Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
Items for sale
Items for Sale
e-Books
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

E-Book Prev Page Return to Index Next Page E-Book
Explosions in Coal Mines
/   \

Popular Ideas About Explosions.

There are some views as to the course explosions take, which are very generally held, and often advanced, not as scientific reasons, but as based on observed facts, more or less common to all large explosions.

Expressions, which are proverbial in the mouths of miners, will now be considered, and it will be found they support the coal dust theory. The writers conceive that the old miners put forward these views as accounting, in an empirical manner, for phenomena that were unexpected. One of the commonest of these expressions is that an explosion always "faces the wind," or "travels against the fresh air." The origin of this saying probably is that, in many eases, in earlier times, explosions, started at the working face by an ignition of fire-damp, extended from the point of origin as a dust explosion, traversing the main intake, the road on which the dust lay, to the downcast shaft, the only course open to it under such circumstances being, therefore, to face the incoming air.

In all the cases under review, except Whitehaven, the explosions extended for long distances, both with and against the current of air. It seemed clear that the direction in which the air was travelling had no influence on the course of an explosion after it was once started. Cases have been observed which make it appear probable that a dust explosion, starting in a main intake, has a tendency at first to go with the air, and not against it. This, however, is only observed at the point of origin.

In order to account for the exhibition of force on the intake air roads and its absence in the returns, it is sometimes said that the explosion travels along the former route because the air is purer there, and better able to support combustion, or that "the gas seeks the fresh air." As a matter of fact, in all the collieries described, the difference between the fresh, or intake air, and the return air was very slight as regards the power of supporting combustion; and the principal impurity in the return air was probably fire-damp. The return air is warmer an4 moister, but lights burn well in it, and all the functions of life are properly performed. One class of workmen, the wastemen, work altogether in it. The writers do not think the difference in the air would have any effect in preventing an explosion extending along the return air roads.

Again, it is said, the sectional area of the return air roads is smaller, that they are more tortuous than the intakes, and so offer more resistance to the passage of the blast. This is true to a certain extent; hut, on the other hand, the return air roads in some of the cases described were for long distances straight, and as large or larger than the intakes. But yet they were not traversed by any explosion.

Then, again, it is argued, that the explosions extend to the shafts because they "act as outlets." This idea has no doubt arisen because the majority of large explosions pass to the bottom of the downcast shafts. The reason of the explosions so doing, may be the fact, that there is generally a line of dusty road extending to these shafts, and not because the shafts act as outlets. The site of the shaft is often the limit of an explosion, owing to its immediate surroundings being damp. Many large explosions have not reached the shafts.

An idea appears to be held that an explosion, caused by the combustion of fire-damp contained in a limited area, can extend for very great distances along the air ways of a mine, for distances apparently out of all proportion to the assumed quantity of explosive mixture.

The fact of explosions so often extending to the downcast shaft along the fresh air roads has probably caused this view to be held. No one has conceived that these roads were in an explosive condition along their entire length, so that, in the absence of ally other means of accounting for the extension of the explosion, it seemed necessary to suppose that a gas explosion at some distant point had so extended itself.

The writers have investigated almost all the explosions of fire-damp which have occurred in the North of England during the past thirteen years; these explosions, causing death or injury to from one to four persons, in no case produced effects greater than might have been anticipated from the known or probable amount of gas present.

The Whitehaven explosion, a pure gas explosion, is partly introduced to emphasise this aspect of the question.

In the five Durham explosions, which are regarded as explosions caused by coal dust, there were many marked examples of the sudden cessation of force, within short distances of places where the supply of coal dust ceased, and where proofs of the existence of flame were visible.

It is common for witnesses in explosion inquiries to speak of the blast passing for long distances from some point of origin, along a road not in an explosive condition, this essential condition not appearing to be considered necessary; in other words, that the force developed at some point, by the combustion of gas and air, had extended itself along confined roadways for long distances, without any addition and without any diminution of violence. The writers deem it of the utmost importance to attempt to set this view aside. It appears to them that the resilient properties of columns of air, in the narrow passages of a mine, are such, that no great force can be exerted at any considerable distance away from where actual expansion due to combustion takes place. A moderate force may be exerted some distance away, but violence sufficient to cause death, or displace timbering, does not appear to extend many yards from the actual explosion.

If the latter view be correct, it is not sufficient, in order to account for explosions such as those described, to say that an outburst of gas has taken place, and has exploded near the outburst. Before the explosion takes place the gas must be mixed with air to the explosive point over the roads along which the explosion extends. It must be explained how it was that certain roads traversed by the current of air after passing the source of gas became explosive, while other roads, traversed by currents from the same source, were untouched by the explosion. It must be explained how the gas backed against large currents of air for long distances, and how all this fouling took place without attracting the notice of men in the currents.

Such witnesses, having fire-damp and air in view only, must assume that these things need not occur before the mines are brought into the state necessary to render the large explosions under notice possible.

Finally, it must be remembered, that in all the five Durham explosions, it is a pure assumption to suppose that any sudden outburst took place.

The following examples from the explosions described may be advanced, as bearing on the above question of the transmission of force.

At Seaham, the men in the South way in No. 3 Pit, into which the explosion extended as far as the air crossings, were not killed, nor injured in any way by the explosion, nor were their lamps extinguished. They were about 400 yards beyond the limit of the explosion, and the road was open from this point to where they were working. Four of these men escaped alive by passing to the shafts by the return air road, the remainder attempting to reach the shafts by the intake perished from after-damp. One of the survivors said, "We felt a heavy wind and small coal flying." The travelling roads in No. 1 Pit, and in the Maudlin, parallel to the haulage roads, and acting as double intakes, being open at both ends, and traversed by currents of air passing off the haulage roads, were not damaged, except near their junction with the haulage roads, although great disturbance was observed on the latter. The doors in the passage leading from the No. 1 Pit travelling road to the return were not moved, although the force necessary to blow down doors is not great. The workmen at the face of all the districts were not injured by the force of the explosion, all having passed out some distance. In many cases their lights were not extinguished. The portion of undamaged road near the shaft, although in the very centre of great violence, had escaped.

At Trimdon Grange the workmen in the Cross-cut district, although in the direct line of the explosion coming up from the main road, were uninjured,, and no disturbance was noticeable on the Cross-cut haulage road, except to a limited extent near the junction. The timber in the horse road between the Second and Third South ways of the Pit Narrow Board district was not displaced, and the driver, horse, and tubs in this length were not injured by force.

At Tudhoe several marked examples of the sudden stop of force were observed.

At Whitehaven the effect produced by the explosion of what must have been a large quantity of explosive mixture of fire-damp and air was quite local. Workmen, within 50 yards of where combustion probably ceased, were not injured. A gust of air was felt a mile away.

At Usworth the explosion extended to the downcast shaft with great violence, and flame had arrived there. Its effects died out rapidly in the vicinity of the shaft in all directions. Two men at the smaller downcast, 40 yards away, escaped alive. A pony in the loose box near was not injured or burnt. Men at the lower level, 18 yards below, were not seriously injured. The explosion, arrested at the Middle North stables, had extinguished the lights of the men at the face, but had not injured them, as they all, with one exception, had passed out a considerable distance in the dark. They would be approached by the explosion from two directions — from the face of the Low North, and from the stables in the Middle North, The undisturbed portion of the main road, though in the direct line of the explosion, had escaped damage. This road was one of three, and all had escaped violence. Both the Hitch North haulage road and air way had been traversed by no force. The lights of the workmen at the face of the Hitch North would appear not to have been extinguished.

In all the five Durham explosions, although great disturbance was observed on the haulage roads, the return air ways, where free from coal dust, were undamaged, except to a trifling extent, by force passing from the intakes. This force died out very rapidly at all these points. At many places doors, stoppings, and air crossings, easily moved, would have allowed passage of force, but no such passage was observed. It is difficult to conceive how a force, capable of causing great disturbance more than a mile away in one direction, should not, in other directions, pass more than 40 yards, except that, in the one case, a vehicle existed which was wanting in the other.

In considering the facts stated, the writers are of opinion that the explosions having been arrested by want of fuel, the damage had ceased with the flame. A gust of air of considerable force would extend some distance beyond the flame, but no blast sufficient to do extensive damage; and the force of the gust of air would appear to diminish rapidly as the distance from the flame increased, lights not being extinguished 300 or 400 yards away.

The fact of the passages of a coal mine being filled with air, an elastic fluid, preserves those passages out of the field of an explosion from damage.

It has been the custom to speak of phenomena such as those described, either as examples of the erratic nature of an explosion, the vagaries of which follow no natural laws, or to get over the difficulty by saying that the district, or part of the pit not penetrated by the explosion, was a cul de sac, notwithstanding the facts that the road was open into it and another road led out of it, and that, in some cases, men rescued stated the ventilation was in its ordinary state at the time.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print