Reports
On the
Explosion in Darley Main Colliery.
Presented to both Houses of Parliament by Command of Her Majesty.
Report Of Mr. Seymour Tremenheere, Inspector of Mines, to the
Secretary Of State.
105, Pall Mall, February 19, 1849.
Sir,
I have the honour to inform you that in obedience to your instructions
of February 3rd, I proceeded to Barnsley, and on the 7th placed myself in
communication with Mr. Warington Smyth, mining engineer to the Geological
Survey, appointed on the part of Government to view the works of the Darley
Main Colliery, and to give evidence to the jury at the adjourned inquest on
the bodies of the persons who unfortunately lost their lives by the recent
explosion in that colliery ; also with Mr. Nicolas Wood, viewer of the Hetton
and other large collieries in Northumberland and Durham, and Mr. B. Biram,
of Wentworth Colliery, viewer to Earl Fitzwilliam, who had been summoned
by the coroner to examine the works previously to the resumption of the
inquiry. And on the 8th or 9th I attended the inquest for the purpose of
reporting to you upon the evidence.
The persons examined as to the cause of the accident were Joseph Thompson,
the underground steward of the colliery, three colliers who were in the
pit at the time of the explosion, Mr. Nicholas Wood, Mr. B. Biram,
Mr. Goodwin, superintendent of Mr. Charlesworth's extensive collieries near
Wakefield, Leeds, and Rotherham, Mr. J. Thomas Woodhouse, colliery viewer of
Overseal, Ashby-de-la-Zouch, and Mr. Warington W. Smyth ; and as the last
five-named witnesses gave a strong and unanimous opinion that the time was
arrived when a system of underground inspection on behalf of the Government
ought no longer to be delayed, and as Mr. Wood mentioned to the jury that in
the spring of last year, on my conferring with him and a committee of the coal
owners and viewers of Northumberland and Durham, a plan for that purpose
appeared very practicable, and likely to be attended with very beneficial
effects, I stated to the jury, by request of the coroner, my own opinion on that
subject.
The evidence established the following facts. The colliery was worked on
a plan by which, as the coal was got out, large cavities were left, only partially
filled by the breaking down of the roof, and those cavities became so many
magazines of explosive gas. Some of them were at the lower part of the
workings, to which the air had the more difficulty in making its way as it had
to be conducted by a downward course. Mr. Wood gave it as his opinion, in
which the other scientific and practical gentlemen concurred, that considering
the amount of gas evolved by that coal (no great quantity), he should deem a
current of from 25,000 to 30,000 cubic feet of air per minute necessary to
ensure the safety of the mine under all circumstances, ordinary and extra-ordinary.
On the day of their inspection they found a current of from 10,000
to 12,000 feet per minute only. But there was reason to conclude that this
was a much greater current than had usually been produced in the mine
during the hours of work, and was probably the limit of what the present air-courses
could convey on the most favourable occasions. In addition to the
distance the air had to travel in a downward direction after leaving the bottom
of the downcast shaft, the draft was greatly impeded by the upcast shaft being
used, for at least 12 out of the 24 hours, for the purpose of drawing water out
of the mine in tubs, the pumps being insufficient to keep it clear. The spilling
of the water during this process not only cooled the air, but impeded the
upward current by descending against it. Notwithstanding this comparatively
small supply of air, and its occasional obstruction by the fall of water, the mine
was considered by the managers so safe that the men were allowed to work
with open candles even in the vicinity of those magazines of gas above mentioned.
It appears that under ordinary circumstances the mine was in fact safe, but
a high wind on the day of the explosion having still further impeded the action
of the upcast shaft, and a change in the weight of the atmosphere having
probably occurred at the same time, the gas is supposed to have descended in
unusual quantity, and to have exploded in coming in contact with the naked
candles.
The verdict was as follows :— "We find a verdict of accidental death on the
75 bodies we have viewed, caused by one or more explosions of carburetted
hydrogen gas or inflammable air, which took place on the 24th of January last
in the Darley Main Colliery ; and we most strongly recommend to the proprietors
that a better mode of ventilation be adopted before they recommence
working the mine, as a preventive against any similar occurrence ; and we think
from the evidence given before us, that the removing of the machinery used
for drawing water out of the upcast shaft is essentially necessary, so as to allow
the air passing out of the mine to have a better and freer outlet. And we also
desire that Mr. Badger, the coroner, report to Sir George Grey, and that he
make known to Her Majesty's Government, that we think it advisable that they
should appoint a scientific and practical person to occasionally inspect the
collieries in this district, and see that there is proper ventilation, and hear any
complaints by the work-people employed therein."
The evidence was not such as to justify the jury in imputing criminal negligence
to any one connected with the mine ; but they show by their verdict that
in their opinion the ventilation had not been managed with all the care and
skill that the circumstances of the colliery demanded. This was the more
evident inasmuch as an explosion took place in this very colliery only two
years ago (February, 1847), which cost the lives of six persons ; thus giving
unequivocal notice that something worse might be apprehended. Indeed it transpired
during the late inquiry, that the viewer and manager (Mr. Locke) had
expressed dissatisfaction at the mode of ventilation, and with some of the
details of management, but had not been a "free agent" to adopt the improvements
he had represented as desirable. Taking this circumstance into consideration,
the recommendation of the jury in favour of underground inspection
of the collieries on the part of the Government is invested with additional
force ; for had this colliery been subject to the inspection of a properly qualified
officer of the Government, there can be no doubt that the manifest errors and
defects of its ventilation would have been strongly pointed out, nor is it to be
imagined that when so pointed out, the owner of the colliery would have been
satisfied with the responsibility of leaving them uncorrected. It cannot be
doubted but that the inspector would have represented to him that although
the quantity of air passing through the mine might possibly be sufficient for
safety under ordinary circumstances, it is not the ordinary condition of a mine
that is alone to be considered, when the lives of so many human beings are
concerned, but those changes in the conditions of safety, which may be constantly
expected from circumstances so variable as the weight of the atmosphere
and the force of the wind, must be looked to and provided for with as much
care and forethought as if the daily safety of the mine depended upon it. He
would have pronounced a decided opinion upon the insufficiency of the air-courses,
and upon the impropriety of obstructing the upward current of air by
drawing water out of the upcast shaft. He would not have failed to represent
the danger of using naked candles in the faces of work, so close to accumulations
of explosive gas, which the accident of a high wind in a particular quarter
or a sudden change in the weight of the air might at any moment bring down
upon them. And it is not too much to say, that had such inspection been
brought to bear upon this colliery even since the explosion by which six lives
were lost in 1847, the late lamentable sacrifice of 75 lives in this same pit
would in all probability not have occurred. It was only in 1847 that the
explosion occurred at the Ardsley Main Colliery about two miles off, in which
73 persons were killed. In about two years, therefore, in this immediate
neighbourhood alone, 154 persons have lost their lives in collieries by explosions,
which there is every reason to believe a proper system of Government
inspection would have prevented.
The subject of Government inspection was brought before the jury in the
evidence of Mr. Wood, who mentioned the circumstance of his having been one
of a committee of colliery viewers in Northumberland and Durham, appointed
by the Association of Coal Owners, &c. in the north, to confer with me by your
request, in the spring of last year, on this subject. Mr. Wood adverted to the
fact that on a minute and careful consideration of the various difficulties of the
question, we came to an understanding upon the main features of a plan,
which in the opinion of those present would answer the purpose, Mr. Wood
expressed a strong opinion at the inquest, that the attempt to legislate on the
subject ought no longer to be delayed. The other intelligent witnesses, having
both a practical and scientific acquaintance with the working of collieries in the
most important coal districts, expressed themselves to the same effect. I was
also called upon by the coroner to state to the jury my opinion on the
subject, which I did not hesitate to do.
I beg to lay before you a report of what I said to the jury, taken from the
"Sheffield Times" of February 10, 1849.
"Mr. Tremenheere, the Commissioner under the Act 5 and 6 Vict. c. 99,
commonly called 'Lord Ashley's Act,' relating to the Mining Population,* was
next examined as follows :—
"The Coroner. — As the subject of underground inspection has been introduced,
I should like to hear your opinion upon it.
"Witness. — I was directed by Secretary Sir George Grey to attend this
adjourned inquest to report to him upon the evidence ; but as you think it
desirable that I should give evidence myself on the subject of underground
inspection, to the necessity of which I have turned my attention, any remarks
I can make are quite at the service of the jury. My duties as Commissioner
under the Act already mentioned, are to put that Act in force, and to make
annual reports to the Secretary of State, to lay before Parliament, on the state
of the mining population ; I have nothing to do with the internal arrangement
of mines, my duties rather relate to the mining population. But in the course
of my inquiries through all the mining districts, I have taken every opportunity
of ascertaining a point of such vital interest to the mining population, as that of
whether it would be practicable to set on foot in this country a system of underground
mining inspection. I have collected the opinions of a great number of
the most scientific as well as practical managers of mines and collieries in this
country, and have, by the direction of Government, inquired into the systems
of mining inspection in France, Belgium, and Germany ; and I have no doubt
that a moderate measure of mining inspection might be very easily devised,
and would not meet with material opposition from those nearest concerned, and
would be attended with a very great saving of life in all the colliery districts
where explosive gas is prevalent ; and it would be very beneficial to the health
of the persons employed in the mines where there is no explosive gas, and where
ventilation is therefore apt to be neglected. You and the jury are probably
aware that this is no new question. It was examined at great length by a
Committee of the House of Commons in 1835, and in 1844 an inquiry was
conducted by Professor Faraday and Mr. Lyell into the circumstances of an
explosion in the Haswell Colliery. In 1845 a Report was made by Dr. Lyon Playfair
on an explosion at the Jarrow Colliery ; and defects of ventilation
were discovered which, in all probability, would have been remedied if pointed
out by a Government Inspector. Sir Henry de la Beche and Dr. Playfair
made a Report on the subject of colliery inspection in June, 1846 ; previously
to that, in January, 1846, Sir H. de la Beche reported to the Government on
an explosion at Risca in Monmouthshire, from which it appeared that a modification
of the system of ventilation, which would have been pointed out previously
by a Government Inspector, would have prevented the loss of several
lives. To the same effect is the Report of Sir H. de la Beche and
Mr. Warington Smyth, on the explosions at Oldbury, in Staffordshire, and at
Coppul, in Lancashire, in the months of December, 1846, and January, 1847;
when it appeared that defects were brought to light which inspection would
very likely have caused to be removed. In March, 1847, there was a Report
by the same gentleman, on the deplorable accident at the Ardsley Main
Colliery in this very district, and again curable defects were brought to light.
Wherever opinions have been expressed, in inquiries before Parliament, or in
the Reports just mentioned, with regard to colliery inspection, their leaning
has been towards a system involving compulsory powers ; and therefore probably
it has been felt to be a matter of too great difficulty to reconcile the
Legislature to the passing of any measure of that kind. My own opinion,
formed after much inquiry and careful consideration is, that a system not
involving compulsory powers would be practicable, and to a great extent
effectual. There should be, I think, power to the Inspector to examine and
report, and to place such report on record, with power to the manager of such
mine to dissent from any such report, and to call in some disinterested third
party whose report should also be placed on record. There are two general
causes of explosion in pits : the first, a defective system of ventilation ; the
second, carelessness of the men. I think the inquiries and reports of the
Inspector, and the full discussion which the system of ventilation in any particular
mine where he saw defects would be subject to, would lead to the
needful modifications, and therefore after a few years reduce the chance of
explosions to those cases which could be traced to the carelessness of the men.
In my Annual Report of 1847, I ventured to call the attention of the Secretary
of State to the subject; and I went into many particulars, which I need not
repeat, in confirmation of the above views. I gave the opinions of several
experienced persons to the same effect, and also instances in which, by the
evidence of practical men and working colliers themselves, inspections by
persons from a distance, and advice after serious explosions, had led to improvement.
In June, 1847, a petition was presented to Parliament, purporting to
represent the opinions of 60,000 colliers, and from which I have made extracts
in my Report. They express a strong opinion that Government inspection
would be of great value to them as a protection to life, and pray Parliament to
adopt a measure with that view. In June, 1847, shortly after the presentation
of that petition, a Bill was brought into the House of Commons by Messrs.
Duncombe, Bernal, and Aglionby, to provide for the better regulation of mines
and collieries, in which it was proposed to empower the Inspector to direct the
owner of a colliery to alter his system of ventilation as the Inspector might
deem advisable, under a penalty of £100. In July, 1847, another Bill was
brought in by the above Members and Mr. Hume, to compel for a limited
period the use of safety-lamps, and wishing to give to the Secretary of State
the power of ordering certain things to be done with respect to the internal
management of mines, and making it a misdemeanour to neglect such order if
no death or injury resulted from such disobedience, and making it a felony if
it did. It is hardly necessary to say that measures attempting to arm the
Government with such stringent powers were withdrawn, probably from its
being seen that Parliament would reject them. In the autumn of that year, I
was instructed by Sir George Grey to proceed to France and Belgium to
inquire into and to report to him upon the laws and regulations relating to
mining inspection ; and although those laws date from the decrees of the
National Assembly of France shortly after the first outbreak of the Revolution,
namely, in 1791, and from subsequent decrees of Napoleon, and although in
those countries the whole mining property belongs virtually to the Government,
and no person can consequently work a mine without permission of the Government
(who can therefore impose their own terms), they always deal very
tenderly with the mining proprietors in the matter of inspection, and give them
every opportunity of being heard before the local authorities, before the
recommendations of the Inspector are carried into effect. In fact they work by
persuasion far more than by force of law. The spirit in which the Inspectors
are directed to conduct their inspection, is that of the utmost forbearance and
as friendly advisers. I state in my Report, which was laid before Parliament
last year, as follows :— 'The law has most carefully abstained from investing
the Inspectors with any direct authority.' The nature of their interposition is
best described by M. Regnaud, in his exposition of the motives for the project
of law presented to the Legislature of France in April, 1810 :— 'The corps of
engineers of mines will diffuse everywhere its intelligence and counsels, without
imposing directions, without exercising any constraint whatever upon the mode
of managing the works. They will enlighten the proprietors and the Administration,
they will examine and establish facts, but in no case will they give
directions.' Again, M. Regnaud states that the object of the Administration
will be 'to use the ascendancy of enlightenment, not the influence of authority,
to persuade, not to constrain.' Other statements with regard to the intention
of the law are to the same effect. And as respects its working, all authorities
in both countries connected with the subject, namely, the Ministers of Public
works, the engineers or inspectors in chief, and the local inspectors in all the
districts I visited, concurred that the law was carried out entirely in that spirit.
One of the engineers in chief in a district where collieries abounding with
explosive gas are most numerous, stated to me : 'We have changed the face
of things in this districts within the last few years by persuasion alone.' Many other
officers of Government in both countries expressed themselves to the
same effect. A great many proprietors of mines whose opinions I asked
on the working of the system of Government inspection, acknowledged that
they received the greatest benefit from it, and that it worked perfectly smoothly.
Without going into further particulars or the exact plans of inspection in those
countries, I may state briefly its results as to the saving of life. In Belgium,
according to the annual statement published by the Minister of Public Works
in 1846, it appears that while the production of coal between the years 1840
and 1844 had increased 20 per cent. and the number of workmen 17 per cent.,
the number of killed by accidents had diminished 15 per cent. Though there
are no published documents relating to this subject in France, the Minister of
Public Works informed me that the actual results as regards the saving of
life were equally marked in all the mining districts. In the autumn of last
year I also made a similar inquiry into the laws and regulations of mining
inspection in Germany, my report upon which has not yet been presented to
Parliament. I will therefore only say that I was permitted to examine the
records of accidents kept by the authorities in some of the most important
districts in Prussia and in the Duchy of Nassau, and it appears from them that
in several important instances there has been a diminution of the proportion of
accidents, traceable very probably to the increased care produced among the
proprietors of mines by their having their attention so frequently called to the
subject, and to the various means of prevention suggested by the inspectors.
In this country we have no records of the kind. The nearest approach that
we have to any such record is a report by the Registrar-General in 1846 upon
violent deaths among men aged twenty years and upwards, of different occupations.
It appeared that among the violent deaths registered in 1840, those
belonging to the navy and merchant service at home, including fishermen, &c,
amounted to 346, whilst those among miners amounted to 496, or a proportion
in the first case of 4006 to every million living, and in the latter of 3939. But
it is evident that any return relating to the deaths of miners which excluded
all under twenty years of age must be very imperfect, as I find from the list
of sufferers by this explosion that out of 75 killed, 32 were under 20 years
of age. Mr. Wood mentioned in his examination that in the spring of last
year I communicated with him and a Committee of leading viewers and
colliery managers in Northumberland and Durham, by direction of Secretary
Sir George Grey, on the subject of the practicability of devising an easy and
satisfactory system of underground mining inspection, and I am happy to say
that I found those gentlemen whose knowledge and experience, and the
amount of their interests at stake, entitle their opinion to particular respect,
entirely favourable to the attempt, and it is very much to be hoped that in
this matter we shall not be much longer, in this country, behind the Governments
of the Continent in their benevolent endeavours to diminish the amount
of human suffering.
"A Juror. — How would you have the inspectors to be paid ? By Government
or the owners of mines ?
"Witness. — I have an opinion on this point, but that is a question for Parliament
to decide. In reply to subsequent interrogations witness said his opinion
was adverse to the inspectors being invested with compulsory powers."
The jury in their verdict desire "that the coroner report to Sir George Grey
and that he make known to Her Majesty's Government that we think it
advisable that they should appoint a scientific and practical person to occasionally
inspect the collieries in the district, and see that there is proper
ventilation and hear any complaints by the workpeople employed therein."
With regard to this particular suggestion of the jury, I beg to be allowed to
observe, that if inspection on the part of the Government is requisite in the
neighbourhood of Barnsley, it is not in the slightest degree less so in several
other colliery districts; and that unless the duties of such inspection be
precisely defined by Act of Parliament, and unless full opportunity be secured
to the owners or managers of mines to be heard in case they dissent from the
report of the Inspector, not only would little good result from it, but much
injustice might be done. Experience has sufficiently shown how little benefit
is produced by the mere reports of persons, however able, when sent down by
the Government to report on the state of particular mines or particular
districts. The recommendations or suggestions, however useful, are not sufficiently
brought home to any particular individuals, so as to attach any definite
responsibility to the neglect of them, and they are consequently apt to be soon
forgotten. Any plan of inspection to be effectual, must result in a definite
statement in writing by the inspector addressed to the manager of the mine ;
"Such a mine is dangerous for such and such reasons." The manager, if he
admits it to be so, would within a reasonable time make the necessary alterations.
If he dissents from the Inspector's opinion he should have the means of calling
in the opinion of a disinterested third party. Should an explosion attended with
loss of life occur after these opinions or either of them have been thus formally
given, the coroner's jury would have some definite means before them of
judging whether there had been any criminal neglect. This is very nearly the
process pursued in France, Belgium, and Germany, as described in my reports
on mining inspection in those countries, and the results of their system are,
that very nearly all the alterations thought right by the Inspectors in order to
the safety of the people are obtained by frank and friendly representations
alone. To use their own expressions, "they act by persuasion and the force
of conviction far more than by force of law." It is true that they can have
recourse to the civil power to enforce their recommendations if the civil power
after hearing both sides think they are right. But the instances in which they
are obliged to have recourse to the authorities are as I have shown in my
reports comparatively few. In this country if the compulsory powers of the
continental systems of inspection were adopted, no one would be able to open
a new colliery without first submitting his plans to a Government Inspector
for approval. This would involve the necessity of such a number of Inspectors,
and such an amount of minute interference, that I apprehend it would be
deemed entirely at variance with the principle of private enterprise and individual
responsibility in this country, however applicable it may be on the
Continent, where various usurpations from time to time upon private rights
have transferred all mineral property from individuals to the hands of the
Government. I believe that, with the disposition existing in all the mining
districts of this country to benefit by the progress of knowledge in such
matters, the information which would be diffused by the Inspectors, the
emulation which would be created among colliery managers (as was observed
by one of the witnesses at the late inquest), the force of public opinion, and in
the last resort the fear of a coroner's jury in case a mine pronounced dangerous
by the Inspector was left unimproved, would in a very short time produce as
good effects as the compulsory system of the Continent, reducing greatly the
number of mines in which the principle or the amount of the ventilation is
defective, and therefore leaving less opportunities for those accidents which are
attributable to the carelessness and recklessness of the men.
I was asked by the jury from what funds I thought the Inspectors, if
appointed, should be paid. I declined entering upon that question with them,
as it was not an occasion on which it could be conveniently discussed. In
France, Belgium, and in the Prussian provinces on this side the Rhine, the
dues payable by the grantees of mineral property are £5 per cent. upon the net
profits. Of this, 2½ per cent. is payable to the owners of the soil; but in consequence
of the minute sub-division of property, the proportion that can be
claimed by any individual is so small that it is seldom asked for. It is the
duty of the Inspectors to examine the books of the different mines to ascertain
the amount of net profits, and to cause the 2½ per cent. belonging to the
Government to be duly paid. It is understood that the sum derived from this
source (received in point of fact by the respective Governments as owners of
the mineral property, and not as a tax), is sufficient to meet the cost of the
inspection and also that of the "Schools of Mines" established in those
countries. In the rest of Germany the dues hitherto taken by the different
Governments have been very high, generally about 10 per cent. of the gross
produce. But as I have stated in my Report on Mining Inspection in
Germany, a proposition was laid before the late Assembly at Berlin, founded
on the consent of the chief owners of mines, and the approval of the officers
of the Government, to assimilate the German to the French Code of Mining
Laws.
No one can be conversant with the great benefit that the admirable Schools
of Mines in France, Belgium, and Germany confer on those countries, without
a regret that this country has so long neglected such obvious means of usefulness.
The foundation on which such a school might be established has been
already laid in this country in the Museum of Economic Geology, which corresponds
to the valuable Museum of the School of Mines in Paris. And that
some means are wanted to raise the standard of scientific knowledge among
persons entrusted with the management of collieries in this country has been
long felt, and perhaps no circumstance has occurred lately which more strongly
confirms that opinion than the late lamentable explosion at the Darley Main
Colliery. It was obvious on the examination of the underground steward,
Joseph Thompson, that he was a very illiterate person. On subsequent inquiry
I was informed that he could only read very imperfectly, and could not write,
yet he was entrusted with the entire responsibility of the underground management
of that colliery during the absence of the viewer, Mr. Locke, who was only
expected to visit the colliery once a month. Upon the discretion of this illiterate
man the daily safety of 100 lives depended. It was he alone who was supposed
to be able to observe with intelligence any of those varying circumstances which
so rapidly alter the conditions of safety in a mine, and to act upon his observations
with promptness and caution. The jury were unable to say that the explosion
occurred in consequence of any want of discretion on his part. But I understand
that he is now to be discharged, and to be replaced by some one of
better qualifications. He had been in charge of the underground management
before Mr. Locke was appointed viewer, and was thought by the owner
to be competent to his duties. Mr. Locke was of a different opinion; but in
this, as in a proposition to improve the ventilation, he was over-ruled. The
circumstance of the low qualifications of the persons entrusted in this neighbourhood
with such important and responsible duties as underground stewards
has now attracted the serious attention of all the principal owners and managers
of collieries around Barnsley, and it was represented to me as their
unanimous opinion, that immediate measures should be taken to create a class
of men of greater knowledge and ability. They are desirous of making use of
the means which are already at hand for such a purpose in the Coal Masters'
Association, for the large number of collieries around Barnsley, Leeds, and
Wakefield. They stated to me that it would be a matter of no difficulty to
form, out of that body, which consists of upwards of 30 members, a committee,
who, in conjunction with a Government Inspector of Mines, should such an
officer be appointed, might examine candidates for the office of underground
bailiff, and grant certificates of qualification ; the examination to embrace the
first principles of natural and mechanical science, as far as applicable to the
mines of the neighbourhood, as well as a practical acquaintance with the best
modes of colliery management. In the absence of any such institution as that
of a School of Mines, which would afford the best agency for granting such
certificates in the various mining districts, this suggestion of the Coal Owners'
Association of Yorkshire is not undeserving consideration.
As regards the question addressed to me by the jury above adverted to,
relative to the expense of a system of underground inspection on the part of
the Government, I may perhaps here be permitted to add, that, after careful
consideration, and an examination of the data afforded by the Factory Inspection,
I am of opinion that a sufficient system of colliery inspection might be
established at about one-third the cost of the inspection of factories, namely,
for between £3500 and £4000 a-year. This is far less than it costs the small
country of Belgium for this humane purpose. And that the expense is not
thrown away in that country, I have shown, in addition to other particulars,
by an extract from the Annual Report of the Minister of Public Works in
1846 ; from which it appears that while the production of coal, between the
years 1840 and 1844, had increased 20 per cent., and the number of workmen
17 per cent., the number of fatal accidents had diminished 15 per cent.
We have no means in this country of ascertaining any such facts or instituting
any such comparison. I believe also, from the inquiries I have made,
that deaths from explosions or other causes frequently occur in mines, which
are concealed from the knowledge of the coroner and of the public. This
would not so often be the case were there Inspectors of Mines resident in the
different mining districts. Moreover, the number of deaths by no means
expresses the amount of suffering produced by these explosions. The number
of persons severely burnt every year, some of whom recover after many months
of painful endurance, while others are incapacitated for life from further
labour, is considerable.
It will be a slight consolation to the survivors of this most painful catastrophe
if it leads to something that may tend to save them from a similar fate. The
amount of misery that has been produced by it can scarcely be fully appreciated
except by those who have been upon the spot. Out of 101 persons that
day in the pit 75 perished ; and there can be no manner of doubt that had this
colliery been subject to inspection by a properly qualified Government officer,
the glaring defects of its ventilation would have been so forcibly represented
to the owner, that in all human probability all these lives would have been
saved. In several contiguous cottages near the scene of the disaster only one
male was left alive. In this same neighbourhood 152 men and boys have been
killed by explosions in collieries within the last two years ; and it is asserted
by competent persons that other collieries in that district are in such a state in
regard to ventilation, that another event of the same deplorable kind may any
day be expected.
I have &c.
(Signed) Seymour Tremenheere.
The Right Hon. Sir George Grey, Bart., M.P.,
* By section 3 of the Act 5 and 6 Vict., c. 99, intituled "An Act to prohibit the Employment of
Women and Girls in Mines and Collieries, to regulate the Employment of Boys, and to make other
provisions relating to Persons working therein," (August 10, 1842), the Secretary of State is
empowered to appoint "Inspectors of Mines." This term "Inspector of Mines" is too wide for the
powers conferred by the Act, which are confined to the carrying the provisions of that particular Act
into effect, and reporting annually to the Secretary of State on the condition of the mining population.
The inconvenience of a term which implies the existence of an office, and of powers, the want of
which is at present under discussion, is obvious.
In December, 1843, I received from the Secretary of State for the Home Department, a commission
and instructions "to inquire into and report to him the manner in which this law was observed, to take
such steps as might be in my power to enforce it, and to report to him from time to time upon the
general state and condition of the persons employed in mines and collieries." No machinery for putting
the Act in force having been provided (as in the Factory Act) by the Act itself, I was permitted by the
Secretary of State to employ the services of professional men in the different districts, who obtained
evidence by means of constables placed under their orders, on which to found prosecutions against
persons neglecting to conform to the Act. Though power is given to enter mines, &c, for that particular
purpose, it has always been found useless.
The Act, as is obvious from its title, has nothing to do with the ventilation or any of the internal
arrangement of mines. An "Inspector of Mines," therefore, in the proper sense of the term, does not
exist. I have myself no practical acquaintance with matters of that kind; and in stating my opinion of
the desirableness and practicability of setting on foot an "Inspection of Mines," I offer it as the result
of my communications on the subject with persons most competent to form an opinion upon it in nearly
all the mining districts.
It was stated in some of the papers, in their report of the proceedings on the inquest, that I
descended and examined the mine with the gentlemen appointed, by request of the jury, for that special
purpose. This is a mistake. Knowing nothing practically about the subject of the inquiry, I could
have been of no use ; and I studiously avoided allowing the jury to receive an impression that there
existed any officer of the Government charged with the duty of the under-ground inspection of mines.
In their verdict they have recorded their opinion as to the want of such an officer.