|
Aldwarke Main Shaft AccidentExtracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1904 Report of W. Walker (page 11) continued Inquest held before Mr. J. Kenyon-Parker, Deputy Coroner, at the Station Hotel, Aldwarke, near Rotherham. 3rd March, 1904. Attending the inquiry were Mr. W. M. Gichard, representing the owners of the colliery ; and Mr. J. Raley (instructed by the Yorkshire Miners' Association) appeared for the relatives of the deceased. E. W. Thirkell, manager of the mine, said he heard of the accident before 6 o'clock on the morning of 23rd February, and immediately proceeded to the place. He could see that the rope was broken. The cage was upon the low landing ; there were two decks to it, and the lower part had telescoped into the top one. The men were inside, and they were extricated as soon as possible and medically attended. The rope which broke was made of special improved plough steel, and had a breaking strain of 56 tons. It was put on on 14th August, 1902, and therefore had been in use about 18 months. The ropes were usually taken off after being in use about two years, and utilised as balance or haulage ropes afterwards. During the last nine years, no rope had been taken off under two years. The total number of draws in the shaft was about 134 in the 24 hours, for 67 for each cage, whereas an ordinary winding rope would do 600 draws in 10 hours, as well as a considerable amount of work besides. The ropes had been examined every day, and every care had been taken. The working load on the ropes never reached 1/10th of the breaking strain. Exhaust steam came up this shaft, and the pit water was salty. John Walker, winding engineman, said he was on duty when the rope broke. He went to work at 4 o'clock in the morning. He had been at Aldwarke 28 years, and learned to wind 35 years ago. He was letting down the third cage load of men at the usual speed, and shut off steam just before he had got half way. When about six revolutions from the bottom he reversed his lever to pull up. When about four revolutions from the bottom the engine came to a stand for a moment, and then the ascending cage began to descend. The broken rope end came over into the engine house. He had examined the ropes in the engine house, and the engine, that morning, and had also tried the ropes with loaded cages. There was a footbrake on the engine, which he used standing up. He would swear there was no sudden putting on of the brake ; he had not applied the brake at all before the accident. Thomas Brameld said his duty was to examine the drawing rope. He inspected the rope about 3 o'clock in the afternoon of the day before the accident. The inspection took from about eight to ten minutes. He examined it by holding a piece of india-rubber, and letting it run through. He found nothing wrong. Sometimes they put the calipers on the rope. The diameter of the rope was 1 1/8 inches. It had shown slight diminution in the diameter since it was bought ; this was through wear. Applying the calipers was the only test he had for testing the circumference of the rope. If the rope was gradually getting thinner he would find it out by the wear of the wires, which he could both feel and see. The real object of letting the rope run through his hand was to find out broken wires. The rope was fixed in August, 1902, and had not been capped since. John Edward Stead, F.R.S., practising in Middlesborough as a metallurgical chemist, was called by Mr. Raley. He had had 32 years practical experience in the testing of steel. On examining the fractured rope he found that the best parts had a breaking strain of 51 tons, and in the weakest parts it was 25 tons. The breaking strain of the whole rope was between 35 and 40 tons. About 3½ tons would be a proper working load. The cause of the breakage in his opinion was due to two things, the rope being weakened at that particular place by a certain amount of internal corrosion. That would probably be hidden to a certain extent. The rope was well protected between the wires by a tarry substance, and had not suffered to any sensible extent by rusting. The diminution of strength was due to friction of the wires as they passed over the pulley. He did not think the accident was caused by the inherent incapacity of the rope ; it was due to some extraneous cause — either the sudden putting on of the brake or the cage stopping. The circumference of ropes could be tested by means of pieces of paper instead of calipers. It was most important that a rope should be perfectly and constantly lubricated in order to prevent corrosion by the damp gases. W. H. Pickering, Chief Inspector of Mines in the York and Lincoln district, put in tests of the rope made by the Sheffield Testing Works, Limited. He had carefully examined the rope, and in his opinion, the cause of the breakage was due to the rope being weakened at that particular place by a certain amount of internal corrosion which he thought would probably be hidden to some extent ; and he thought there must have been a sudden check of the engine. He was further of opinion that winding ropes should be recapped every six months. If the rope had been worked constantly, there would not have been the same amount of rust going on. The jury returned the following verdict :— " That the deceased lost their lives through the breaking of a rope whilst descending the Parkgate shaft, but there is not sufficient evidence to prove the cause of the rope breaking ; and the jury further recommend that the ropes in the upcast shaft be more frequently changed."
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||