II. — THE L.21 FACE
The L.21 is a longwall face, about 180 yards long, advancing into an area of the Lower Black Vein Seam beyond a fault of about 20 feet displacement.
The Winning out of the Face
An advancing longwall face, known as the M.21, in the Meadow Vein Seam, about 30 feet vertically above the Lower Black Vein, had struck this fault as an upthrow which brought the Lower Black Vein beyond it up to within about 10 feet of the horizon of the M.21 face. Advantage was taken of this fault to leave the Meadow Vein and work the Lower Black Vein instead.
The M.21 face was 140 yards long with an intake loading gate at the left end and a return gate at the right end. A stone drift was driven from each gate through the fault to the Lower Black Vein. At the intake end, the drift and its continuation in the Lower Black Vein were driven in line with the gate, but at the return end the drift was driven at an angle of 42 degrees to the right of the line of the gate. Its continuation in the Lower Black Vein was driven on this bearing until the length of face to be won out had been increased to about 180 yards when it was turned back parallel to the intake gate, and the winning out of the L.21 face roughly parallel to the fault was completed.
Method of Work and Organisation
The face started as a normal production unit on 15th September, 1952, and had advanced about 23 yards up to the time of the explosion.
The coal was hand-got with the aid of pneumatic picks and filled on to shaker conveyors of which there were three in series on the face which had a gradient in favour of the load of about 5 inches per yard. Two belt conveyors in tandem in the intake gate conveyed the coal to a tub-loading point some 350 yards from the face. All machinery was driven by compressed air from compressors at the surface.
Roof control and support were by means of strip packs, 5 yards wide, with 5-yard wastes and rows of steel bars set at right angles to the face on steel props.
The gateways were formed by ripping the roof and were supported with steel arches and gateside packs. Shots were fired by the deputies in these rippings using Unigex (Eq.S.) explosive, but no shots were ever fired in the coal. Cardox shells were occasionally used to bring down the roof in the wastes.
For the suppression of airborne dust, the coal face was infused with water once every 24 hours, all the pneumatic picks were worked wet, and water sprays were used at the transfer point and tub-loading point on the intake gate. These measures were effective.
The face was worked on a 24 hours cycle by three shifts arranged as follows :—
| Morning Shift | 7.0 a.m. to 2.30 p.m. | Coal getting. |
| Afternoon Shift | 2.50 p.m. to 10.30 p.m. | Conveyor turning, ripping and packing. |
| Night Shift | 11.15 p.m. to 6.45 a.m. | Strip packing and water infusion. |
The face normally yielded about 400 tons of coal per cycle.
A deputy was in charge of each shift, and the deputies changed shifts on a weekly rotation. Except at week-ends, each deputy made the pre-shift inspection for the succeeding shift.
The "Companion Road" and the "Arcade"
One of the objectives in extending the length of face when passing from Meadow Vein to Lower Black Vein was to make provision for the development of a scheme to provide a second intake airway for the L.21 district. This scheme involved, inter alia, the driving of a third drift through the fault in line with the length of return in the Meadow Vein and its continuation as a roadway in the Lower Black Vein.
The driving of the drift had not been started, but the roadway to form its continuation in the seam was commenced shortly after the L.21 face started and was advanced with the face. This roadway was known as the "Companion Road".
For the ventilation of this roadway an airway was formed through the goaf to connect it to the return. This airway was made seam height only, about 14 feet wide, supported by means of wood props and bars and a row of soft wood chocks on either side. It was known as the "Arcade."
These names will be used henceforward in this report as also will the local names of "Carrier Gate" for the intake and "Top Level" for the return.
Ventilation and the occurrence of firedamp
The district was ventilated by a separate split of air of nearly 10,000 cubic feet per minute. This quantity was appreciably increased by the exhaust air from the engines when the conveyors were running.
According to the results of air samples taken by the management, the average methane content of the air current was about 0.25 per cent. at a point 10 yards on the return side of the face and nearly 1.0 per cent. further outbye near the drift through the fault.
The deputies had reported a "diluted issue" of inflammable gas in the Top Level on practically every inspection since the face started, and one of the deputies, H. Williams, had reported a "diluted issue" in the Companion Road on 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 6th October. No other deputy had reported inflammable gas in the Companion Road, and there was no mention of inflammable gas other than the above in any of the deputies' reports covering the period since the face started.
In the case of the Top Level, it would appear that the firedamp reported was a small feeder which was found after the explosion to be issuing near the roof at the ripping face in a cul-de-sac formed at the bend where the roadway had been turned back parallel to the Carrier Gate. This cul-de-sac, ripped to the same height as the roadway, was utilised to house a compressed-air haulage gear for hauling trains of timber and materials in the Top Level which was the supply road for the face. A small auxiliary fan, driven by compressed air and slung from the steel arches in the Top Level, delivered air through a pipe range to the vicinity of this feeder.
The question of inflammable gas in the Companion Road will be discussed later in this report.
The afternoon shift on 10th October
The deputy in charge of the L.21 district on this shift was George Greenhaf. The pre-shift inspection had been made by deputy T. Isaac who had reported the district in order and free from inflammable gas except for the usual "diluted issue" in Top Level.
The face workers employed were the four conveyor turners and the parties of repairers who advanced the three gateway rippings. Also employed at the face on this shift were the now deceased deputy Arthur Griffiths and five men — two repairers and three assistants — who normally worked under his charge on backbye repair and maintenance work.
Due to transport delays outbye of the loading point during the preceding morning shift, sufficient coal had not been worked off the face for the conveyors to be moved forward, and the work done on the afternoon shift up to the time of the explosion was as follows
In the Top Level no shots were fired but the rippings were dressed down with an airpick to make room for the setting of another steel arch. This stone, together with some lying from the previous day, was filled on to the face conveyor. Two repairers and an assistant were engaged on this work.
In the Companion Road, a heap of ripping debris lying on the floor was filled on to the conveyor and a steel arch was set. No shot was fired. One repairer and an assistant were employed here.
In the Carrier Gate, three shot holes were drilled in the ripping face and the shots were fired simultaneously by deputy Arthur Griffiths at about 5.0 p.m. The debris from these shots was filled on to the gateway conveyor and this work had not been completed when the explosion occurred. Two repairers and three assistants were employed here.
The four conveyor turners and two assistant repairers were engaged in casting debris from the face conveyors into the strip packs. One of these men worked between the Top Level and the Companion Road and the others between the Companion Road and the Carrier Gate.
A surveyor and two assistant surveyors were also in the district making a check survey for the purpose of setting away the third drift through the fault to connect with the Companion Road. They commenced the survey at its outbye end and proceeded via the Top Level and the face to the Companion Road.
Immediately before the explosion occurred, the position was as follows
All the face workers were about to re-start work after a break for food which they had eaten at, or quite near to, their respective working places as described above.
The surveyor was at the dial set on the face side of the conveyor opposite the Companion Road into which he had just taken a sight to a tripod set near the entrance to the Arcade. One assistant, D. H. Boddington, was sitting near him and the other assistant, J. Beauchamp, was near the tripod in the Companion Road.
Both deputies were on the Top Level. G. Greenhaf was talking to the men at the roadhead and A. Griffiths had gone to fetch an explosives canister which had been left near the hauler house.
The positions of all persons in the affected area at the time the explosion occurred are shown on the plan.