Chapter VII.
COLLIERY LEASES AND RENTS. COLLIERIES OF THE BISHOP OF DURHAM AND OTHER PROPRIETORS. THE SURFACE, WAYLEAVES, ETC. LEASES FOR LIVES, RENEWABLE BY FINE; TENTALE RENT, RENT UPON TONNAGE, BY THE ACRE, BY AMOUNT OF VALUE SOLD, OR CERTAIN RENT ONLY. GENERAL CLAUSES OF A. COLLIERY LEASE. MODE OF VALUING MINES — OPINIONS OF J. PEASE, S. DOBSON, T. J. TAYLOR, H. W. SCHNEIDER, M.P., AND OF M. DUNN, ONE OF HER MAJESTY'S INSPECTORS OF MINES. VALUE OF ROYALTIES.
Colliery Leases and Rents.
In the Parliamentary Enquiry before a Select Committee of the House of Commons in the year 1836 on the Coal Trade, and in the years 1838 and 1839 on Church Leases, much valuable information was given on the subject of Leases, Royalties, Wayleaves, &c., particularly in regard to the system adopted in the district of the Northern Coal-field. The evidence of Messrs. Buddle, Wood, Davison, and other competent authorities, was to the following effect :— The Bishop of Durham's collieries are generally let on leases for three lives, and so me for years under certain reserved annual rents, in both cases renewable by fine. The Dean and Chapter leases are for 21 years, on payment of a fine or a certain annual and tentale rent, and sometimes on the payment of a fine and tentale also, in which case the fine covers a stipulated number of tens to be worked annually. In letting a colliery on a certain annual and tentale rent, the rent is to secure to the lessor a fixed income from the colliery, for which the lessee is allowed to work a certain number of tens, at a stipulated rate per ten; and he is to pay the same rate per ten for any surplus workings over that quantity; but the lessee must pay the annual rent whether he works the quantity of Coal to cover it at the stipulated rate of tentale or not; the lessee having the power, during the whole term of the lease, or some limited number of years, to work up the deficiency. If, for example, a colliery let for a term of 21 years, at a certain annual rent of £1,000 and a tentale of 208., he would be entitled to work 1,000 tens to cover the rent of £1,000; but for every ten which he should work more than 1,000, he would have to pay 20s. On the other hand, if he should work only 900 tens, he still pays the £1,000 rent; but he would be entitled to work up the arrear of 100 tens, the next or any succeeding year of the term, without paying any tentale rent for the same. The ten is a local. or customary measure, and very arbitrary; it varied in different periods, and had its origin from a keel-load consisting of ten chaldrons; but it seems now to have settled itself to a positive standard, and more particularly with the Dean and Chapter of Durham. The usual ten is 440 Coal bushels, of 36 gallons Winchester, which equated to weight is 48 tons 11 cwt. 2 qrs. 17 lbs. and a decimal of 9.2; that is, a fractional measure. The Dean and Chapter found it more convenient to adopt a measure which is not so fractional, and they have made theirs 432 bushels, which is 47 tons, 14 cwt. In the Coal trade, generally, the ten is now considered as 48 tons. The Bishop's collieries are frequently worked by sublessees, who take or purchase the mines of the immediate lessees under the Bishop. The lessee generally enters into a covenant with his sub-lessee to renew for an equivalent term to which he may acquire by renewal from the Church.
The surface is frequently purchased without the under ground property; sometimes the surface is in one proprietor, the stone in the hands of another, and the Coal in a third, and no party able to get at the subterraneous strata without encroaching upon the property of the other. In letting the surface, the Dean and Chapter reserve the right of granting the wayleaves, sinking pits, and other easements for working the collieries. Most of the large Coal tracts in the manors belonging to the See, on the contrary, contain copyhold and customary freehold lands, in which the Bishop cannot grant to his Coal lessees these privileges, unless sanctioned by the custom of the particular manor. The rents charged for granting wayleaves, and other privileges, upon the lands of the Church, to persons working other Coal than that of the Church, form a large and increasing part of their revenues. Both the See and the Dean and Chapter, with respect to their own collieries, give the lessee of the colliery all those privileges with the lease of the Coal; but if other parties want to have a wayleave across the same land, the Dean and Chapter give it to them upon paying a certain wayleave rent, together with compensation to the occupiers of the surface at the rate of double rents for the land taken. The rates of way-leaves are arbitrary, inasmuch as the Church can fix what sum they please. In some instances, the Church reserves the power to allow others to come down a railway already made, paying the first person who made the waggon-way or railway for the wear and tear of his road, and the Dean and Chapter a wayleave rent in addition. First of all, the person applying was to pay the person who was the first lessee for the wayleave, for the wear and tear, by taking Coals down his way; and then he pays the Dean and Chapter so much besides that, for the privilege of going. Covenants are generally inserted in these mining leases, prohibiting the approach within a certain distance of mansion houses or plantations; and the lessee is bound to restore the land, after the working of the mine ceases, to its fit condition. — (See History of the County of Durham, 1857, Vol. I., pp. 144 and 147.)
Mr. Dunn, in his Treatise on the Winning and Working of Collieries, 1852, says — "The principle upon which rent is reserved by the proprietor, in the leasing of collieries, is governed, in different districts, by ancient custom, or by some peculiar circumstance; but the basis is founded upon the probable profit to arise from the fair and proper working, and the extraction of the greatest quantity of Coal possible from the mines. In many cases, customs were established under circumstances subsequently altered; but all are more or less intended to bear upon an efficient working of the mine, and the disposal of the produce. Hence the now universal custom of reserving the rent upon one or other of the following principles, viz. :— 1. Rent upon tonnage; 2, rent upon the amount of sales; 3, rent by the acre of Coal — one foot thick, and so in proportion; and 4, rent certain — viz., a certain sum per annum, independent of the quantities of Coal that may be raised from the property. This principle of letting, however, is now nearly obsolete.
Please Note: These web pages retain the original pagination from the publication