Appendix.
Home Office,
Whitehall,
8th April, 1913.
I am directed by the Secretary of State to say that he observes from the annual return which you
have made to him in pursuance of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, that up to the date of the return no
provision had been made at the . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mine in regard
to the training of rescue brigades and the provision of breathing apparatus as required by the Rescue
and Aid Order of the 2nd April, 1912. In the memorandum which was issued to owners of coal
mines on the 4th May, 1912, with a copy of the Order, it was pointed out that the Order came into
force at once and that it would be necessary for each owner to take steps without delay to comply
with the requirements of the Order, but that reasonable time would be allowed in Which to complete
the formation of the rescue brigades and to obtain the requisite supply of breathing appliances. The
Order has now been in force for nearly a year, and owners have therefore had ample time in which
to make their arrangements for compliance with its requirements. The Secretary of State cannot but
take a very serious view of the failure to carry out the Order at your mine. He must point out that
the obligation to comply with the Order rests upon the owner, agent or manager of each mine
individually, and the owner, agent or manager, in the event of failure to comply with the Order, is liable to
a fine of £20 and to a further fine of £1 for every day during which the failure to comply continues.
The Secretary of State directs me to say that unless you can give him a definite undertaking that
energetic steps will be taken at once to secure a full compliance at your mine with the requirements
of the Order at an early date, it will be necessary for him to take legal proceedings to enforce its
provisions.
I am to add that the Secretary of State is advised that a "smoke helmet" which is supplied with
fresh air by means of a tube and bellows is not a portable breathing apparatus within the meaning of
the Order. The phrase "a portable breathing apparatus" as used in the Order means a self-contained
apparatus which, in the event of rescue operations being necessary, will enable the wearer to visit any
part of the mine, and a "smoke helmet" which would only allow the wearer to proceed to a very
limited distance in advance of the fresh air would not meet the requirement.
I am,
Your obedient Servant,
R. A. S. Redmayne.
The Lanarkshire Coal Masters’ Association.
To The Members.
174, West George Street,
Glasgow,
19th April, 1913.
Rescue And Aid Order Of 2nd April, 1912.
Dear Sirs,
With reference to this Order and the circular letter of Mr. Redmayne, Chief Inspector of Mines,
dated 8th curt., thereanent, which doubtless you have received, I beg to inform you that the reports
of the Special Committee appointed by the Executive of this Association to consider the matter were
submitted to a Meeting of the Executive held on Wednesday last, and on the recommendation of the
Committee, the Executive instructed me to advise our Members that they should at once take steps
to give effect to the annexed Sections of the Order, which are obligatory, irrespective of the more
important questions of Rescue Stations and the kind of breathing apparatus required to be provided to
comply with the Order.
The latter question is being discussed with Mr. Walker, H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines for
Scotland, and it is probable that a test case will be raised in Scotland to determine the matter.
In the meantime you can acknowledge receipt of Mr. Redmayne’s circular, and state you are
advised that the matters referred to therein are being dealt with between Mr. Walker, Chief Inspector
of Mines, and the Association, but that you are to take immediate steps to give effect to Sectoin 3,
Sub-sections (a), (b), and (c) ; and Section 5, Sub-sections (b) and (c) of the Order.
Yours faithfully,
Robert Baird, Secretary.
P.S. — If you have any difficulty in knowing the best Companies from whom to obtain the
electric hand-lamps and oxygen reviving apparatus, I could make arrangements to order them for you
on reduced terms for a large quantity, on your informing me of the number of each you require and
where they should be sent.
R. B.
The full text of the Sections referred to in the annexed circular are as under :—
(3.) (a.) There shall be organized and maintained at every mine, as soon as is reasonably
practicable, competent rescue brigades on the following scale :—
| Where the number of underground employees is 250 or less | 1 brigade |
| Where the number of underground employees is more than 250 but not more than 700 | 2 brigades |
| Where the number of underground employees is more than 700 but not more than 1,000 | 3 brigades |
| Where the number of underground employees is more than 1,000 | 4 brigades |
But the Owner, Agent or Manager of a mine, at which the total number of
underground employees is less than 100, shall be deemed to have complied
with this provision if he has acquired the privilege of calling for a brigade
from a Central Rescue Station.
A group of mines belonging to the same owner, of which all the shafts or exits
for the time being in use in working the mines lie within a circle having a
radius of two miles shall, for the purpose of ascertaining the number of
brigades required, be treated as one mine.
(b.) A rescue brigade shall consist of not less than five persons employed at the mine, carefully
selected on account of their knowledge of underground work, coolness and powers of
endurance, and certified to be medically fit, a majority of whom shall be trained in
First Aid and shall hold a certificate of the St. John’s Ambulance Association or of
the St. Andrew’s Association.
(c.) There shall be selected from the ranks of each rescue brigade one person or leader who
shall act as captain of the brigade.
(5.) (b.) There shall be kept at every mine tracings of the workings of the mine up to a date not
more than three months previously, showing the ventilation and all principal doors,
stoppings and air crossings and regulators, and distinguishing the intake air by a
different colour from the return air, which tracings shall be in a suitable form for use
by the brigades.
(c.) There shall also be provided and maintained at every mine which maintains a rescue
brigade or brigades —
(i.) Two or more small birds or mice for testing for carbon monoxide.
(ii.) Two electric hand-lamps for each brigade, ready for immediate use and capable
of giving light for at least four hours.
(iii.) One oxygen reviving apparatus.
(iv.) A safety lamp for each member of the rescue brigade for testing for fire damp.
(v.) An ambulance box provided by the St. John’s Ambulance Association or
similar box, together with antiseptic solution and fresh drinking water.
The Lanarkshire Coalmasters’ Association,
174, West George Street,
Glasgow.
22nd April, 1913.
Rescue And Aid Order Of 2nd April. 1912.
Mr. Redmayne’s Circular Letter Of 8th April, 1913.
Dear Sir,
With reference to the above I beg to refer you to the Meeting which you had on 6th February
last with the Committee appointed by this Association to discuss chiefly the question of breathing
apparatus to be provided under the above Order, and to state that the reports of the Committee
thereon were considered by the Executive of this Association on Wednesday last, and they have
instructed me to write you on the subject.
While they are of opinion that in the area covered by this Association the question of "Rescue
and Aid" is not one Of urgency in the interests of safety, they recognise that the Order which has
been issued must be complied with in respect of sections (3) (a), (b), and (c) ; and (5) (b) and (0) and
the five subsections under the latter, and they have advised the Members of the Association to
comply without delay with the provisions of these sections, and doubtless this will be done.
With regard to the principal question raised as to the kind of "portable breathing apparatus,"
required by section (5) (a), my Executive are of opinion that for the mines within this Association,
smoke helmets and bellows apparatus will be found to be the safest and most suitable, and that they
comply with that section.
The arrangement made between you and the Committee with regard to this matter was, as you
will remember, that should my Executive decide as above, you were to advise the Home Secretary of
their decision, and in the event of his disagreeing with their finding that the question in dispute
should be decided by a test case raised against one of the members of the Lothians Coal Owners'
Association, to which the Committee agreed.
In view of the terms of Mr. Redmayne’s letter, the Home Secretary may disagree with my
Executive with regard to smoke helmets, and I presume that under such circumstances the test case
referred to will be proceeded with.
I shall be glad to hear from you after you have had time to confer with Mr. Redmayne on the
subject.
Yours faithfully,
(Signed) Robert Baird.
W. Walker, Esq.,
H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines,
Tyne, Lodge, Grange Loan, Edinburgh.
21st April, 1913.
Rescue And Aid Order Of 2nd April, 1912.
Dear Sir,
With reference to your circular letter of 8th curt., I am advised that the matters therein
referred to are being dealt with between Mr. Walker, Chief Inspector of Mines, and the Lanarkshire
Coalmasters’ Association. So far as Section 3, Sub-sections (a), (b) and (c) and Section 5, Sub-sections
(b) and (c) of the Order are concerned, I shall take immediate steps to have these given effect to.
Yours faithfully,
George Pate.
R. A. S. Redmayne, Esq.,
Home Office,
Whitehall, London.
Tyne Lodge,
Grange Loan,
Edinburgh,
25th April, 1913.
Robert Baird,
Secretary,
The Lanarkshire Coal Masters’ Association,
174, West George Street,
Glasgow.
Dear Sir,
I am in receipt of your letter of the 22nd inst, respecting the Rescue and Aid Order, and
will reply to it in due course.
Yours faithfully,
W. Walker.
H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines.