Lundhill Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1857
Report of Charles Morton (page 134)
Accident No. 11 in the Tabular List.
Explosion of firedamp at Lundhill Colliery, near Barnsley.
On Thursday morning the 19th February 1857, about 220 men and boys went to
work in this pit; and soon after midday a terrific explosion occurred, which involved a
sacrifice of life unparalleled in the annals of coal mining.
It has been ascertained that 189 persons perished on this memorable occasion,
120 of whom were adults ; 185 corpses were ultimately found, but of the remaining
four not even a trace has been seen. Ninety women were by this dreadful visitation
deprived of husbands, and 220 children eventually left fatherless.
In addition to the appalling and irreparable amount of human suffering inflicted,
the proprietors of the mine have sustained a pecuniary loss of nearly £20,000.
The Lundhill colliery is located between the villages of Wombwell and Elsecar,
and at a distance of about five miles south-east from the town of Barnsley. The
pits are sunk on the north-eastern and dip-side of the Rotherham and Barnsley
coal field, and are almost the deepest in South Yorkshire.
Messrs. Simpson, Stewart, Taylor, and Galland were lessees of the mine at the time
of the great explosion in February 1857. Mr. Henry Holt, of Wakefield, was appointed
chief viewer a few weeks previously; but Mr. Joseph Coe, the resident under-viewer,
had for several months personally directed and superintended the various operations.
The workable seams of coal at Lundhill are the Wathwood, about 46 yards deep, and
nearly 4 feet thick ; the Abdy, about 75 yards deep, and nearly 3 feet thick ; and the
Barnsley, about 214 yards deep, and from 7¾ to 8½ feet thick.
A limited portion of coal had been excavated in the Wathwood and Abdy seams,
which were soon abandoned ; and more extensive works were then opened in the Barnsley
or principal coal of the district.
The shafts were three in number; firstly, a water pumping and downcast pit, about 77
yards deep, and 10 feet diameter, which was sunk to the Abdy seam ; secondly, a down
cast and coal drawing pit, about 217 yards deep, and 11.3 feet diameter; and thirdly,
an upcast and furnace pit, about 215 yards deep, and 9¼ feet diameter; the two last
mentioned pits being sunk to the Barnsley seam.
The three shafts, which were situate within a distance of three chains, were all connected
by drifts in the Wathwood and Abdy seams; and the coal-drawing pit was,
of course, connected with the furnace-pit in the Barnsley seam.
The gaseous character of the coal measures at Lundhill was forcibly and fatally
attested during the sinking of these shafts in August, 1854, when a fearful explosion of
firedamp killed six persons.
The particulars of that lamentable occurrence are recorded at page 60 in the volume
of Inspectors' Reports, printed in 1856.
Seeing that the Barnsley coal was here being won in a new and untried locality,
and at an increased depth, it might reasonably be anticipated that on the first opening
of the pits, and the subsequent working of the mineral, copious feeders of inflammable
gas would frequently be met with, not only in the coal beds, but also in the
superincumbent strata.
For the better elucidation and explanation of this dreary subject, I have appended
to my Report two maps of Lundhill colliery. No 1. map shows the position and extent
of the underground works in the Barnsley seam, and the system of ventilation at the
period of the great explosion. No. 2 map is an attempt, though necessarily a very
feeble and imperfect effort, to portray the condition of the same works after the explosion,
and to show the places where the dead bodies of the unfortunate sufferers were
found.
By the aid of No. 1 map it will be seen that in working the mine, four levels
extended northward and southward about 22 chains each way from the shaft ; pairs of
boardgates were also driven westward (at intervals of about 5 chains) on the rise of
the steam, and cutting at a right angle the lines of natural cleavage.
Four pairs of boardgates, rising 1 in 14, were turned out of the north levels, and five
pairs out of the south levels ; No. 1 boardgates on the south side of the drawing-pit
being the longest, and they had proceeded about 19 chains towards the west.
Between and in connexion with these several pairs of boardgates, banks had been
excavated in a westerly direction, as shown on the map ; the leading banks being about
20 yards wide, and the following-up banks on the north and south sides of each goaf
being about 6 yards wide.
Four goaves were opened in the northern division, and five in the southern division of
the pit ; the boardgates being kept in advance of the leading banks.
This imprudent practice of working coal simultaneously in leading banks and following up
banks is peculiar to the collieries of the Barnsley district.
The aggregate area of mineral got from the main seam at Lundhill up to the time of
the explosion was nearly 14 statute acres.
The principal tramways were laid along the north and south horse-levels and up the
west boardgates, with branches right and left out of the latter into the leading banks and
following-up banks.
The levels and boardgates were maintained by pillars of coal; but the immediate
entrances to all the banks, and the bank faces themselves, were supported by wooden
props and chocks, and by packwalls (3 or 4 feet wide, and the height of the seam), built
with the roof-stone of the mine.
In working the mineral, about half a yard of the upper part of the seam was temporarily
left to secure the roof; but this coal was afterwards extracted from behind the
props and chocks.
The Barnsley seam at Lundhill is covered by 6 or 7 yards of blue bind, which falls
in the goaf sooner or later; higher up, there are strong strata of stone, which may have
broken down in some of the larger goaves ; and further up (about 23 yards above the
main coal) there is a thin layer of coal, which was said to yield firedamp.
Gas was also given off at the boardgate and leading-bank faces in the Barnsley seam;
but there were no large "blowers," nor was there known to exist any dangerous accumulations
of firedamp in the goaves prior to the great explosion.
The ventilation of the colliery was promoted and maintained both day and night by
an arched furnace (8 feet long, and 8.3 feet wide), placed near the bottom of the upcast
pit, and flanked by a narrow archway on each side ; the return air of the mine passing
through and over and along the sides of the furnace.
The total volume of air produced was stated by Mr. Joseph Coe, the resident underviewer,
to be from 50,000 to 60,000 cubic feet per minute, which was equally divided
into two currents at the bottom of the downcast-pit.
One current was carried northward to the extremity of the horse level (see No. 1
map), thence westward into and across the face of No. 4 banks ; thence further west up
No. 3 boardgates, and so on to No. 3 banks, No. 2 boardgates, No. 2 banks, No. 1 boardgates,
and No. 1 banks, until it arrived at a boardgate which conveyed it eastward to the
ventilating furnace.
The other current proceeded southward to the extremities of the water level and
horse level ; thence westward into No. 5 banks, up No. 5 boardgates, and so on to No. 4
banks, No. 4 boardgates, No. 3 banks, No. 3 boardgates, No. 2 banks, No. 2 boardgates,
and No. 1 banks, until it reached No. 1 boardgates, where it joined the northern current
and returned with it to the furnace.
These two currents of air were usually deemed adequate to dilute and render
harmless the gases evolved ; and there were no observable symptoms (previous to the
day of the accident) to indicate that the works were in an explosive condition, or
that the atmosphere of the mine was dangerously impregnated with firedamp.
There were several defects in the ventilating arrangements which deserve to be
noticed : the objectionable system of getting coal in following-up banks on two sides of
each goaf, necessitated the introduction of an inordinate quantity of doors, the latter
numbering more than 50. The doors at the eastern ends of the boardgates were single,
and they ought to have been double. Door-keepers were stationed only at these boardgate
ends ; they were improperly allowed to go off duty for nearly an hour at dinner
time, and it is worthy of remark, that during this interval the great explosion occurred.
The bratticing in the extremities of levels, boardgates, and slits was generally too
far from the faces, and in some instances was altogether omitted. Although the principal
airways of the colliery had originally been of ample size, yet some of the air passages
in the north-western part of the works subsequently became obstructed by falls
of roof, which had not been removed. The ventilating furnace, instead of being
supplied exclusively with pure air direct from the downcast pit, was exposed to and
entirely fed by the return air of the mine.
There is no positive proof, however, that inflammable gas accumulated from the
careless leaving open of a door, or that it ignited at the furnace. Candles were commonly
burnt by the hewers and hurriers, but occasionally Davy lamps were employed in
unsafe places.
The hazardous operation of building pack walls adjoining and almost in the goaves,
was carried on with naked lights or with Davy lamps as the packers thought fit ; the
lamps were never locked, and were frequently used without tops ; the lamps found
in the works after the explosion had the gauzes screwed off.
The colliery was worked day and night by relays of men and boys, two deputies being
employed to take charge of each of the two shifts.
Special rules for the conduct and guidance of the workpeople had been established
and published in accordance with the requirements of the Act of Parliament ; but in
some important particulars they had been either wholly disregarded or only partially
observed.
I have annexed to my Report a copy of the special rules which were printed and
distributed.
There is nothing in the testimony of the surviving witnesses to show that during the
morning of the 19th February any great fall of roof was heard in the goaves ; that any
unusual supply of gas or deficiency of air was apparent in the works ; or that any serious
danger was apprehended ; yet, about half-past 12 o'clock at noon, and from some
unknown cause, an astounding and devastating explosion was suddenly experienced.
From the top of the furnace pit a prodigious volume of dust, smoke, and flame
arose to a considerable height, accompanied by a loud report; the rope, chain, and cage
at the drawing shaft were also violently thrown up to and got entangled with the pulleys;
and a long and agonizing delay took place in preparing and adjusting the tackle
requisite for making a descent into the mine.
About three hours after the blast, Messrs. Joseph Coe, William Porter Maddison,
Robert Charles Webster, John Warhurst, William Beevors, William Utley, and others
attempted to descend the drawing-shaft ; but their downward progress was unavoidably
retarded by displaced boards and other impediments.
At the bottom they found 20 persons alive (but more or less scorched or injured),
who were immediately sent out of the pit.
The most dreadful havoc had been and still was going on around them ; the dead
bodies of men and horses lay among confused heaps of overturned corves, shattered doors,
broken timber, and fallen roof stone ; the furnace and its arches were in ruins ; the
solid coal in the neighbourhood of the upcast shaft had ignited ; burning masses of coal
were tumbling from the sides, and the fire was raging fiercely and spreading rapidly;
the stables were in flames, and combustible gas showed itself in the safety lamps
within a short distance. Another explosion of gas seemed imminent ; well-grounded
fears were entertained by the courageous explorers that the furnace pit might collapse
and stop the draught of air, or that the wooden framing in the other shaft might catch
fire, and thus cut off their own retreat. Smoke and after-damp were very strong in
some parts, and firedamp prevailed in every boardgate.
Amidst such destructive elements, these heroic men traversed the levels northward
and southward (about 400 yards in each direction) to seek and rescue other survivors;
but their search was in vain. They also went thirty or forty yards up, and remained a
short time listening in the several west boardgates, until their further progress was
arrested by the absence of air and the presence of gas; but they neither saw nor heard
any living persons (except themselves).
In this frightful and perilous exploration they passed probably a score of human
corpses ; and they had no doubt whatever (and there can be none) that the remainder
of the miserable sufferers had ceased to exist, because of the deadly vapours which then
pervaded and rendered inaccessible the other parts of the mine.
At half-past seven o'clock, these brave and meritorious fellows returned to the surface,
where a most impressive spectacle presented itself.
A column of flame 100 feet high rushed furiously from the furnace pit, while clouds of
blazing embers and sparks rose much higher; and dispelling the darkness of that
memorable night, shed a lurid glare on the sorrowful and despairing countenances of an
immense assembly of men, women, and children.
At this solemn crisis the owners and managers of the colliery, consulted briefly with a
number of local mining agents, who had kindly volunteered their assistance; and they
unanimously resolved, that in order to save the mine from becoming an irretrievable
wreck, it was absolutely needful to check the ingress of atmospheric air to the subterranean
fire by closing the mouths of the two downcast shafts ; and they were accordingly
covered over with planks and clay as soon as possible, leaving the upcast or furnace pit
open.
The experiment proved successful ; the intensity of the flames gradually abated, and
long before midnight they altogether disappeared above ground ; but dense volumes of
smoke continued to issue from the top of the unclosed shaft.
On the following morning I met Messrs. John Thomas Woodhouse, of Derby,
Henry Holt, of Wakefield, and several other colliery viewers at Lundhill ; I fully agreed with
them in opinion as to the prudence and propriety of the resolution adopted on the
previous evening ; and it was also approved next day by Messrs. Nicholas Wood and
George Elliot (mining engineers from the county of Durham), who were requested
to lend the aid of their professional experience and advice in this great emergency.
The imperative necessity for closing the pits at the time and in the manner just
mentioned was abundantly confirmed at a subsequent period, when the discovery was
made that the works in the Wathwood coal had been on fire from the furnace shaft to
the extent of 45 yards on the rise and 30 or 40 yards on the dip, and within a distance
of 30 yards from the pumping pit, and 15 yards from the drawing shaft ; and that the
fire had also extended in the Abdy coal along the whole length of the drift from the
furnace pit to the drawing shaft, and had nearly burnt through one of the wooden
conductors in the latter.
At my suggestion, the proprietors of the colliery delegated to four chief viewers
the unenviable power and responsibility of re-opening the mine and recovering the
bodies of the unfortunate victims, and they were authorized to engage (at the owners'
expense) such assistants as they deemed requisite. Accordingly, Messrs.
Nicholas Wood, George Elliot, John Thomas Woodhouse, and Henry Holt, undertook the
chief direction, and they appointed Messrs. W. P. Maddison, C. R. Webster,
John Brown, R. R. Maddison, Edward Potter, A. Palmer, Thomas Cooper, Joseph Coe,
and Richard Pease, to assist them and carry out their instructions.
On the day after the explosion, the mouth of the furnace pit was closed, with the
exception of an aperture eight inches wide across the middle, from which ascended a
rapid current of smoke, watery vapour, and carbonic acid gas, mixed with air from the
downcast shafts, the coverings of which were not quite tight.
At 4 o'clock on the same day the temperature in the furnace pit, 20 feet below the
surface, was 105°; and at the same hour next day it had fallen to 85° ; nevertheless, it was
pronounced positively dangerous to open and descend the shafts, inasmuch as the great
mass of highly heated if not actually blazing matter, underground, would be rekindled
into flames by the re-admission of atmospheric air ; and another explosion might and in
all probability would follow.
It was suggested that carbonic acid should be injected ; but, considering the large
quantity of incombustible gas then issuing naturally from the top of the furnace pit, it
was deemed superfluous to apply it artificially.
A strong jet of steam was forced into one of the downcast shafts, with a view to subdue
the fire ; but the safest, the most effective, and the only certain cooling agent in this
and all similar cases must unquestionably be water. The springs in the pumping pit,
amounting to about 200 gallons per minute, were therefore allowed to run from the
Abdy seam into the workings of the Barnsley coal below, and an additional supply of 100
gallons per minute was obtained by diverting the water of an adjacent brook into the
drawing shaft ; it was also wisely determined to keep the pits entirely closed until the
water rose above the roof of the mine at the bottom of the furnace shaft.
For several days the temperature of the air escaping from the upcast pit gradually
decreased ; on the afternoon of 21st February the thermometer at 20 feet below the
surface registered 85° ; on the 22nd February it indicated 80° ; on the 23rd it diminished
to 77° ; on the 24th it declined to 75° ; on the 25th it fell as low as 72° ; and the heat at
the bottom of the shaft was ascertained on the 24th February to be 81°.
Two or three days subsequently these favourable manifestations not only ceased but
were reversed ; on the 27th February the air at the bottom of the pit had a temperature
of 91°, which, on the following day, rose to 100°; the water in the bottom being 83°,
while that flowing in at the top was only 45°. On the 3rd March the heat of the water
in the mine had further increased to 85°, and on the 5th March to 87°.
The elevation to which the water should be permitted to ascend in the shafts and
workings was a subject of frequent and anxious deliberation. It was essential that the
whole of the burning matter underground should be completely submerged ; and therefore
the extent to which the fire had spread before Messrs. Coe, Maddison, and Webster left
the pit on the day of the explosion, and would probably advance afterwards, demanded
and received the most careful investigation ; and, eventually, it was considered advisable
and necessary that the water should rise until it covered the roof of the Barnsley coal at
a point not less than 90 yards to the west of the furnace.
To ensure the accomplishment of this object, and allowing liberally for the resistance
which the confined and compressed gases (occupying the upper part of the mine) would
offer to the westward progress of the water, it was decided that the influx and accumulation
of water should be continued until it attained the height of 20 yards in the furnace
pit ; and that upon its reaching this limit, the extraction of the water should be commenced
and persevered in day and night.
In the meantime some preparatory operations were going on. As soon as the water
had risen above the level of the furnace arch, the tops of the shafts were uncovered, the
drawing-pit was bratticed, and the damaged lining, framing, and conductors were
thoroughly repaired; doors were put in the communicating drifts between the downcast
and upcast shafts, both in the Wathwood and the Abdy seams, (safety-lamps being used ;)
and three cisterns or tubs, containing 500 gallons each, were made of strong sheet iron,
for the purpose of lifting out the water.
Numerous observations were also taken of the temperature and depth of the water, the
heat of which at the bottom of the furnace pit was greatest on the 5th March, when the
thermometer registered 87° ; the temperature gradually lessened until the 19th March,
when it fell to 61°; again it increased until the 24th March, when it rose to 66°; and
on the last-mentioned day, the water having slowly gained a maximum depth of 60½
feet, its further influx was arrested, and the drawing of it in tubs was started and
continued without intermission for nearly a month, until the mine was drained.
It had been anticipated that during the subsidence of the water, abundant and abrupt
discharges of pent-up gas would occur ; therefore the burning of naked lights was
strictly forbidden in, and at the top of the shafts, and none but locked safety-lamps were
permitted.
The benefit of this precaution became apparent on the night of the 4th April; when a
large volume of inflammable air was liberated suddenly from the mine, and fired harmlessly
in the safety-lamps above ground ; and it continued to escape plentifully until
next day.
The water in the pit, which had previously been lowering at the rate of about 2 feet
per day, stood forty feet deep on the 4th April ; in twelve hours it fell fifteen feet, and
in twenty-four hours it had gone down more than thirty-one feet ; which may be said
to indicate the column of water that the imprisoned and compressed subterranean
atmosphere had sustained.
The heat of the water, which on the 24th March was 66°, had abated to 61° before
the 5th April; and as the surface of the water was now below the level of the furnace
archway, and a natural efflux of gas established from the interior of the mine to the
upcast shaft, proofs were obtained of the temperature of such gas, which was found to
be 63° only.
The heat of the air at the bottom of the furnace pit having diminished from 100° on
the 28th February to 63° on the 8th April, and that of the water from 83° to 61° during
the same period, there was good reason to infer that the underground fire had been
extinguished ; but the fact of its being so could not be ascertained until the water was
sufficiently reduced in the downcast shaft to re-admit atmospheric air into the works.
On the 17th April, the water being only 3 feet deep in the downcast, and a current of
air having passed freely for two or three days to the upcast, and the temperature
decreased to 57°, the first examination of the mine was made, — northward about 20
yards, southward to a great fall of roof near the furnace pit, and westward to the stables
which had tumbled in.
There were no perceptible signs of active or latent combustion ; consequently the belief
was strengthened that the whole of the burning matter had by long submergence been
effectually cooled.
For some time previously, measures were being devised and prepared with a view to
clear the mine of gas, and to introduce a temporary system of ventilation without the risk
of kindling a furnace. Two fans (kindly lent for this purpose by Earl Fitzwilliam) were
fixed above ground to draw air from the upcast shaft; and arrangements were also
made to apply a waterfall as an auxiliary ventilator in the downcast shaft. Each fan
was about 5¾ feet diameter, having a cylinder 12 inches diameter, and supplied with
steam from the colliery boilers.
Driven by straps at an average speed of 200 revolutions per minute, the fans produced
an underground air current of 15,000 or 16,000 cubic feet per minute, which was subsequently
augmented to 23,000 or 24,000 cubic feet by the aid of water running from the
brook and from the pumping engine into the downcast pit, whence it was lifted in tubs to
the surface.
On the 17th April it was resolved to commence the search for and recovery of the
dead bodies, and to proceed as expeditiously as possible, consistently with safety to
the persons employed in so nauseous, arduous, and hazardous an undertaking.
Six companies or relays of practical miners (each company numbering twelve men)
were selected for this duty; each man's working hours were limited to four ; and two
experienced deputies, and at least one of the assistant viewers superintended the labours
of each company. Safety-lamps alone were used, — the most approved being Stephenson's.
The dead colliers, and horses, lying in the immediate vicinity of the pit bottom,
were first removed ; and it may be imagined that the putrid stench exhaled was almost
intolerable, and would have been quite overpowering, but for the liberal application of
various neutralizing and deodorizing compounds; namely, tar, chloride of lime, and
McDougal's disinfecting powder, — the latter being the most efficacious.
Dr. Stenhouse's charcoal respirators for the mouth, and Mackintosh gloves for the
hands, were serviceable ; and it was also deemed expedient that a medical adviser
should be continually on the spot.
As regards the sanitary regulations observed in the handling, shrouding, and final
interment of the corpses, I have thankfully to acknowledge the valuable suggestions
and recommendations received from Mr. Holland, Inspector of Burial-grounds.
A reference to No. 2 map of the colliery will show that in the neighbourhood of the
furnace, and stables, the solid coal had been extensively on fire ; and the roof in several
places was so much tumbled down as to present very formidable obstacles in the path of
the explorers ; and some of the heaps of fallen roof-stone had with great difficulty to be
cleared away before air could pass or access be obtained to the more distant workings.
In and around the site of the previously existing conflagration, oft-repeated and
diligent examinations were made, and much debris and ashes removed, in order to
determine positively whether any hot or smouldering embers remained unquenched; and
although the air felt close and warm, and a smell of burning was occasionally experienced,
no actual fire or smoke was discovered, and the real temperature did not exceed 67°.
The biggest falls of roof-stone were on the north side of the drawing pit, and more
especially in the horse level and in No. 1 west boardgates ; and as it soon became
evident that the southern half of the mine was more open and in other respects more
approachable, it was decided to restore the ventilation of this portion in the first instance,
and meanwhile to shift the immense falls which obstructed the avenues to the north.
Accordingly, one current of air was carried from the downcast shaft along the south
levels, by means of temporary wood stoppings (immediately followed by permanent brick
ones) erected in the slits, and double doors fixed in the entrances to the west boardgates.
On the 30th April the face of the south levels was reached ; and the air was
next forced westward (by similar contrivances) up Nos. 5, 4, 3, 2, and 1 boardgates,
successively, and then turned eastward to the upcast pit.
When the great falls of roof on the north side of the shaft had been either cleared
away or surmounted, another current of air was in like manner conveyed into the
extremity of the north levels on the 8th May ; and in less than a fortnight after, the air
was travelling westward to the face of Nos. 4, 3, 2, and 1 boardgates, in succession,
and finally to the upcast pit.
The original design was to re-establish the ventilation as far as practicable in the same
courses which it occupied prior to the explosion ; but it was soon found that such
intention could only be fulfilled after the lapse of many weeks, or perhaps months, because
of the vast masses of shale and roof-stone that had fallen in and blocked up the bank
faces.
Notwithstanding these unavoidable hindrances, the air was circulating freely in all the
levels, headings, boardgates, and slits, and was passing through or over several of the
goaves before the 22nd May, at which date more than a hundred dead bodies had been
recovered; and before the end of July, nearly the whole of the remainder had been dug
out from beneath the accumulations of debris just mentioned.
During the execution of these works, a prodigious amount of ridding, stowing, packing,
timbering, and bratticing had to be performed ; and as the area of exploration gradually
extended, more labourers had to be engaged.
Firedamp was encountered at almost every step, and often in so concentrated a state as
to extinguish Stephenson's safety lamps ; afterdamp was also abundant and strong ; and
the copious effluvia evolved from such a large number of decomposing and putrid
corpses added sickening and noxious ingredients to an atmosphere already too much
loaded with destructive gases. Nevertheless, the ventilating and lighting arrangements,
and the disinfecting appliances were so complete and effective, and the assiduity,
judgment, caution, and attention of superintendents and miners were so great and
unceasing, that no serious accident occurred to any one of the numerous persons
employed in this unusually difficult and long protracted task.
To describe correctly the minute details connected with the explosion, and with the
dismal and tedious operations that followed, is impossible ; and to re-produce now the
full catalogue of horrors then daily witnessed, will ; probably be thought neither advantageous
nor requisite ; but I may, perhaps, be permitted briefly to notice a few of the
many painful proofs of terrific force and violence which accompanied this fiery blast.
Bulky balks of timber were broken ; substantial brick arches and stoppings were
prostrated ; thick packwalls and firmly fixed props and chocks were knocked down ; strong
malleable iron rails were riven up and contorted ; stout wooden door-frames were split
and iron door-bands bent ; doors, brattices; and corves were shivered to fragments ; two
human bodies were dismembered, and the pieces scattered over a space of forty yards ;
the heads or limbs of other corpses were blown from the trunks; many were so dreadfully
burnt and mutilated as to be unrecognisable ; one man was found transfixed by the pick
with which he had been in the act of cutting coal; a second appeared to have been
killed (as if by an instantaneous shock) while drilling a hole; and several were sitting
at dinner.
On the contrary, some of the unfortunate victims were neither burnt nor bruised,
but seem to have expired quietly under the insidious and suffocating influence of
afterdamp.
With a view to ascertain the condition of the mine as left by the explosion and
subsequent immersion, and to discover (if possible) the origin and cause of the catastrophe,
the chief viewers and myself, attended by the assistant viewers, made careful
inspections of all the underground works that were accessible; and with the aid of No.
2 map of the colliery, I will now endeavour to give an accurate summary of the results.
The cage and corf, which at the moment of the blast stood at the bottom of the
drawing pit, were driven northward, the cross-timbering of the shaft being broken on
the north side, while that on the south side was undisturbed. At the entrance to the
furnace pit two dead bodies were found, and the effects of much violence were manifest.
Proceeding along the south horse level, the stoppings and doors on the right hand
were blown to the west; in the water level, a shovel, in its southward flight, had
penetrated a fissure of the coal. The symptoms of greatest violence appeared between
No. 4 and No. 5 boardgates ; the stoppings in the slits between the horse level and
the water level were driven some east and some west, apparently according to the
comparative precedence of the hurricane in one or other of these levels, in its progress
southward.
The indications generally induced the belief that the blast swept from the No. 1, or
furnace boardgates, along the levels towards the south, but it left behind no traces of
fire.
The stoppings and doors in No. 5 boardgates were driven southward, but there were
no appearances of fire ; the corpses of men and boys were found in their working places,
but not burnt.
In No. 4 boardgates, the stoppings and doors were blown southward ; the blast seems
also to have passed in a westerly direction, and to have been strongest in the upper
part of these boardgates, scattered remains of a human body being picked up ; and, at
the face, a man was found forcibly driven upon the point of the pick with which he had
been working. Other corpses were fearfully mutilated here, and the iron rails were torn
up and bent ; it was stated that one of the victims was burnt, but no appearances of fire
could be detected on the coal or wood.
The stoppings and doors in No. 3 boardgates being thrown towards the south, the
blast must have been from the north ; and judging from the mangled condition of the
dead bodies, it had been very powerful.
Although these boardgates and the slits leading into No. 2 south goaf were particularly
examined, not any signs of fire were visible ; it was thought, however, that some of the
corpses were partially burnt, but on this point there was reason to doubt.
In No. 2 boardgates the stoppings and doors were blown to the south, and the blast
appeared to have come from the north, diverging, westward with immense force to the
face of the boardgates, where the dead bodies were considerably mutilated, and some of
them were said to be burnt, although the wood and coal dust were not in the least degree
charred.
A glance at No. 2 map will show that, in the No. 1 or furnace boardgates three of
the stoppings and doors were driven southward, one was thrown northward, one was left
standing, and the direction of the remainder could not be ascertained, as they were
completely obliterated by the great violence of the blast, which, had prevailed more
intensely towards the boardgate faces, where the corpses were found much mangled
and burnt. Unmistakeable indications of fire from the explosion were seen in both
these boardgates, and in the slits communicating with No. 1 south goaf and No. 1
north goaf. Singularly enough, unignited gunpowder was found in a slit leading
southward, which had escaped the blazing cloud that flew along. From the circumstance
of nearly a score human victims being taken out of the western extremity of these
boardgates it is reasonable to infer that men and boys had assembled there for dinner.
The upper and principal arch of the ventilating furnace had not fallen, but the
subordinate arches and the furnace itself were knocked down, and the solid coal in this
locality had been on fire.
The inspection of the works, thus far, proved clearly, that the explosion began on the
northern or the north-western side of the pits, and passed from thence to the southern
division of the mine.
Proceeding to examine the levels north from the drawing shaft, it was found that the
slits into the stables were so closely tumbled in that the position of the doors and stoppings
which formerly stood there could not be satisfactorily ascertained; neither could
any trace be discovered of the door belonging to the entrance of No. 1 boardgates.
The stoppings of the next three slits on the left hand were driven eastward, and the
door at the end of No. 2 boardgates had entirely disappeared.
Going further along the north horse level to No. 3 boardgates, the stoppings were blown
to the east (with one exception) which appeared to have been moved by two opposite
forces.
The brickwork and door-frame were standing in the entrance of No. 3 boardgates,
the door being removed eastward, though not violently ; and the rails and sleepers
remained undisturbed. The next three stoppings indicated still less violence, and
though one of them seemed to have gone partially eastward, the others were thrown to
the west.
At the face of the north horse level the blast had evidently been weaker, for the
brattices, though laid flat, were neither broken nor scorched ; and unmelted candles were
left hanging. Several dead bodies were found along these levels ; some were burnt,
others were not.
There had been fire in No. 4 boardgates, one burnt corpse being recovered from
thence ; and the position of a stopping and a sheet showed that the blast had passed up
the boardgate, and into the middle level towards the south.
Access to No. 4 goaf was blocked with great falls of roof on its northern side,
where an obstruction of the airway from a similar cause had existed prior to the
explosion.
In No. 3 boardgates the general condition of the stoppings and doors indicated that
two moving forces had been in action (one northward, the other southward), — bricks
and other fragments being blown both ways, as shown by the darts on No. 2 map. The
south side of No. 4 goaf was approachable from these boardgates, but no traces of fire
appeared in the following-up bank, or in the leading bank; and in the latter, candles not
melted remained hung up, and bodies not burnt were dug out; in the slits leading from
No. 3 boardgates into No. 3 goaf strong evidence of fire was visible.
The north side of No. 3 goaf was much fallen, as well where the airway had been
obstructed before the explosion, as at two other points where we attempted to enter it.
The brick stoppings in No. 2 boardgates were left standing, but all the doors were
driven towards the south. Strong indications of fire were apparent in several places,
as marked on the plan ; in one of the slits, two Davy-lamps (having their gauzes
screwed off) were picked up, two burnt corpses were lying near, and charred coal dust
was observed around.
It is worthy of remark, that the spot just mentioned is nearly opposite to the obstructed
air-way before alluded to.
Although some "tokens," with the string not burnt through, were found hanging
in a slit further west, yet it was obvious that an intense fire had passed along the board
gates, at the face of which burnt bodies and parts of bodies lay entangled among torn
up rails and scorched fragments of brattices. Candles, with the tallow melted off, were
seen in the back boardgate; and, in several slits communicating with No. 2 goaf, other
signs of fire resulting from the explosion were apparent.
At the intersection of No. 1 boardgates and the middle level, the standing fire had
coked the coal three or four feet into the solid ; and the roof had fallen quite close to a
considerable height.
In these boardgates, one door was left standing, and one stopping forced southward,
but all the rest had disappeared ; so violent had the blast been, that they were not only
shattered, but the remnants of them were swept away. The corpses found here were
burnt, and the sides of the boardgates and slits exhibited indications of fire, some of which
had been produced momentarily by a flying volume of blazing gas, and others by the
more lasting conflagration that raged in the vicinity of the stables.
My inspection of the two divisions of the mine discovered that firedamp in a state of
combustion had been present in No. 1 south goaf, and in No. 1, No. 2, and No. 3 north
goaves; but it was impossible to determine exactly in what place and by what means
the gas was first ignited.
The probability, however, is that firedamp had gradually accumulated, or was suddenly
liberated by a fall of roof, in one or both of the two most northern goaves, where the
airways were already obstructed; that it kindled at the naked lights in the immediate
neighbourhood of No. 2 boardgates ; and passing towards the south, the explosion gained
strength from additional supplies of inflammable gas met with in its rapid career across
No. 2 and No. 1 north goaves, and No. 1 south goaf.
Other speculations were and may still be entertained by persons well qualified to
form correct opinions as to the origin of the calamity ; some of them will hereafter be
noticed in the abstract of evidence given at the coroner's inquest, and in my own
concluding remarks which follow that abstract.
Throughout the whole of these anxious and long-protracted proceedings, I cordially
co-operated and shared responsibility with Mr. Nicholas Wood and his colleagues, in all
their consultations, arrangements, and resolutions; and I am glad to be able to state that
no material difference of opinion arose in any of our numerous discussions, deliberations,
and determinations.
Where the science, prudence, vigilance, experience, skill, energy, and firmness of the
chief and assistant viewers were so severely taxed, and so generously, strenuously, continuously,
and successfully exerted, it would be difficult and invidious to draw comparisons
or make distinctions ; and I heartily bear testimony to the unflinching courage, unwearied
industry, exemplary patience, willing obedience, and noble self-sacrifice displayed by the
miners and labourers employed in the painful, unhealthy, arduous, and dangerous duty of
re-opening and repairing the dilapidated works, and searching for the burnt, disfigured,
and putrescent corpses.
Dismissing for a time the recollection of their own pecuniary losses, the open-handed
but unostentatious charity and liberality of the Lundhill colliery masters towards the
survivors, and towards the many distressed and bereft widows, children, and relatives,
were unceasing.
The sympathy and benevolence of the West Riding public were also intensely excited ;
and a general subscription (to which the Lundhill Coal Company contributed £500) was
speedily commenced and perseveringly promoted, until an aggregate amount of £10,676
was realized.