Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 21st October 1880 (cont.).

Mr. Stratton recalled.

3,691. (The Coroner.) Have you sought for the book in the cabin? — There are two men here who made a search last night — Miller and Spence.

3,692. (Mr. Wright.) Perhaps this can go on the notes. It may be useful to Mr. Stratton; the book was kept on a ledge behind the iron door.

(The Witness.) No, just in front of it; the iron door was in a barrel arch, and there was a bit of deal laid on the barrel at the bottom of the door, and the book used to rest on it.

3,693. Were the iron doors blown away? — The iron doors were blown away — blown off the shutters. They were crumpled up.

(The Coroner.) That would be near the spot where the book was lying.

3,694. (Mr. Wright.) You assume that the book disappeared with the door? — I should probably think it has.

3,695. (The Coroner.) And search has been made and it is not forthcoming? — Yes. Joseph Spence and Miller made a search last night.

Adjourned for a short time.

(Mr. Jones.) Some observations were made by me and my friend, Mr. Wright, yesterday morning, with regard to a communication being made to the Home Office in accordance with a suggestion which came from the Home Secretary, or rather in answer to a suggestion which came from us as to an experimental chemist being employed, or some mining engineer, or both. We have come to the conclusion that we shall be satisfied — and that is our unanimous opinion — so far as the mining engineering part of the work is concerned, with the reports of Her Majesty's inspectors. With regard to an experimental chemist, we have come to the conclusion, and we have adopted a form of resolution which we have put into words, as Mr. Wright had expressed a desire that it should be reduced to paper: "That the Coroner and Mr. Wright be requested to inform the Home Office, that it is the desire of the association that experiments be made by an experimental chemist with the coal dust in Seaham Colliery, with a view to ascertain how far it may produce an explosion or increase and intensify an explosion." That practically contains what we desire. I hand you one copy (addressing the Coroner), and Mr. Wright another copy (produced.)

(Mr. Wright.) I am not sure that a chemist is the person to undertake this investigation

(The Coroner.) Mr. Wright and I will discuss that point, and we will send your resolution to the Home Office, and after we have discussed the matter, we will tell you the conclusion at which we have arrived, which we hope will meet with your views.

(Mr. Wright.) I think we may adopt that course. There is this practical difficulty, that we shall have to deal with, namely to get the coal-dust that existed in the mine before the explosion, because it would be necessary for it to be produced as it was taken out of the mine.

(Mr. Jones.) My learned friend wants to make me an experimental chemist.

(Mr. Wright.) Nothing like that — simply to have the subject matter of the experiments verified and put on the depositions.

(Mr. Jones.) The coal dust in the pit is identical with what was there before the explosion, and I apprehend that that is a matter of detail which could be left to the parties who make the experiments.

(The Coroner.). I put it this way — do you say that on the shot being fired in the pit, with coal dust flying, that it is possible that that coal dust may be so communicated with by the shot-firing as to cause an explosion?

(Mr. Jones.) Well, of course, as far as that goes, you will quite see how difficult it is for me to be called upon to express any opinion.

(The Coroner.) I do not want you to express an opinion that such a possibility may occur.

(Mr. Jones.) I am instructed that a mixture of coal dust in certain proportions with hot air may produce an explosion. I do not say that it is so. It is the point which is open to consideration. I say, consequently, that it is possible that if an explosion did take place, that explosion would be extended in its effects.

(The Coroner.) That, I think, would be admitted; would intensify it.

(Mr. Jones.) Therefore we want to have the opinion of a scientific person, whose authority is undubitable, as to whether the coal dust in this Seaham coal is of such a character as would be likely either to act as the original cause of an explosion, or as a transmitter of an explosion.

(Mr. Edge.) I think it is more for a practical Government inspector or gentleman of experience of that kind to deal with. You must assume the addition of coal dust being in a cloud in the air, and see whether the firing of a shot would produce an explosion.

(Mr. Wright.) The Coroner and I will consider that question.

(The Coroner.) We will consider and represent what your view is and the representation already made by Mr. Jones in our hands, and the Home Office will decide upon the whole thing.

(Mr. Wright.) What I want is this: It is a question of evidence. Supposing you sent a resolution to the Home Office that coal dust at Seaham is transmitted, they would ask where is the coal dust.

(Mr. Jones.) That is a matter of detail, with all deference. That is a matter which can be considered by you, Mr. Coroner, and Mr. Wright, and also by the gentleman who will be appointed by the Home Office.

(Mr. Wright.) Call it detail or principle, where are we to get the coal dust?

(Mr. Jones.) I think I may deal with that here. The next proposition that I have to deal with is this "That Mr. Bell and Mr. Willis, accompanied by certain officials of the colliery and certain representatives of the miners, do go down the Seaham pit for the purpose of reporting as to the presence and quantity of coal dust in the mine, and to take samples of the same." I dare say, sir, that samples will be taken by Mr. Bell or Mr. Willis.

(Mr. Willis.) But that would be coal dust after the explosion, and which is a very different thing, or may be a very different thing from the coal dust before the explosion.

(Mr. Jones.) I quite understand that. But I apprehend in certain parts of the mine where coal dust would be found totally unaffected by the explosion in certain parts of the mine where the explosion had not permeated. Of course, I feel a diffidence in entering into details.

(The Coroner.) I see no objection.

(Mr. Wright.) I have not the least objection if the inspectors desire to assist in the operation.

(The Coroner.) What do you say, Mr. Edge?

(Mr. Edge.) Well, I may say, on behalf of Lord Londonderry, that I have no objection to the inspectors being accompanied by the representatives of the miners.

(Mr. Jones.) No doubt the representatives would do what is right.

(Mr. Edge.) The representatives would take the samples through the inspector.

(Mr. Willis.) And we would be prepared to say where we found it, and why we took it.

(Mr. Jones.) I think Mr. Wright requested Mr. Stratton to provide him with certain information. Perhaps Mr. Edge would offer that the same information should be afforded to us.

(Mr. Edge.) What is the information you require?

(Mr. Jones.) There is a list given by Mr. Wright to my learned friend.

(Mr. Wright.) It is not yet settled formally.

(Mr. Jones.) Might I ask that the same information should be given to me as is given to Mr. Wright?

(Mr. Wright.) I will undertake that Mr. Jones shall have what I get.

(Mr. Edge.) What is that you wanted?

(Mr. Wright.) It is only details as to the ventilation, and to have the airways and sections shown, and that kind of thing.

(Mr. Edge.) You will no doubt see that everything is given to you what is required of that kind.

(The Coroner.) Now, I must say, that so far as I am concerned, my own opinion, and the opinion of the jury is, that the evidence I should like to have stronger, before we get into the scientific evidence, is the point at which the bodies were found burnt, killed by the shock of the explosion, and the men killed by the after-damp, clearly shown by evidence that we can act upon and all agree to, and also the points where a continuous course of fire, where merely singeing or burnt can be shown, together with any spaces in the neighbourhood where there is a continuous course of fire, of any spaces between the roof — the proper roof and places that are timbered close up, or what you might term hermetically sealed. That is what I should like to have before we enter upon the scientific evidence, in addition to what we already have.

(Mr. Edge.) Very well.

(Mr. Wright.) Things of the nature of loftings.

(The Coroner.) There is only one thing that I should like to have at this sitting. It is a list of the men brought out of the pit dead. Mr. Stratton will perhaps prove that. Will you ask Mr. Stratton to give it Mr. Edge?

(Mr. Edge.) I would suggest that this is done. Of course, the representative of the Marquis and the representative of the miners would point out where they would like samples to be taken from, and, of course, the inspector also; but I would suggest that to avoid the necessity of a lot of analyses, that the inspector should save a portion taken, or that some person sent by the Home Office should send a portion there that we might have a part to make an analyses.

(Mr. Wright.) I have no doubt that the gentleman who instructs you (Mr. Wright), who is on the spot, will be able to arrange how that is to be done. There will be no difficulty.

(Mr. Edge.) Whichever inspector comes down, I say that he should retain a portion of each particular sample.

(Mr. Willis.) I would like to suggest this: Let us first ascertain whether the Home Office will grant this request, and supply an analytical chemist, before we go to gather samples, and may be the inspectors, the owner's representative, and the workmen's representative may communicate with the person who is so appointed, as to what specimens what ould like. I think I would leave it more to the person appointed.

(Mr. Jones.) Certainly.

(Mr. Willis.) That would meet the difficulty.

(Mr. Jones.) I think that would be agreeable.

(Mr. Bell.) That is a matter of detail in ordering the thing.

(Mr. Edge.) At least the portion of the package kept by him could be identified by him.

(Mr. Bell.) After we have the samples, of course we will keep a portion of them.

(Mr. Jones.) I have no doubt that both Mr. Bell and Mr. Willis would pay attention to what was said by the representatives of the men, as to the place whence the coal dust would be taken.

(Mr. Marshall.) Mr. Forman will go down.

(Mr. Bell.) Oh, yes.

(Mr. Jones.) Or one of the miner's association.

(Mr. Marshall.) It is for the satisfaction of the men that we should have this question of the coal dust examined.

(Mr. Bell.) I understand.

(Mr. Wright.) Was that proved that it will fire.

(Mr. Marshall.) The men have a dread now of it, which we want to get rid of.

(Mr. Willis.) I would contend that it is no use collecting a wheelbarrow full, and afterwards find that the Home Office will not go into the matter.

(Mr. Bell.) We certainly will not go into the pit until we get the instructions from the Home Office, because the Home Office might say no.

(Mr. Marshall.) They might say no, but I do not think they will.

(Mr. Jones.) That is a subsequent procedure.

(Mr. Marshall.) They will appoint Professor Abel.

(Mr. Edge.) We want an able professor, anyhow. Mr. Stratton is here now.

3,696. (The Coroner to Mr. Stratton.) You are already sworn? — Yes.

3,697. Have you got there the list of bodies recovered, and killed in the explosion? — Yes.

3,698. Is it the test or a true statement of those already recovered? — Yes, I have pencilled one observation where we discovered Burns or Pinkard. He is called Burns there, but he is really Pinkard. He was identified as Pinkard.

3,699. He was working with you under an assumed name? — Yes, or something of that sort.

3,700. (Mr. Edge.) It is not correct there? — No. Hindson's number is still 33 there. It might be altered to Lowrie's number. We found the face of Lowrie's watch where Hindson's body was found.

3,701. (The Coroner.) The list, except the numbers on the plan, is correct? — All the men that are on that list are found.

3,702. (Mr. Bell.) Then you have not an index to that map.

(The Coroner.) I believe you are preparing one.

(The Witness.) I have not had any instructions to prepare one.

3,703. (Mr. Bell.) But I would like to see an index corresponding with the names. By referring to that index we ought to be able to find it on the map? — A simple copy would show that.

3,704. That is by numbers? — The pits were numbered before they were named.

3,705. To follow that out. Well, take No. 7 (pointing). The name No. 7 corresponds, and then there are remarks in that column.

(The Coroner.) The next question I will ask you to settle is as to what time we should adjourn this enquiry.

(Mr. Jones.) One matter more, which I just mentioned to Mr. Wright, and I think he agrees with me in what I said. It is somewhat following upon your own observations. It would be very advisable to have a chart of the workings, showing the position, perhaps marked in different coloured inks would do it, of three classes of bodies, those which are burned, those which died from the force of the explosion that were not burned, and those which died from after-damp or the absence of air.

(The Coroner.) I think you will get that from the numbers on the plan without a chart.

(Mr. Jones.) It would be a convenience.

(The Witness.) I have brought a plan here to-day showing those burned and mutilated and killed by the shock.

3,706. (Mr. Jones.) I thought that was mentioned? — Yes; they asked for a chart. I have got it in the room. Mr. H. B. Wright has it. There is a plan before you, just in front of you, Mr. Wright.

(Mr. H. B. Wright.) This is our own plan.

(The Witness.) I did not mark the after-damp.

(The Coroner.) Are you agreed as to the time of the adjournment? Let it be after the Maudlin is fully examined, if possible, before we meet again. Will any of you say anything about it.

(Mr. Edge.) All that I can say about the Maudlin is that there is a great deal of difference of opinion as to when it would be safe to open the Maudlin, and we trust that it may be opened in a couple of months or less. Of course it may be much longer.

(The Coroner.) Well, we must risk that. In case we adjourn to a particular day, I will re-open the enquiry; but I don't think that the bar need attend if we cannot go on. But I would attend merely to take the recognizances of the jury to appear at a future day at a time when the Maudlin would be open.

(Mr. Edge.) If the Maudlin is not open before the date of the adjournment, we may take it that the bar need not attend. If it is, we are to attend. Will you suggest a date?

(The Coroner.) The week commencing 13th December, either the Monday or the Tuesday, the 13th or the 14th. How will that suit you, Mr. Forman?

(Mr. Forman.) I agree.

(The Coroner.) I did say that I would keep Monday for myself, but seeing that I should like to finish the enquiry at the next sitting, I shall say the 13th of December at half past ten in the forenoon, and go forward.

The Inquiry was adjourned accordingly.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print