1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 5th January 1881.
The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 5th January 1881.
Seventh Day.
Jacob Steel sworn.
3,707. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A miner.
3,708. Where do you live? — Seaham Colliery.
3,709. (Mr. Jones.) You are a stoneman, I believe, are not you? — Yes.
3,710. You have worked at Seaham Colliery for 15 years? — I have worked 20 years from first to last, but I have been away part of the time.
3,711. You have worked for 15 years consecutively there? — No, I have only been back about 12 months.
3,712. Where were you before that? — I was at North Hetton.
3,713. How long were you from Seaham Colliery? — About six years.
3,714. Do you remember the 7th of September, the Tuesday? — Yes.
3,715. Did you on the day go down the pit? — Yes, at night.
3,716. What time? — 10 o'clock.
3,717. What part of the pit did you go to? — To No. 1 pit.
3,718. What seam? — Do you understand the plan? — Well, no one exactly.
3,719. What seam was it you went to? — It is a Hutton seam.
3,720. Down what pit did you go to that — No. 2 pit.
3,721. That will be the Harvey seam, will it not? — Yes; it is called a Hutton seam; it is a Hutton seam.
3,722. What were you doing down there that night? — Making waggon ways.
3,723. You were not, I believe, firing any shots? — No.
3,724. All went right for some time. Did you notice anything? — No, I did not notice anything.
3,725. What was the first thing you did notice — the first indication there was of anything having happened? — About 20 minutes after 2 o'clock in the morning I found a great whirl of wind, and the air changed.
3,726. Where were you then — how far from the shaft? — About 1¼ miles, I think.
3,727. You say the air changed. What do you mean by the air changed? — It slackened for about two minutes — two or three minutes.
3,728. Was the air altogether stopped apparently, or do you mean that it did not come with such force? — No, it was all still, and then a whirl of wind came; it was still about a minute or two, and then the whirl came.
3,729. A rush of wind? — A rush of wind.
3,730. Where were you? Were you in a main air way, or where were you at the time? — I was in the waggon way.
3,731. And did the wind come from the direction of the pit shaft? — Yes.
3,732. Who were with you at the time? — William Morris and Joseph Taylor, two miners.
3,733. After some conversation, I believe, what you did was, you went on working? — Yes, went on back to my work again.
3,734. Until what time? — Until about twenty minutes to four o'clock, I think.
3,735. When did this puff of wind take place — about what time, as near as you can fix it? — Twenty-five past two in the morning when it reached us.
3,736. Did you after that begin to observe any stythe coming in? — No; we went back to our work and were at it until 20 minutes to 4 o'clock; then we observed the stythe coming in; there was a bad smell coming in.
3,737. From what direction did it come? — Away from the shaft.
3,738. Then you made your way out up the No. 2 shaft? — Yes.
3,739. No. 2 seam drift you went to first? — We made our way to No. 2 shaft.
3,740. But you went first to the drift? — We came to the shaft, and then from the shaft took the drift.
3,741. Then did you get to No. 1 shaft? — Yes.
3,742. In getting to No. 1 shaft from No. 2 shaft, did you come across any falls? — Yes, not until we got up the drift away from the furnace.
3,743. Then you got on 1 Maudlin side of No. 1. When you get beyond the drift where did you come out? — We came out at the Maudlin side.
3,744. Before you got to the furnace coming through the drift up to the time you got to the furnace did you notice any falls? — No.
3,745. (The Coroner.) He says there were no falls until he got up the seam drift away from the furnace. — I noticed that the furnace doors were blown out.
3,746. (Mr. A. Jones.) In what direction were the furnace doors blown? — They were blown to the No. 1 side, out over across to the No. 1 side; the doors were entirely taken out altogether.
3,747. Would that be from the direction of the Maudlin? — Yes.
3,748. Were the doors lying down? — The doors were taken away — blown entirely out.
3,749. Were they broken? — Yes.
3,750. Going on from the furnace, did you come across anything else in your way? — Yes, a big fall.
3,751. Where was that? — That was about 50 yards from the No. 1 pit shaft.
3,752. What indications had you as to the direction in which the blast had gone — which way were the falls lying? — There were four or five tubs of furnace coal standing on No. 1 side.
3,753. Which side was that on? — Standing on the Maudlin side.
3,754. Did you notice any of the props? — Yes, the props were blown in over towards No. 1 side — the south side.
3,755. Did you make any observation at the time? — I said to the other men whom I was working with, "She has gone full across here;" that is, across the shaft to the No. 1 side, and she had taken the fore ends of the tubs right out.
3,756. The fore ends of the tubs were towards the No. 1 shaft? — She had catched the fore ends of the tubs and blown them across to No. 1 side.
3,757. What was the observation you made at the time as to the direction from which you thought it came? — Well, we thought she had come from the Maudlin.
3,758. Just say what you said you said to your mates? — I just said, "I think she has come from the Maudlin side here, she has blown everything towards this No. 1 side."
3,759. (The Coroner.) Did you say the explosion had come from the Maudlin side or the Maudlin seam? — From the Maudlin side.
(The Coroner.) It did not go any further than the Maudlin side.
3,760. (Mr. A. Jones.) Did you see anything that led you to think that it came from the Maudlin seam rather than from No. 3 Hutton? — I went into the cabin where the overseer was, and he was on his knees, kneeling down, much burnt. I lifted him up. The iron door that was in the cabin was blown right out along the drift towards the No. 1 side. I did not see the door, but the crooks that the door was hanging on.
3,761. Do you know the curve that goes to the Hutton? — Yes.
3,762. What side of the curve was this? — On the Maudlin side of the curve.
3,763. Was it before you got to the curve on your way to the shaft? — Yes, the curve was before we got to the shaft.
3,764. Was it where you saw these tubs and timber lying in towards the shaft — was that before you had got to the curve? — No, we had got round the curve.
3,765. Where you found the timber blown towards the shaft was between the curve and the shaft? — Yes.
3,766. What I asked you was this, Did you see anything to lead you to believe that the blast might not have come from No. 3 Hutton? — No, we did not see anything.
3,767. (The Coroner.) Did you see anything to prevent it? — No.
3,768. (Mr. A. Jones.) Did you see anything to prevent it having come from No. 3 Hutton? — No, we did not see anything; it might have come in that direction.
3,769. It might either have come from the Maudlin seam or from No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
3,770. What state was the place in? There was timber you have told us blown about — did you see dust in large quantities? — No. I did not see any dust; but the tubs standing at the shaft were all covered over with dust; there were three or four inches of dust just upon the tubs; I thought they were tubs of dust, until I found them and found there were coals underneath it.
3,771. You found that they were coals covered with dust? — Yes.
3,772. You did not notice what state the dust was in? — No, I did not take that much notice.
3,773. Were you able to notice whether the dust that lay on the timber was burnt or not? — No, I did not take so much notice.
3,774. I believe you found Laverick? — Yes.
3,775. Where did you find Laverick? — In the cabin.
3,776. Inside it? — Inside.
3,777. Where was Laverick — in the cabin, seated? — No, he was down upon his hands and knees on the cabin floor.
3,778. Did you see any part of the cabin that was injured? — Yes; the cabin was all broken up; the stove that was in it was all smashed up; there used to be a little stove in it.
3,779. Which side of the cabin was it that was injured? — The left side going in.
3,780. Was that the side you go in on your way to the shaft? — Yes; that is, the left side is towards you as you go into the cabin.
3,781. In what way was the injury to the cabin — how did it come? — The iron door was blown out.
(The Coroner.) According to him it all came in the same direction.
3,782. (Mr. Jones.) All in the same direction? — Yes.
3,783. Now, after leaving the cabin where did you go to? — Just sat down on the outside of the cabin.
3,784. Did not you go across the shaft towards No. 1 Hutton? — I went across a little bit from the tubs; I stepped off one on to another and went across so far.
3,785. How far did you get into the in-take of No. Hutton? — Not far; it may be about 40 or 50 yards.
3,786. Did you notice which way the things were lying there? — Yes.
3,787. Did you go to the crossing? — No, not in the bye crossing.
3,788. Did you see the same indications of the blast having travelled in that direction? — Yes, it travelled in the same direction.
3,789. In-bye? — In-bye all.
3,790. What did you see that led you think that? — I just saw the timber all blown out; it knocked all the things out, and tossed them to that side.
3,791. In what state was the air then? — It was in a good state just as usual. I did not see any difference.
3,792. You saw some tubs as you went in-bye to No. 1 Hutton? — As I came from the Maudlin side inbye.
(The Coroner.) Is that into the in-take?
(Mr. A. Jones.) Yes.
(The Witness.) As I was going across, the tubs were all cocked up one upon the top of the other.
3,793. Were they cocked up in-bye? — In-bye over.
3,794. Did you go up as far as the big fall? — Yes, as far as the No. 1 side; that is as far as I went; I durst not go any further.
3,795. There was a brick tunnel where you got to an arching? — No, I did not get to that.
3,796. But, before you got to the arching you found there was a fall? — Yes.
3,797. Between you and the arching? — Yes.
3,798. (The Coroner.) When you got to Laverick's cabin, did you see anything of a book lying about? — No.
3,799. You did not see a register? — No.
3,800. Did you know he kept a book in there? — Yes, I know he kept a book.
3,801. And you did not see anything of it? — No.
3,802. (Mr. Edge.) Did you see the furnace man? — Yes.
3,803. Where was he lying when you saw him? — He was lying half in under the furnace bars.
3,804. Would not that in itself indicate that the blast had gone towards the furnace? — I could not say which way it had gone.
3,805. You say you found the furnace man lying in under the bars; he would not be there unless he was blown in there? — Yes.
3,806. Would not that indicate that the blast had gone towards the furnace? — No, I think it came from the furnace.
3,807. How do you account for the fact that the furnace man was found under the bars? — I cannot say for that.
3,808. Were not the doors leading into the furnace blown in-bye towards the furnace? — No, taken out the other way.
3,809. Where did you say you saw the first tubs after you left the furnace? — On the Maudlin side, standing at No. 1.
3,810. Were they standing at the bottom of the pit? — Yes.
3,811. Close on to the shaft? — Close on to the shaft.
3,812. Then I suppose they were standing just where going from the Maudlin you would get to No. 1 shaft? — Yes.
3,813. And just about the place where you would get to if you were coming down from No. 1 pit towards the south? — The tubs were standing at the Maudlin side to go to the No. 1 furnace.
3,814. Was the timber you have spoken of that you saw there between the tubs and the shaft? — Yes.
3,815. Between the tubs and the pit's mouth? — Yes, the tubs were standing betwixt this big fall and the shaft; there was a big fall betwixt the shaft and the Maudlin way, you know.
3,816. The cabin you found Laverick in was close to the bottom of the shaft? — Close to the bottom of the shaft.
3,817. And the iron door, of course, is entered from the way, and on the left hand at the far end of the cabin is the iron door which was blown out? — Yes, it is on the left hand as you go into the cabin.
3,818. But it is at the far end of the cabin? — Yes, close to the far end.
3,819. That iron door would be blown out no matter whether the blast came from the Maudlin direction or from No. 1 direction? — I do not know for that — yes, it would be blown out any way.
3,820. It would be blown out by the blast coming into the cabin? — Yes, I should think it would.
3,821. I want to see how far you went along No. 1 in-take? — Forty or fifty yards.
3,822. You did not go to the first crossing? — Yes, I went to the first crossing.
3,823. Did you notice the bricks had been blown out at all? — The tubs were scattered about and the timber.
3,824. I am asking about the bricks? — I did not notice any bricks.
3,825. Between the shaft and the crossing did you meet any bricks on the way lying about? — No, not to take any notice of. I had a very bad light.
3,826. Where were the tubs you say you saw in No. 1 in-take? — The tubs from the Maudlin side; the ways lead right from the Maudlin side to the No. 1 side.
3,827. Were all these tubs you have spoken of together close to the bottom of the shaft? — Close to the bottom of the shaft, reaching from one side of the pit to the other.
3,828. You say you went as far as a big fall in No. 1. Where was that — how far did you go up? — The No. 1 side.
3,829. Did you turn into where the engineman was? — No, I was not up that far.
3,830. What kind of a fall was it — was it a fall of the brick arching or a fall of the roof? — Fall of the roof.
3,831. (Mr. Wright.) Did you go and see where Brown's body was? — I saw him when I was coming out from No. 3 shaft.
3,832. He was at a place where there was a refuge hole? — Yes, lying close to it.
3,833. Was he in the hole? — Not when I came to him.
3,834. How was he lying outside the hole? — Upon his back.
3,835. Which way was his head? — Out-bye; his feet would by lying close to the refuge hole at the outbye end.
3,836. Were his clothes on fire? — I could not tell that; I never examined them.
3,837. Did you notice at all whether he had been burned? — Yes, he had been burned a little.
3,838. Whereabouts? — About the breast, I think.
3,839. He was lying on his back? — Yes.
3,840. Was his face disfigured? — It was black ; you could not tell; it was all covered with muck.
3,841. Did he seem to be very much blown about? — No, he did not seem to be blown about at all, or else he would not have been lying there.
3,842. Did you notice how his blasting gear was standing? — No.
3,843. Did you see them at all? — Yes, his tools were standing by the side.
3,844. Against the wall? — Yes.
3,845. When you saw him? — When I saw him.
3,846. About the separation doors. Are you quite sure; which way do you say they were blown — the doors, you told us, were blown away? — They were taken out; they were blown in towards the No. 1 side away from the furnace.
3,847. Are you quite certain that they were not blown in towards the furnace? — Quite certain of it.
3,848. Which furnace are you speaking of? — No. 2.
3,849. And which doors are you speaking of? — No. 1; the doors are for No. 1 and No. 2.
(Mr. Wright.) Mr. Bell will ask him which doors he means.
3,850. (Mr. Bell.) Was it the three doors leading into the furnace from the No. 1 travelling arch, or was it the door straight down? — The doors on the left hand going into the furnace, not the doors straight down going to the No. 1 pit — it was the doors leading to the furnace.
3,851. Did you see the other three doors straight down? — No, I never saw them.
3,852. (Mr. Wright.) Were you in the pit in the year 1871, do you remember? — Yes.
3,853. Do you remember an explosion happening then? — I remember it happening in 1880.
3,854. I am talking of 1871 — nearly ten years ago? — No, I was not in then.
3,855. What parts of the colliery have you worked in besides the part that you were working in at the time of the explosion — have you ever worked in No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.
3,856. And No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
3,857. And the Maudlin? — Yes, and the Harvey and all.
3,858. Have you ever seen gas? — No, I never saw any gas, not in the Harvey.
3,859. Nor in any other part? — No.
3,860. Have you ever seen a cap on a lamp? — Yes.
3,861. Often? — Well, the cap is upon all the lamps.
3,862. No, I mean a cap of gas? — No, I never saw any at all.
3,863. All the time you were in the pit? — All the time that ever I was in the pit.
3,864. Was the ventilation good in your time always? — Yes.
3,865. (Mr. Wright.) I will ask the witness this question at once. I think it is a proper question to ask. I am going to ask all your men this question, Mr. Jones. (To the witness.) So far as you know, have there ever been any complaint amongst the men of the management of the colliery in any way? — I never heard them say anything.
3,866. Did they generally reckon it to be well managed? — Yes.
3,867. Was there ever any complaint that there was not enough money spent in the colliery, or anything of that sort? — Well, as regards that, there is always somebody complaining. It does not matter what it is, they are always complaining.
3,868. But was there ever any complaint of that sort? — You want to know what the majority of the men thought.
3,869. Yes, what the majority of the men thought? — Well, taking the majority, I never heard them say anything.
3,870. You think they were satisfied? — Yes.
3,871. What was the sort of complaint that you heard some of the men sometimes make? — I never heard none of them make any complaint at all.
3,872. Then I do not think that required that qualification you made just now. You told us something about tubs of dust? — No tubs of coal.
3,878. I thought you said tubs of dust? — Well, there was a little bit of dust covered over the tubs of coal.
3,874. Have you ever seen tubs of dust? — Yes, many a time.
3,875. They take it out in tubs? — Send it to bank.
3,876. Send it to bank in tubs? — Yes.
3,877. Regularly every day? — No.
3,878. How often? — They generally stow it down in the pit.
3,879. Stow in the goaf? — Yes.
3,880.? — Are you talking of fine coal dust which lies on the top of the timbers, or stuff which is really small coal — screenings? — Well, I really could not tell that.
3,881. Is it scrapings up from the trolly way — do you mean that? — Yes, I think it would be. It might be on the top of the tubs, or it might be the dust from the bags, or anything; I could not tell.
3,882. You came by the road out of the Maudlin as you came up did you? — Yes.
3,883. Did you hear men jowling? — I heard the men jowling down the pit.
3,884. In which pit? — No. 1 pit. I was in the No. 1 shaft then.
3,885. You heard them jowling in the No. 1 pit? — Yes, I walked down towards them. I heard them jowling and I jowled to them.
3,886. Did you ever hear any noise from the Maudlin? — No, not the least.
3,887. Not at any time? — No.
3,888. There were some men who came out alive from the Maudlin, were there not? — No.
3,889. From no part of it? — No.
(Mr. Edge.) They came alive out of No. 3 pit before the explosion. There was no one came out alive from the Maudlin after the explosion.
(Mr. Wright.) Out of no part of the Maudlin?
(Mr. Edge.) No.
3,890. (Mr. Wright.) There was nobody came alive after the explosion out of any part of the Maudlin? — No.
(Mr. Edge.) Will you ask him if he knows whether Brown's body was disturbed before he saw it?
(The Coroner.) Yes. We may take it that he saw some one put the fire out.
3,891. (Mr. Wright.). Did you know that Brown's body had been moved before you saw it? — No, I did not know.
3,892. (Mr. Bell.) Do you say that those three doors were blown in. Did you see the remains of the doors? — There were only two doors where I came out. I did not see the other doors straight down.
3,893. The doors into the furnace? — There are only two doors that leads into the furnace, I think.
3,894. We know of three; but did you see the remains of the doors — the deals — the boards — that they were broken up? — Yes, they were carried about.
3,895. That was just at the place where they had been blown from? — It was just at the place where they had been blown from.
3,896. From? — Yes.
3,897. And they might have been blown either in or out? — Well, I could not tell exactly which way the doors had been blown, because they had been broken right up, some lying in the middle of the road and some by the side.
3,898. (Mr. A. Jones.) You have spoken about the cabin and the direction in which the blast had come. You remember the position in which Laverick was sitting? — Yes.
3,899. If the blast had then come from No. 1 Hutton? — Well, it shifted itself about many times before we got to him.
3,900. Yes, no doubt; but in the position in which you saw him, supposing the blast had come from No. 1 Hutton, would it have blown that side of the cabin out in which he was then? — No.
3,901. It would not? — No.
3,902. That is solid. Assuming it not to have blown that side out, being solid, would it have injured him? Would it have blown him to pieces where he was then sitting? — I could not say that. It was a miracle that he was not blown all to pieces as it was.
3,903. You know the iron door of the cabin was blown to pieces? — Yes, it was blown right off the crooks.
3,904. Now take that iron door at the side. That was the side of the cabin, was it not? — Yes, it was at the side of the cabin.
3,905. That was blown out? — Yes, it was blown out.
3,906. Just think of what I am asking you. If the blast had come from No. 1 Hutton, would it have blown out that door? — If it had been at the other side, I think it would have blown right across to the Maudlin side.
3,907. Do you remember where the door was? — Yes.
3,908. Supposing the blast had come from No. 1 Hutton, would it have blown that door out? — Well, if the blast went into the cabin, it would have blown the door out.
3,909. To which side?
(The Coroner.) I do not think you can strengthen the witness's deposition, Mr. Jones.
(Mr. A. Jones.) No, I do not think so.
3,910. Is the Harvey seam the only seam you have worked in? — No, I have worked in other seams.
(The Coroner.) He has worked in three seams.
3,911. (Mr. A. Jones.) You have worked in three seams? — Yes.
3,912. Where were they? — I worked in the Hutton seam — No. 1 Hutton seam, I have worked in the Harvey, and I have worked in the No. 3 seam.
3,913. Have you ever noticed on any previous occasion a lull there, like that which you have spoken to? — No.
3,914. You never have? — No.
3,915. (Mr. Edge.) Can you see that (holding up a rough sketch to the witness)? — Yes.
3,916. You go into the cabin that way (pointing on the sketch)? — Yes.
3,917. This is your left hand and this is your right? Yes.
3,918. The door is about there? — Yes.
3,919. And there is a part of the wall here — Yes.
3,920. And behind the wall there is a seat? — Yes, along by the right side.
3,921. A seat a little bit back, so the iron door which you speak of is about there? — Yes.
3,922. And the seat on which the onsetter generally sits is about there, with that little protection there between him and the road outside? — Yes.
3,923. How far would the iron door be above the man's head where he was sitting on the seat? — About three feet.
3,924. He would be sitting here, and the iron door would be over there? — Yes, the iron door was right against him on the opposite side.
(Mr. Wright.). It might possibly save some time if I might make a suggestion. According to such limited experience as I have in these things, it does not very much matter what you find in any one particular place. It is always uncertain what the effect of a blast is in these cases. It depends on the whole evidence as to the state of things in the mine generally. It does not matter very much what you find at a particular place.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Clearly, at the same time, what I understand is this, that the indications, so far as they have hitherto gone, uniformly point to the blast having travelled in one particular direction.
3,925. What I want to ask you is about this door, you understand that is the entrance into the cabin (pointing out sketch)? — Yes.
3,926. And this would be where Laverick would be? — Yes.
3,927. And here is the door on the other side? — Yes.
3,928. And here is No. 1 Hutton up here? — Yes, and there is a drift leads away from that door to the No. 1 fire-hole.
3,929. Quite right. In which direction was that door thrown? — It was blown along the drift, towards No. 1 fire-hole.
3,930. Along the drift? — Yes.
3,931. If the blast had come from No. 1 Hutton, it would not have struck that door? — If the blast had came from No. 1 Hutton it would not have struck the door.
(The Coroner.) His opinion is that it would not. That is as far as you can get it.
(Mr. A. Jones.) Quite so. You understand what I mean, Mr. Wright.
(Mr. Wright.) Yes; I will go further if you like. I do not mind putting it stronger than you put it. If the blast had come out from No. 1 Hutton, it probably would have blown him all to bits, but that is not conclusive.
(Mr. A. Jones.) I do not say it is conclusive.