Summary Of Conclusions
91. I summarise my conclusions as follows :—
1. The accident was an explosion of firedamp, initiated at the left hand corner of 5's Face by an electric arc from the damaged trailing cable of a coal cutting machine. The explosion was propagated to some extent by coal dust. (Paragraphs 38 and 46.)
2. The firedamp involved emanated from the Low Haigh Moor Seam some 7 feet below and was emitted fairly rapidly, though not suddenly, from floor breaks mainly at a fault. (Paragraph 53.)
3. The ventilation of 5's Unit did not, by standards of good practice, allow a sufficient margin of safety. As the result of defects in short term planning and in execution, there were air leakages so great that the velocity of the air at the left hand corner of the face was not sufficient to deal with any substantial increase in the usual make of firedamp. (Paragraph 63.)
4. In respect of both choice and maintenance of equipment, insufficient attention was given to precautions against coal dust in 5's Unit. (Paragraphs 72 — 77.)
Summary Of Recommendations
92. In summary, my recommendations are as follows:
Ventilation
1. The appropriate development plan for a colliery should show particulars of ventilation, including the means to be adopted for ventilating new workings at each stage of their development. (Paragraph 64.)
2. At all levels in the industry there should be energetic efforts to overcome the difficulties which are resulting in workmen being reluctant to carry and use firedamp detectors. (Paragraph 67.)
3. Regulation 7 (5) of the Coal and Other Mines (Ventilation) Regulations, 1956, is technically defective and should be amended. (Paragraph 66.)
Precautions against Coal Dust
4. It should be made obligatory to provide stone dust barriers on coal conveyor roads underground. (Paragraph 75.)
5. Coal cut by machine should be cut "wet". (Paragraph 77.)
Electricity
6. A further attempt should be made to devise an electrical protective system that will be capable of eliminating, or at least substantially reducing, the dangers of incendive arcing from a damaged trailing cable. (Paragraph 82.)
7. Local arrangements should be made between individual managements and H.M. Inspectors to ensure that notice of intention to introduce electricity is given at appropriate stages in the development of an electrical installation. (Paragraph 79.)
Statutory Reports
8. Under-managers should be given legal responsibilities similar to those imposed on the manager by section 10 of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954. (Paragraph 89.)
Acknowledgments
93. I wish to express to the various representatives who attended the Inquiry my very real appreciation of the help which they gave in bringing out the facts relating to this accident and to express to the witnesses my thanks for the frank and fair way in which they gave their evidence. I must also express sincere thanks to the Mayor and Corporation of the City of Wakefield, who generously allowed the Wakefield Town Hall to be used for the proceedings; to the surveying staff of the Wakefield Area of the National Coal Board for the excellent plans produced for use at the Inquiry; and to Mr. W. Fitzsimmons for his invaluable help in the preparation of this Report.
I have the honour to be, My Lord,
Your Lordship's obedient Servant,
T. A. Rogers.