I. Description Of The Colliery And Method Of Working.
(b) The Occurrence of gas in the Workings. — As has been stated, the total volume of air in the respective splits was quite ample for the adequate ventilation of the mine, and from close questioning of many of the witnesses, firemen and workmen, I have arrived at the conclusion that the longwall faces were swept by brisk currents of pure air, and firedamp had not, so far as I could discover, ever been detected in the body of the air current at any of the faces under normal conditions of working. Gas did, however, occur at certain parts of the mine under conditions which will be specified later on.
Particular reference was made during the course of the Inquiry to some mining and exploratory places which were being driven into the solid coal, far in advance of the longwall faces. These places were in the North and South Plodder. In the North Plodder there are a pair of such places, one (Eccleston's) being 30 yards beyond the last holing, and the other (Brown's) 68 yards; and in the South Plodder there were another pair of such places, one of which was 118 yards in beyond the last holing and its companion place 60 yards. I heard no evidence that these places were being properly ventilated, i.e., that an air-current was carried into the face by means of bratticing or air-pipes. But these facts had no bearing on the occurrence of the explosion.
I interrogated the manager as to the ventilation of Brown's place, but he said he could not say whether it was provided with bratticing or air-pipes at the time of the explosion or not. For some weeks before Brown's place had fallen here-just about this place here (indicating)-and Brown was engaged in taking forward this ripping that you can see here (indicating) . . . . in order to make room to pack the dirt in from the road . . . . and I could not say definitely whether cloths or pipes were used; I should say they were. I cannot imagine that the fireman would drive a place so far without using some artificial means. Eccleston's place was being worked at the time of the explosion, there was one man in it."
Q. "Was that bratticed ? — A. I do not think so."
Then coming to the South Plodder, Mr. Tonge stated that the place driven 118 (he gave the distance as 120) yards in beyond the last holing was not bratticed. He said the air circulated naturally as the place dipped slightly. I put it to Mr. Tonge that the fact that the place dipping was no reason in favour of its being properly ventilated. Nevertheless, remarkable as it may seem, they do not appear to have experienced trouble from gas in the place.
Q. "You say it is slightly down hill ? — A. Yes.
Q. "And you instance that as an argument in favour of its being ventilated? Well, I say I will give you verticality ? — A. Of course, I have been in certain pits when it has been fairly cool at a depth of 100 yards, but I would not--
Q. "You tell me you do not consider it satisfactory ? — A. No, I do not; but as a matter of fact in that place the air came into it and passed out along the roof. The heat of the gas, if there were any, and the heat of the men formed a sort of little natural ventilation.
Q. "Mr. Tonge, you do not wish to make me believe that is satisfactory, do you ? — A. I do not for one moment wish to say I consider that was right, but the men down the pit largely judge by whether a place is naturally cool and whether it is ventilating itself or not, and that is what they were doing there. It was ventilating itself for some reason or other.
Q. "A place cannot ventilate itself, you know. However, I will not press it ? — A. I mean, I have already admitted in the other Inquiry that I think they ought to have put some cut-throughs there. They ought to have had the cut throughs on.
Q. "Or brattice ? — A. Or brattice. Personally I prefer the cut-throughs.
Q. "Now, had you any trouble with gas there ? — A. No.
Q. "Was gas never reported ? — A. I am not sure whether they reported a show diluted as made, as they called it
Q. "Oh! do not use that ? — A. A short time before. I think it is in the Report Book.
Q. "They could not use the expression 'diluted as made' there, could they ? — A. Well, they had no trouble from gas there, Sir.
Q. "You have not heard of any complaints of gas there ? — A. No, not before the Inquiry."
Coming now to the recess commonly known during the Inquiry as the "heading," at the extreme end of the No. 1 Jig in the North Plodder district, this place, which was twelve yards wide and driven seventeen yards in advance of the longwall face, constituted a cul-de-sac, up the west end of which was carried a stone pack to within a few feet of the face, and a portion of the air-current passing along the longwall face passed up and ventilated the place in the manner shown in Fig. 1.
This was just the place in which one would expect to find gas. The air current would be somewhat slack when the canvas sheet was not hanging across the end of the longwall face where the air-current entered the return airway. This sheet was placed there with a view to forcing into the recess or heading more air than would naturally split from the main current; but when the conveyor was carrying coals to the tubs in the return the flap would be held up.
The manager was of the opinion that 25 per cent. of the air passing along the conveyor face would enter and ventilate the heading. This is as it may be. I have no doubt that when the canvas flap was in position sufficient air would pass into the place, but in view of the fact that gas was being given off in the place in detectable quantity, I doubt whether the air current would be ample enough to meet requirements when the flap or sheet was not in position. When I inspected the place the canvas flap was in position. I asked Mr. Tonge if he had any figures to show what quantity did go into the place, and he replied
"Yes, I have. It is based upon the quantity of air that is passing now, or that was passing about a fortnight ago, during the course of the first Inquiry. The proportion that was going up the back of the pack then was one-quarter of the total proportion of air of the total quantity of air that was going along the conveyor face. There was three-quarters there was 75 per cent. going straight through and there was 25 per cent. going up into the heading.
Q. "The proportion would be as one to four ? — A. As one to three.
Q. "I beg your pardon, as one to three ? — A. As one to three, yes, so that assuming that we had 8,000 feet of air along the face, there would be 2,000 feet going up into the heading and 6,000 feet going straight through."
When I made an inspection of the place two days before the Inquiry I was able to obtain ¼-inch cap on the flame of the safety lamp when the lamp was held up near the roof and against the coal face at the west corner, but there was no indication of gas in the main body of the air of the place, although the ventilation was not completely restored.
The manager gave it as his opinion that more gas was made in the heading after the explosion than before:
"I think there has been more gas made in that heading, Sir, since the explosion than was made before, for this reason-and you no doubt saw it yourself-that the coal roof with two feet of coal that has been spoken of has been broken up right from a point just north of the jig wheels to the top. The coal has been driven into practically all the way along, and that is the coal that makes the gas, and we are draining now; we are draining the whole of. that area, I think, and if anything I believe that the gas that is found in that heading to-day-the quantity that is found there to-day-is greater than the quantity that is ordinarily made, because of the breaking up of the roof."
Any gas made in the recess would not pass on to the face but into the return airway and be swept away, as will be seen from Fig. 1.
In the Top Yard district occurrences of gas in quantity at the face were by no means uncommon, and were due chiefly to the proximity of a large fault (faults in gassy mines are likely places for gas "feeders "). As the working places approached this fault gas began to show in them, consequently the east side places were those affected. In fact, so much gas was given off now and again at such places that the men working in them had to be sent home, and I do not doubt that the rumours respecting the dangerous character of the mine are in a large measure to be accounted for by this fact. I think the management would have been well advised, knowing the spot at which the gas would occur, if they had arranged in advance to keep a brisker current of air on these places, and so not have rendered it necessary to stop them and send the men home. Or, if this was not possible, to have kept working places in reserve, so that the men could have finished their shift in them. I can hardly credit the statements of William Bullough, the night fireman, in respect of the amount of gas given off in places approaching the fault, viz., that the amount given off was so great that even in the event of a very great increase in the air-current the places would still have continued to be gas laden.
Q. "Seeing these two places were the places that were approaching the fault, and the places at which you would expect to get gas, could you not have put more air on to those two places ? — A. We could have taken it all there if we had thought it best, but we didn't think it best.
Q. "I do not want you to take it all. Could you not have made those two places free of gas by putting more air on to them-could you have done that ? — A. It would not have stopped them from giving off gas.
Q. "It would not have stopped them giving off gas, but it might have diluted the gas as made. Could you not have diluted that gas to such an extent as to be harmless ? — A. No, not for a time we couldn't-not straight away we couldn't; if we had had all the air there it would have still been giving off.
Q. "Now try and be serious, these are not funny questions at all. The gas would still be coining off, but could you have rendered that gas-by increasing the current-could you have rendered that gas harmless ? — A. No, I do not think we could have taken it away sufficiently to allow the men to work in.
Q. "You mean to say the volume of gas was so great that even if you throw the whole current on, the whole of the pit's current, you could not have rendered it innocuous ? — A. No, it would not be fit to work in.
Q. "Then the only conclusion I can arrive at in that case is that the gas must have been coming off in enormous quantities ? — A. Yes.
Q. "Did it ever come off as a blower ? — A. No, you could not hear a blower or anything.
Q. "Do you seriously mean to say that, although there was not a blower, the gas came off in such quantities that no volume of air could be put on to render it harmless ? — A. Yes, I do not suppose anything could have taken it away"
If the gas did not come off as a blower nor yet as a sudden outburst, and the evidence of witnesses showed that it did not, and if as soon as the other places came into line with those at the extreme east of the district the gas disappeared (Mr. Tonge's evidence), I am of the opinion that a comparatively small increase of the split from the Top Yard intake, which ventilated these places, would have kept them clean. I am quite prepared, however, to find that no contravention of the Coal Mines Regulation Act was committed in respect of the manner of ventilating this part of the face, and I do not doubt that some may differ from me in the opinion that the best mining practice was not followed. The fact of the occurrence of gas in this part of this mine had, happily for the management, no bearing on the explosion.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.