3 Hutton? — I cannot say. I did not see them there.

4,526. That is the only thing you go by, whether the men were burnt? — Yes.

4,527. Have you taken any means at all, by inspecting the mine yourself, to form any conclusion as to whereabouts the explosion happened? — I could not say at all.

4,528. Have you taken any means, is the question, to try and inform yourself? — Well, I have tried as I passed along, but I have not had very much chance to do it.

4,529. Is it not your very business to see that all these parts of the mine are right? — Well, the circumstances at the time did not enable me to do it. The first thing to do was to put all the fires out, and after that was done there was a very short time elapsed before we had to make ready for lighting the furnaces, because it was in my department. The stuffing had to be made ready and put in to make things right for lighting the furnaces, and that was my department, while the explosion was going on.

4,530. You have been fully employed and have not been able to form any theory on the subject? — No.

4,531. Have you your report book? — I have it in my pocket.

4,532. Is it your special duty to examine the goaf edges? — Yes.

4,533. Show me your last report of the goaf edges — the No. 3 Hutton, will you, before the explosion? — I was at it frequently, but I did not mention them all.

4,534. I want your report. Your duty is to examine the goaf edges frequently and enter the result of your observations each day in your report book, and sign the same? — I was on them regularly, but I do not put the goaf edges in the report.

4,535. Do you put into your reports anything about the air current? — That "all is right," that is all.

4,536. Show me your last report about the air currents in No. 3 Hutton? — There it is, sir. (The same was handed in.)

4,537. No. 3 Hutton seam? — And low main?

4,538. And low main. There seems to be no observation there at all. That is your way of reporting, is it. That means, you found all right? — Yes. If there is anything wrong, I state it.

4,539. Show me your last report of No. 3 Hutton return air courses? — (pointing.) That is No. 3.

4,540. This is the way you do it, "Are they all right?" and so forth — you just put "yes" to them? — Yes.

4,541. I do not want to mislead you at all; you have answered that question? — Yes.

4,542. The question is, "Have you examined the return, the in-take, and the goaf edges, and are they all right?" and the answer is "Yes?" — Yes.

4,543. You have nothing to do with firing shots, have you? — In my department I have.

4,544. It is in your department? — No; in my department I have to do with firing the shot in the returns.

4,545. You have to do with returns? — Only with the returns.

4,546. Are shots ever fired in the returns? — Occasionally they are.

4,547. What parts of the returns have you known shots fired in? — Just here (pointing to plan).

4,548. When was the last? — A long time — four years ago.

4,549. None except those? — No.

4,550. And except fired in the returns, you have nothing to do with them? — No.

4,551. I rather gather that you have not made a very minute examination of the mine to see what course the explosion took, but try and see if you can answer this. Could you anywhere, in any part of the mine that you noticed, see anything to indicate that the blast had come out of the return? — No.

4,552. And gone into the in-take instead of coming out of the in-take and gone into the return? — No.

4,553. Are you able to say, so far as you observed, that it did not in any case come out of the return? — I know nothing of it.

4,554. Are you pretty confident that the explosion did not happen in a return? — I think it did not. I never see no indications of it.

4,555. And that it did happen in in-take somewhere? — Well, it happened somewhere.

4,556. I say it happened in an in-take but not in a return. Why do you say you think it must have happened in an in-take, and that it certainly did not happen in a return? — You asked me if I had seen any indications.

4,557. Quite so? — And I have not seen any indications coming out of the return.

4,558. But you have seen indications going out of the in-take? — I have seen indications of going into the return.

4,559. (Mr. A. Jones.) You said just now, Mr. Spence, that when one furnace draws upon another, it not merely affects that portion of the return which was pointed out to you, but that it affects the whole mine? — It affects that as well as any other place.

4,560. You speak of one furnace drawing upon another, and you say it affects the whole mine? — The whole returns and in-takes, when one is slack or when they are both out, or when they are all going.

4,561. When they draw one upon another, in what way would you say it affected the whole mine? — When the furnaces are all at work there is more ventilation and more air.

4,562. Clearly, but you stated that it would not affect this particular return? — Not any more than the remainder.

4,563. I want to understand what you mean ; when one furnace draws upon another, what would be the effect throughout the whole mine? — How do you mean — the one drawing upon the other?

4,564. I am taking your own words; you said, "If one furnace draws upon another it will affect, not merely that particular part, but it will affect the whole mine." — I understand that when one is rather shack, the other is going rather fuller, that is, one upon another, as you call it.

4,565. Is that what you call drawing one upon the other? — Yes.

4,566. What would be the effect upon the mine then? — If one furnace is slack and the other going full, of course it affects the whole mine more than if all are going alike.

4,567. What would be the effect? — Slackness of ventilation.

4,568. Slackness of ventilation clearly; and when they are both going alike, what would you say then; would you say that the ventilation would be better then? — When the one is out, and the other in, or the one slack, and the other going full.

4,569. I think you say that that is not an uncommon thing, do you not, of one furnace drawing upon another? — It should not be only when there is a call for one to be damped and the other not.

4,570. Still, not uncommonly it happens that you find one furnace drawing upon another? — I cannot say that it does happen, except, as I say, when one furnace is ordered to be damped while the other is going.

4,571. How often would that occur? — Only when the shiftman is doing something, or we clean the drifts out, or the like of that — mostly at the week ends.

4,572. When would you have either of these furnaces damped down prior to the explosion? — You will find it in the report.

4,573. Can you state to me, by referring, when it would be? — Yes.

4,574. Had anything been done to the furnace on that night — the night of the explosion? — No. It would be on the 5th September.

4,575. On the 5th September the furnace had been damped down? — Yes.

4,576. When would it be in full working order again? — Some time of the Sunday.

4,577. That would be on the 5th? — The morning is when it happens to be damped; perhaps it goes away at 11 o'clock — sometimes 2.

4,578. The 5th September you are speaking of? — Yes.

4,579. Was the 5th September on a Sunday?

(The Coroner.) Yes.

(The Witness.) According to my report it is.

4,580. (Mr. A. Jones.) Then you say it would be in working order again on the same day it was damped down; is that what I understand you to say? — Yes, generally. For something like four hours, sometimes six, sometimes it happens to be eight, just as they get through the work in the shaft.

4,581. Was that the last time that either of the furnaces was meddled with? — Yes.

4,582. And time last time anything was done to either of the furnaces before — up to the time of the explosion?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Up to what date?

(Mr. A. Jones.) The 5th September.

4,583-4. I do not know how long you said you had been in the colliery? — How long?

4,585. Yes? — A long time.

4,586. About 10 years? — I have been above 20 years.

4,587. Do you remember when long wall working was first introduced into the colliery? — Well, I remember a little about it.

4,588. How long ago was that? — I am sure I could not say now.

4,589. I do not want you to say to a month or two; I should like you to say to a year or so. Would it be three or four years back, or more? — I did not belong to "in-bye" at all when I was formerly in this place. I was at wagon-way work, and stone.

4,590. You have a knowledge of long wall being introduced? — I heard about it.

(The Coroner.) I think that it is in Mr. Stratton's evidence in chief.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I know it is. I am quite aware of that.

4,591. Do you know that complaints at that time were made about long wall working being introduced among the men? — I have heard them talking about it.

4,592. Have you heard them talking about it at the time it was introduced? — Well, I cannot say exactly whether it was at the time or not.

4,593. Since then you have heard it talked about? — I have heard a talk about long wall, but as to the exact time of starting I could not say.

4,594. (The Coroner.) Was it because there was more danger of gas explosions by working that way? was that the reason? — No.

4,595. What was the reasons — to have done with it?

(Mr. A. Jones.) It is an easier way of working, is it not?

(The Witness.) It is not so well to air, I suppose.

4,596. Not so well to air or to ventilate; at all events your experience of long wall working leads you to believe it is not so well to ventilate? — Well, where the air is carried so far in wagon ways, it is not so well to ventilate a long way as a short way; everybody knows that.

4,597. Do you remember when shot firing — I mean for the purpose of getting coal, was last practised in the colliery? — For getting coals?

4,598. Yes, for the purpose of getting the coals? — I suppose that will not be so very long since in the main coal.

4,599. How long ago? — Shortly before the explosion — I think they were firing then ; I am not certain.

4,600. How long. What do you mean by "shortly before?" Close up to the time, I think.

4,601. Close up to the time of the explosion they were firing shots for the purpose of getting the coal? — In the main coal — I think so.

4,602. In the three seams set out on the plan, the Hutton No. 1, the Hutton No. 3, and the Maudlin; how long is it since they had ceased to fire shots there for the purpose of getting coal?

4,603. (The Coroner.) Is not Turnbull the under viewer? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) You will get it far better from Turnbull, than from this witness.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I would sooner get it from this witness.

(The Coroner.) He is only telling you what he thinks — not what he knows.

4,604. (Mr. A. Jones to witness.) Do you know yourself? — No, I had nothing to do with firing the shots in the coal.

4,605. You have got the general supervision for ventilation ; however I had better in that case reserve my examination upon that for the viewer. In what part of the colliery have you most found gas; in what seam do you consider the most gas is to be found? — I am sure I cannot say.

4,606. You have had a large experience in the colliery; perhaps you can give me a general idea as to what seam you find most gas to exist in? — In No. 1, west side.

4,607. Would you just put your hand on the plan, pointing out where it is? — On this side (pointing).

4,608. On the west side down the far-off way? — Well, I have seen it down there too.

4,609. That is where it is most found in the colliery, is it? Where does that gas come from; is it gas that comes out in blowers or from the edges of the goaf? — Off the goaf edges.

4,610. There would not be gas there where you put your hand first? — Oh, yes.

4,611. Is there goaf there? — Yes; this is goaf (pointing).

4,612. But not where you put your hand first? — No, it travels round here from the east.

4,613. Then is all the gas you find there attributable to the goaf? — I think so.

4,614. Have you not found gas in that part of the colliery coming from the roof and floor? — No.

4,615. Never in that part of the colliery? — No.

4,616. In what parts of the colliery have you found any? — Not in the returns ; I am only speaking of the frictions.

4,617. You do not know anything outside the returns? — No.

4,618. Do you not know of the working places? — No, I have nothing to do with them.

4,619. You have not found it come off the roof or the floor from the returns at all? — No.

4,620. There are water standages, are there not, in that seam? — No. 3 east?

4,621. Yes? — Yes.

4,622. Have you ever known gas come off the water standages on to the in-takes? — No.

4,623. Have you never known such a thing? — No.

4,624. I suppose there is nothing to prevent that taking place as the water rises in the standages, is there? — I do not think it can do so; the pressure of the air outside is not allowed to come into the intakes.

4,625. As the water rises in the standages the water is brought up to certain levels? — If it should do it would go away in the returns, but I have not seen any indication of it.

4,626. I am taking the case of the water standage coming on to the in-take; have you never known gas come off from a water standage on to the in-take? — Never, any water standage.

4,627. (The Coroner.) You say you never saw any indication of gas in any standage? — No.

Then you could not see any come off.

4,628. (Mr. A. Jones.) Never seen any in any of the standages? — I thought you were alluding to these first?

4,629. I was. I will take you now to all the standages. On what standages have you seen gas? — I have no particular standages. All the places where water is accumulated and it is not ladled out or drawn out.

4,630. But you have found gas on them? — I have not.

4,631. On no standages? — No.

(Mr. Edge.) Your question is rather misleading.

(The Coroner.) I think it is cleared up now, Mr. Edge.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes, I think it is.

4,632. You did not sign your report as the men's delegate without reading it to see that it was correct? — When Mr. Crozier wrote it out I told him what to put in — that was the only one left, and I said to him "put it down" as he was going to write his own on the same pit, and I told him to mention that place, Robert Sullivan's place.

William Crozier has not put it down. That is what it comes to.

4,633. (The Coroner.) Then you do not make your own the same as the one you sent into the colliery? — We write them both alike.

4,634. In this case it has not been the same

4,635. (Mr. A. Jones.) Have you got your own report book here? — No, it is at the colliery.

Let us have your report book up here.

(The Coroner.) It does not come to the knowledge of the colliery people.

(Mr. A. Jones.) It is only to show that it was entered.

(The Coroner.) I do not dispute the fact of his having found the gas, but he has not entered it upon the report.

(Mr. A. Jones.) However, you bring your own book down to-morrow morning.

4,636. (Mr. Edge.) Did you find no other portion of the mine in which there were indications each way — except in the neighbourhood of the staple? — Well, I have told you about the staple, but can only go from the staple to the Maudlin engine.

4,637. Is that the only part of the mine in which you found indications going out-bye and in-bye? — In that seam it is.

4,638. In any other seam did you find indications going out-bye and in-bye? You have been into No. 1 Hutton, I suppose, since the explosion? — Yes.

4,639. How soon after the explosion did you go in? — About six that night, between six and seven that night, at any rate.

4,640. Did you notice where the bricks which had come down from the arch were — where they had blown to? — That is where the overcast was.

4,641. No; before you got to the over-cast pit, shaft No. 1, did you notice where any of those bricks were? I will put it to you, did you notice that some of the bricks in the archway were blown out-bye ---? — Yes, there were indications that they had travelled out-by there.

4,642. Did you see bricks blown 20 and 30 yards out-bye there? — I could not say how far?

4,643. You saw them blown out-bye ---? — I saw some certainly.

4,644. Did you notice any hay as you went in? — I noticed it blown both out and in.

4,645. Between the Polka end and the shaft, blown out-bye in the engine plane? — Yes.

4,646. Did you notice between the first stable you came to and the first east?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Is it not enough for you that we have it on the evidence that there are indications both ways.

(Mr. Edge.) Other witnesses have not seen this.

4,647. Did you notice between the first stable you come to in going into No. 1 Hutton (between that and the pit shaft) hay? — Yes, I noticed hay there.

4,648. Where could it have come from except from the stable? — The idea flew across my mind that it had come out of the second west stable.

4,649. That is further still? — Yes.

4,650. Did you see a big piece of coal that had been blown out of the side of one of the refuse holes? — I did not notice any.

4,651. You did not notice a large lump of coal? — No.

4,652. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You know where Venner's shot was? — Yes.

4,653. And where Hindson's shot was? — Yes.

4,654. And where Brown's shot was? — Yes.

4,655. You say that in your judgment the signs were most consistent with the explosion having happened somewhere about the bottom of the staple? — Yes.

4,656. Were they consistent also with its having happened so far as Brown's shot? — Well, I cannot trace them away from the Maudlin engine.

4,657. You cannot carry it any further than that in your judgment? — No.

4,658. (Mr. Bell.) A portion of your drift in No. 1 east return comes up to here, the Geordie bank? — Yes.

4,659. Have you ever found gas between the Geordie bank returns and this point (pointing to plan), the extreme east point? — No ; here is a standage of water which is syphoned out occasionally.

4,660. Has there ever been any gas found in this drift, between the Geordie bank and down to the north main trouble? — No, not to my knowledge.

4,661. Has there occasionally been gas found between the trouble and this point down here? — No.

4,662. Or down here? — No. Not before for a long time, I had not seen any.

4,663. How can you account for gas appearing in the returns after the explosion when none appeared before? — Because the ventilation after the explosion was not as it was before.

(The Coroner.) Not so good?

4,664. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) That would be a good answer for a short time, but would that be a good answer after the 8th November and the 16th December? — It has never been as it was before.

4,665. Was the ventilation never restored up to the 16th December? — No, and it never has been yet.

4,666. That is a fair answer.

4,667. (Mr. Edge.) I understand you to say that on the occasion when you have found a trace of gas within 60 yards of the furnace, it was merely the dullness of the air you noticed? — You would see a slight indication of gas, very slight.

(The Coroner.) Have you any indications you want to call his attention to (addressing Mr. Wright)?

4,668. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes. From the beginning of this book down to the time of the explosion, there is no entry of your having seen any gas? — No.

4,669. But after the explosion happened I see there is some entries of gas? — Of course there was some.

4,670. Do you mean to say there was none before, or that you altered your system of entering it?

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print