V. — MATTERS ARISING FROM THE EXPLOSION
Ventilation and the Occurrence of Firedamp in the Companion Road
The evidence which could be obtained as to the state of the Companion Road in regard to ventilation and the occurrence of firedamp during the period before the explosion was conflicting and unsatisfactory.
Apart from deputy H. Williams who, as previously stated, had reported a diluted issue of firedamp on four occasions during the period 1st to 6th October, all the deputies concerned denied ever having detected inflammable gas in this road. Deputy G. Greenhaf states that on the shift of the explosion he made an inspection of the district between 3.30 p.m. and 4.30 p.m. during which he made tests with a lowered flame at various points in the Companion Road right to the back end and saw no indication of firedamp.
On the other hand, the repairer, I. Lisak, who was regularly employed at the Companion Road rippings, states that he had frequently sensed the presence of firedamp by smell and had confirmed its presence by testing with the flame safety lamp which he usually carried. On the shift of the explosion he did not take a flame safety lamp into the mine, but he states that he could smell firedamp near the roof at the ripping face and that he reported this to deputy Greenhaf shortly before the explosion occurred. Greenhaf denies this, but Lisak's statements are supported by his assistant, T. Palczykewycz.
There is also a conflict of evidence regarding the means, if any, adopted for directing part of the main air current into the Companion Road. With one exception, the deputies maintain that there was never any need for bratticing because the air current split naturally at the face and a sufficient quantity of air for the adequate ventilation of the Companion Road and Arcade took this alternative route. The one exception is again deputy H. Williams who states that on 3rd October he hung a canvas brattice from the roof to the floor along the centre line of the Companion Road from the coal face right to the back end in order to dilute the issue of firedamp which he had detected, and that this brattice was still in position on 6th October, the last day he worked in this district. The other deputies have no recollection of having seen this sheet. There was no trace of it found after the explosion, yet no-one admits having removed it.
Again, there is fairly conclusive evidence that a canvas sheet was hung across the face so as to divert part of the air current into the Companion Road during the morning shift on 10th October by T. Isaac, the deputy in charge, yet this deputy states that he has no recollection of erecting this sheet. This sheet was found lying on the floor after the explosion, and the weight of evidence is that t was in this position when the explosion occurred.
What seems to be clearly established by the evidence is that there was no definite policy laid down by the management or adopted by the deputies for ensuring the adequate ventilation of the Companion Road.
It is probable that when the Arcade was first formed a sufficient quantity of air would split naturally from the main current on the face, but as the length of the Companion Road was increased by the advance of the face, and the height of the Arcade was reduced by convergence, this quantity would automatically decrease until a stage of marginal ventilation was reached where any slight increase in resistance or in the make of firedamp would cause firedamp to accumulate in the Companion Road. The height of the Arcade at the time of the explosion was only 18 inches to 2 feet and it would appear that this marginal stage had already been reached.
None of the deputies' reports gave any indication of the state of the Arcade, and all the deputies admitted that they had travelled it only about once a week. Had they inspected this airway twice each shift as they were required to do under Sections 64 and 65 of the Coal Mines Act, 1944, as amended, they would surely have taken steps to have it properly maintained if only to avoid discomfort in travelling it.
Even though the deputies had failed to report the deterioration of the Arcade. it should have been obvious to the management that maintenance work would be necessary to counteract convergence as the face advanced, and it would have been prudent to put this work in hand at any early stage.
It should also have been obvious that the Companion Road, extending back from the face between wastes in which firedamp could be expected to accumulate, was a place where it was essential to ensure positive ventilation, and a system of bratticing for this purpose should have been laid down by the management and carried out by the deputies.
Had these precautions been taken, it is most unlikely that an explosive mixture could have formed in the Companion Road.
Persons Authorised to use Internal Relighter Flame Safety Lamps
The surveyor and his two assistants had been issued with Midget internal relighter flame safety lamps under an authorisation by the manager specifying surveyors but not naming individuals. This may have been within the letter of Article 1(c) of the Safety Lamps (Re-lighting) Order, 1929, but it permitted the issue of one of these lamps to any assistant surveyor with little practical experience.
To take the case of John Beauchamp, he had been an assistant surveyor for four years during which he had spent much time below ground and had, so he says, detected firedamp on the flame of a safety lamp. Nevertheless, a more experienced person would probably have suspected the presence of inflammable gas when he found the flame of his lamp extinguished on entering the Companion Road the first time, and would surely have confirmed its presence and retreated on the second occasion.
It cannot be too strongly emphasised that the presence of inflammable or noxious gas should always be suspected when there is no other obvious reason for the extinguishing of the flame of a safety lamp or when undue difficulty is experienced in relighting a safety lamp by means of an internal relighter.
During the afternoon shift on 10th October, there were 16 workmen wholly employed at the L.21 face, and only one of these workmen — the repairer at the rippings in the Top Level — was provided with a flame safety lamp for detecting the presence of inflammable gas. At least two such detectors should have been provided to comply with the Coal Mines General Regulations (Firedamp Detectors), 1939. The repairer, I. Lisak, working at the Companion Road rippings, usually carried a flame lamp as a detector but did not do so on this shift.
It would appear that a sufficient number of competent workmen had been appointed by the manager, but the deputies have admitted that they took no steps to ensure that these workmen did, in fact, carry detectors and that there was a sufficient number of detectors in use each shift to comply with the Regulations. The management cannot escape responsibility for allowing this state of affairs to continue.