On Sunday, August 3rd, at about 3 p.m., a back shift of 25 men under the
charge of fireman Reilly went down No. 15 pit. Their departure was superintended by
J. Owens, the under-manager. They had all naked lights except Reilly and McCann,
the last named of whom was going to work in an exploring place to the extreme
north of the mine.
The men were substantially divided into three groups; one, of eight men, was to
work in No. 2 machine section; two men, Alexander Brown and Hugh McCann, were
to work at pumps at the extreme north of the mine, and the remaining fifteen were to work
a coal-cutter and do other work in No. 1 machine section on the eastern side. Charles Reilly,
the fireman, was to superintend them all. As it was Sunday the usual pit headman
was not employed, but John Lees, a boiler furnaceman, acted at the pit-head and took the
names as required by the Eight Hours Act. No coal was to be drawn and the checkweighman
was not present. Prior to the coming into force of the Act in July, 1912, it
seems to have been usual in many mines in Great Britain not to have a bottomer if men
and coal were not being regularly raised. The Royal Commission on Coal Mines, however,
recommended that in all cases a bottomer should be stationed at the pit bottom as
long as there were persons in the mine, and this recommendation was carried into effect
in the Act of 1911. This Act, which came into force on July 1st, 1912,
requires (Section 53 (2)) that so long as persons are below ground, other than mine
officials or persons authorised to give signals, a bottomer shall be in constant attendance
for the purpose of receiving and transmitting signals.
In addition to this section, however, a set of rules was in force at the colliery made
under the Coal Mines Regulation Act of 1887, which provided that, in the absence of a
bottomer, the signals might be given by the fireman if duly appointed for that purpose.
By virtue of Clause 126 of the Act of 1911 these rules remained in force till they were
supplanted by new regulations, which came into force on September 10th, 1913, after the
date of the accident. These new regulations do not allow the fireman to act as
bottomer.
It was usual to have a regular bottomer on week days: on Sundays it was usual,
if the man Etherson who usually acted bottomer on week days went down, to send him
to work away from the bottom. The fireman usually acted as bottomer on Sundays. On
the day of the accident, Sunday, August 3rd, Etherson did not go down the mine at all,
but Reilly, the fireman, rang the men down, and then went to his duties of examining
the mine, leaving the bottom of the shaft unattended until he returned.
If there had been a bottomer on Sunday his duties might have been to clean up
any coal that might be about near the pit bottom, but, as no coal was being drawn, he
would probably not have had anything to do. His duties would also have been
probably to turn out the electric lights at the pit bottom when the men had gone off
to their work in the mine. As it was the lights do not seem usually to have been lit on
Sundays.
The back shift, as has been said, descended about 3 p.m. and proceeded to the cabin
at the top of the brae, 125 yds. from the pit bottom. Here some of them took off their
coats and left them hanging near the cabin and some in the telephone space. Most likely
the coats contained matches and perhaps pipes — they generally took their matches and
pipes to their working places. Others carried their coats further in-bye. They then all
proceeded down the Main Dook Brae to the lamp-station, where they waited until Reilly
had inspected the workings.
The lamps used by Scottish miners differ much from the candles usually employed
by miners in England. They consist of a small tin something like a coffee pot with
a lid that snaps down and a wick about ¼ inch in diameter. The men provide their own
oil for which they pay about 2s. 3d. per gallon. This oil is called "seal oil," but is
composed in reality of fish and cheap mineral oil, with upwards of 50 per cent. of heavy
Scottish paraffin oil mixed with it. The flash point of the compound is high and I could
not learn that it is specially inflammable or dangerous.
The lamps are hooked on to the miners’ caps and in consequence of the movements
of the wearer his cap and clothes become more or less impregnated with oil, which, sometimes
causes them to be set alight. In naked light pits the miners carry pipes and matches
and smoke when and where they please. This custom has existed for years and years, and
they do not consider it dangerous because there have been so few accidents from fire.
The oil is carried down the pit in small tin flasks and most miners have one in their
pockets. On going into the mine each man sees that his lamp is trimmed and full
of oil, and throws away an exhausted wick. While still burning, he will often
cast it on the ground, and tread it out after he has lit his new wick from it. There
is no evidence that the officials or men at the mine were careless in the use of their
lamps.
The men in machine section No. 1 appear to have reached their station at about
4.30 p.m. and commenced work. Soon afterwards a fire broke out at or close to the
cabin and no doubt extended to the timber which lay over it. The smoke of this
fire was of course at once carried along the Main Dook Brae, and rapidly spread
into the workings. At some time, probably about 6 p.m., the fireman Reilly
smelt smoke, and concluded that something was wrong. He appears to have
warned the men in No. 2 machine section, and then gone across to No. 1 section and
warned the men there. In this he did his duty. The men in No. 1 section then went
by way of No. 1 machine level and turned southwards into the main airway, down
which the smoke was coming; they thus were going straight into danger. The two
pumpmen went the same way. If a communication door had been opened so as to
short-circuit the air and smoke, and if the men had remained in their working places,
it is probable that the whole of them might have been saved. It must, moreover, be
remembered that Reilly is reported to have said that he did not know where the fire was.
He had never seen such a thing as a fire in his pit before ; consequently his omission was
only what many men would have done in like circumstances.
Among the men following this path was Robert Dunbar, a man who was well
acquainted with the roads and workings. He was followed by Keenan and O’Neil.
Having, with very proper courage, waited for and revived O’Neil, who was one of his
party of three, and finding the smoke very thick in the main Brae, he turned eastwards
into Stewart’s level, in a direction shown by the red dotted lines on the plan
and, having gone through a door, got into the return airway (to a point he
might have more directly reached from the place where he was working). Thence
he went on by McLaren’s and Harrigan’s headings into Connor’s heading, finally
along the communication level and through the two doors at No. 3 Bench, an into the
downcast fresh-air way of No. 17 pit, which was supplying air to another mine, and so
with his party escaped.
His coolness, knowledge of the mine, and good sense saved his party; and had
the others followed him, all might have been saved. His action illustrates the use of
Rule 60 of the New Regulations, which provides that where one of two ways of egress
from a mine is along a road not usually travelled, every fireman shall at least once a
quarter traverse the whole of such way in order to make himself thoroughly acquainted
with the same.
The rest of the men who had been working in No. 1 machine section went into the
main-airway, and as they started about 6.30 p.m. it seems probable that by 7 p.m. or
7.30 p.m. they were all dead.
Of the men in No. 2 machine section, four went along the return eastwards, but
instead of continuing in the return and passing along the cross-road over the main
airway, which was their only chance, they all went through the door leading into the
main-airway and perished. Of the four who remained in No. 2 machine section three
died, but one, Michael McDonald, got into a "dead-end" of air, lived till Monday
forenoon and was rescued. The total number of men who perished was 22.
A little before 8 pm. Dunbar’s party having come up shaft No. 17, went over to
No. 15, where they found that the firemen of the night shift, William and
Joseph Brown, had gone down.
Presently they came up. It appears that on their descent they saw nothing of the
fire till they turned the corner of the main-airway — then they saw the pit on fire.
William Brown was of opinion that the cabin had caught fire. He saw the cables
burning, but not sufficiently to induce him to think that the fire had been caused by
electricity. He came up, and descended again with a party to try and put the fire out, but
failed.
William Owens then went over to 17 pit, got the air-current reversed and then rescue
parties were able to descend at No. 17 shaft. Two bodies were discovered at 11 p.m.
There was no rescue apparatus at the pit. Although preliminary steps had been
taken to form a brigade, no brigade had been formed, nor rescue apparatus of any
description provided. Canaries and the other apparatus specified in section 5 (c) of the
Rescue and Aid Order of April 2, 1912, had been provided. Hence the rescue work had
to be commenced by men without rescue apparatus, but provided with canaries.
At 12 midnight Mr. McLaren, the Senior Inspector of the western part of the
Scotland Division, arrived, and at once went down No. 17 shaft. By this time the
reversal of the air current had considerably cleared away the smoke and poisonous gas,
and he was therefore enabled to get to the main road near where it is crossed by
Stewart’s level. Meanwhile a rescue brigade had been telephoned for. The nearest was
at Cowdenbeath, in Fife, about 50 miles away. They got the men together at 11 p.m.,
started at midnight, and arrived about 3 am. At first they were told that smoke-helmets
and bellows were all that was required, and Forrester went down with some, and some
men only to find they were useless and to come up and go down again with a party
provided with the W. E. G. self-contained oxygen breathing apparatus. He came to
where Inspector McLaren was, who asked him to take a canary and go southward along
the main road, that is to say, backwards towards where the fire was. He fitted on the
mouth-piece of the apparatus and did so, and found a number of bodies. As the canary
was not affected, showing that the reversal of the air current had now made that part of
the mine safe, the ordinary rescue parties were able to complete their task of finding the
bodies, and by mid-day on Monday all had been discovered. One, as before mentioned,
Michael McDonald, was still alive, and was brought completely round with the help
of Dr. Miller.