50. Whilst the prevention of dangerous accumulations of gas underground is the first step towards reducing the explosion hazard, the elimination of sources of ignition is another extremely important aspect of the problem. Our review has brought to light the following matters which call for attention.
Protection and Siting of Motors and Switch gear
51. Where mining practice admits of a choice of site for electrical apparatus, due regard must be paid to the hazards of falls of ground and of firedamp in the selection of the site. Where there is no choice, or where the choice is very limited, it is particularly important to provide proper safeguards against these hazards. To reduce the risk from falls, special care should he taken to ensure that effective support is given to the roof and sides in the immediate vicinity of the apparatus. To guard against the hazard from firedamp, steps should be taken to ensure that the apparatus is designed to afford (i) reasonable mechanical protection against material damage from falls or other causes, and (ii) suitable electrical protection against the danger from incendive sparking should the apparatus unfortunately be damaged. The ease with which a layer of gas next to the roof, or a gas accumulation in a cavity, can be brought down to floor level must be recognized. In our view there is scope for improving the effectiveness of the built-in guards provided by manufacturers for the mechanical protection of motors and switchgear, but the importance of keeping size and weight within practicable limits must be kept in sight in this respect. Additional protection can be obtained by the provision, where practicable, of separate canopies over the apparatus and its ancillary equipment.
Protection of Electric Cables
52. It is clear that for the protection of electric cables in places where shots are to he fired such makeshift arrangements as covering them with a piece of conveyor belting are quite inadequate. We recommend the systematic use of a sufficient length of a strong protective material such as, for example, a steel pipe through which the cable is threaded — this is particularly applicable in bottom canch work — or channel iron, H-section steel girder or some type of steel arch cover especially designed for the purpose, to lay over the cable. Whatever method is adopted, it should be carefully chosen to suit the particular circumstances. The responsibility for providing the necessary protective equipment rests with the owner and manager, just as the responsibility for seeing that it is systematically used rests with the shotfirer.
53. We have heard evidence as to the suitability of various types of cables for underground use, and in view of the doubts which have been raised about the mechanical strength of paper-insulated cables we recommend that this matter should be further examined jointly by the National Coal Board, H.M. Electrical Inspectors and the manufacturers.
Shotfiring Cables and Exploders for Firing Large Rounds in Drifts
54. It is now a condition of use of large capacity exploders that cable of a proper specification shall be used and that it shall not be jointed. We welcome this important step in improving the safety of firing large rounds of shots in drifts, and also the N.C.B. Instruction requiring the weekly examination of all such shotfiring cables by or under the supervision of an electrician of the mine. To facilitate compliance with the prohibition of jointing, the specification is such that the cable can be scrapped when necessary. Apart from the weekly inspection by an electrician it is important that the shotfirer or his assistant should examine the cable visually each time that it is used and, if it is damaged, replace it or cut off the defective portion.
55. We are glad to note that the National Coal Board have obtained models of the Schaeffler exploder, which incorporates a time limit on the flow of current, for trials in this country and that action is being taken by the Board to examine the possibility of modifying the Beethoven exploder to reduce the risk associated with its use in its present form. We recommend that this modification should he pursued as a matter of urgency. The omission of zero delays would be a further protection against post-firing contact.
Earth Leakage and Overload Protection
56. Special attention should be paid to the care of apparatus for earth leakage and for overload protection, since these are not required to operate in the normal course of events but must work effectively and instantaneously whenever a dangerous electrical fault affecting one or the other develops. This requirement clearly can only be met by high standards of supervision and maintenance.
Standards of Practice
57. A special responsibility in respect of explosion risk rests on colliery electricians, since an error or momentary carelessness on their part may be the agency which causes a disaster. We appeal to all electricians to maintain the high professional standards which their duties demand; never to permit themselves easy makeshift alternatives or to accept slipshod standards as a substitute for a proper workmanlike job; and in particular never in any circumstances to take the foolish risk of carrying out work on live electrical apparatus. The co-operation of the professional institutions can, we are convinced, be of great value in propagating a sense of the high status and responsibility of the colliery electrician's work.
Electrical Circuits
58. In condemning the practice of searching for electrical faults while the circuit is still live, we nevertheless appreciate the practical difficulty in which electricians find themselves in trying to locate faults with the circuit made dead. This in our view is a very real problem and we urge that the electrical industry should be encouraged to develop easier methods than are now available for tracing electrical faults when the power has been cut off.
59. The need for care in the installation and maintenance of ventilation equipment — e.g., relating the fan to its duty, avoidance of excessive leakage and precautions in the use of auxiliary fans — has been stressed earlier in this report.
60. We would emphasize to all employed underground the need for common sense and reasonable care in the treatment of underground equipment, and a responsible awareness of the potential consequences of its abuse. There are a number of instances in the explosions we have studied which indicate an alarming indifference by underground employees to the possible consequences of the maltreatment of equipment. Underground equipment is robust and remarkably long suffering; but there is a limit to the amount of abuse it can take without some impairment of safety.