6. Of the practical mining requirements for protection against the possibility of underground explosions, the need for good ventilation is undoubtedly the most important. The explosions we have examined clearly show that apart from collieries which, ordinarily, mining men would refer to as "gassy" there is a potential gas hazard even at those collieries they would refer to as "non-gassy". Freedom from the gas hazard can never he taken for granted and sound ventilation is the first line of defence. The essential requirements are a well-planned ventilation system, adequate facilities for gas detection, meticulous inspection and effective dispersal. These are discussed in greater detail below.
Ventilation Planning
7. A pre-requisite to sound ventilation is a carefully planned method of working a mine or seam in which due regard has been paid to the problem of ventilating the workings. Whatever the particular problems presented by individual collieries may be, the important general requirement is that there should be a plan, and that the colliery ventilation system should not he merely the result of expedients progressively adopted as the workings advance. The capacity of the fan and the ventilation layout should be selected having regard to the highest duty they will be required to perform, and the colliery officials should be fully conversant with the overall development plan for the ventilation of the colliery, both as a whole and especially as it affects The particular part of the pit for which they may be responsible. In our view there is considerable advantage to be gained by including ventilation amongst the items covered by the general development plans for a colliery which are agreed and signed by the mine management and specialist engineers concerned in the Area and which cannot be altered subsequently in any major respect without the agreement of these signatories.
8. Similarly, all colliery officials who have a responsibility in connection with the ventilation should be familiar with the statutory ventilation plan of the mine. In particular, under-officials should be familiar with that part of the ventilation plan which applies to the section of the mine in which they work. All officials should be informed of projected changes in the ventilation system and, likewise, the person responsible for the preparation of the statutory ventilation plan and for keeping it up to date should also be notified promptly of all such changes.
9. Some features of modern mining methods present particular ventilation problems especially in the driving of the high roadways of large cross-sectional area required for horizon mining or modified horizon mining layouts. These roadways clearly need to be of a size to carry the ventilation requirements of the development as finally planned, and there are no grounds for suggesting that at present such roadways are in general of larger dimensions than their future role requires. Nevertheless, difficult problems of ventilation velocity frequently arise in the early stages of development when the quantity of air passing in these roadways is necessarily only a small proportion of that which the roadway will carry when development is complete. We refer below to the gas layering problem which may arise in these conditions.
10. Another source of difficulty is the development of double unit faces served by three roadways. The roadway layout of an individual face raises separate considerations from those underlying the recommendation in the report on the Creswell Colliery fire for the provision of duplicate intakes to a main district. The purpose of that recommendation was to provide escape routes for the district as a whole in the event of a fire or other accident affecting the overall ventilation system, whereas the arrangements on an individual face are determined mainly by the operational requirements of that face in respect of ventilation, transport of coal and supplies. Whatever the circumstances, a coal face should never have two adjacent gate roads which are both either intake or return airways unless steps are taken to maintain effective ventilation in both airways and along the length of face between them.
11. Our purpose in referring to these problems at this point in our report is to stress the valuable service that the ventilation specialist engineers can provide. It is most important that when confronted with difficult decisions the local management should take advantage of this expert advice, which should always be available to them. One situation on which the specialist ventilation engineer should he consulted is when the ventilation systems of two or more collieries are interconnected, since this can give rise to extremely complicated and possibly dangerous conditions.
Gas Layering
12. The problems arising from the presence of thin gas layers — sometimes only a few inches thick — lying along the roof of roadways and in high places generally are exemplified in many of the explosions we have examined and are a matter which calls for the most careful attention. Clearly, prevention is better than cure but the possibilities of the existence of such layers and the vital need to detect them as soon as possible must be recognized. The hazard is twofold because of the physical difficulty of access for the purpose of testing and because the amount of gas may be so small as to escape detection unless special care is taken. The main danger of thin roof layers is not so much the quantity of the gas present in the layer itself as that the layer may trail back into the waste, or roof cavities and breaks, and serve as a fuse to larger and more dangerous concentrations of gas. Another danger lies in the ease with which such layers can be brought down by a fall of roof and get so mixed with air in the process as to be readily ignitable even at floor level.
13. We have examined the experimental evidence available on this problem of gas layering and note with interest and approval the research which the Safety in Mines Research Establishment are currently carrying out. We refer to this again in Para. 39. Air velocities vary at different horizons in a roadway and the velocity at the sides and roof is considerably less than at the centre. Experiments have shown that a layer of gas is capable of backing up against the normal roadway ventilation current, a fact which needs to be appreciated by all concerned, particularly Deputies.
14. Our recommendations in regard to testing for and dispersing thin gas layers appear below under the appropriate headings.
Gas Emission
15. An important lesson emerging from a study of these explosions is the ability of small rates of gas emission, trifling in themselves, to build up into dangerous concentrations, or at least to form a continuous train back to dangerous concentrations elsewhere, unless due precautions are taken to detect and disperse them. A complementary aspect of the problem is the danger represented by local concentrations of gas collecting at vulnerable points without any perceptible effects on the general standards of ventilation. It is, therefore, important to exercise special care in testing for gas in places where it is likely to collect (e.g., on ripping lips, at high places on roadways, along the waste edge and in the fast end of faces) and not to allow satisfactory determinations of gas in the general body of the air to induce a false sense of security. Nowadays, explosions seldom arise from the ignition of gas present in the general body of the air. Most of the explosions we have reviewed have been caused by the ignition of gas which had accumulated in thin layers next to a high roof, in roof cavities or other places outside and unaffected by the main ventilation airstream. There are, however, several incidents in which the evidence of gas in the general body of the air at particular points might have served as a warning of a developing danger, had the evidence been noticed at the time. Even a small increase in the relatively small gas content of successive air samples taken from the general body of the air in the return airway from a district may he significant, since such an increase can have an effect locally which is much greater than the size of the increase would, at first sight, suggest. A system of regular sampling along the waste edge is a particularly valuable precaution against local concentrations of gas which might otherwise be overlooked.
16. The objective should he to have and to maintain in hand a sufficient margin of ventilation to provide for the normal contingencies of mining, such as gas emission due to a fall of roof in a waste or a drop in barometer, and not to be in the position of having to operate a ventilation system which is already fully extended in coping with the normal.
17. Particular attention should be drawn in this connection to the means whereby compliance with Section 56 of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, can be achieved in order to minimize the danger of gas emission from the waste. The appropriate steps must be decided according to the circumstances of the individual case, but it seems to us that precautions such as gas drainage, improvement in control of the strata in the district as a whole and in the support of the roof in the face workings including strengthening of the waste edge supports, and ample ventilation can, either individually or in combination, make a valuable contribution towards the solution of this problem.
Vulnerable Points
18. We have already pointed out that the gas hazard tends to be greater at particular points. Ordinarily among such places are the highest points of roadways and ripping lips, roadway cavities, wastes, the highest point of an inclined face and fast ends. All such places call for special care on the part of those concerned with gas inspection and the maintenance of good ventilation. A matter to which we would draw attention is the need for the provision of adequate and appropriate means such as "bleeder" or gas drainage systems for removing the gas which may collect in the wastes of retreating longwall faces. Special problems are presented by room and pillar workings, e.g., the need to avoid excessive air leakage through wastes during pillar extraction and through pillared areas.
19. The ventilation of localized vulnerable points does not always require the use of special mechanical means such as an auxiliary fan. We recommend that consideration should always be given to diverting part of the normal ventilation airstream, e.g., by means of a brattice or some other suitable airduct, to deflect an adequate amount of air to scour the places concerned.
Supervision of Ventilation Systems and Equipment
20. It is important that the efficiency of ventilating systems and all their equipment is kept under close review to ensure that they are actually achieving what they are intended to achieve and to effect any alterations necessary in the light of changing circumstances. Particular care should be taken to ensure that the fan is at all times suitable for its duty, that it is properly installed, and that excessive leakage due to unsatisfactory separation of intake and return airways is avoided. We note that the National Coal Board has a system in force for regular returns from each colliery of air measurements, firedamp determinations and determinations of air leakages. Copies of these returns go to the Area Ventilation Engineer and we would draw attention to the valuable service this official can provide in keeping a general watch on ventilation conditions at each pit in his Area.
21. The installation of fans underground calls for the utmost forethought and attention to detail, and special care must be exercised to ensure compliance with the relevant requirements of the Ventilation Regulations relating to such matters as the avoidance of recirculation of air and the siting of the fan. The decision whether or not an auxiliary or booster fan is necessary in a particular case clearly depends on the circumstances. Whenever it is proposed to install a fan underground other than an auxiliary fan, the colliery manager is already required by statute to consult a specialist engineer about its type, size and location and on its effect on the mine ventilation. In our view he should also consult him when a system of auxiliary fan ventilation is being established.
22. A particular aspect of ventilation practice which calls for notice is the ventilation of headings and drifts. There are arguments for and against forcing and exhausting ventilation in such places, and neither has a clear advantage over the other. In our view reversible ventilation for headings and drifts has many advantages over a permanently exhausting or forcing system, since it can he used either to blow in fresh air or to suck out fumes according to the changing requirements in the drift, and we consider that its wider application to coal mines warrants further investigation.
23. Safety from the explosion hazard underground obviously depends on thorough and conscientious testing by those charged with this responsibility. One danger to be guarded against is the false sense of security engendered by the assumption that because a place is habitually free from gas, it will always he free from gas. Deputies and other under-officials must he thoroughly aware of their responsibility under the Act and Regulations and must have a clear understanding of the extent of the mine for which they are personally responsible, including all airways and roadways, even though these may not be travelled frequently. The intention of Section 55 of the Act is perfectly clear, viz., that all parts of the mine (other than waste or such other parts as may be prescribed) must be either ventilated, stopped-off or stowed-up. We note that the National Coal Board has issued Notes for Guidance on "Manners of stopping-off in relation to Sections 55 and 56 of the Act" and we recommend these Notes for Guidance and the relevant sections of "The Colliery Official's Handbook to the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954", also published by the Board, as valuable works of reference for use by all concerned with the operation and maintenance of colliery ventilation systems.
24. Extra care is called for in testing for gas along the waste edge of new developing faces, especially prior to and during the period of first weighting, since it is at these times that there is a particular liability to gas emission — see Para. 45. In certain cases deep waste sampling may be desirable. We would also emphasize the importance of the Deputy recording, for the information of the colliery management, a full account in his statutory report of any unusual incidents reflecting on the efficiency of the ventilation system, e.g., the quantities and location of any gas encountered or the stoppage of any auxiliary fan.
Methods of Testing
25. If the Deputy is to make satisfactory gas inspections, he must have suitable means for this purpose, such that he can make thorough and searching tests in the time available without detriment to his other duties within the shift. The biggest problems confronting the Deputy in this respect are the detection of gas layers along the roof of high roadways, possibly 12ft. or 14ft. above floor level, and the detection of gas in cavities.
26. For the purpose of testing for gas in high places there are two basic alternatives, either to bring down a sample of the atmosphere to a gas detecting instrument held at normal level, or to raise the instrument to the level where gas may be present. Neither method is without considerable difficulties, and we consider that further investigations and trials will have to be devoted to this practical pit problem to determine the best solutions.
27. We have studied with interest the various efforts which are being made to produce suitable equipment in the form of an aspirating tube to enable the Deputy to take samples of the atmosphere from points otherwise inaccessible, e.g., high places or from within the waste, and especially gas in a thin layer next to the roof in a high roadway. Such equipment as we have seen is mostly designed for application with a methanometer such as the interference methanometer. We note, however, that similar equipment is being developed for use with a flame safety lamp, modified to enable the aspirated gases to he fed into the combustion chamber of the lamp without being diluted with air. The objective of any such development must be to produce equipment which is sufficiently robust, handy and reliable for routine daily use by the Deputy, and which will very quickly give an indication as to the presence of gas.
28. As to the other alternative, viz., raising the instrument to the gas, in our view a Deputy cannot be expected to climb up to reach the level to be tested except at special and localized points, e.g., ripping lips or isolated cavities where suitable staging or other suitable means of access should always be readily available. Nor can adequate testing be achieved by holding a lamp raised at arm's length if this still leaves a space between the lamp and the roof or the top of any cavity.
29. We are satisfied that the main instrument for routine gas testing by the Deputy must for the present remain the flame safety lamp and that until such time as better methods of testing for gas at ordinarily inaccessible places are developed, an acceptable indication of the presence or otherwise of gas in such places can be given by the flicker and colour of the flame if the lamp is raised to the roof with a fairly full flame by such means as a stick. The purpose of this test is to ascertain whether a gas accumulation is present, not to obtain a precise measurement of the actual gas percentage, and the quick reaction of the flame will he sufficient for this purpose. When the flame lamp is being used in this role it is essential that the top feed only is open and that the lamp is held sufficiently long for any gas present to reach the flame.
30. It is also essential where this method of testing is used that the person required to employ it should have training in its use and application. A simple method of attachment of the lamp to the rod is to drill the latter longitudinally to take the end of the lamp hook, but it would he advantageous if improved methods of rigid connection could be devised which eliminated the use of the hook, and permitted the lamp to be raised hard against the roof and at an angle to the observer so as to improve control and observation. Consideration should also be given to the production of flame safety lamps with flat tops and top air feed only.
31. We have noted the system adopted at some mines whereby special gas measurements at the roof of roadways are taken by a person who is specially appointed for the purpose and who at once advises the Deputy if any gas is detected. The presence of such gas is then confirmed by the Deputy. While sympathizing with the intention underlying this arrangement, it is perhaps open to the objection that it may result to some extent in divided responsibility. As the law now stands, however, it cannot excuse or exempt the Deputy from examining such roadways during his statutory inspections of the district. The aim must therefore be to provide equipment suitably designed to enable the Deputy himself to carry out such gas testing as is necessary for the safety of his district, and to enable him to comply with his statutory duties. Investigations are being made into the various methods and types of equipment which could he used by Deputies for testing for gas at ordinarily inaccessible places, and we recommend that these investigations and trials be pursued energetically as a priority project.
Design of Flame Safety Lamps
32. We assume that anyone issued with a flame safety lamp as a detector will also have the written permission of the Manager of the mine (as required by Regulation 15 (i) of the Ventilation Regulations) to use an electric lamp as his working light. We accordingly recommend that the emphasis in future on safety lamp development should be on the use of this equipment as a means of gas detection rather than as a means of illumination.
33. As regards relighter lamps, we welcome the introduction of alternatives to the pyrophor bar relighter such as the battery relighter and recommend that the development of any other promising alternative methods should be pursued. Now that the battery relighter is available, there is scope for a considerable reduction in the size and weight of such lamps.
Automatic Gas Detectors
34. The main value of automatic gas detectors is to check ventilation conditions on the face. They also have a valuable application at special points of potential gas risk, e.g., the highest points on roadways, and we would welcome further work on their development. For the purpose of giving warning to those working in the vicinity, however, they require to he used in conjunction with some form of visible or acoustic alarm. Their installation must not be allowed to create a false sense of security; they are an insurance against risk, but not a substitute for personal vigilance.
Carrying of Firedamp Detectors
35. We are perturbed by the number of incidents in which firedamp detectors have not been used or even carried by the workmen in the requisite numbers as required by the Ventilation Regulations. A new and powerful campaign down to colliery level should be initiated through the consultative machinery and in conjunction with the local union officials to obtain the co-operation of the workmen in carrying out in full the requirements of the Regulations. We consider that the effectiveness of providing these firedamp detectors can be appreciably improved either by arranging for the issue of relighter lamps on a more liberal scale or by ensuring that there is a sufficiency of underground relighting stations. This would eliminate the risk of lamps once extinguished remaining unlighted throughout the shift or, alternatively, the necessity of taking in spare lamps or sending lamps to bank for relighting.
36. Both as a wise measure in itself and as an example to the workmen, we would stress the value of senior officials carrying a firedamp detector when underground. In our view no senior official of the mine should make an underground visit unless he is carrying a flame safety lamp or alternative instrument.
37. There is a need for all working underground to tackle the gas problem positively and energetically whenever it occurs and, if the responsibility for taking counter measures falls within their sphere of duty, to take whatever steps are appropriate to prevent the danger from building up into an actual menace to safety, or, if not, to report it to an official. This responsibility embraces everyone, management, under-officials and workmen, but clearly there is a special responsibility resting on the Deputy to take active steps to disperse gas which he encounters in his district. As a corollary, the owners and the manager have a responsibility to see that the Deputy has the means to hand to fulfil this task — sufficient ventilation, reliable means of detection, and the equipment necessary for the actual job of dispersal.
38. The mechanics of gas flow are analogous in some respects to those of water. Just as water will flow downhill and collect in any declivities or sumps in the floor, so gas in mine roadways will flow uphill along the roof and collect in any cavities or "sumps" in the roof. Compared with water, however, gas has the big advantage that once the accumulation is dispersed and mixed with air it does not separate out again. This emphasizes the primary importance of an ample ventilation stream of sufficient velocity to break up any gas concentrations which may be present and to scour them out of the workings.
39. The results of the research which the Safety in Mines Research Establishment are conducting into means of tackling the gas layering problem are not expected for some time. We regard this work as of great importance to the safety of coal mining operations, and urge that it should be given priority in the allocation of staff and resources. Meanwhile, we consider that the best practical local means at present available for preventing or dispersing accumulations of gas in roadways — apart from good general ventilation, the importance of which we have stressed above — is the use of brattices at the key points where gas may he expected to accumulate. The brattice should be large enough to provide the air velocity necessary to break up the layer. Inclined brattices, as recommended in the Ministry of Power Safety Pamphlet No. 26, "The Ventilation of Rippings" are of considerable value in directing the air current to the point where it is needed.
40. In certain circumstances the use of brattices at the face to maintain good ventilation conditions is equally important. For example, brattice may be necessary to divert an air current into a fast end or where required into the wastes, or to ensure that any dead zones created by failure to maintain consistent pack advance are nevertheless swept by the ventilation.
41. For preventing or dispersing roof layers of firedamp in drifts of large cross-sectional area the use of a brattice such as we recommend for other roadways is generally not sufficient because of the low ventilation velocity. In drifts, therefore, the use of small individual branch pipes from the main ventilation duct to blow air into or exhaust air from places where gas is likely to accumulate would seem to be preferable, and we recommend that underground trials of this method should be carried out. This remedy, however, clearly cannot be used on such a scale as to reduce the quantity of air delivered at the tunnel face to below the minimum required.
42. While the use of a brattice will usually he sufficient for gas dispersal from the normal small roadway cavity, an exceptionally large roadway cavity calls, in our opinion, for special treatment, first for the detection of gas and secondly for clearing any that may be found, and we recommend the use either of a small auxiliary fan to blow air into the cavity or of small drainage pipes to exhaust the gas into a return airway.
43. We have already drawn attention to the fact that a layer of gas close to the roof may move against the direction of the ventilation current. Colliery officials should also he aware of the ability of gas in certain circumstances to act as a plug in a roadway without breaking up under the action of the air current, thus impeding the ventilation current in much the same way as a fall of rock on the floor.