Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 21st October 1880 (cont.).

Mr. William Cummings re-called and sworn.

3,541. (Mr. Wright.) You recollect at the time when you first heard the explosion? — Yes.

3,542. I want to know, as near as possible — do you understand this plan? — No.

3,543. I want you to describe as near as possible where you were when you heard the explosion.

(The Coroner to Mr. Stratton.) Perhaps you will explain the plan to him.

3,544. (Mr. Wright.) First of all, which pit were you in? — No. 3 Hutton seam.

3,545. In the west way? — No, in the south.

3,546. Were you near the crossings at the landing? — No.

3,547. Further in-bye? — Further in-bye.

3,548. Much further in-bye? — Close up to the face — the west side.

3,549. That would be at the very end of the working? — Yes, somewhere about here.

3,550. On the face of the working, the second pillar? — From the right.

3,550a. What do you call this goaf near where you were? — Carr's goaf No. 1.

3,551. As you travelled out from that point, where was the first fall you came to? — In the main way.

3,552. Whereabouts in the main way?

(The Coroner.) Show the way you came, if you can.

3,553. (Mr. Wright.) You came back along the intake? — Yes.

3,554. You came back along the in-take till you came to the crossing by the landing? — No, not that far down. Close to where the stone is.

3,555. How do we describe that? A pillar up from the innermost crossing on the main in-take. That was the first fall you found. There are doors on each side — stoppings on each side? — Yes.

(Mr. Wright.) We may take it, sir, in this way, I think, most conveniently — that the first fall was just south in-bye of where the 13 bodies were found — 30 yards from the bodies beginning No. 7.

(Mr. Jones.) 30 yards south?

(Mr. Wright.) South of where the 13 bodies, beginning No. 7, were found?

3,556. (The Coroner.) Is that the point where they persisted in going to the shaft? You went into the return? — I did.

3,557. (Mr. Wright.) Then you came back in-bye along the in-take? — Yes.

3,558. And then turned into the return? — Yes, the west return.

3,559. And made your way out? — Yes.

3,560. Then the next fall —

(The Coroner.) Well, let us see that the witness understands it. Mr. Stratton, see that the witness understands what he is saying.

3,561. (Mr. Wright.) You can follow it when you are shown, I suppose? — Yes.

3,562. How many yards from the main coal door was the next fall you found? — Somewhere about 60 yards.

3,563. That would be where the body marked 13 was found? — Where we found the first body. It was through the two separation doors.

(Mr. Bell.) This place through the doors where your finger is, Mr. Wright.

3,564. (Mr. Wright.) That timber from the tubs — could you see which way it was blown? — In over.

3,565. In-bye? — South over.

3,566. Were there any other falls you came across before you got out? — Yes.

3,567. Whereabouts? — The next one we came to was the Maudlin, where the Maudlin engine is. We came to a wreck before that.

3,568. Where was the wreck? — (The witness explained, standing at the plan.)

3,569. About where the crossing is? — Yes.

3,570. Could you tell which way that was blown? — No, I could not say exactly.

3,571. Then you came to the engine plane? — Yes.

3,572. How was that? — The bricks were lying beside where the shaft is.

3,573. Towards No. 3 pit? — Yes, where the fall was, the timber was lying towards No. 1.

3,574. Towards No. 1 shaft? — Towards No. 1 shaft.

(Mr. Wright.) Very well, that is all I have to ask him.

3,575. (Mr. Jones.) From none of the falls could you form any idea as to which way the blast had come? — Well, not particularly, except this fall that I have mentioned where the Maudlin engine is. That is the only indication that I have.

3,576. That was the only place. What did that seem to indicate to you? — Well, where the timber was lying it was gone out over towards No. 1.

3,577. Gone over towards No. 1? — Yes, there.

3,578. That is the only indication you had? — That is all.

3,579. When you heard the explosion could you form any idea as to which direction it was coming from? — Well, it was coming in over.

3,580. Coming in over? — We felt the wind come in over. We found the smoke coming in over.

3,581. You found smoke coming towards where you were working? — Yes, we met the smoke directly.

3,582. How do you men "met" it? — As soon as the brattle went off there was a smoke.

3,583. Did you hear the brattle before you got the smoke? — No.

3,584. Felt the smoke first? — No, no.

3,585. What, then? — We heard the wind first, and then the brattle, and then the smoke.

3,586. You heard the wind first, and then you heard the noise of the explosion? — The brattle.

3,587. The brattle is the noise of the explosion? — Yes.

3,588. And then you felt the smoke? — Yes.

3,589. Can you at all indicate the length of time that elapsed between your hearing the wind and the smoke coming to you? — Well, I think the wind would last something like a quarter of a minute — the wind would; and the brattle followed directly in about another quarter of a minute. It sounded that long.

3,590. A quarter of a minute from the wind, and then the brattle a quarter of a minute? — Yes.

3,591. And then how long before the smoke? — Well, it was directly.

3,592. Directly after the noise of the explosion? — Yes ; as soon as ever we rose off our seats where we were sitting, and left our clothes, we met the smoke coming gradually in.

3,593. You did not feel any blast or anything of the kind near where you were? — Oh, no, just what I have told you — we had no fire there.

3,594. And you met no after-damp? — Oh, yes.

3,595. You met after-damp? — Oh, yes; we travelled in till we could not travel any farther.

3,596. But did you find the returns clear when you got into the returns? — The return was very clear.

3,597. Very clear? — Yes, till we got up to where the main return goes to the furnace; and then it was standing very thick.

3,598. Then it was very thick? — Yes, very thick there.

3,599. Was there a current of air going down the returns? — No.

3,600. No current? — No; there was a little coming downwards from the furnace, instead of going up.

3,601. Coming from the furnace? — Yes, travelling down from the furnace.

3,602. How far were you from the furnace — could you point it out? — Well, I could not say, I have never been at that furnace.

3,603. But whereabouts would that be on your way back? Would that be just as you come into the Maudlin in-take? — No, it is just as you come from the main coal staple.

3,604. Just as you were coming from the main coal staple you say. It was as you were coming along the main return that you felt the air? — That is not the main return — yes, that is the main return, of course. It is just there coming down from the furnace.

(Mr. Stratton pointing on the plan.) That is where you would catch it first, coming from the furnace, he says — there is the point where he would mean.

3,605. (Mr. Jones.) Well, that would be the return, would not it?

(Mr. Stratton.) Yes, sir, that is the main return.

3,606. (Mr. Jones.) Would that be where you caught the air? — Yes.

3,607. It would be? — Yes.

3,608. In the main return? — In the main return.

3,609. As it turns to the furnace? — Yes.

3,610. Was it coming a strong current then? — No, oh, no; very little air was coming — very little at all.

3,611. But there was a little coming? — A little was coming.

3,612. Can you tell — perhaps it is scarcely a fair question to ask, possibly, but could you tell at all whether the air was pure air that was coming, or waist mixed? — No, it was not pure.

3,613. It was not? — It was mixed with the smoke.

3,614. Had you noticed while you were working in the Hutton that night that the ventilation was at all slack — I do not mean that it was bad; but did you notice that the ventilation was less? — No ; we had better ventilation that night than we had the night before when we were working. The reason is because the place was a hole — a hole into one another.

3,615. Just at the spot where you were working. But I mean in the main in-take did you notice that the current was not so rapid? — I found no difference.

3,616. You found no difference? — No, not to take any notice — no; just as usual.

3,617. Have you noticed much coal dust in that part? — No; it is a new road.

3,618. In the main in-takes have you noticed? — No.

3,619. I am not speaking of where you were working? — No, not where I was working.

3,620. I am not talking about where you were working. In the main in-takes? — No.

3,621. Not much? — No.

3,622. Well, how much? — Well, I cannot say how much, but I never felt it very much.

3,623. I am not asking what you felt; but it lies on the ground, I suppose there? — Yes.

3,624. Can you give me any idea what depth it lies on the ground, because it is important? — Well, I could not say.

3,625. I do not mean to a hair's breadth. Does it lie to the extent of an inch? — I never found any coal dust flying except —

3,626. No, not flying. Just listen to the question.

3,627. (The Coroner.) I think you may take his answer. You never noticed any coal dust flying? — No, except when five or six were coming together and the young men might scrape it up.

3,627a. The young ones scraping their feet along, I suppose — doing it purposely? — Yes, just to blind the older people — they take a glory in it.

3,628. (Mr. Jones.) When they kick their feet, a cloud of dust flies up and blinds the older people? — Yes, that is when they kick it up; but I have not seen any dust lying to do any damage.

3,629. No, I am not asking you that. Answer my question — that is quite sufficient. Now, you know the timber? — Yes.

3,630. The timbering. How thick — I am not asking you to tell me within a hair's breadth, but I am asking you how thick the dust lies on the timber? — I have never seen any.

3,631. You never looked for it, I suppose? — No, I never looked for it.

3,632. I suppose the timbers are thick with coal dust, are they not? — Not always.

3,633. Not always? — Oh no.

3,634. When are they not? — Well, it has to be an old place that is standing; that is, black that way, with the air travelling through.

3,635. But I am asking about the main in-takes? — I have never seen any to my recollection.

3,636. But do you mean that there is no coal dust lying on the timbers, or that there is. Which do you mean? — Well, I cannot say. I have never seen it.

3,637. You never noticed it? — Never noticed it. It is a thing I never did notice.

3,638. It might be there without your noticing it? — Yes, it might be there.

3,639. You never had your attention directed to it, I suppose. When the tubs are travelling, when the set is on, does much dust fly there? — Sometimes there is much if the run is going hard.

3,640. On the night of the explosion you say smoke came. Did you notice dust flying too? — Where we were sitting both smoke and dust came.

3,641. Did they come in any great quantity? — Yes.

3,642. Thick? — Thick; there was coal like hazelwood nuts.

3,643. Some of it was big? — Big; yes.

3,644. It was mixed with coal dust — coal dust and small coal? — Yes.

3,645. How far were you in from the shaft? — Half a mile.

3,646. About half a mile in from the shaft, you were? — Yes.

3,647. Did you know of any shots being fired in the Hutton that night? — No.

3,648. You did not? — No.

3,649. I am speaking of No. 3 Hutton? — No.

3,650. That is where you were — No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.

3,651. You never heard of any shots? — No.

3,652. Being fired? — No.

3,653. Were you working broken long wall or boards? — It is whole working.

3,654. You were driving boards then? — Yes, boards and walls.

3,655. But is there any broken in the Hutton which is being worked? — There is a goaf each side.

3,656. Yes, I know. I do not quite follow you now. What I want to know from you is this: were you working broken workings in No. 3 Hutton? Was anybody? Were they being worked? — Well, there has been a lift or two taken off next the goaf — next the goaf side.

3,657. Can you tell me whereabouts next the goaf? Would that be west? — West ; the west side, two pillars from the face.

3,658. When was that being done? — Well, I think I was in that way a week before the misfortune — that side.

3,659. You were working on the broken, were you? — Yes, I was assisting the men.

3,660. Were you working from the goaf, or towards the goaf? — From the goaf.

3,661. How far had the goaf fallen from where you were? How much roof was behind you? — It was a close goaf; it was in our goaf.

3,662. But had it fallen in close by to where you were working? — No, there was about three yards.

3,663. From the goaf where you were working? — Yes.

3,664. While you were working there did you see, or did anybody see who was with you any gas? — No, not where we were.

3,665. Where was it that gas was seen, then? — Gas? We never saw any there.

3,666. No ; but did you hear of any near there? — Oh, no; not in that district.

3,667. Not in that district? — No, I never see any, nor heard tell of it. It lies out of my way, that.

3,668. Do you know what part they have seen it? — No, I never see any.

3,669. Have you heard the men speak frequently of gas coming out of the goaf? — No.

3,670. You never heard men frequently say gas was coming out of the goaf? — No.

3,671. Have you heard men speak of the gas frequently? — No, I have not been that long in it.

3,672. How long have you been in there? — About sixteen months.

3,673. Did you notice at the Maudlin which way the engine doors were blown? — No, I could not tell that now.

3,674. Did you pass by Laverick's cabin? — We came to it.

3,675. Was Laverick in it when you came? — Yes.

3,676. Which side of the in-take in Laverick's cabin? On the left, as you are making to the shaft, or on the right? — It is at the left of the bottom of the shaft, going in.

3,677. Going in-bye? — Left going in-bye.

3,678. Then it is to the right going out? — Yes.

3,679. Did you notice Laverick's cabin — whether it was much knocked about? — Well, all that I noticed was the iron door was taken out that goes into the boilers.

3,680. His cabin? — No, I did not take notice.

3,681. You did not take notice of his cabin at all? — No.

3,682. I ought to have asked you this: you told us about No. 1 and No. 3 engine, that there are main doors there. Is that so? — Yes.

3,683. Two main doors? — Yes, two main doors. I would not like to say.

3,684. And you spoke about seeing some timber there blown? — Yes; that is where the fall was.

3,685. Now, can you tell us what the condition of those main doors was? — No, I never saw them.

3,686. Were they gone? They had disappeared? — I never remember seeing them at all.

3,687. (Mr. Edge.) You have told us of meeting a little smoke in the main return? — Yes.

3,688. It was coming from the direction of the furnace? — Yes.

3,689. You do not know where it had got into the return? — No.

3,690. It might, of course, have got into the return if any of the stoppings had been blown away between the point where you were and the furnace? — I thought this over-cast was knocked down in the main way. It would come through that direction.

(Mr. Jones.) I am sorry my witnesses are not present just at the present moment. They will be here in a very few minutes.

(The Coroner.) Then, in that case we had better adjourn. I have to ask Mr. Stratton one question.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print