Report
On the Causes of, and Circumstances attending, the Explosions
which occurred at Barnsley Main Colliery, Barnsley, Yorkshire,
on the 16th and 17th February, 1942
Major The Rt. Hon. G. Lloyd George, M.P.,
Minister of Fuel and Power.
11th August, 1942.
Sir,
In accordance with directions dated 18th March, 1942, I have held a formal Inquiry under Section 83 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, into the circumstances of the explosions which occurred on 16th and 17th February, 1942, at the Barnsley Main Colliery, Yorkshire, by which 13 persons were killed and 29 injured, and I have the honour now to report thereon as follows:
By arrangement with Mr. Sanderson H. B. Gill, H.M. Deputy (and Acting) Coroner, the Inquiry was held jointly with the adjourned Inquest at the Town Hall, Barnsley, on the 25th March and subsequent dates, terminating on 10th April after sittings occupying six days. I am grateful to Mr. Gill for so cordially agreeing to this arrangement at some inconvenience to himself, and to the representatives of the parties and others who co-operated in the proceedings.
The Owners of the colliery (the Barrow Barnsley Main Collieries Ltd.) were represented by Mr. A. S. Fumiss, Solicitor; the Yorkshire Mine Workers' Association by Messrs. J. A. Hall, W. E. Jones, T. Oakey and (for the local Branch) T. Brown; the National Federation of Colliery Deputies by Mr. W. T. Miller; and the Yorkshire Deputies' Association by Messrs. J. Edwards and J. Howard.
Mr. H. J. Humphrys, H.M. Divisional Inspector and Mr. C. M. Harvey, H.M. Electrical Inspector, represented the Mines Department, and Dr. H. F. Coward, Acting Director, the Safety in Mines Research Board.
A list of the dead with the cause of death in each case is given in the Appendix.
The verdict recorded by the Coroner was as follows :—
Frederick Wood died from toxaemia due to burns sustained from an ignition of gas caused by the fusing of an-electric trailing cable attached to a coal cutter. The other twelve men died from the causes stated in the medical evidence (see Appendix) following an explosion in the Barnsley Main Colliery whilst they were working as members of a rescue party sealing off a district in the mine which had got on fire, the deaths being by misadventure in each case.
In a very clear review of the evidence, the Coroner went on to make some observations and recommendations which may be thus summarised :—
1. In my opinion there has been no serious breach of rules or regulations under the Coal Mines Act by either the Colliery Company or the workmen.
2. I am of opinion that the electric trailing cable was not sufficiently examined when it arrived at the face and before the current was turned on. I understand that the regulations provide that such a cable must be examined once by the cutter-man in each shift, but there has been no evidence that this was done in this case, and it seems to me that it would be well if the regulations were amended to provide for a proper examination by instrument at the commencement of each shift before the power is put on.
3. I recommend that everyone working in a coal mine should receive adequate instruction on the question of gas and making the necessary tests for it and reporting it at once.
4. In regard to criticisms of the scheme of ventilation of B. face made by the workmen's representatives and the installation of doors in place of sheets, I express no opinion beyond saying that so far as I can see there is no evidence that any fire reached the corner at the top of the left hand tail gate or that any explosion of gas took place there.
5. The workmen's representatives have laid great stress on the danger of electrical apparatus in mining operations where gas is present, and seem desirous that a recommendation to exclude the use of it should be made. As this is a highly technical matter and one with which my Inquiry as Coroner is not definitely concerned, I propose to leave it in the hands of the Commissioner.
6. Questions relating to the situation and construction of the stoppings and the number of men employed on the work have also been put by the workmen's representatives, but the colliery officials are of opinion that all the work that was done was satisfactory and was done with the approbation of all concerned, and no evidence to the contrary has been put before me; so I propose not to make any recommendation on these points but to leave them to the Commissioner to deal with.