V. — Matters Arising From The Explosion
Frictional Sparking from Light-Alloy Roof Bars
From the evidence taken during the investigation, it seems clear that sparking at the wedges of the Schloms bars was by no means uncommon, particularly with the shorter bars, of which many of the wedges had been burred and somewhat distorted during their previous use at another colliery so that it was often difficult to drive them out. This sparking had been observed by workmen, deputies and the overman, none of whom had considered it dangerous or attached much importance to it because they had always been accustomed to seeing similar sparks when steel struck steel or hard stone. No report of this sparking had been made to any of the higher officials, all of whom say they were entirely unaware of this sparking until after the explosion. On 8th February, what is described as a "flash about 4 inches long" occurred when a wedge was driven out on the Panzer Face. This was seen by Mr. R. D. Evans, assistant manager, and steps were immediately taken to withdraw all the Schloms bars from use and replace them with all steel supports.
The tests carried out at the Safety in Mines Research Establishment on light-alloy bars from the Panzer Face showed that the sparking hazard was not confined to the friction of the wedge in the slot of the bar. Incendive sparks could be produced by striking the edge of a bar against a piece of rusted steel; by striking the edges or flat sides of a bar with a piece of rusted steel; and by striking a glancing blow with a light hammer on a rusted steel surface smeared with aluminium from previous contact with a bar.
It may be of interest to record that the alloy used in the construction of these bars was found to contain : — Al 93.64 per cent. Si 0.61 per cent. and Mg 0.59 per cent.
This is yet another case where the investigation of the circumstances attending an explosion has revealed that there was not a sufficient number of detectors on the face for compliance with the Coal Mines General Regulations (Firedamp Detectors), 1939. Flame safety lamps were provided as detectors and only three of the face workers carried such lamps on the shift of the explosion, whereas five was the minimum number necessary for compliance with the Regulations.
A point worth stressing is that two of .the three flame lamps were used by coal getters and only one by a person whose work was performed at or near the waste edge. One of the getters who had a flame lamp worked at the extreme return end of the face and says that he made careful tests for gas at about 8.45 a.m. and found none. Had this detector been used at the waste edge near the return end of the face the sequence of events might well have been very different.
It is the duty of the manager to ensure to the best of his power that these Regulations are fully complied with and that each of the detectors provided is properly used by a competent workman.
Firedamp in Wastes behind Longwall Faces
This explosion provides further evidence that, if there is any possibility of firedamp accumulating in wastes behind longwall faces, steps must be taken to prevent the inflammable or explosive fringe of the accumulation from extending into the face working. The most certain way of achieving this is by solid stowing of the goaf; where this is not practicable, other methods, such as ventilation of the wastes or gas drainage, must be adopted.
A system of drainage from the wastes behind the Panzer Face by means of pipes through the No. 9 pack was adopted when work was resumed, and a measure of success was achieved.