(f) On the Application of Section 68 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911
In his submission Mr. Moffat also suggested that the operation of Section 68 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, would have assisted to prevent this accident, the implication being that the circumstances of the present disaster warranted the application of the provisions of this Section. It is clear, however, that the management considered that the Section did not apply in this case. The Section reads as follows
"Where any working has approached within forty yards of a place containing or likely to contain an accumulation of water or other liquid matter, or of disused workings (not being workings which have been examined and found to be free from accumulations of water or other liquid matter), the working shall not exceed eight feet in width, and there shall be constantly kept extending to a sufficient distance, not being less than five yards, in advance, at least one borehole near the centre of the working, and sufficient flank bore-holes on each side at intervals of not more than five yards."
It is probable, as Mr. Moffat said, that if the requirements of this Section of the Act had been carried out they would have assisted to prevent and, indeed, may have prevented, the inrush, for it would have meant that the approach to the outcrop would have been made by a heading eight feet wide, so that there would have been much less likelihood of falls and less likelihood of the moss breaking through. Headings approaching the surface should be narrow.
But was it legally necessary to observe the requirements of Section 68? It has long been recognized that the application of this Section of the Act in certain circumstances is difficult to determine. Mr. Morison, in his final submission said the Section did not apply in this case and partly supported his contention by putting forward a construction of the Section from a legal point of view. This construction is of such general interest that I propose to quote it in full.
"Section 68 raises, of course, different questions. You will know, Sir, whether the information with which I have been supplied is correct or not, but I am told that, since the findings in the Stanrigg Inquiry, in mining practice, Section 68 has been considered as referring only to workings approaching unexamined workings which do, or may contain, an accumulation of water or other liquid matter. Now, whether that be mining practice or not, of course, I am not in a position to say, but I hope I may be of some assistance in attempting the construction of Section 68, and submitting to you that that is very plainly what it does mean. You will see, Sir, that the Section starts out 'Where any working is approaching within 40 yards of a place containing, or likely to contain, an accumulation of water or other liquid matter, or of disused workings not being workings which have been examined and found to be free from accumulations of water or other liquid matter . . .' certain precautions are to be taken. Now, the three important parts of the first part of the Section, for the purposes of argument are, in the first place, the words 'a place containing or likely to contain an accumulation of water,' secondly, 'disused workings' and, the most important, the parenthesis, 'not being workings which have been examined'. Now, it is clear, I think, that 'not being workings' can't possibly refer only to 'disused workings', because, in the first place, the Section doesn't say so and, in the second place, because any other construction would lead to this ; even if the place 'likely to contain an accumulation of water' had been examined and found to be free from water — if you didn't include the rest of the words it would mean you would have to take the precautions in the Section all the same. Therefore, I say that the word 'workings' in parenthesis there must mean that the place 'containing, or likely to contain an accumulation of water' is a working. Now, if that construction of the Section from a legal point of view is correct, well, of course, there is no question here; the workings weren't approaching another working".
Strangely enough, the Report (1927) of the Departmental Committee on the Prevention of Dangers in Mines from Accumulation of Water or other Liquid Matter, which discusses at length the defects and the application of Section 68 of the Act, does not refer to the difficulty in the interpretation of the word "place" in the phrase "a place containing, or likely to contain an accumulation of water or other liquid matter". But where they do use the word "place" in their comments on the Section, it is clear that its meaning is synonymous with an underground working. I cannot presume to give a legal interpretation — that is a matter for the Courts — but in my opinion the word "place" as used in the first sentence of the Section is in a practical way appropriate in its context only when applied to an underground working, used or disused; and the precautions required by the Section were not the most effective or, indeed, the appropriate precautions to be taken in the circumstances which arose in this case.