79. The technical aspects of the explosion hazard to which we have referred all add emphasis to the importance of the human factor. Immediately following any serious accident, it is usual to ask if there is any technical failure which might at any moment occur again elsewhere; and, anxious not to prejudge any human factors that may have played their part, to direct attention to those automatic aids on which safety in industry today increasingly depends. Whilst we agree that, wherever practicable, the best use should be made of such aids, it is a fact that the operations of a coal mine are, by their very nature, often not well suited to their application. There can be no automatic guarantee of safety in coal mining. Risk often lies in the combination of a number of small contributory causes that create the rare situation in which a disaster may occur — causes which rarely lend themselves to prevention by legal enactment.
80. But however much statutory regulations and automatic safety devices are applied, no amount of safety equipment and legislation can succeed without the active co-operation of management and workmen all down the line. We are convinced that the safety of a pit depends very largely upon the extent to which the individuals in it — management and men alike — want it to be safe and are prepared to exert themselves to see that it is safe. However large the army of Inspectors, officials and safety officers may be, they cannot possibly exercise continuous influence for day-to-day safety on every yard of all the hundreds of miles of coal faces from which coal is won in this country and along the thousands of miles of underground roadways on which it is hauled.
81. Not only must everyone take responsibility for his own safety and that of his own working place; he must also have continually in his mind the safety of others. He should therefore be interested in anything that he happens to see in the course of his work that might affect safety. The day-to-day effort to eradicate negligence or carelessness or any departure from good mining practice must lie in the main with those best able to detect it — the men in the pit. In this matter the under-officials and, in particular, the Deputy have a special responsibility of which due account must always he taken in their training.
82. We realize that this means big changes of attitude and mind. It means a real acceptance of responsibility for safety by every individual who works in a pit; it means that the Act and Regulations will not be regarded merely as a catalogue of imperatives and penalties, but as a code of good mining practice that everyone willingly accepts and is at pains to observe — a code where every exception will at once be challenged. We realize, too, that it means a big change of emphasis in the approach of all concerned to the problems of safety.
83. There must, of course, be no letting up on endeavours to find safer methods and machines, better safeguards against hazards and fuller use of specialists; to obtain more effective and speedier application of the beneficial discoveries of science and research; and to improve our systems of education and training. Every practicable step must be taken to ensure that the physical and environmental conditions in a mine are made as far as practicable such that a casual act of carelessness does not inevitably lead to an accident. All this is just sound common sense and, indeed, sound economics.
84. We think, however, that there is a need for a change of emphasis in our educational approach to safety problems with a view to developing the right attitude of mind to these problems. The importance of education and training as a means of providing a basis of technical competency in officials and workmen is well recognized and good progress has been made in this direction, but we believe that not enough emphasis has been placed on teaching all entrants to mines that death and injury by avoidable accident are an evil and that those who contribute to the risks by carelessness or indifference, let alone by downright recklessness, are committing a moral wrong. The right moral approach to the problems of safety would mean a tremendous advance. Where this approach prevailed, departures from the code of good practice and good conduct would be few and far between and the actions of the man who, for example, smoked in a safety-lamp mine or discarded unused explosives underground would he recognized for what indeed they are — thoroughly anti-social, irresponsible and criminal. We recommend that the moral approach to the problems of safety in mines should be given greater emphasis in all education and training courses and particularly in the preliminary training courses for all new entrants to the industry.
85. The value of joint consultation as a means of propagating a sense of the importance of safety in all its aspects is already widely appreciated and every opportunity should be taken to make use of this machinery to bring about improved standards of safety awareness. Through the consultative machinery greater efforts should be made to develop and encourage the growth of the personal feeling of responsibility for safety by the individual; to ensure that by direct approach to the official under whom any individual works, or by whatever is the most effective way in the circumstances, the individual can promptly register any observation he has to make about the safety of the mine; and to ensure that arrangements are made so that all such observations are considered with the least possible delay.
86. In discharge of our terms of reference relating to the measures required to bring our findings to the notice of management, officials and workmen, we recommend that special steps should he taken for the full and frank consideration throughout the industry of the lessons emerging from this report which, in view of the importance of the subject-matter, we think should be given the widest possible circulation. We appeal for the support of all the constituent bodies represented on our Committee in ensuring that these lessons are carefully studied at all levels throughout their own organization, and for their co-operation in achieving a thorough examination of the report throughout the consultative machinery and particularly by Colliery Consultative Committees. Apart from consideration of the report through the medium of the consultative machinery, we urge that special meetings should be convened, sponsored by the local Colliery Consultative Committees, to bring its lessons home to the very large body of the Board's employees who do not directly participate in the activities of the consultative machinery. In our view, the local Inspectorate have an important contribution to make in all these meetings and discussions, and we think it essential that they should be invited to participate. We hope that the Institution of Mining Engineers and the Association of Mining Electrical and Mechanical Engineers will also arrange for meetings and discussions by their members. We recommend that the Board should arrange for the publication of articles in Coal magazine and in the technical journals. We consider that films, suitable for showing to colliery canteen or welfare institute audiences, on such aspects of our investigation as the layering of gas in high places and methods of gas detection would be particularly valuable. The film already made by the S.M.R.E. demonstrating their models designed to illustrate the travel of flame in underground explosions is eminently suitable for showing in this connection.
87. in conclusion, we would state that we do not consider any change in the present statutory requirements to be necessary as a result of experience of explosions in recent years. The existing Regulations lay down adequate safeguards if they are properly carried out. The remedies are to hand and it is for all employed in the industry to apply them.