The Earl of Carlisle to Sir George Grey.
The Earl of Carlisle presents his compliments to Sir George Grey,
with the accompanying Report of Mr. Warington W. Smyth, respecting the
causes of the recent explosion at the Darley Main Colliery.
Office of Woods, &c,
February 21, 1849.
Report of Mr. Warington Smyth.
Geological Survey Office, Feb. 17, 1849.
Sir,
Having had the honour to receive from you on the 2nd instant the
instructions of Sir George Grey, authorising me to proceed to Barnsley, and to
examine the Darley Main Colliery, for the purpose of giving evidence before
the jury assembled to inquire into the lamentable explosion of the 24th
January, I have to state, that on the 5th February I proceeded to Rotherham,
and communicated on the subject with the coroner, who had adjourned the
inquest to the 8th instant. On the 7th instant I inspected the workings of the
colliery, in company with several eminent viewers, who had been requested by
the jury to attend for that purpose ; and on the 9th I gave evidence relating to
the causes of the catastrophe, and the means which might tend to obviate such
accidents in future. I have now therefore only to submit a concise description
of the system of working and ventilation practised at the Darley Main Colliery,
and to point out modifications of both which might have been attended with
great advantage as regards the security of the workmen.
The Darley Main Colliery is situated in Worsborough Dale, somewhat
more than a mile S.S.E. of the town of Barnsley. Its excavations occupy an
area of about 120 acres, and communicate with the surface by three shafts, of
which two are placed at a small distance asunder, on the south side of the
workings, one serving as an "engine-pit" for pumping water ; the other as a
"bye-pit" for raising coal ; whilst the third, used also occasionally for drawing
water, is mainly devoted to the purpose of an upcast for the return air. The
depth of the former shafts is 131 yards ; that of the latter, which is on the
rise of the beds, only 75 yards.
The seam of coal, which is about eight feet in thickness, and generally
known as the Barnsley coal, is worked by a method commonly adopted in
this part of Yorkshire, and intermediate in its general features between the
"post and stall" work of the North of England and the "long wall" of Shropshire.
A pair of galleries is driven along the level of the coal, from which, at
intervals, "boardgates" or headways are pushed up to the rise and down to
the dip of the seam, forming inclined roadways, which lead to the larger and
parallel excavations termed "banks" or "breaks." The "board-gates" are
protected on each side by a thick pillar of coal, whilst the banks are worked
with a face of such a width (25 to 30 yards) that the roof falls in, and as
fast as the men work upward to the rise, the "gob" or "goaf" continually
follows them to within a few feet or yards of their position at the bank-face.
It is only when the whole field has been explored in this manner that the
"pillars" of coal are attacked, and the proportion of useful fuel to be
obtained will then much depend on the judgment which has been exercised
in adapting the dimensions of the workings to the peculiar circumstances of the
locality.
In the present instance, all the pillars of coal on the "rise" or western side
of the main level had been temporarily abandoned till the whole should have
been extracted from the "dip" side, and it is therefore with this part of the
colliery only that we have now to deal.
It will be seen from the accompanying plan that the meeting of a "throw"
or fault and of the boundary, gives an acutely angular form to the north-eastern
part or extreme dip of the workings (A B in the plan), and it was here that
the principal extraction of coal was effecting when the late melancholy catastrophe
occurred.
The moving force employed for the ventilation is the rarefaction of the air
in the up-cast shaft (which is 9½ feet in diameter) by a furnace of large dimensions
adjoining the bottom. The down-cast air descends the "bye-pit" (also
of 9½ feet diameter), proceeds a short distance along the main level, and then
turns down the first "dip-board," whence it enters into the south "breaks," and
having passed the faces of all three of them, again follows the dip of the coal
down to the level, whence it continues northward till it meets the farther
"dip-boards," and is led to the extreme dip of the workings (A in the plan).
Hitherto the air has been confined in one current, but it is at this point split or
divided into two parts, one of which is intended to ventilate the nearer
"break," the other the "break" which is bounded by the "throw." After
clearing this district, which, from its proximity to the fault, its increasing goaf
and the activity of the coal-getting, was the most precarious part of the mine,
the entire stream of air is conducted by the faces of three of the upper
"breaks," and then again split ; and whilst one portion of the current passes
direct to the fires of the under-ground steam-engine, and then to the up-cast
shaft, the other circulates round the outside of the "rise" or western "breaks,"
and passes to the furnace at the base of the same shaft.
Under this arrangement the mine appeared to be perfectly safe on the 10th
of January, when Mr. Charles Locke, the viewer, and Mr. Jeffcock, made their
half-yearly survey, and considered themselves justified in using candles in all
parts of the workings. On the day before the accident a violent gale of wind
was blowing, and the men were called away to the surface, not, it is stated, in
consequence of any defect in the ventilation, but because the banksman was
unable, from the force of the storm, to continue his duties.
The state of the pit appeared also satisfactory on the fatal morning of the
24th January, when, after the preliminary examination of the workings by
Joseph Thomson, the "bottom steward," 101 men and boys descended between
5 and 6 a.m., and commenced their various labours. At 20 minutes after 11
the eruption from the shaft of a dense jet of smoke and coal-dust announced
to those at the surface that some fearful casualty had occurred below, and as
soon as the force of the blast had subsided, measures were promptly taken to
extricate the sufferers ; Broadhead, the engine-tenter, and Armitage, a labourer,
being the first to penetrate into the noxious atmosphere of the pit. Messrs.
James Beaumont and G. P. Maddison from some neighbouring works attended
at the spot within half-an-hour, and continued in company with Mr. Locke
(who coming from a distance could not arrive till after midnight) and others
to labour with courage and assiduity in their dangerous task till all the victims
of the explosion had been brought to day. It is owing to this promptitude
and to the arrangement of the ventilation (which ensured even after an accident
a supply of air from the pit bottom as far as the engine) that many of
those who were carried out as dead from the effects of the after-damp subsequently
recovered. The result, however, was that no fewer than 75 human
beings lost their lives; whilst of eight horses employed underground, six
perished.
When, according to my instructions, I inspected the workings, all the doors
and stoppings which had been injured by the blast were replaced, and the
ventilation was thoroughly re-established. It was evident on examination that
the principal explosion had occurred in the "break" or wide excavation next
to the throw (B), and that a fire of less intensity had taken place in the south
"breaks ;" in both localities there was therefore an accumulation of fire-damp,
to which the stormy weather and diminution of the atmospheric pressure must
greatly have contributed. All the men were working with candles, whence
the oozing out of the gas, or its sudden expulsion by a fall of roof, would at
once ignite the whole contents of so dangerous a magazine. Now there can be
little doubt that if, on the one hand, the current of circulating air had been
much more ample, or on the other, if the men had all made use of safety-lamps,
the explosive gas might have been carried off innocuously ; and it
becomes, therefore, important to consider whether improvements in the methods
employed might not advantageously have been adopted.
It was clearly the belief of all parties connected with the colliery, that since
the coal seam produced in a general way but little fire-damp, the existing
ventilation was quite sufficient. But it must be remembered that it is only on
extraordinary occasions that its efficacy is really tested, and that the volume of
air should be at all times adequate, if the atmospheric pressure were suddenly
diminished, or any other unforeseen circumstance occasioned the presence of an
unusual quantity of explosive gas, to dilute it to a non-explosive point and
sweep it quickly away. The ventilation was probably more brisk on the day
of inspection than before the explosion, and yet the volume of air which passed
through the colliery might, without much difficulty, and without needing
additional shafts, have been doubled or trebled. No accurate measurements of
the rate if the air current had been made ; but if we take as a unit of volume
9000 cubic feet per minute, the mean between the extremes which were estimated
by different parties, we find that this quantity is but a third part of
what is circulated through most of the collieries in the north, and but a tenth
of what is thought requisite for such as considered very fiery.
In contemplating, therefore, the causes which contributed to the late fatal
disaster, and the means which may tend to their prevention in future, I must
express my conviction that several of the details, both of the working and
ventilation, might be altered for the better, and that an inspection by a properly
qualified officer of the Government would probably have directed attention to
such defects. It might be remarked at this colliery, as in too many of our
coal-workings, that the standard of "good ventilation" among persons concerned
with it was far too low, and that the most practicable mode of raising that
standard would be the occasional visit and suggestions of a person possessed of
greater general experience and an intimate acquaintance with the best examples
of the art in various districts. By such inspection I believe that sources of
danger under the following heads might have been pointed out, and perhaps
gradually corrected, viz.:—
1st. The insufficient quantity of air for extensive workings in a coal seam
well known occasionally to evolve fire-damp.
2nd. The method of working the coal, which leaves the goaf or old break
too open, from the imperfect settlement of the roof, and prevents at air from
sweeping in an unbroken stream by the face of the workings. An improvement,
however, involving so serious a change as the alteration of the plan of
laying out the works, could only be brought about gradually.
3rd. The practice of drawing water in the upcast shaft was highly
prejudicial, not only as filling a portion of its area with the tubs, guide-rods, and
buntons, but as cooling it to such a degree as must materially affect the upward
current.
4th. The upcast shaft was too shallow in comparison with the downcast, the
latter having been sunk in higher ground ; and if a tower or stack of sufficient
dimensions had been raised above the former, its power would have been
much increased.
5th. When fire-damp has been detected in the old breaks it is improper that
the men should be allowed to work near them, and particularly to their rise,
without the use of safety lamps being enforced.
6th. The coal being known sometimes to evolve gas, it is most imprudent to
feed the fire of the underground engine with a portion of the return air, which
might occasionally be in an explosive state, instead of "scaling" off a little of
the intake air for that purpose.
7th. The agent upon whom devolved the charge of all the underground
operations between the monthly visits of the viewer, was, although very careful
and zealous in his vocation, a man of too little experience and general
knowledge (being unable to read or write) to be able to cope with the emergencies
which cannot but frequently occur, and which place in jeopardy the lives of
so many human beings and a large amount of valuable property.
Such are the points in which the management might have effected alterations
tending to prevent explosions. Another too-widely spread and fertile source
of accident, viz., the ignorance and recklessness of the colliers, can only be met
by increased opportunities of education among the labouring classes ; but I
have no doubt that occasional inspection on the part of the Government, and
the gradual infusion of knowledge by a better educated class of underground
agents, would also be instrumental in raising the moral and intellectual
condition of the workmen, at the same time that it afforded them increased
security of life.
I have, &c.,
(Signed) Warington W. Smyth
Sir Henry de la Beche, C.B.