Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 5th January 1881 (cont.).

Mr. John Turner sworn.

3,932. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A stoneman.

3,933. Working where? Were you in the pit when the explosion took place? — No.

3,934. (Mr. A. Jones.) How long have you worked at Seaham Colliery? — Since 1871.

3,935. (The Coroner.) Were you in the 1871 explosion? — No.

3,936. (Mr. A. Jones.) What seam have you been working in last? — No. 3 Hutton seam.

3,937. How long have you been working in No. 3 Hutton? — It may be four or five months.

3,938. Before September do you mean? — Yes.

3,939. On the 7th September were you in the colliery? — Yes.

3,940. No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

3,941. Up to what time? — Till 11 o'clock.

3,942. (The Coroner.) 11 o'clock in the day or night? — In the day.

3,943. (Mr. A. Jones.) What had you been doing in No. 3 Hutton? — Making wagon ways.

3,944. Where? — Straight ahead — on the straight-on way.

3,945. How far in? — I cannot say exactly the distance.

3,946. How far from the shaft? — About half a mile. I cannot say exactly the distance.

(Mr. Bell.) Following that blue line.

3,947. (Mr. A. Jones.) That would be going down south in No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

3,948. How far from the face? — Two pillars.

3,949. (The Coroner.) What length are the pillars? — About 60 yards, I believe.

3,950. (Mr. A. Jones.) About 60 yards each? — Yes; I believe so.

3,951. That would be about 120 yards? — Yes; from the face.

3,952. Do you know anything of shot firing? — Yes.

3,953. In No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

3,954. When do you last know of shots being fired there before the explosion, not since? — Well, there was a shot fired that night.

3,955. A shot fired there that night? — Yes.

3,956. What night do you mean? — The night of the explosion.

(The Coroner.) Was he there?

(Mr. A. Jones.) No.

(Mr. Edge.) Then I do not think you ought to ask hmm the question.

(Mr. A. Jones.) What do you know about that shot firing there?

(Mr. Wright.) I think it is hardly fair.

(The Coroner.) I want to see what is coming before I say anything.

(Mr. Wright.) He cannot be asked as to anything that happened when he was not there.

(The Coroner.) But he might have known of the preparations that were made for firing the shot, if it is within his own knowledge.

(Mr. Wright.) That is not a thing which Mr. Edge should be obliged to take an objection to.

(Mr. A. Jones.) If he makes an objection I shall be happy to deal with it, but I do not think you should take the objection for him.

(Mr. Edge.) My instructions are not to take any objections to it, but I rather think it is hardly fair to put the question to this witness in this way. If you will ask the witness what he knows, as a fact, I do not object.

(The Coroner.) That is exactly the way in which Mr. Jones wants to get it.

(Mr. Edge.) Anything he had, or saw, or did.

3,957. (Mr. A. Jones.) Do you know anything yourself about a shot being fired in No. 3 Hutton? — My mate fired a shot that night.

3,958. (The Coroner.) How can you know it? — I heard of it when I went back.

(The Coroner.) You can tell us what state you left the place in, and that there was a preparation made for firing a shot; but you cannot tell us that a shot was fired?

(Mr. Wright.) If you will be a trifle more regular I dare say Mr. Edge will not object. If he states what he said to his mate, or what his mate said to him, I daresay he will not object.

(The Coroner.) Mr. Jones, will you examine him as to how he left the place. He says the place was prepared for shot firing, as I understand him, but he certainly cannot tell whether that shot was fired, or whether the place was in the state in which he left it.

(Mr. Bell.) What place do you mean?

(The Coroner.) The place where the preparations were made.

3,959. (Mr. A. Jones.) Do you know anything about the preparations for the shot firing? — Yes.

3,960. You do? — Yes.

3,961. On that morning? — Yes.

3,962. Where was this shot being fired? — In the refuge hole by the side of the staple.

3,963. (The Coroner.) Did you yourself prepare the place? — No.

3,964. Did you see it? — Yes.

3,965. You saw it before you left at 11 o'clock on this morning? — Yes.

3,966. (Mr. A. Jones.) Whose shot was it you saw preparations for? Was that Brown's shot? — No.

3,967. Whose — Hindon's? — No.

3,968. Venner's? — Yes.

3,969. Can you tell me how far in-bye that was? — In-bye where?

(Mr. Wright.) We have all this proved.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Possibly.

(Mr. Bell.) Ask him how far it was from the main coal staple.

3,970. (Mr. A. Jones.) How far was it from the main coal staple? — It may be 20 or 30 yards; I could not say.

3,971. Who were preparing to fire the shot there? — The two Venners.

(Mr. A. Jones.). I think my friend, Mr. Wright, is somewhat mistaken. I do not think this evidence has been given.

(The Coroner.) Yes. There is an epitome — If I may call it so — in the previous evidence.

(Mr. A. Jones.) We have the fact that two shots were fired, but we have not the locality.

(Mr. Wright.) Indeed we have. We have Venner, Hindson, and Brown.

(The Coroner.) Yes.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Have you the time when they were fired?

(Mr. Wright.) It is all on the note. If it is not, by all means supplement it. They are marked on this plan, I believe.

(The Coroner.) You cannot prove by this witness the time it was fired?

(Mr. A. Jones.) No.

(Mr. Bowey.) We can shew the indications of shots being fired both before and after.

(The Coroner.) If he can show the state the place was in before it was fired, I am quite willing that you should get that from him.

(Mr. Bowey.) We can.

(The Coroner.) Very well. Then get it from him.

(Mr. Wright.) Mr. Jones, I hope you will not misunderstand us in the least. There is no desire to stop any question of any kind.

(Mr. A. Jones.) No; certainly not. I quite understand that.

(Mr. Wright.) But all we do wish is that the ground should not be gone over again unnecessarily.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Quite so; but I am quite sure the Coroner will not say that I am doing so.

(The Coroner.) If you are prepared to prove the place where Venners' shot was, which was afterwards fired, then I am quite prepared to hear you.

(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes.

(The Coroner.) Then will you do that?

3,972. (Mr. A. Jones.) It was at three o'clock in the morning you went in, was it not? — Yes. I went down at three.

3,973. What did you see then as to a shot having been fired? — The morning before the explosion?

3,974. Yes? — They were busy drilling a hole when I went in.

3,975. They were busy drilling a hole to fire a shot? — Yes.

3,976. Who? — Venners.

3,977. What were Hindson and Rawlings doing at that time? — They were taking stone away from the place where they had fired a shot.

3,978. Where had Hindson and Rawlings fired a shot? — Twenty yards further out from where Venner's was.

3,979. (The Coroner.) Were you present when that shot was fired, or did you only see that the shot had been fired? — I only saw that the shot had been fired.

3,980. (Mr. A. Jones.) When you went in a few days after the explosion, did you see any indications of a shot having been fired at Venner's place? — Yes. The shot was lying there.

3,981. That was after the explosion? — Yes.

3,982. That was Venner's place? — Yes.

3,983. Did you see any indications at Hindson's and Rawling's place of a shot having been fired? — They had not fired one that night.

3,984. I think this is important. You say Hindson and Rawlings had not fired a shot that night? — No.

3,985. Why do you conclude that Hindson and Rawlings had not fired a shot that night?

(The Coroner.) Which night?

(Mr. A. Jones.) The night of the explosion.

(The Coroner.) He cannot prove that any more than I can.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I think he can. I will prove it.

(The Coroner.) He leaves at 11 o'clock in the morning

3,986. (Mr. A. Jones.) You say after the explosion you went down and saw where Venner's shot had been fired? — Yes.

3,987. Did you see any sign of Venner having fired a shot? — Yes.

3,988. What did you see? — I saw the shot lying there.

3,989. You saw the shot lying there? — The stones lying, at least, where they had fired the shot.

3,990. (The Coroner.) Had he fired it, or had the explosion fired it? — That I cannot say.

3,991. (Mr. A. Jones.) You know a shot had been fired? — I know a shot had been fired, but I could not say whether the explosion fired it, or whether he had fired it.

3,992. You knew it by the stones which had been brought down? — Yes.

3,993. Had that shot been partly cleared away? — Venner's?

3,994. Venner's? — It had not.

3,995. Now as to Hindson's and Rawlings's shot, how came you to the conclusion that no shot had been fired at Hindson's and Rawlings's that night? — Yes, I came to that conclusion.

3,996. Why? — Because they had plenty of stones lying when they went in at 12 o'clock that night to keep them going — before the explosion.

3,997. Do you mean by that that they could not have cleared away the stones in order to have fired a shot? — No, they could not.

3,998. (The Coroner.) Do you mean that — that the stones they had got they could not clear away to fire a shot — Hindson and Rawlings? — Yes, Hindson and them.

3,999. (Mr. A. Jones.) I understand you to say, briefly stated, that you come to the conclusion that Venner had fired a shot because you saw him drilling for a shot on the Tuesday morning, and after the explosion you saw that a shot had taken place? — Yes.

4,000. By the stone being left there? — Yes.

4,001. And you come to the conclusion that Hindson and Rawlings had not fired a shot that night? — Yes.

4,002. Because you said that you saw that they had plenty of stones which would keep them engaged clearing away before they could fire another shot? — Yes.

4,003. Those stones you having seen on the Tuesday morning? — Yes.

4,004. Do you know that there were paraffin lamps at the staple bottom? — Yes.

4,005. And that they were used? — Yes.

4,006. That is the main coal staple? The main coal staple bottom.

4,007. That would be at the staple bottom, I suppose, for the purpose of looking after the tubs? — Yes, at the staple bottom.

4,008. How many of those paraffin lamps were there? — About two, I think.

4,009. I suppose they were the ordinary tin paraffin lamps? — Yes.

4,010. When was it usual to light them? — The master shifter used to light them when they started to hang on betwixt two and three o'clock in the morning in the winter time.

4,011. When they used to set on, were they invariably lighted? — They used to be lit all the daytime and all the night-time

4,012. When they were working? — When they were working; then they were put out when the night shift were down.

4,013. When the morning shift began they would be lit again? — Yes, the master shifter used to light them.

4,014. What time do you say that would be, between two and three? — Between two and three in the morning; not exactly that time, but somewhere about that time I would say.

4,015. Did you ever know any occasions when those paraffin lamps were not lit? — They were put out.

(The Coroner.) Mr. Jones, that is very wide.

(Mr. A. Jones.) I am speaking of what he knows from his own recollection.

(The Coroner.) But it is so wide; "Did you ever know any case when they were not lighted." You got it that they were generally lighted.

4,016. (Mr. A. Jones.) I will put the question in this form: Did you ever know any orders given that they should not be lit? — No.

4,017. You never knew that? — Never.

(The Coroner.) I should rather take it that they were always lighted.

4,018. You say that you left the pit at 11 o'clock on the morning prior to the explosion? — Yes.

4,019. When you left the pit did you see any more sign of danger in shot firing in that locality than you had at any other previous time? — I never did.

4,020. (Mr. Edge.) The only question I want to ask is this : — Here is Venner's shot that you spoke of; I think this is the position in which it was fired; did you go down as one of the exploring party, or did you go down to bring the men up? — No, I was not down for a week after the explosion.

4,021. Were you down when the man was found up this drift here? — I was not.

4,022. You were met there and you do not know anything about it? — No.

4,023. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) So far as you know or can judge, is it generally the feeling in the pit that it has been properly managed? — Properly managed?

4,024. Yes? — For aught I know.

4,025. You never heard any complaints of the management? — No.

4,026. Nor of want of timber? — No.

4,027. Nor of anything being wanting to keep the pit right and fairly worked? — No, I never did.

4,028. Have you any opinion of your own as to how this explosion happened? — I have an opinion, like anybody else.

4,029. But what is it; let us hear it? — My opinion is that she fired at the staple bottom with the paraffin lamps. That is my opinion if I must have an opinion.

4,030. You think that the gas was fired by the paraffin lamps at the bottom of the staple? — Yes.

4,031. How do you think the gas came there? — I think it had stolen out through the night.

4,032. Where from, do you suppose? — From the old workings.

4,033. Do not be afraid to tell us anything you have to tell? — I am not in the least afraid.

4,034. You think it came from the old workings? — Yes.

4,035. In the No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

4,036. You think it came out in the night from the goaf? — Yes, I think it stole out during the night.

4,037. And worked into the returns, do you suppose? — Yes.

4,038. Or into the in-take, which? — The returns.

4,039. Then how do you think it got from the returns into the in-take at the bottom of the staple? — It came out of the in-take at the bottom of the staple. It had stolen through there.

4,040. The staple is in the in-take, is it not? — No. 1 staple is not in the in-take.

4,041. It is in the return, is it? — Excuse me — the staple is in the in-take proper.

4,042. In your judgment did the gas work out from the returns into the in-take, so as to get to the bottom of the staple? — I think a quantity must have come away out of the goaf that night, stolen in through the door by the staple.

4,043. Do you understand this plan? — I never had a chance of seeing one. We never had a chance of seeing the plan.

4,044. You cannot understand it? — No, we never had a chance of seeing the plan.

4,045. Then do you think the gas first of all got into the returns at No. 3 Hutton seam? — Yes, I think so.

4,046. And followed the returns right up to No. 3 pit? — No ; to the staple bottom.

4,047. To the staple bottom only? — Yes.

4,048. Just try to bring your mind to this. I do not want to cross-examine you, but I want to know what it is you really think; the staple bottom is in the in-take? — Yes.

4,049. It is not in the returns? — No.

4,050. How would the gas, in your judgment, get from the returns into the in-take so as to reach the lamps at the staple bottom? — It would be quite possible to steal through the brickwork. The brickwork giving way, it would steal through the brickwork or come through the door.

4,051. What door? — The door through the staple bottom.

4,052. What brickwork would that be? — The doors are built of brickwork; all doors are built up with brickwork.

4,053. Is the old goaf of No. 3 Hutton to the rise or the dip from the staple? — To the rise.

4,054. So that it would have to work down. I do not for a moment say you are wrong, but supposing the gas had got into the returns, stolen out in the night, as you suggest, and so working its way along to get to the staple, it would have to pass through two doors if my plan is right? — Yes, it might be getting through the staple ; the brickwork it might get through in many a way.

4,055. Have you any reason to suppose that those doors were ever left open? — They are not left open.

4,056. They are not left open? — No, not to my knowledge — at least, they had no right to be left open.

4,057. Are they fixed when shut? — Yes; locked, I believe.

4,058. Always kept locked? — Yes.

4,059. You think the gas could have leaked through the brickwork round those doors, and so have got in there? — Yes.

4,060. That is the only theory you can form? — Yes, that is only my opinion; I have only an opinion, like everybody else.

4,061. That is your opinion; I am not questioning for a moment your right to hold it. Have you been over this part of the mine yourself to see how far the condition of things is such as you would expect to follow if it had happened in the way you suggest? — No.

4,062. Do you happen to know that those two doors which we have been talking of were blown away? — No.

4,063. In fact, you do not know anything about the symptoms? — No; I was not down there till a week after the explosion. I was employed at "bank."

4,064. Have you ever known gas come off in any considerable quantity from the old workings? — Yes, I have seen many times when gas has come off.

4,065. In the No. 3 Hutton? — Oh, no ; but through my experience I have seen gas come off.

4,066. (The Coroner.) But you must deal with this pit? — No, not there.

4,067. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) In no part of the colliery? — No.

4,068. Have you ever known gas get into in-takes in any part of this colliery? — I have seen a little — not anything of any consequence; I have seen a little gas in the in-takes.

4.069. Which in-takes? — In the Maudlin I have seen some.

4,070. What part of it? — I have been in to all parts of the Maudlin in-take.

4,071. I mean in what part of the Maudlin in-take have you seen gas? — The east side I have seen gas.

4,072. In the trolley ways? — No.

4,073. I am asking about the in-take? — No, I never saw any gas in the in-take.

4,074. That is all I am asking you about at present? — Oh, no, not there.

4,075. Never in any part of the colliery? — No, not of the in-take.

(Mr. A. Jones.) What do I understand? I understood him to say that he did see symptoms of gas in the in-take.

(The Coroner.) No, that is a mistake; it is in the returns.

(Mr. A. Jones.) That is a mistake.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) In the returns he has seen it — not in the in-take.

4,076. (Mr. A. Jones.) Do you know any water standages in No. 3 Hutton? — Yes, there is a water standage.

4,077. You know water standages in No. 3 Hutton? — Yes, I know where it is quite well, but I have never been in it.

4,078. Do you know of water standages in the Maudlin? — Yes.

4,079. Have you ever known gas on the water standages in the Maudlin? — No.

4,080. Do you go through, yourself? — No.

4,081. You do not know and cannot speak of your own knowledge. Have you ever heard of gas coming off into the intakes? — No.

4,082. I suppose there would be a strong current up by the staple? — Yes.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print