"I estimate the profit, when a certain per cent. is spoken of, on the probable quantity of Coals to be sold, in the first place; the probable price to be obtained, in the next place, for them; the probable expense of working those Coals, and the probable profit that would be made, under all the circumstances connected with that colliery. If I was an original proprietor, I should calculate my profits on the sum invested; if I were a purchaser, I should calculate it upon the purchase money I had paid. The rate of percentage would differ, whether I was an original purchaser, or a purchaser subsequent to that; presuming the price I paid for the share subsequent was more or less than the shares were originally. I have known instances occur both ways. I would myself not be content with 8 per cent. profit. I disposed of my share in the Hetton Colliery at the rate of £324,000 for the whole colliery."
Redemption of Capital.
The following hypothetical statement of redemption of capital, as applied to the deep collieries, was laid before the Committee by Mr. Matthias Dunn :— Supposing one of the deep collieries to cost fitting up for a 31 years' lease, everything included, £100,000, of which engines, railways, waggons, &c., to comprise £30,000; but that at the termination of the lease the said stock will only bring £20,000, thus leaving for redemption during the lease £80,000.
Now as the amount of £1 per annum for 31 years, reckoned at 4 per cent., will amount to £60, it will require, to redeem the above sum, the annual deposit of £1,333, being upon the original capital 1¾ per cent. per annum. If the same capital was to be redeemed in 21 years, it would require £2,500 per annum, or 2½ per cent. Therefore, assuming for redemption 2 per cent., common interest 5 per cent., and additional for mining profit 7 per cent., equal to 14 per cent., which includes all necessary costs of working and keeping up the supply of Coals. Assuming the current working charges, rents, &c., to amount to 19s. per Newcastle chaldron; the above interest upon original expenditure of 5 per cent. or £5,000 per annum upon 40,000 chaldrons, will be 2s. 6d. — total £1 1s. 6d., say, for contingences, £1 2s. 0d. Present selling prices, 28s. 6d. and 24s. 6d., and supposing equal quantities, would be 26s. 6d., or 4s. 6d. profit, which will be 9 per cent. upon the original investment, covering redemption of capital and mining profit.
If the vend, instead of being 40,000 chaldrons, should be less, the annual profit will be reduced in proportion, as it will be if the Coal should not produce so large an amount of the higher priced Coals.
Assessing Coal and Iron Mines.
In assessing this species of property, no uniform principle has been preserved. The royalty, rent, or galeage, paid to the proprietor, becomes in some districts the criterion of the rateable value of a Coal mine; but disputes continually arise as to the value of the mine at the time of rating, in the absence of some general principle. To such extent have differences and discontent prevailed in the mining districts, that the subject was considered of sufficient importance to become a matter of enquiry, in 1857, before a Select Committee of the House of Commons; and before this Committee a number of competent witnesses were examined in order to ascertain the practice adopted of rating mines in the different mining districts.
Joseph Pease, Darlington, gave evidence as to South Durham, and stated that he had nine or ten collieries at work, and was also largely interested in Iron mines; had about 1,000 or 1,200 freehold cottages of his own for workmen. Was not rated upon any principle; the battle is fought upon the poor-rates, and the assessors endeavour to get as much as they can. Was rated, perhaps, for the mine in one township; had his railroad in another township; and the shipping places in another township; and each of these townships endeavour to assume that the larger amount of profit is got in that township. Coke ovens are rated when in different townships, and that is twice rating the identical Coal — once upon the raw material and again upon the manufactured, which is called "oven-tax." Should like to have the Coal rated as a whole with fixed principles; but the real principle is to rate upon the rent. It would be a boon if some fixed rating were devised; it is a perfect anomaly to charge Coal mines exclusively.
T. J. Taylor, mining engineer, Earsdon, is interested in Coal mines, and pays all rates which property, under any circumstances, are liable to, except tithe. In South Northumberland the tentale rent of the collieries is taken as the basis of the rating. When the colliery is situated in one township and the pitmen's cottages in another, we proceed in this way :— Supposing the total rent, after deductions, to be £2,812 10s. 0d.; say there are 300 dwelling houses, double and single, at an average rent of £3 10s. each, that would be £1,050; deduct 1-4th as per Tenement Act (in some cases as high as one half is allowed; that would be £262 10s. — which leaves for pitmen's dwelling houses £787 10s. 0d. in this case the rating would be in the township where the mine is worked and the plant situated £2,025, the pitmen's dwellings in another township £787 10s. 0d., making the total sum to be rated upon £2,812 10s. 0d. The same principle is adopted where the Coal is worked in different townships. Has doubts as to the policy of rating Coal mines at all, but thinks there should be no distinction as to rating other kinds of minerals. If there is no actual produce from a mine it is not rated; and as a rule we are not rated until we actually get a profit out of the mine. There has been a decrease of rates in the colliery districts with which he is more immediately connected.
T. E. Forster, mining viewer, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, spoke of the practice at Seaton Delaval district, Northumberland. We take, he said, the tentale rent as the basis for rating. All property connected with the mine is included in the tentale rent ; but we have a railway through the township which also pays. We are never rated during the sinking of a colliery, because there is no beneficial occupation. The rate paid includes the agents' houses, miners' cottages, and all buildings connected with the works.
Thos. Powell. — Has been engaged in the Coal trade in South Wales for 47 years. Works more Coal than any other person in South Wales. Does not work much Iron mine. Pays nearly £3,000 a year in poor-rates in respect of his collieries and machinery, considers it unjust that Iron mines should be exempt from rates, whilst Coal mines pay them. Pays rates not on the actual royalty, but on a royalty which the parish considers a fair value.
Please Note: These web pages retain the original pagination from the publication