Returning to the shafts, and starting from the West Pit, the stalls in a stable on the right side of the road, at (6), had been blown northward. The explosion appeared to have passed between the East and West Pit workings by a short travelling road connecting the haulage roads near the shafts. In the West Pit, the disturbance, such as displacement of timbering, causing heavy falls of roof, and the blowing out of doors and stoppings, continued up to the limits shown by broken lines on Plan 2. At the West way landing (7), the return wheel of the haulage rope was forced in-bye out of its hearings. A door beyond the lauding was blown in-bye. The explosion had not extended far along old No. 5 way. At the junction of No. 6 and new No. 5 haulage roads a balk supporting brickwork, at an unused air crossing, was forced in-bye (8). In new No .5 way, at (9), large timbers were blown in-bye. At (10) the chain attaching the main rope to a set of tubs was broken. The tubs were being drawn in-bye by the tail rope at the time of the explosion, the main rope drum running loose on its shaft. It is possible that the breaking of this chain was caused by falls of stone on the rope further out. At (11), in the whin dyke, a sheet of thin iron plate, placed near the roof to protect persons passing along from water issuing from the roof, was observed to have been blown 21 yards in the direction of the shaft. This was near the limit of the explosion in this direction, and was clearly caused by a reversed current. There was no one in the workings beyond it. All the doors, air crossings, and such stoppings as were moved, were blown from the intakes to the returns. No disturbance was observed in the return air ways.
Indications of the presence of flame were almost entirely confined to the bodies of the victims of the explosion.
Thus men were burnt near the downcast shafts. Men were also burnt at the following places :— In the East Pit; near the Shieldfield way end, near the Croxdale way end, near the Coldstream way end, and between there and the Sunderland Bridge way landing: in the West Pit; near No. 6 way end, near No. 5 way end, and in No. 6 way, the men in the engine set were burnt at (10).
The explosion caused no fires in the mine.
At the time of the explosion there were, on the plane of the explosion, some 60 or 70 men. All to the south of the pits survived, and a few men were rescued from the neighbourhood of the shafts, some of whom afterwards died.
There was a fire at a boiler on the plane of the explosion, about 1,000 yards from the shafts to the south, and not in the field of the explosion.
All the workmen on the in-byeside of the caution boards had safety lamps; some of those on the out-byeside of the caution boards had safety lamps and some open lights. There were open lights about the shafts, and the workmen who, at the time of the explosion, were being drawn in-bye in a set of tubs, at (10), had naked lights with them.
Gunpowder was to be used at two points on the night of the explosion; one of these points was on the main intake, between the shaft and the Shieldfield way end. Two men here were blasting down stone in order to enlarge a stenton, or passage, between the intake and return air ways.
Classifying the workmen on the plane of the explosion as before, we have :—
| 1st. — Survivors. |
| 2nd. — Victims in the field of the explosion. |
| 3rd. — Victims outside the field of the explosion. |
The survivors stated that they had been under no alarm up to the moment of the explosion. The master shifter, or official in charge of the pit, was one of them. He had been in the field of the explosion, but, being in a cabin, was somewhat protected. He was burnt and rendered insensible. At the time of the explosion he was within 100 yards of the downcast shafts. An engineman, in an engine house within 20 yards of the shafts, was also rendered insensible.
The victims in the field of the explosion were all found at or near where their work required them. There was nothing to suggest that up to the moment of the explosion anything had alarmed them.
The victims engaged at or near the working faces, or at points beyond the limits of the explosion, had all moved some distance, bringing their lamps with them in most cases; they had succumbed to after-damp.
The observed indications of the direction of the explosion were not sufficient to point, at all conclusively, to any particular place as being the point of origin; they are not, however, inconsistent with a point of origin which the writers strongly incline to think may be deduced from the consideration of certain other facts. On a portion of the Sunderland Bridge haulage road, between (3) and (4) 100 or 120 yards in length, none of the timber, of which there was a considerable quantity, was displaced; although the timber was swept out of the road extending from each extremity of the undisturbed length for long distances. This undisturbed length of road lay in the direct course of the explosion, and was the connecting link between the sections of the pit on each side of it. The only other roads at this point were the return air ways, one on each side of the intake, and no explosion had passed along either of them. There was nothing to explain why an explosion, on arriving at either end of this undisturbed portion of road, should have had its violence so reduced as to pass it over without blowing out the timbering, and should resume its full force at the other cud. On the contrary, this length of road had been raised above the coal for the convenience of haulage, so that there were no stoppings to blow out at the sides and relieve the pressure. It appeared more probable that the origin of the explosion lay in this undisturbed length, and that in some manner the force had increased in both directions. At the time of the explosion two stonemen were engaged in blasting down stone about the centre of the undisturbed length of road. They were removing stone above a stenton in which stood a door leading to the return air way. They had been passed by the master shifter about half-an-hour before the explosion; they were then drilling a shot-hole at right angles to the haulage road and within a few feet of it. After the explosion the shot was found to have been fired, and the bodies of the stonemen were found about 40 yards from it, nearer the shaft, this being a position they might assume in relation to the shot after igniting the fuse. These facts appear to indicate that the firing of the shot and the explosion had been simultaneous. The road where the shot was fired was dry and dusty, and there was timber near the shot on which dust might rest. On both sides of the shot, and within a few feet of it, was a pack wall of loose stones, in the interstices of which coal dust would collect.
The circumstances present a striking similarity to those observed at Seaham and Usworth, viz., the existence of a portion of undamaged road, in the centre of which a shot had been fired, the road on each side of the undamaged portion having been swept by the blast for long distances.
The presumption is that the concussion of the shot had filled the air with coal dust, and flame following had ignited the coal dust, which carried the explosion to all parts of the pit where there was a sufficient amount of dust to support the flame. The place where the shot was fired was swept by an air current of more than 20,000 cubic feet per minute, direct from the downcast shaft, so that it is highly improbable that any gas was present.
In this explosion there were two cases where the blast was arrested at considerable distances from the face on coming to places where the roads were damp or wet. One was in the Shieldfield way, where the effects of the explosion ceased near the engine-landing, where there was a pump and the road was wet. The men in the workings beyond had come out after the explosion, and were found dead at the landing; they had been killed by after-damp. The other case was in No. 6 way of the West Pit. The road from the whin dyke inward was damp, and the effects of the explosion gradually diminished from that point, until, before the landing was reached, they had died away altogether. The shafts were wet and the roads near them damp; the explosion did not extend beyond the shafts. No damage was done in the return air ways.
This explosion, like that at Seaham, was almost entirely confined to intake and haulage roads. The two main districts into which it extended were ventilated by currents of air coming down separate downcast shafts.