Some striking features of these explosions may be pointed out.
In the Whitehaven explosion, coal dust could have played no part, but a large volume of gaseous mixture, which was known to exist before the explosion, must have been ignited, probably by a defective safety lamp.
The effect of this explosion was strictly limited, so far as violence was concerned, to the immediate vicinity of the explosive mixture. The violence or force of the explosion was less than in any of the Durham explosions. The flame had not extended 50 yards from where the explosive mixture had been before ignition. The workmen, in the field of the explosion, had all been under some alarm before the explosion, and, after it, had moved about 100 yards, one of them escaping alive. Their bodies exhibited no signs of the severe burning common after explosions in dusty pits. No signs of burning were observed except on the bodies of the victims. The explosion had extended along the return side of the brattice.
The five Durham explosions all present the following features.
In the absence of a knowledge of the danger of coal dust they could not have been expected. No accumulations of gas were known to exist, approaching in quantity what would be necessary to cause the wide-spread destruction, nor were such accumulations considered possible.
In all the five explosions the downcast shafts were damaged. At Trimdon Grange, Tudhoe, West Stanley, and Usworth the explosions did not cross or pass the downcast shafts they were wet shafts, and the roadways in their vicinity were damp. At Seaham, the explosion crossed the downcast shaft, and extended far beyond it. This shaft was dry. In the four wet shafts the damage was limited to a few yards above the plane of the explosion, the dry shaft was damaged for more than 80 yards above the plane of the explosion.
In all cases, the violence and flame of the explosions were confined to those roads on which there was much coal dust. The greatest extent and amount of violence was on the intake and haulage roads, or between the downcast shafts and the caution boards or lamp stations, where gas could be least expected, and where naked lights were used daily.
In those cases where the explosions extended into the working faces less violence was apparent, but more evidence of burning in the shape of coked coal dust.
In no case was the return air way the route by which an explosion passed from one part of the pits to another. The explosions did not extend indifferently by all accessible routes, but, in passing from one district to others, were confined to the intake and haulage roads. On these roads was the fresh air entering the mine and much coal dust. The return air ways carry off all the gas made in the mine, but are free from coal dust.
The return air ways were unaffected at Seaham, Tudhoe, and Usworth, and were affected only to a very limited extent at Trimdon Grange and West Stanley, next those parts of the working faces over which the explosion had extended, and where the dust in them was chiefly coal dust, and where coked coal dust was observed after the explosions.
Intake air roads, such as the two travelling roads at Seaham, and the air way to the Hitch North district at Usworth, over which no coals were led, and which were comparatively free from coal dust, escaped.
In many cases the explosions were arrested at places where the haulage roads were wet or damp. The most marked examples were the North Main Coal at Seaham, the Cross-cut way at Trimdon Grange, the Shieldfield and No. 6 ways at Tudhoe, and the Middle North and Hitch North ways at Usworth. In all these cases. the air passing along the intakes which escaped, was common with or taken from currents passing along other intakes over which the explosions did extend. In several cases the explosions were arrested before reaching the face on horse roads, where the dust was largely mixed with stone dust. This was the case in the South way of No. 3 Pit at Seaham, and, probably, the Lawson's way at Usworth.
The explosions passed in every case towards the goaves; that is, whenever the course of an explosion was traced, the doors, stoppings, and movable bodies were blown towards, and never from, the goaves.
In no case did the explosion ascend or descend vertically, so as to extend the explosion on other planes. The direction of a passage, whether vertical or horizontal, would not influence the extension of an explosion of a gaseous body. Little coal dust collects in shafts or staples, so that flame supported by it will be checked in them.
In all the five Durham explosions there was no evidence that, up to the moment of the explosion, any movement had taken place amongst the workmen indicative of alarm.
We have then to consider the possibility of some mixture of fire-damp and air, in any given area, exploding and carrying its effects instantaneously over certain roads only, not expanding equally on all sides, but passing in a most capricious manner over the haulage roads only. This is difficult to conceive.
Or we have to consider the roads passed over as already containing, in themselves, the elements of explosion. If this were due to fire-damp and air the issue of fire-damp must be assumed from sonic source, and it does not appear conceivable that it should extend itself over one particular set of roads only, missing out other roads equally available. While this issue, of what would have to be an enormous volume of fire-damp, is going on no alarm is felt by any of the workmen, some of whom were using naked lights.
The only possible explanation appears to the writers to be that the roads traversed by the explosion contained elements of explosion of such a character as not to alarm the workmen, and these elements could only be coal dust and air, with a small percentage of fire-damp added in some parts.
The Seaham, Tudhoe, West Stanley, and Usworth explosions were simultaneous with the firing of shots in stone, and the flames of these shots are concluded to have been the means of ignition. In these cases the explosion took place when the pits were occupied by repairers and stonemen, the only time when the operations of the mines allowed the shots to be fired.
At Trimdon Grange the explosion was probably initiated by a small explosion of fire-damp and air, and in this ease the pit was occupied by the ordinary workmen.
In three of the cases, Seaham, Tudhoe, and Usworth, the shots were fired on a main intake air road, in stone, and, passing the points where the shots were fired, were currents of air of 61,000, 23,000, and 26,000 cubic feet per minute. In one of these three cases the shot had been ignited by a naked flame. The writers are of opinion that the air in these three cases would be practically free from fire-damp. At West Stanley, a stone shot had been ignited by a naked flame at the working face, in a place containing much dust, and the air in this case would contain a small percentage of fire-damp.
In the four cases where the point of origin is assumed to have been a shot, there was a marked absence of disturbance near it ; in the three cases where the shot was fired on a main intake, no timber was displaced for from 50 to 75 yards on each side. Where the shot was fired at the face, no timber was displaced for 80 yards from it. None of the shots were blown out shots — one was evidently an over-charged shot.
At Trimdon Grange, where the explosion is supposed to have been originated by a small explosion of fire-damp and air, the absence of damage at the point of origin was not marked.
It is well known that gunpowder is largely used in coal mines, and it would appear probable that, if in one case a shot causes an explosion, these disasters should be of more frequent occurrence, but an examination of the conditions under which gunpowder is used will help to explain this apparent anomaly.
Gunpowder is used at the face of workings —
In coal,
In stone drifts and staples.
Near the face and on the in-byeside of the engine planes it is used
In taking down top stone,
In taking up bottom stone,
so as to make roads available for the passage of horses, and these roads sometimes become engine planes.
In all the above cases there are usually no deposits of dust approaching in character those on the upper parts of old haulage roads.
Between the shafts and the engine landings the roads are completed, and gunpowder is rarely used on them; when it is used it is generally at points where the haulage road is above or below the level of the seam, and is altogether in stone, and it is then used in making refuge holes, removing side stone, so as to obtain access to the coat or in enlarging the road. Thus the shots at Usworth and Tudhoe were fired at points where probably a shot had not been fired since the road was completed as a haulage road. At Seaham, the shot was for the purpose of enlarging a refuge hole ; and it may be stated that on the 25th October, 1871, an explosion took place at Seaham Colliery, which was simultaneous with the firing of a shot in the stone near the point where the shot was fired in the explosion under consideration. Moreover, during the year 1872, on the firing of a stone shot near the same point, an explosion was caused, which, happily, did not spread.
None of the shots assumed as points of origin were blown out shots. A blown out shot is one in which the gunpowder blows out the stemming or tamping, in the drill hole, and does not throw the stone. The gases and flame from the combustion of the gunpowder all escape at the mouth of the drill hole. Where the resistance offered by the stemming and the stone to be thrown is nearly equal, they may give way together, and in such a case flame will issue from the drill hole. When the drill hole is short, and the length of the stemming consequently limited, an issue of flame is probable. There is always flame at the place where the powder lies, and a variety of conditions will determine the issue of flame into the air and its amount. It may depend to a large extent on the position of the dust, whether a larger quantity of it will be disturbed and thrown into the air by a blown out shot, or by a shot throwing its burden.
The writers think it possible that the shock communicated through the stone to adjacent surfaces will be greatest when the shot is not blown out ; on the other hand, the rush of gases into the air will be greatest and more concentrated when the shot is blown out; In one case the energy of the gunpowder expends itself in moving and shaking solid stone, in the other in moving the stemming in the drill hole and the air outside it.
If there is a quantity of upper dust hanging to the stone and timber, and heaped up on the ledges, a shot doing its work may be more likely to throw this dust into the air than a blown out shot, and a small issue of flame might complete the conditions necessary for its inflammation.
If the dust is on the floor the shock of a shot doing its work would not disturb it to any considerable extent ; the rush of gases from a blown out shot, directed downwards, would be more likely to throw it into the air.
The shots fired at Seaham, Tudhoe, and Usworth Collieries were all by the side of and at right angles to, old haulage roads, with stone surfaces; they were about midway between roof and floor. The tremor communicated to the adjacent stone and timber would dislodge and throw into the air coal dust of the finest and most inflammable character. The air currents had high velocities, which would favour the extension of the flame by the dust.
The shot fired at West Stanley Colliery was under different conditions, and at a place where the presence of any upper dust was improbable.
The direction of the drill hole in this case could not be determined, and we are left to conjecture what the exact conditions were which led to the inflammation of the dust. There would be some fire-damp in the air, and there may have been coal dust in the stemming of the shot.
Blown out shots are sometimes referred to as being in themselves capable of causing an explosion on a limited scale, and of carrying flame to distant points, frequently burning men who had retired to places where they considered themselves safe from any possible effects of the shot. That is to say, gunpowder placed in a drill hole blows out the stemming, and causes explosive results and burning a considerable distance from the drill hole. The writers have often heard of examples of this in coal mines, but never in metalliferous mines, where gunpowder is largely used; thus the experience of the writers in metalliferous mines in the North of England, including the Cleveland ironstone mines, and the Cumberland and Lancashire hematite iron ore mines, has never furnished them with an example of the kind; and Dr. C. Le Neve Foster, one of H.M. Inspectors of Metalliferous Mines, in answer to a query on the subject, says, in a letter dated 18th January, 1886 :— " I have never heard of a blown out shot doing a considerable amount of damage in a metal mine. The phrase in use at metal mines is that the charge 'blows out the tamping.' No cases of men being burnt by flames, which penetrated to points previously considered safe, have ever been reported to me." It appears to the writers that effects produced by blown out shots in coal mines, and, by some, wholly attributed to the powder, must be caused by some agent other than the gunpowder, otherwise the same phenomena would be observed wherever it is used.
It is found that coal dust is always present when flame extends far from a blown out shot, and is sometimes accompanied by fire-damp.