1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 21st October 1880 (cont.).
Mr. Robert Barlow called and sworn.
3,164. (The Coroner.) Which seam are you overman in? — The Maudlin seam.
3,165. You take the whole of the Maudlin seam? — Yes.
3,166. (Mr. Wright.) How long have you been in the Seaham Colliery? — Altogether about 16 years gone May.
3,167. You were there in 1871? — Yes.
3,168. Do you remember the explosion that happened in 1871? — Yes.
3,169. Tell us whereabouts that happened? — I cannot.
3,170. Was it never found out? — Not to my recollection.
3,171. You know nothing about it? — I know it was blamed for No. 2 bank-head.
3,172. (The Coroner.) Show us where that is? — I cannot on the plan.
3,173. Where is No. 2 bank-head? — Right up on the west way, No. 3 Hutton seam; it is not in the plan.
3,174. In the old west way? — Yes.
3,175. How do you mean that was blamed for it? — That is what was settled, I suppose, at the coroner's inquest.
3,176. That it was gas from there, do you mean? — Yes.
3,177. Is that what you do mean? — Well, yes.
3,178. (The Coroner.) Was there a shot fired near that point at that time? — Not that I am aware of.
3,179. (Mr. Wright.) Was the goaf blamed for the gas? — No, not that I am aware of.
3,180. How was the gas supposed to have come? — An outburst.
3,181. That is all you know about it? — Yes.
3,182. Both parts of the Maudlin, I think you said, are under your charge? — Yes.
3,183. When were you last over this, before the explosion? — I was in the west district the day before.
3,184. And in the east district, when? — The day before that.
3,185. Did they appear to you all right at those times? — Yes.
3,186. You saw no indications of gas? — Not the slightest.
3,187. Or of danger of any kind? — No.
3,188. (Mr. Edge.) Was it the 7th of September?
(Mr. Wright.) You were over the west side on the 7th September, and over the east side on the 6th? — Yes.
3,189. Your duties extend not merely over the Maudlin itself, but right round by the shaft? — Yes.
3,190. And the staple at the shaft? — Not the staple — not further than No. 3 shaft.
3,191. Is that curve in your district? — Yes, that is the way I go up the shaft.
3,191a. Do you not get in further east than No. 3 shaft? — I never go in further than by the shaft.
3,192. Let us have your report on gas; have you your book here? — Yes.
3,193. I find that on June 21st you found gas in the north side of the return, No. 3, gateway? — Yes.
3,194. "Loose jude" — what does that mean? "Loose jude falling very sore." What is the meaning of that entry? — I hardly think it would read that way.
3,195. "Loose jude?" — It might be the loose end of a jude.
3,196. What is that? — That is falling next the coal, and stopping the air from coming through.
3,197. How long was the air stopped there? — It might be a few hours; I cannot tell exactly.
3,198. July 19th, "Examined the south side return, and found gas in three cavities in air-ways, next to this?" — Yes.
3,199. Whereabouts in the return could that be? — Up there (pointing on the plan).
3,200. Near the long wall? — Yes.
3,201. Again, July 19th, "east long wall come on this morning, long headways, coarse; a great deal of water came away, and stopped the flat two hours?" — Yes.
3,202. There was no gas then? — No.
3,203. August 7th, "Deputies report gas in No. 3 gateway, eastward." That is the same place? — Yes.
3,204. The easternmost long wall of all? — Yes.
3,205. In this report book, August 18th is a off-work? —
(Witness.) That is the 19th.
(The Coroner.) "East broken and long wall good, except No. 2 gateway; found gas No. 3 gateway at night."
(Mr. Wright.) That is on the 23rd, according to what is before me. The dates must be wrong.
(The Coroner.) On the 18th of August the entry in the book is, "Half-work to-day. On the 19th he has got the report that you have there.
(Mr. Wright.) There must be some mistake in the date.
3,206. (The Coroner.) Can you find the next entry of gas after August 7th? — The 18th is, "Off work Sunday morning."
3,207. The next is, "East broken and long wall good, except No. 2 gateway?" — The 19th, that is Monday.
3,208. You have told us that you did make the reports which I read; therefore whether they are in the book or not, the gas was there. When did you find the gas in the east long wall? — On Monday.
3,209. What Monday? — Monday the 19th.
(Mr. Wright.) It is not in the book on Monday the 19th.
(The Coroner.) I do not know how your abstract has been made, but I should take it that there is a clerical error in the abstract.
(Mr. Wright.) He tells us that on two occasions he found gas in No. 3 gateway, and now he says it was on Monday the 19th.
(The Witness.) That was the first indication. There is the next indication (referring to the report book), the 23rd.
3,210. "Gas in No. 2 gateway all night, and was free from gas when I left at three in the morning." Then, August 24th, "East broken and long wall good and free from gas." Was there much gas in the Maudlin during the last three months before the explosion? — No, not a great deal.
3,211. Did you find it in other places besides the ones you pointed out? — No.
3,212. Have you been over the Maudlin since the explosion? — I have been about there in the west way, and I have been down in the east way.
3,213. That is only a little way — a few yards into the east way? — Yes, 700 or 800 yards from the shaft.
3,214. Take the west way; most of the men were alive there for some time; could you see any indication which way the blast had gone there? — According to my indications, it went here (pointing).
3,215. Take the east way; were there any indications as to which way the blast had gone there? — The first day when I went in, on the 8th, when I first went I found timber lying up in that direction.
3,216. In-bye? — Yes.
3,217. As if it had been blown in-bye? — Yes, that way.
3,218. The timber over the air crossing? — Yes, at this end, laid down against the wall.
3,219. Did you see any other signs? — No; I did not go down beyond this at that time. I had to retreat back again.
3,220. You are sure you saw no other since that time? — No, not at that time.
3,221. Did you begin afterwards? — Yes, about half an hour.
3,222. What did you see then? — Mr. Turnbull and I went in, and there were bricks blown that way in-bye — the inside of the over-cast going to the east.
3,223. Did you see anything else at that time? — No.
3,224. At any other time afterwards? — I never saw any further sign.
3,225. (The Coroner.) All the indications as far as you have seen in the Maudlin have gone in over? — Yes, to the best of my knowledge.
3,226. Have you known a cap shown in the returns, or in any other part of the east Maudlin? — No, not the slightest.
3,227. Say, within a year? — No.
3,228. Never anything of the sort? — No, I have never found it.
3,229. How often do you travel the returns? — You will find it in the report book.
3,230. Once a week? — Sometimes oftener, sometimes twice a week — it depends upon circumstances.
3,231. You do not go over the whole of the returns? — It may be half at a time.
3,232. What do you carry with you — a Davy? — No, a Clanny.
3,233. That does not show a cap so readily as a Davy, does it? — Yes.
3,234. So far as you have noticed, you have never found any gas in them at all? — Not in these east returns.
3,235. Nor in the west? — I have found a little in the west here, but very little.
3,236. Between the two walls on the west side? — Yes, I was in one morning travelling, and I found some.
3,237. How long ago? — I cannot say.
3,238. Three months before the explosion? — More.
3,239. Six months? — I cannot say.
3,240. That is close to the face? — No; perhaps 200 yards from the facing.
3,241. Had there been any shot fired in the Maudlin the night of the explosion? — Yes.
3,242. Whereabouts? — Three or four shots were fired in that drift previous to the explosion. The men gave over about one o'clock.
3,243. How would you describe that drift? — The drift from that (pointing on the plan).
3,243a. (The Coroner.) Is it west or east? — To the bottom of the incline.
3,244. (Mr. Wright.) In the main in-take? — Off the main in-take.
3,245. Just at the bottom of the incline? — Yes.
3,246. How many shots? — There might be three or four that night; it depends upon circumstances.
3,247. You say they were all fired before one o'clock? — Yes.
3,248. Were you down there yourself that night at all? — No.
3,249. How do you know the men were out? — I saw them.
3,250. Where else were shots fired that night? — James Brown fired shots somewhere about here (pointing).
3,251. Where No. 1 body was found? — Yes.
3,252. That is the shot we have heard of? — Yes.
3,253. You do not know that he fired it; all you know was that it was fired? — Yes.
3,254. That was not cleared away at all? — No; it is lying yet.
3,255. How soon in the ordinary course would the stuff be cleared away after a shot had been fired? I am speaking of that particular place? — It might be left two or three days there.
3,256. The other shots you told us of were at the stone drift? — Yes.
3,257. Were any other shots fired in the Maudlin on either side that night? — No.
3,258. None on the east side? — No.
3,259. When were the last shots before the explosion fired on the east side? — About seventeen or eighteen months ago.
3,260. Does your district extend to Venner's place? — No.
3,261. Whose district is that in? — Weatherall's.
3,262. You just go to a level with No. 3 pit? — Yes.
3,263. Is there much dust in the Maudlin? — A little.
3,264. Much coal dust? — Of course, going along a travelling road there is a little dust lying.
3,265. What do you mean by a little — several bushels of it in a hundred yards? — There might be dust lying there a quarter of an inch or half an inch thick.
3,266. How wide? — An inch or two lying just near the edge of the stone.
3,267. Have you seen the air filled with dust in any part of the pit? — I have seen a little flying from the engine set as it has been travelling by.
3,268. Whereabouts would that be? — Along here from the set (pointing).
3,269. That is the only thing that you have seen that has made the dust fly in clouds? — Yes.
3,269a. Did you examine yourself the places where these shots were fired before leave was given to fire them? — Yes.
3,270. When did you examine them? — I examined this on the morning I went in.
3,271. That is the 7th? — Yes.
3,272. (The Coroner.) Where Brown was? — Yes.
3,273. (Mr. Wright.) And the other place where the stone drift is? — I did not examine there before they fired the shot; the men themselves examined that before the shots were fired.
3,274. That is contrary to the rules, is it not — No.
3,275. Shots are allowed to be fired in the stone drift without the place being examined by anybody but the man who fired? — The man is authorised to examine by Mr. Stratton.
3,276. The men who are to fire them? — Yes.
3,277. Was that place examined by Mr. Stratton before he gave leave to fire? — No.
3,278. On whose examination and report would leave be given to fire the shots there? — I apply to Mr. Turnbull.
3,279. Would he examine it? — I do not know exactly whether he would examine it.
3,280. The man who wants to fire the shot comes to you; is that it? — He comes to the master shifter.
3,281. And the master shifter comes to you? — Yes.
3,282. Does he tell you that he (the master shifter) has examined it? — He will examine it?
3,283. He will tell you that he has examined it and that it is all right? — Yes.
3,284. Then you go to Mr. Turnbull and tell him that the master shifter has examined it? — I might.
3,285. What is the use of his coming to you if you do not take means to find out whether it ought to be fired? — We might make an examination of it previous to firing the shot, before we give leave.
3,286. But you think there it is unnecessary? — It is almost unnecessary to examine it.
3,287. You did examine it in this case before the shot was fired? — It is a long time since we stopped firing there.
3,288. Who ought to have examined it? — I do not exactly know.
3,289. You must give me an answer; it is your business to know about these shots. Whose duty was it to examine? — The master shifter would be the responsible man at night before the shot was fired.
3,290. This was at night, was it not? — Before the first shot is fired in a place.
3,291. Take this particular case. You know where the shot was fired, and you gave leave to fire it; I want to know whose business it was to examine the place before leave was given to fire the shot? — The main shifter.
3,292. Which? — The one that was in that night — Walter Murray.
3,293. Is he here? — No.
3,294. Is he lost? — Yes.
3,295. Taking the mine where Brown's shot was — is there any place near there where the gas could have collected in any way? — Not that I am aware of.
3,296. Any lofting or anything of that sort? — No. There might be a foot above the baulks; there is no loft over it.
3,297. There is about a foot above the baulks? — Yes.
3,298. You would not call that a lofting? — No.
3,299. Are there many parts of the mine where there is a cavity of a foot or so above the baulks? — Yes.
3,300. Many places? — Yes.
3,301. Would that place be ventilated in any way? — We have only the natural ventilation coming in-bye.
3,302. The natural ventilation would be above the baulks? — Yes, it would work over the baulks.
3,303. Is there anything put to turn the ventilation over the baulks? — No.
3,304. The baulks would be close together? — No; a foot or 18 inches. Each baulk bears its own weight.
3,305. Except that, you know of nothing? — Nothing else.
3,306. Where the gas could possibly be collected? — No.
3,307. Could it collect anywhere near the Maudlin engine? — Not that I am aware of.
3,307a. Do you know of the practice of shot-firing in this mine, in any part of the colliery having been discontinued for a time? — And commenced again?
3,308. Yes? — No.
3,309. There were never several months or years that people were prohibited from firing shots? — I do not know.
3,310. No, not in any part of the mine? — No, not to continue.
3,311. Then we will take the part where they never did continue again. Was it stopped for good and all in any part of the mine? — The firing stopped there (pointing.)
3,312. How long ago? — I cannot say.
3,313. A year ago? — It might be.
3,314. Not two years? — I cannot say exactly, it might be 12 months.
3,315. (Mr. Jones.) What part is that? — The west incline.
3,316. (Mr. Wright.) Between the two long walls? — Yes.
3,317. Why was it stopped there? — We found the doors standing open one morning. I went away, and I found some gas in some place by means of the doors being opened.
3,318. Do you know how the doors were opened? — No.
3,319. Somebody's negligence, I suppose? — Yes.
3,320. Do they not close of their own accord? — They ought to have been blocked.
3,321. Somebody must have propped them open? — Yes.
3,322. After that you thought it not safe to fire shots in that part of the Maudlin? — Yes.
3,323. Was there much gas collected at that time? — Yes, there was a fair bit.
3,324. Enough to be dangerous? — Yes.
3,325. Point out the spot where gas collected at that time? — There (pointing.)
3,326. Would that be near the incline wheel? — That has been shifted now.
3,327. Is there any other part of the mine where shot-firing has been stopped altogether? — Yes, there (pointing.)
3,328. That is in the east Maudlin? — Yes.
3,329. About how long ago is it since shot-firing was stopped there? — 17 or 18 months, as near as I can guess.
3,330. Was that because of gas? — No, because we stopped working, and turned it into the long wall.
3,331. Would that make it proper to stop firing shots? — It is in the broken.
3,332. And you thought it unsafe? — Yes, of course.
3,333. Of course it is unsafe to fire in the broken? — It might be or not; it is no part of the colliery.
3,334. So far as you know, was there any other part of the colliery, in any of the pits, in which shot-firing was stopped? — No, I cannot say that I do.
3,335. Is there no part of the colliery in which shots are fired in the broken? — Not that I am aware of; I think not.
3,336. Do you go along No. 1 at all? — Yes.
3,337. Did you form any judgment which way the blast had come? — Yes.
3,338. Tell us what your conclusion was? — The first thing that struck my attention was in No. 1 shaft. I observed the same thing that Miller spoke about — blowing to the north.
3,339. That is out-bye — what was it blown? — The shield of a wheel that Miller spoke of.
(Mr. Jones.) Is that the tyre?
(Mr. Bell.) A sheet to protect it.
3,340. (Mr. Wright.) Coming further in-bye what was the next thing? — I observed the timber lying in that direction.
3,341. In-bye? — Yes.
3,342. (The Coroner.) Where? — To the north.
3,343. (Mr. Wright.) Where? — The shaft bottom.
3,344. What was the next thing? — The bricks were blown out-bye in the overcast.
3,345. (The Coroner.) Where is the overcast?
(Mr. Wright.) The first air-crossing.
3,346. The bricks would be blown out-bye? — Yes.
3,347. Going still in-bye, what was the next thing? — There was a two-foot wheel slipped 10 or 15 yards out-bye.
3,348. From where? — I could not say. It seemed as if the wheel had slidden away, and in sliding, the hay had swept the road.
3,349. Was there anything to show you that the wheel had slid, or only that the hay had brushed the floor? — I looked, and I thought it had come from a place further in?
3,350. The wheel? — Yes, the wheel and all; five or six yards beyond.
3,350a. You thought that the wheel had come from the stables? — No; from five or six yards beyond. I thought the hay had come from the stables.
3,351. Going further, what was the next thing? — When I got here (pointing) I thought it had gone both ways.
3,352. (The Coroner.) The polka way end was the first indication that it had gone both ways? — Yes.
3,353. (Mr. Wright.) Did you notice any tubs? — They were blown all to bits.
3,354. Which way? — I thought out-bye.
3,355. Did you go into the travelling way? — Yes, I went to the deep point along with Turnbull.
3,356. Were there any signs there? — I thought it had gone in.
3,357. Between the two stables? — Yes.
3,358. Show me where you are talking of now? — Here are the stables (pointing). When I got to these two stables I thought it had gone this way.
3,359. (The Coroner.) Which stables are those? — No. 1.
3,360. (Mr. Wright.) You are talking of No. 2 west stables? — I do not know what they call them.
3,361. (The Coroner.) What were the indications there? — The hay blown in over.
3,362. (Mr. Wright.) On the other side of these stables in the travelling way — in the same stables — did you notice any indications which way it had gone? — Well, I could hardly say from here, but from here I think it was blown both ways.
3,363. From the junction between the travelling way and the main in-take — that is, about half way between the two sets of stables — you thought it had gone both ways? — Well, I could not form any opinion.
3,364. You could not form any opinion? — No.
3,365. I thought you said just now you did form an opinion — which do you mean? — I did not form any opinion which way she had gone from there to there. I could not say.
3,366. But above the junction you formed an opinion that it had gone out-bye, did you? — Yes.
3,367. And below the junction you formed an opinion that it had gone in-bye? — Yes.
3,368. There is a bit of about two or three hundred yards that you could not say about? — Yes.
3,369. (The Coroner.) The evidence to you from what you saw was neither in-bye or out-bye? — For that bit.
(Mr. Wright.) Between the junction and the second west stables.
3,370. (Mr. Jones.) Of this you are clear — that the tubs were gone in-bye? — At the shaft.
3,371. Yes, were blown in-bye — that Miller spoke to, you know? — Yes; but I did not say they were in-bye. I said they were blown out-bye.
3,372. (The Coroner.) Both of them were out-bye? — Out-bye as far as I could judge.
3,373. (Mr. Jones.) The tubs were said to appear by the last witness to go in-bye — you think the tubs were blown out-bye? — Yes.
3,374. What makes you think that? — Well, they were lying more in a heap to the north than they were to the west.
3,375. What do you mean, "more in a heap?" — More together — more rubbish lying together.
3,376. Were they piled up? — Yes; they were more piled up to the north than they were to the south.
(Mr. Wright.) Are you talking of the same set of tubs? They may be different tubs.
(Mr. Jones.) Let us see; let us test them then.
3,377. Proceeding in-bye, did you find any tubs which would indicate to you that they had been blown in-bye? — No.
3,378. Were they the only tubs? — Yes, the only tubs that I saw.
3,379. Were they all broken to bits? — No, I do not suppose they were.
3,380. (The Coroner.) Were those trucks standing in the dish? — They were lying just at the top end of the dish.
3,381. They were the same that Miller alluded to? — I do not know.
(Mr. Jones.) They must be; only sir, perhaps Miller could say if there are any other tubs.
3,382. There were no other tubs you say you saw? — Not about there.
3,382a. Were there any other tubs between the shaft and the hay? — There were some more down just there, but none there (pointing.)
3,383. Just attend to my question. I say between the shaft and the hay? — No, not that I see.
3,384. I suppose you would have seen them if there were any? — Well, I might; probably I might.
3,385. Do I understand you to say that you judge because they were piled up? — Yes.
3,386. How do you mean, "more piled up." I do not understand your answer? — Well, they were laid up more in a heap at the out-end more than they were at the in-end — all jammed up together that way.
3,387. Against what were they jammed? — Against one another.
3,388. On the top of one another? — Yes; broken to bits on the top of one another.
3,389. Were they all broken? — Well, I do not know exactly whether they were all broken about the shaft or not ; but they were all broken there.
3,390. At any rate you won't form any positive opinion, is that so? — Well, that is my —
3,391. Why — do you disagree entirely with what Miller says? — Yes.
3,392. You do? — Yes.
3,393. Now, will you kindly point to where shotfiring was prohibited about seventeen months ago in the east way of the Maudlin, where the broken was, you know? — There (pointing.)
3,394. Just show how far it extends south, please, carefully? — That is north.
3,395. Yes, I know. Show how far it extends south, I say, where the broken is being worked, and the shot firing prohibited? — I do not understand you.
3,396. Show me how much of the workings it extends to. Over how much of the workings was shot-firing prohibited? — Well, just there, look you (pointing.)
3,397. Not any further south than that? — No.
(The Coroner.) And he gave you the reason, Mr. Jones — because they were altering.
(Mr. Jones.) I quite understand that, Sir.
3,398. Is the broken being worked there now? — We were working long wall working.
3,399. You were working the broken? — Yes.
3,400. Will you point out to me the exact position of that stone drift? — I cannot.
3,401. Well, whereabouts, as near as you can? — Well, it should be, understand, of this.
3,402. You now told us that four or five shots were being fired that night? — Yes.
3,403. Where were these shots being fired? — Along there (pointing.)
3,404. Was any shot being fired that night down in the east way of the Maudlin? — No.
3,405. No shot at all? — No.
3,406. Underneath. Just explain that again please, will you. You say it was being fired underneath what? — Underneath this. It was going underneath this. This is the Maudlin seam, and we are going down to the Hutton seam there.
3,407. Then it was a drift from the Maudlin to the Hutton? — From the level of the Maudlin to the Hutton seam.
3,408. Can you tell me the names of the men who fired those shots? — Well, I can tell you six of them.
3,409. Oh, there were six men? — Yes.
3,410. How many shots were there fired, do you know? — That night?
3,411. Yes, by these-six men? — I could not say. I only made a guess. There might have been four.
3,412. There might have been more? — No, there could not be any more.
3,413. Why not? — Because they never drill any more holes than two a piece — never fire any more shots than two a piece.
3,414. Well, if there were six men, that might be twelve shots? — Yes, in the twenty hours.
3,415. There might have been twelve shots fired? — There might.
3,416. Then why did you say three or four. There might have been twelve. You do not know how many were fired. Now will you tell me the names of the six men? — Yes, William Hardy — ---
3,417. I will just ask you first, are these men alive? — Yes, at least, I expect all alive. Mat. Robson, George Wanless, William Plews, John Mason, Robert Wilson.
3,418. How long is it since you had a blue cap showing in any part of the Maudlin seam? — Somewhere about the 23rd August, I think.
3,419. The 23rd August? — Yes, I think so.
3,420. Will you tell me what part the blue cap showed? — Yes. There and there (pointing.)
3,421. You do not make any report of it in this book do you — of the gas showing the 23rd August.
3,422. (The Coroner, reading.) Ten o'clock at night, found gas in No. 2 gateway all night ---? — There is "two" for "one" there. I beg your pardon.
(Mr. Jones.) Wait a moment.
(The Coroner.) "23rd August, at ten o'clock at night, found gas in No. 2 gateway all night, and free from gas when I left at three o'clock in the morning.
3,422a. (Mr. Bell.) Is that "all night" or "all right."
(The Witness.) "All right," it should be.
(Mr. Wright.) "All right, and free from gas."
3,423. Just point out where it was, please.
(Mr. Jones.) Just point out on the plan the spot? — Yes, there you are (pointing).
3,424. (Mr. Wright.) That is long wall? — Yes.
(Mr. Jones.) Yes; that was all broken.
(Mr. Wright.) East long wall.
(Mr. Jones.) Yes.
3,425. Now, that was the last time you heard of a blue cap showing. Now, previous to that, what was the last time. Any other time that you heard? — Yes.
3,426. Where? — There (pointing).
3,427, Is that in this book? — Yes; I think it will be there.
3,428. When would that be? — Well, I am sure I do not know. It would be in the book.
(Mr. Wright.) "There" conveys no meaning on the notes at all. North-west of the Maudlin against the long wall.
3,429. (Mr. Jones.) Was this broken being worked there? — Yes.
3,430. Now the whole of the north-west Maudlin and the north-east Maudlin, is it broken? — Yes.
3,431. It is all broken? — Yes.
3,432. Now perhaps I had better put the question to you. When did you last hear of a blue flame showing in the north-east Maudlin? — On the 23rd August; I think it is there.
3,433. Just point me there in the north-east Maudlin? — There (pointing).
3,434. I do not mean there. Perhaps I ought to have said further up north, where the stone drift is? — There?
3,435. Yes: when did you last ---? — I never see none at all.
3,436. I do not mean exactly there, but about that region. When did you last hear of gas showing a blue cap? — I never see any at all there.
3,437. No, but when did you last hear? — I do not know.
3,438. Just try and cast back your memory? — If anybody else had said it was there or found it was there I should have known.
3,439. Have you ever heard of gas showing a blue cap in the north-east Maudlin — that part I told you? — About here? (pointing.)
3,440. Anywhere — yes, higher up? — No.
3,441. You never have? — No, not about there.
3,442. Well, where is the nearest to these that you have heard of it? — There.
3,443. That is another place; you have not shown me that before? — No, but I showed this gentleman.
3,444. How long is it since you have had gas reported to you in the neighbourhood of the new stone drift? — Never.
3,445. Never what? — Never heard it reported.
3,446. Never heard of any gas being there? — No; not about there.
3,447. That is the same character, is it not? It is all broken wall close to the drift? — Well, that is a long way from there to there (pointing.)
3,448. Yes; it is all broken wall, I say, near the drift, is not it? — I do not understand you.
3,449. The workings are broken — the long wall I ought to say. Are the long wall workings near the drift? — Yes; beyond the drift, and the east of the drift.
3,450. How many hewers were down in the pit by this shift? — On the 8th?
3,451. Yes? — About fourteen, I think.
3,452. In the pit altogether, I mean. In the Maudlin seam, I mean, that is your seam? — Well, somewhere about 150, I should think, as near as I can guess — 153 or 154.
3,453. Hewers or shifters? — Hewers.
(Mr. Bell.) You are confusing the night shift with the day shift.
(Mr. Jones.) Perhaps I am.
3,453a. I mean at the time of the shots being fired — how many hewers were down in the pit? — Forty-three or four.
3,454. That is what I want, forty-three or forty-four hewers. Now there are two sets of stables — there are some in the east Maudlin, and some near to the shaft. Are those in the east Maudlin used? — Yes.
3,455. They are? — Yes.
3,456. Do you know of four men going down — four horse keepers going down? — I hear tell of them.
3,457. You only heard tell of them? — Yes.
3,458. Do you know what stables they were going to? — One I knew. Two of them were going to mine.
3,459. Which are yours? — There is one (pointing.)
3,460. In the east way? — Yes.
3,461. In the east Maudlin? — And there is the other.
3,462. (The Coroner.) Two horse keepers shortly before the explosion would be going to your Maudlin stables? — Yes.
3,463. (Mr. Jones.) You have heard that they were carrying large tin lanterns? — Yes.
3,464. Then you allow tin lanterns — these naked lights — you allow them to be used on the main in-takes to the stables? — Yes.
3,465. All the way? — Yes.
3,466. Both day and night? — Yes.
3,467. Which way would they go — would they go down the in-take? — Go from No. 1 direct this way; one would go down there, look you into that stable, and one go this way (pointing).
3,468. That is not an in-take is it? — Yes.
3,469. But is not there a return to get to the stable? — Yes; but it only goes that way.
3,470. Does not he go by the return to get into the stable? — No.
3,471. Or the other stables? — No.
3,472. Oh, all in-take? — All in-take.
3,473. You know nothing about the firing of these shots? You had nothing to do with it — those shots which you do not know the number of? — No; the men fired them themselves.
3,474. Do you know who authorised these men to fire them? — Mr. Turnbull authorised me to give orders to the master shifters.
3,475. Then you gave orders to the master shifter? — Yes.
3,476. And is he dead? — Yes.
3,477. He is killed? — Yes.
3,478. (Mr. Edge.) Where is the caution board on the east way down there? — Somewhere about here (pointing).
3,479. Then the stables to which these two men were going in the east way would be on the out-bye side of that caution board? — Yes; one was going to here, and one to there.
3,480. My friend has asked you whether you allowed naked lights on the whole of the in-takes. I suppose naked lights are not allowed beyond the caution board? — No.
(Mr. Jones.) Oh, yes, that was given in evidence. I meant as far as the stables.
3,480a. (Mr. Edge.) You have told us there were 43 or 44 hewers down at the time these shots were fired? — Yes.
3,481. What were they doing? — They were hewing coal.
3,482. Were they digging up the coal? — Yes.
(Mr. Jones.) He has answered the question.
(Mr. Edge.) I thought I was cross-examining the witness.
3,483. What were they actually doing? Were they filling the boxes? — They were hewing and filling them.
3,484. The stone drift where shots were fired — has that got a separate return of its own? — Yes.
3,485. Does it pass over any other working place? — No.
3,486. You have been asked about shot-firing being prohibited. I do not know whether you quite know what the meaning of "prohibited" is. Do you know that shot-firing was forbidden, or that shot-firing was simply discontinued? — Discontinued.
3,487. As a matter of fact, there was no actual prohibition? — No.
3,488. At the time that the shots were fired in the district, was the coal hard to be worked? — Yes, very hard.
3,489. And when the shots were discontinued had you got into kinder coal? — Yes, we had got into the coal called "canny."
3,490. You have spoken about a doorway being propped open? — Yes.
3,491. My friend has put it to you whether that door was left open by mistake. In your judgment as an overman, would the door be left open by mistake — propped open? — I do not think it was a mistake; I believe it was maliciously done.
3,492. You believe it was maliciously done? — Yes.
3,493. There was an inquiry into it, was not there? — There was.
3,494. And I believe a large reward was offered by the proprietor of the colliery? — There was.
3,495. For any information leading to the conviction of the person who had done it? — Yes.
3,496. Now, as to the in-bye stables — you know, No. 1, that you were speaking about — you say there were indications there of the blast going in-bye? — Yes.
3,497. That is in-bye along the travelling way? — Yes.
3,498. There is a passage from the travelling way through into the engine-plane, is not there? — Yes.
3,499. Near the stables? — Yes.
3,500. Which end of those stables did the hay stand at? — Well, that I cannot say.
3,500a. You do not know? — No.
3,501. Now, the indications that you have spoken to at the in-bye stables — they were merely indications at the stables along the travelling way? — Yes.
3,602. Just point out on the map where it was that you said that you had seen a little dust fly in the Maudlin? — Along here (pointing).
3,503. Do you know whether any sets were running at the time of the explosion? — Yes; a set was at the time.
3,504. Where? — Going up here.
3,505. At the time of the explosion? — Oh, no; I beg pardon. I do not know that, I mean the dust.
3,506. When was the pit done that night — when did they cease running the sets? — Well, I am sure I would not like to say exactly the time — somewhere about 12 o'clock I should think.
(The Coroner.) You wanted a question put, Mr. Jones?
(Mr. Jones.) Mr. Wright will put it.
3,507. (Mr. Wright.) Just calling your attention for one moment to the place of the old west way of No. 3 Hutton, where there was an explosion in 1871 — the place where that happened in 1871 is goaf now, is not it? — Yes.
3,508. (The Coroner.) For what distance away — how far into the goaf? — A quarter of a mile or more.
(Mr. Wright.) The place where the explosion happened in 1871 is now a quarter of a mile into the goaf.
3,509. One question about your long walls — are you working those three pieces of long wall in the Maudlin now? — Yes.
3,510. You are working them outwards, I suppose? — No; working them inwards.
3,511. Do you stow these pieces that are coloured black? — Yes.
3,512. Stow them full? — Yes.
3,513. Where do you get the stuff from? — We get the stuff from the falls.
3,514. You build up the retaining walls to keep the stowage in the goaf? — Yes.
3,515. And stow it up close to the roof? — Yes.
3,516. Quite close? — Quite close.
3,517. You do not leave any air-way over the top? — No.
3,518. You fill the stall roads full? — We draw them out and let them fall.
3,519. (The Coroner.) Take the timber out and let it fall? — Take the timber out and let the thing fall.
3,520. (Mr. Wright.) What width are the timbers in the long wall? — Five yards.
3,521. And you let the top fall there? — Yes.
3,522. There would be a cavity where it falls? — There must be a top somewhere.
3,523. Because the land way wont come down? Are there any cracks or openings that you have noticed in the roof, where the top has come down, there in that way? — No; we have had very few of them. Not since we have worked the long wall work.
3,524. Did you have any gas come off the goaf? — Yes; at the low end.
3,524a. Near the ground? — Yes.
3,525. At the places you showed us before? — No.
3,526. Just show me where? — At the raw edge here.
3,527. That is all along the low end? — The bottom end.
3,528. "All along?" — Yes.
3,529. Much gas? — No.
3,530. Does it commonly come off there? — Just as the barometer may rise or fall.
3,531. With a low barometer? — We should have a little coming off.
3,532. All along the bottom end, you mean? — Yes; outward.
3,533. Just show me where the stuff comes from that you fill the long wall goaf with? — Well, we draw this out; we pull it out again, and prop this up.
3,534. You take the coal out? — Yes.
3,535. What is the stuff that you put in to fill the space? — Stone.
3,536. Where do you get the stone from? — As we draw the place out.
3,537. That is the stone you got by driving the roads? — Yes.
3,538. Do you find that enough? — Yes.
3,539. You never have to bring it? — No, we have enough and to spare.
3,540. What do you do when you have got too much? — Let it bide where it is.
(The Coroner to Mr. Jones and Mr. Edge.) I am afraid I must ask you two gentlemen if, on Mr. Wright's further examination, you have any questions to put.
(Mr. Edge.) I have none.
(Mr. Jones.) No, I think not. I think Mr. Wright has elicited all that I require.