












































|
Introduction
1. The Sub-Committee was appointed by the Safety and Health Committee of the Coal Industry National Consultative Council in October, 1957, with the following terms of reference:
| | "(a) |
To consider the summaries prepared by the Ministry of Power of the circumstances, conclusions, and recommendations in respect of the recent sequence of explosions, in particular the incidents at Lewis Merthyr. Sutton, Chanters and Barnburgh Main Collieries:
|
| | (b) |
to report to the Safety and Health Committee of the C.I.N.C.C. on the basis of the information considered in (a):
|
| | |
| | (i) |
the lessons to be learned from the explosions and the steps which could be taken to prevent similar happenings in the future:
|
| | (ii) |
the measures which could be taken to bring the findings referred to in (i) to the notice of managers, officials and workmen."
|
|
2. Apart from the four incidents specifically mentioned in the terms of reference, the Sub-Committee considered some earlier explosions to which attention was drawn by the Ministry and four which occurred subsequent to our appointment. A full list is as follows:
| Bedwas Colliery, Monmouthshire, 10th October, 1952 |
| Horden Colliery, Durham, 23rd March, 1953 |
| Glyncorrwg Colliery, Glamorganshire, 13th January, 1954 |
| Nantgarw Colliery, Glamorganshire, 9th May, 1955 |
| Blaenhirwaun Colliery, Carmarthenshire, 6th September, 1955 |
| Lewis Merthyr Colliery, Glamorganshire. 22nd November, 1956 |
| Sutton Colliery, Nottinghamshire, 21st February, 1957 |
| Chanters Colliery, Lancashire, 6th March, 1957 |
| Barnburgh Main Colliery, Yorkshire, 26th June, 1957 |
| Kames Colliery, Ayrshire, 19th November, 1957 |
| Risehow Colliery, Cumberland, 26th November, 1957 |
| Golborne Colliery, Lancashire, 7th December, 1957 |
| Lindsay Colliery, Fife, 14th December, 1957 |
3. In addition to the detailed consideration of each of these explosions, discussions were held with various experts from the Ministry's Safety in Mines Research Establishment, the National Coal Board and the National Union of Mineworkers; with practising-deputies, representing the National Association of Colliery Overmen, Deputies and Shotfirers; and with H.M. Inspectors. We gratefully acknowledge the valuable help received in this way. We should also like to record our sincere appreciation of the great service given to us by the Joint Secretaries, Mr. F. J. Neary and Mr. R. Wakefield. Not only did they give valuable help in the preparation of this Report as well as in the ordinary secretarial work inseparable from the functioning of the Committee, they were also able to give much help and guidance on many of the matters discussed during our deliberations.
4. Our purpose throughout has been to examine means of improving standards of safety and safeguarding against further explosions. Those we have reviewed inevitably reveal a number of features which, seen in the light of after events, cannot be regarded as in accordance with the highest standards of foresight and good mining practice. These incidents, however, are important for the present purpose only to the extent that they suggest ways in which similar dangers can be averted in future. To avoid anything which might he construed as an attempt to assess blame for past events, we have not related our findings to the individual explosions but have expressed them in general terms.
5. Our conclusions are set out under the following main headings:
| Ventilation |
| Strata control |
| Care and maintenance of equipment |
| Other mining factors |
| Human factors |
|
|