Report by J. T. Robson, Esq.
Sir,
About 1.45 p.m. on Tuesday, 11th April 1893, a fire occurred in the Four Feet Seam at the Great Western Colliery, which resulted in the loss of 63 lives.
The Great Western Colliery is situated at Gyfeillon, in the Rhondda Valley, about two miles above Pontypridd, in the heart of the South Wales Steam Coal Field. It is one of the largest collieries in the district, and is owned by the Great Western Colliery Company, Limited, whose registered address is "The Exchange, Bristol." Messrs. Forster Brown, and Rees, mining engineers, of Cardiff, are the consulting engineers for the company.
The managing staff consists of — Mr. Hugh Bramwell, agent; Mr. William James, certificated manager; Mr. David Rees, certificated under-manager; Mr. Evan S. Richards, holder of a first-class certificate, acting as assistant manager. Mr. W. M. Jones is the surveyor and Mr. R. L. Molyneux the mechanical engineer. There are 3 overmen and 17 firemen.
Mr. Bramwell, the agent, who is a mining engineer and certificated manager, succeeded Mr. H. T. Wales on 1st January of the present year.
There are three shafts, via., the Hetty Pit (downcast), which is sunk to the Six Feet Seam, and is 398 yards deep; the No. 2 Pit (upcast) sunk to the Five Feet Seam, a depth of 473 1/3 yards ; the Tymawr Pit (upcast) also sunk to the Five Feet Seam at a depth of 472 1/3 yards.
Coal is raised at each of the three shafts. At the Hetty Pit, the Four Feet and the Six Feet Seams are worked. The Four Feet Seam, lying about 25 yards above the Six Feet, is passed through in the shaft, but, for greater safety and convenience in winding, all the coal is raised from the Six Feet Seam, the lowest landing in the shaft.
At No. 2 Pit only the Five Feet Seam is worked at present, the coal being raised from the landing at this seam.
At the Tymawr Pit, the Five Feet Seam is also being worked and raised from the Five Feet landing.
The ventilation of the colliery is produced by two Schiele fans, each 15' 3" diameter, one of which is placed near the top of No. 2 Pit, which is elliptical in section, the diameters being 14' 4" and 10' 9" respectively ; the other fan is fixed near the top of Tymawr Pit, also an elliptical shaft, measuring 16' x 10'. The downcast or Hetty Pit is circular and 16' in diameter. About 270,000 cubic feet of air per minute is circulated through the workings, which are amongst the most fiery in the South Wales District.
The whole colliery is well equipped with modern machinery and appliances for producing a large output of steam coal, and both the Hetty and No. 2 Pits have been safely and successfully worked since the year 1877, when these shafts were first sunk to the steam coal measures. Prior to this the house coals had been worked.
The Tymawr Pit had only recently been acquired by the Company, and sunk by them to the lower steam coal seams. Previous to this the east workings in the Four Feet from the Hetty Pit had been extended beyond the Tymawr Pit, and since the latter was an upcast shaft, it became more convenient to connect these workings to it for the purpose of ventilation; so that now one large district of Four Feet Seam at the Hetty Pit has a direct communication with the Tymawr upcast in that seam.
On the accompanying plan, reduced to a scale of 4 chains (88 yards) to the inch, are shown the position of each shaft, all the workings in the Four Feet Seam lying to the east of the Hetty Pit, which are the parts affected by the accident in question, and their connexions with the landing in the Six Feet Seam in this pit.
It may be stated that the total number of persons employed in the three pits was about 1,460, of whom about 950 were at work on the day shift on the day of the accident. Of this number 212 were in the east workings of the Four Feet Seam, and were all placed in jeopardy by the fire. Of the 212 persons 78 were in the East Main Dip, and 134 in the East Main Level. Those in the other portions of the mine, although never in danger in consequence of the fire, were all speedily withdrawn and sent to the surface.
Haulage by machinery is largely adopted and, in common with many of the larger collieries, compressed air is used for the transmission of power from the compressing plant on the surface to work the underground machinery. There are no less than 15 hauling engines in the whole of the seams in connexion with the colliery, and it was at one of these engines that the disastrous fire originated. The position of this engine is shown in red and marked "Engine" on the plan annexed.
Before dealing more particularly with the engine it may be convenient to shortly describe the haulage roads and the workings in the parts affected.
On the east level in the Six Feet Seam, about 120 yards from the Hetty Pit, a main road marked "East Hard Heading" branches off at right angles, and this road, rising 1 in 6, cuts the Four Feet at a distance of 156 yards. It is here where the engine in question is situated. From this point the road marked "East Main Dip" is continued in a straight line for a distance of 270 yards, and then turns to the right, here called Sam Cull's Dip, and continued a further distance of 400 yards. At a point 176 yards down Sam Cull's Dip a pair of headings branch off at right angles to the right, and 160 yards lower down two headings branch off to the left. The headings to the right extend 396 yards to the rise, and those to the left 114 yards to the dip. These headings and the 29 stalls at work in them formed one ventilating district, which may be termed the East Main Dip, and it will be seen from the plan that it was ventilated to the No. 2 upcast.
From the top of the East Hard Heading referred to, just inside the engine, another main road, marked "Four Feet East Level" on plan, branches off to the right for a distance of 463 yards to the top of "Thompson's Dip." Following Thompson's Dip 103 yards, "Witt's Level" is reached branching off to the right, and this extends 548 yards to the working headings which are to the rise. Returning to Thompson's Dip it will be seen that it is continued in a straight line to the bottom, a further distance of 363 yards. On the east side is a level extending 143 yards to the working heading, and on the west side another level, reaching the last of three headings at a distance of 288 yards. These three divisions form one large district ventilated to the Tymawr upcast. The roadways above mentioned are the haulage roads and also form the intake airways. They are all of a minimum section of 50 square feet.
From the Hetty Pit to the top of the East Hard Heading, a distance of 280 yards, the roadway is arched throughout. Inside of this point, with the exception of a short length forming an air-crossing 15 yards farther in on the East Main Dip, the roadways are all double-timbered, most of the timbering being lagged.
There were about 72,000 cubic feet of air per minute passing up the East Harding Heading and beyond the engine for a few yards, where it was split; about 57,000 going to the East Level and 15,000 to the East Main Dip. The velocity of the current at the engine would be about 20 feet per second.
The mine being a very dry one naturally, provision is made for damping the roadways and laying the dust by a system of spray-jets, fixed at intervals of about 40 yards in the principal intakes, the water for which is conveyed from the surface by a column of pipes, partly 2 inches but chiefly only 1¼ inches in diameter, down the shaft, and continued along the different haulage roads. Altogether there are 5 miles of piping laid for this purpose.
The engine was fixed immediately over the roadway upon pitch pine beams resting on side walls of masonry. It consists of two 10-inch cylinders with a 12-inch stroke, working two loose drums by spur gearing, geared 4 to 1. The drums are 3½ feet diameter, each of which has a break fitted to it consisting of an iron strap, to which are bolted elm curb blocks, the brake extending half the circumference of the drum, with a bearing 4 inches wide. The brake leverage of one drum, working the main rope, is 15 to 1; that of the other working the tail-rope is 45 to 1.
This engine works the haulage on the East Hard Heading, the East Main Dip, and the East Level as far as the top of Thompson's Dip.
Six trams at a time are hauled up the East Main Dip by the main-rope drum, and lowered down the East Hard Heading by the tail-rope drum. Twelve trams at a time are hauled along the East Level by the main-rope drum and lowered down the East Hard Heading by the tail-rope drum, and while a "journey" is being hauled out from the East Level the tail-rope is attached behind and drawn out, so that the next empty journey may be hauled in by this rope, which passes round a sheave at the inner end of the East Level. When a journey of 12 trams, having a gross weight of 19.2 tons, was being lowered by the tail-rope drum down the Hard Heading there would be a strain of 3.2 tons on this drum, and the breaking would consequently be severe.
The woodwork in connexion with this engine consisted of two wooden cross-beams 12 inches square, 13 feet long ; one cross-beam 12 inches by 10 inches; 13 feet long, one cross-beam 8 inches square, 10½ feet long ; two longitudinal beams 14½ inches by 8 inches, 16 feet long; a platform of 1½-inch deal 10 feet by 4 feet; and the elm blocks forming the brakes.
The situation of the engine being on a main intake airway, the engineman had placed canvas brattice cloth at the ends and below the drums to afford shelter from the strong current and the dust blown off the loaded trams in passing. With the exception of a small quantity of cylinder oil, olive oil for the bearings, and some cotton waste for cleaning the engine, there was no inflammable material about it other than the woodwork and canvas mentioned. Doubtless there would be a considerable amount of oily and greasy matter adhering to the woodwork below the drums.
The lighting was by an electric incandescent lamp, this lamp being the last of a series fixed at intervals from the shaft inwards in this direction.
Fire had never been anticipated here, and no special provision had been made to deal with a fire. There was, however, an upright pipe, branching off the pipe supplying water to the spray-jets, with a few feet of hose attached, the upright pipe being provided with a tap, so that water could be drawn if necessary. One bucket was kept at the engine.
It may here be mentioned that the engineman who usually worked this engine had been absent for some days owing to ill-health ; and, although this man appears to have been in the habit of keeping the bucket filled with water, and occasionally using the water to cool the brake of the tail-rope drum, the engineman on duty at the time of the accident had not provided himself with water.
On the day of the accident I was engaged at a colliery near Merthyr and did not reach home till after 9 p.m., too late to proceed that night to Pontypridd in response to the telegram which had been sent to me at Swansea. Mr. J. Mancel Sims, Assistant Inspector at Cardiff, had heard of the occurrence and proceeded at once to the colliery, reaching there at 8.45 p.m. Mr. J. D. Lewis, Assistant Inspector, residing at Swansea, was apprised of the telegram reporting the fire on his return home about 6 o'clock that day, and he also went to the colliery, reaching it about 12 p.m. Both Mr. Sims and Mr. Lewis went underground and remained at the colliery until my arrival at 10.45 a.m. on the following day.
After being informed by them and the officials of all the circumstances that were then known, and consulting with them and with some mining engineers and managers from other collieries, I made an examination of the scene of the fire, and saw what steps were being taken to extinguish it and reach the workings beyond. It will be convenient at this juncture to describe shortly what had taken place so far as was then known.
The fire appeared to have been discovered by a boy named Edwin Matthews, who had descended the Hetty Pit about 1.30 p.m. to work with a collier on the afternoon shift in the Four Feet Seam. In passing up the East Hard Heading he noticed something on fire below the engine, called to the engineman, and then ran back towards the Hetty Pit. A "journey" of trams was then being hauled up the East Main Dip, and George James, the engineman, stopped the engine, came down to the roadway and saw one of the beams on fire. He along with the rider of the journey, John H. Thomas, who had run out to the engine to see what was the matter, endeavoured to put out the fire by beating it, but failed. They then tried to draw water from the tap above, but there was no water in the pipe. In a few minutes they were joined by some men who came in from the shaft, and directly afterwards by David Rees, under-manager, who happened to be near the Hetty Pit bottom when the alarm of fire was given. The pipe conveying water to the spray jets had by this time been broken by the engineman, but little water could be got from this source, and some of the men were then carrying water in buckets from a cistern in the stables in the Six Feet Level at the bottom of the East Hard Heading.
The fire was now beginning to spread inwards, and it caught the timbers supporting the roadway at the top of the East Main Dip and the entrance to the Four Feet East Level.
The first intimation of something having happened reached the Tymawr Pit a little before 2 p.m., when John Cannon, the hitcher in the Five Feet Seam, heard someone crying from the Four Feet Seam above "Let's have the carriage, quick." He went up with the next cage, and sent up to the surface three cage loads of men, when he became affected by the smoke, and ascended himself with the fourth cage load. Three or four more cage loads were raised from the Four Feet, the last one bringing up only one man, named William Fletcher. While these men were being raised one man, Jesse Titley, probably owing to his exhausted condition, or the difficulty of seeing the cage in the smoky atmosphere which then prevailed, fell down the shaft and was killed.
Four other men who had managed to reach the landing at Tymawr Shaft were too exhausted to get over or through the wooden fence protecting the entrance to the shaft, and although several attempts were made, both by some of those who escaped and others, they could not, in the then state of the atmosphere, be rescued alive.
The speed of the ventilating fan at Tymawr Pit had, unfortunately, been increased soon after it became known at the surface that something was wrong. Probably, this was done in the excitement of the moment, and in the belief that an explosion had occurred. The increase-of speed from 51 or 52 revolutions, the normal speed of the engine, to 60, and then to 75, continued up to about 3 o'clock, and no doubt augmented the current of air passing up the East Hard Heading, and along the Four Feet East Level, thus fanning the flames in a greater degree and carrying the smoke more quickly through the Four Feet East Workings.
Between 2 and 3 o'clock Mr. James, the manager, had arrived at the scene of the fire, and soon decided that it would be a proper course to reduce the speed of the Tymawr fan to about half the normal speed, and this was done. On being informed shortly after this of the state of matters at the Four Feet Landing in the Tymawr Pit, and thinking that probably the whole of the men in the East Level District had been able to reach that landing, he sanctioned the stoppage of the fan there, and the lifting of the covers at the top of the pit, with the object of turning that shaft into a downcast and thus getting fresh air at the landing, to effect the rescue of the men there. The fan was stopped between the hours of 3.15 and 4 p.m., and during this time the bodies of the four men who had died at the landing were brought up, but no more men came out alive by that road, nor could any sign of life be seen within the short distance (about 100 yards) inwards, which Mr. Jones, surveyor, and others were able to penetrate. The fan was then run at half speed.
The next step taken by the manager appears to have been an attempt to reach the East Main Dip workings by way of the return airway. It was, however, found impossible to do so, the smoke being too thick in the return.
About 4.15 p.m. Mr. Bramwell arrived, descended the pit, and joined Mr. James, the manager. Soon after this steps were taken by them to increase the supply of water by laying another line of pipes from the shaft to the fire, but efforts had never been relaxed in using to the best advantage the available supply by the original pipes and by carrying it from the stables and the sump at the shaft.
Fortunately the brick arch forming the air-crossing over the East Main Dip, 15 yards beyond the engine, helped considerably to stop the spread of the fire down this road, and about 6 p.m. the fire had been subdued here sufficiently to admit of an attempt being made to reach the workings of East Main Dip. William Rosser, a fireman, and brother of the fireman in this district, got down as far as the first door, 210 yards distant, and opened it to help the smoke to clear away from the dip, and keep it from going inwards to the working headings. His light went out, and he returned to the engine. Getting another lamp, and this time accompanied by Morgan Thomas, overman, and Lewis James, fireman, he again went down the Dip, and passing the second door near the top of Sam Cull's Dip, and the third door beyond the first working heading, both of which doors were found open, reached the men, numbering 78, including the fireman, Thomas Rosser, all gathered together and uninjured about 100 yards up Holbrook's Heading. They then all walked out by the intake, reaching the surface about 6.30 p.m.
Great credit is due to Thomas Rosser, the fireman of this district, for his coolness and prompt action on discovering that smoke was entering the workings by the intake. It appears that he first felt the smoke about 1.45 p.m. while standing near the double parting on Holbrook's Heading, and at once went up the dip, meeting David Richards, master haulier, who told him that there was a lot of smoke coming down the dip behind him. Thomas Rosser immediately sent some men into the working places with instructions to withdraw all men and boys and bring them to the double-parting. Rosser, Richards, and another man, William Devereux, went up the dip, through the smoke, and realising the gravity of the situation, made an effort to reach the outermost of the two doors with the intention of opening it and thus short circuiting the air current. They, however, failed in this, and returning, opened the second door near the top of Sam Cull's dip, and then reached the double parting again where the men were beginning to gather. Although most of the men wanted to make an attempt to get out by the main intake, Rosser was able to dissuade them from this course.
By and bye the atmosphere, notwithstanding the opening of the door above-mentioned, became by diffusion so impregnated with smoke that he had to move the men further up the heading. He then opened a door between Holbrook's and Ostler's Headings, and afterwards another on the first crossing 73 yards up these headings, finally erecting a brattice across Holbrook's Heading inside of this crossing and retreating with the men to the inbye side of it. They waited here, about 280 yards from the face of Holbrook's heading. Gas had by this time accumulated in the headings and stalls, and before they left Rosser had ascertained that it showed in the lamp 120 yards from the face.
Some more unsuccessful attempts had in the meantime been made by those on the surface to enter the Four Feet Seam by the Tymawr return, but it was not until about 8 a.m. on Wednesday, when Mr. Bramwell, Mr. William Stewart of Harris' Navigation, and Ivor John, a fireman, made the attempt, that this was accomplished. They reached by way of Bidman's Old Dip and Osborne's Cross Heading, James Holbrook's level, where they found the dead body of a haulier and two horses, but the air was too heavily charged with smoke to remain many minutes in it and they returned to the surface. Mr. Stewart was much affected by smoke but recovered in a day or two.
Efforts to overcome the fire in the Four Feet East Level were continued during the night and the following day, but the work of getting the water to the front became more and more difficult owing to the falling in of the roof and the smoke and steam from the burning mass behind, buried more or less by the falls. By mid-day on Wednesday it was possible to reach the engine situated 70 yards outside of Thompson's Dip, and the dead body of the engineman was seen in the engine house.
The condition of the air in this level, however, was such that no one could remain long in it, and it was deemed unwise to make any more attempts until the fire had been reduced in dimensions and the roadway cooled down to some extent.
The utilisation of the compressed air pipes had been considered by the management, and Mr. Treherne Rees, one of the consulting engineers, at an earlier period, but dismissed on the ground that, as these pipes were only standing a pressure of 55 lbs. per square inch, it would be too risky to put a strain of 520 lbs. on them, that being about the pressure due to a column of water the height of the shaft. Upon further consideration it was decided to try this means, with the precaution of tapping the column at a point about 70 yards above the bottom of the shaft in order to relieve the pressure on the column. This plan was carried out with success, and by 11 p.m. on Wednesday the extra supply of water delivered by these pipes at the engine, and conveyed from there by lines of hose pipes, enabled the falls to be sufficiently cooled to warrant a thorough exploration of the east district and Thompson's Dip. This work was completed by organised parties between 1 and 2 o'clock on Thursday morning, but no sign of life was discovered.
The figures on the plan annexed show the position where the bodies of the unfortunate men and boys were found. It will be seen that three were found within 25 yards of the engine where the fire originated. One of these, No. 62, the lampman, had been buried beneath a heavy fall at his post in the lamp station, where he would most likely be at the time of the outbreak ; his not getting out from such a short distance appears to show that the fire spread very rapidly in that direction, and that the smoke at once overpowered him. The three others, Nos. 47, 48, and 63, may or may not have been at the places where their bodies were found. All these four bodies were much burned, the burning doubtless having taken place subsequent to death by suffocation. The body of John Nichols, No. 50, found at his engine, was very slightly burned, but whether this was before or after death it is impossible to say. It is however improbable that he moved far from his engine, if at all, after the smoke reached there, which it would do in a minute from the outbreak. The position where the bodies of Dan. Spooner (No. 49) and Thomas Price (No. 52) were found indicates that these persons were both endeavouring to escape by the intake; that of Frank Grainger, inclineman No. 51, does not afford such indication, for he may have been at or near the place at the time in the discharge of his duties.
It is a remarkable fact that many of those working in that portion of the district lying nearest to the Tymawr shaft were lost, while several who were in the two further portions escaped. Probably smoke would reach each division about the same time, as the distances by the intakes do not differ much. The distance from the working headings to the Tymawr shaft by the return varies considerably ; that from the farthest east portion being 878 yards, that from the east side of Thompson's Dip 560 yards, and from the west side only 442 yards. It was in the latter portion where the body of David Davies, the fireman (No. 60) of the district was found, near that of Mark Osborne, a collier. Osborne had just resumed work after an accident to his leg, and from the statement of those who escaped from this part of the district it appears that Davies, the fireman, was delayed in assisting Osborne out, after having done his best to get the other men gathered together and sent out. How it came that so many of those who were lost in this part had attempted to go out by the intake instead of the return is a mystery, for most if not all of them would be aware of their proximity to the Tymawr upcast.
Of the 134 men and boys in the East Level district at the time of the accident, 71 came out by the Tymawr upcast shaft alive and uninjured. The 134 persons were distributed as follows :—
In the East far end there were 52, of whom 37 were saved and 15 lost;
In the East side of Thompson's Dip there were 23, of whom 14 were saved and nine lost;
In the West side of Thompson's Dip there were 48, of whom 19 were saved and 29 lost;
On the roads inbye of the engine there were 11, of whom one was saved and 10 lost.