61. Coal dust played little or no part in the majority of the explosions covered by our review. This may in part have been due to the more effective steps now taken to prevent and suppress coal dust at its source, together with the precautions taken against accumulations of dust on roadways and, in part, to the weak nature of the initial gas explosion in one or two cases where the gas was ignited at the explosive fringe of a rich accumulation which was above the explosive range. But, be that as it may, it was disturbing to find that in at least two explosions coal dust did play a part in propagating the explosion along parts of roadways which the management considered to he wet enough to cause the dust in them to be indispersable and which, moreover, were not visibly dusty.
62. In his report on the Kames explosion the Commissioner concludes that coal dust played a part in the propagation of the explosion. He states that in his view, however, "the officials genuinely believed that there was insufficient dust to propagate an explosion, that the dust present was too damp to he raised into the air, and consequently that it was unnecessary to take any other precautions".
63. Our review of recent experience certainly suggests that we need more knowledge than we presently have in relation to the potential danger of roadway dust which is judged to be sufficiently damp or wet to prevent it being raised into suspension in the air.
64. We have, therefore, examined with special interest the results of recent experiments carried out at the Research Station, Mikolow, Poland, under the direction of Dr. Cybulski, on the effects of moisture on the explosibility of coal and stone dust mixtures.
65. These experiments were carried out with a coal dust which is particularly explosive and furthermore the initiating explosions used were very powerful and the other conditions were exceptionally favourable for wet coal dust to propagate explosion. For example, Dr. Cybulski was able to explode a fine dry dust containing 87.5 per cent of incombustible matter placed on the roof bars. It was also found possible in the most favourable conditions to propagate an explosion from coal dust which was so wet that the mixture had a consistency of wet paste from which water trickled out. One of the points noticed was that, although dust mixtures became more difficult to explode as the moisture content increased, they produced more violent explosions once they did ignite.
66. The results of the Polish research indicate the desirability of further investigation in this country into the coal dust explosion hazard, based on the types of coal dust found here. We think that further information is clearly desirable on the need for stone dusting in damp or wet roadways, and on the effect of using waterproofed stone dust. As a first step towards obtaining the additional information required as to the extent of the coal dust explosion hazard and the best methods of combating it, we recommend that a working party of experts on coal dust explosions should be established to consider all the available evidence, including the results of both British and Polish research, and to submit a report, with recommendations, on their investigations.
67. In the meantime managers should continue at all times in compliance with the present Regulations to ensure (i) a high standard of cleanliness in respect of dust accumulations on roadways, (ii) stone dusting at frequent intervals on the "little and often" principle and (iii) the proper installation of stone dust barriers in accordance with the N.C.B. directive.
68. Thorough cleaning up and stone dusting are important at all times, but particularly in room and pillar workings because of the larger amounts of coal dust which tend to be deposited in such workings. Coal-getting operations in a narrow place with solid coal on either side cause inevitable degradation and there is in any case a tendency for coal to flake off the sides of the narrow roadways and then he ground underfoot. The absence of stone dust from roadway ripping and packing operations which, if present, would help to dilute the make of coal dust is another important factor which must not be overlooked. Furthermore, where conveyors are used in room and pillar workings the numerous transfer and loading points required can be responsible for a heavy deposition of coal dust. The need for specially high standards of coal dust cleaning-up and stone dusting in room and pillar working should therefore be recognized by all persons concerned.
69. It is necessary in the light of the evidence we have examined to stress the need for scrupulous compliance with the requirements of the Explosives Regulations, both as regards the firing of shots and the handling of explosives underground. In particular, the jettisoning or concealment of unused explosives underground to save the trouble of returning them to store at the end of the shift is a practice which cannot be too strongly condemned. The statutory requirements in regard to the maintenance of records of explosives issued, consumed and returned to store do not permit of any ambiguity and suitable systems are described in the Handbook on Shotfiring. It is essential that everyone concerned should co-operate in carrying them out effectively.
70. We have already made an interim recommendation on this point to the effect that anyone found smoking or with contraband on his person underground, or within a "no smoking" area on the surface, should be liable to instant dismissal and to permanent prohibition from employment anywhere in the industry again. We are glad to note that these proposals have been endorsed by all the constituent bodies in the industry, and are confident that, if properly applied, they will be of considerable help in combating the contraband problem.
71. We have given careful thought to the proposal that a stop should be put now to the use of naked lights underground, a proposal largely based on the fact that no coal mine can be regarded as immune from the danger of explosions.
72. Mines in which naked lights are used fall into two legal categories. First there are the mixed light mines, being mines part of which are on a safety lamp basis and part on a naked light basis. Then there are the naked light mines, being mines in which naked lights have been in universal use from a period prior to the passing of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954.
73. The trend in recent years has undoubtedly been towards a continual reduction in the use of naked lights in mines. This trend cannot but be accelerated by the implementation of the provisions of Section 62 (5) of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954. Under this Section all mixed light mines must become safety lamp mines in the full statutory sense by 31st December, 1960. This means not only the prohibition of naked lights in any part of such mines but also the introduction throughout these mines of certain consequential and costly additional requirements. The more important of these include the use of flameproof electrical apparatus, of permitted explosives, the employment of qualified shotfirers and the prohibition of the blasting of coal from the solid.
74. In the case of mixed light mines, therefore, acceptance of the proposal to abolish the use of naked lights underground would mean the implementation of the provisions of Section 62 (5) of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, now, instead of on 31st December, 1960 — a step that would not be worth while in some instances, e.g., the case of a "mixed light" pit which may be closed before the appointed day.
75. Circumstances are different, however, in the case of naked light mines. To prohibit the use of naked lights in these mines — which, incidentally, are under no obligation by law to prohibit the use of naked lights-and to require them also to become safety lamp mines in the full statutory sense would certainly bear very harshly on the economics of such mines. Many of these mines are old and small and are nearing the end of their economic life; moreover, many of them are not managed by the National Coal Board. Although the prohibition of naked light lamps in such mines would eliminate the explosion risk arising from this source, it does not follow that it would automatically remove the explosion risk arising from the practice of smoking underground. In collieries which have always been naked light pits it is well known that the smoking habit becomes firmly established and experience has shown that the sudden imposition of a requirement to use only safety lamps does not necessarily mean a change in the ingrained habits of those employed.
76. Thus there is no suggestion that the imposition of safety lamps would markedly reduce the explosion risk in these mines. Nevertheless, we consider that for the industry to work towards the elimination of naked lights in mines would be a step in the right direction and we recommend accordingly. In carrying out this policy we recommend that in cases where the colliery is not required by law to become a safety lamp mine, relief should be provided from certain of the consequential requirements of the Act and Regulations when safety lamps are introduced such as the use of flameproof apparatus and of permitted explosives.
77. Our review of the recent explosions indicated that in some instances there was room for improvement in the arrangements for calling out rescue brigades, especially with a view to reducing the interval between the occurrence of an explosion and the time at which the first rescue brigade left the fresh-air base.
78. We are glad to learn that the National Coal Board have completed an investigation into the organization of the work of rescue brigades, with a view to strengthening the organization and effecting improvements where necessary. We welcome this approach. which we consider to he the right one in the circumstances.