H. W. Schneider, M.P. — Is a large proprietor of Iron mines; his largest mine is the Park Mine, Dalton, Lancashire. Approves of a rate on mines when profitable. Considers it unjust to rate exhaustible property, such as mines, in the same way as land or farms.
S. Dobson, mining engineer, Glamorganshire, thought that the whole system of rating in regard to Iron works, Coal works, and mines generally, ought to be remodelled, and that the rates would then be less oppressive. The system at present in operation is extremely defective and unsatisfactory. No fixed principle is adopted. Mines, whether Coal or Iron, should not be rated on the royalties, but on the annual value to let, making due allowance for the exhaustible nature of mines.
F Wragge, manager of Lord Granville's collieries and ironstone mines and works in Stoke-upon-Trent, &c., spoke of the want of uniformity of system in the rating of collieries in North Staffordshire; thought it unfair to take the royalty on Coal mines as the basis of assessment; the property is sold rather than leased. The interest of the royalty. and not the royalty itself, which is capital, should be rated.
Geo. Whieldon, proprietor of considerable mines of Coal and Ironstone, near Coventry, stated that in his district the Coal is rated to the poor, and the ironstone is not rated. Thought the system of rating mines under the 43 Eliz., which exempted Iron mines, unjust. Is of opinion that funded property, and all other personal property, should be rated to the poor if mines are so rated. Payment of rates by Coal mines under the present system, is a rate upon capital rather than upon the rent of the mine. In his district the value of property by the opening of mines had been increased far more than sufficient to compensate for any additional burthen which may have been thrown upon the poor-rates. Has worked the Hawkesbury Colliery, situate about five miles from Coventry, since 1826; his father and brother worked the mines previously — they have been worked above a century. For 25 years during his father and brother's proprietorship, there was not one shilling of profit; not a single dividend received, nor even the rent of the surface land, the expenses were so great. Manufactories pay a small amount of rate as compared with collieries. He would make this one observation with respect to buildings and manufactories being rated, not profits; many people he knew were getting their £5,000 and £6,000 a year, and what did they pay? not one-fourth part so much as he paid to the support of the poor; because it was merely upon their buildings; and not only was that a glaring fact which showed the injustice of the principle upon which property was now rated to the poor, but, he might add, that these manufactories, these large extensive buildings were always valuable; they might be converted into dwelling houses in a populous locality when they were done with; but the mines were all under ground; they were of no value whatever after the mineral had been worked out; there were no houses or factories, or any thing of that kind; it all remained under ground, unproductive entirely.
Rob. Heath, a Coal and Iron master, at Newcastle-under-Lyme. — Is Chairman of the North Staffordshire Coal and Iron Masters' Association. Considers the system unfair of assessing the North Staffordshire collieries under the royalty or mine rent, inasmuch as the royalty is in many instances portion of the purchase of the estate. He computes that in proportion to the number of hands employed respectively in the earthenware manufactories and in the collieries, the latter pay nearly ten times as much as the former to the poor-rate. The miners, he thought, are more provident and better cared for by their masters than the potters. Collieries do not derive any benefit from local improvement rates.
Several other witnesses were examined, who all spoke to the unsatisfactory state of the law in regard to the rating of mines. As the enquiry proceeded, the Committee admitted, that they found the subject assumed an importance much greater than had been anticipated, involving enormous sums of money and enormous interests. The whole of the evidence was published in Aug., 1857, to which the Committee appended a Report; the Report is very brief, and is as follows :—
Committee's Report.
"That your Committee have taken evidence on the subject referred to them from all parts of the country. This evidence has shown that the liability of mines to be rated to the poor and other parochial rates is full of anomalies, and (except in the case of Coal mines) depends more on the form of agreement between the lessor and lessee than on any general rule of rateability. Although mines (other than Coal mines) are not as such rateable, yet, where the royalty or due is reserved in kind, it is held to be rateable on the legal principle, that the lord who receives it is an occupier of land, and as such is subject to be rated for his occupation under the statute of the 43rd of Elizabeth, The reservation of royalties in kind appears, from the evidence, to be still the practice in Derbyshire, and in some districts of Cornwall, and to have been the universal practice in Cornwall till the year 1832. Where the royalty is reserved in the shape of a money payment, such liability is held not to exist. Open mineral workings, quarries, and Coal mines, are deemed to be rateable, and are rated, in all cases. Your Committee is of opinion, that there are no valid grounds for these distinctions. That so long as Coal mines, and open mineral workings, and quarries are assessed to the different local rates, your Committee see no reason why the rating should not be extended to all other mines. That open mineral workings, or quarries, and close mines, should, as far as rating is concerned, be placed on the same footing. That evidence has been given of peculiar customs existing in Derbyshire, and that the lord's dues, arising from lead mines in that county, are taken in kind, and are assessed both to the poor and highway rates That it has been contended with great force before your Committee, that in the assessment of mines the principle should be recognised, that the working of a mine, of whatever description, is the using up of the corpus of the estate, and not of the mere annual produce capable of re-production. That in making the assessment on mineral property, of whatever description, all plant and machinery, locomotive or stationary, in any way connected with or belonging to the mines, and which is incidental and necessary to the working thereof, should be assessed as a whole, together with and as part of the mine, and not separately. — 5th August, 1857."
COST OF THE ENQURIRY. — During this Parliamentary Enquiry there were thirty-three witnesses examined from the various mineral districts; and the total sum paid for expenses of journeys and allowance during absence from home, amounted to £296 15s. 6d.
Please Note: These web pages retain the original pagination from the publication