71. I recommend that:
| | (i) |
all winding engines be examined and modified as necessary to ensure that the mechanical brakes should always be capable of bringing them safely to rest;
|
| | (ii) |
where possible the operation of winding systems should not rely on 'single line' components. If this cannot be achieved the systems should be modified to ensure that 'single line' components are designed, operated and maintained to prevent danger;
|
| | (iii) |
all winding engine brake components essential for safety be nondestructively tested as necessary and the tests should be repeated at appropriate intervals;
|
| | (iv) |
a design analysis be made of all winding engine brake components essential for safety to ensure that the working stresses can be sustained and to establish definitive life. This analysis should take account of the fluctuations of stresses irrespective of the conventional static factors of safety. The use of screwed components should be avoided wherever possible;
|
| | (v) |
the control systems of electric winding engines be reviewed with the object of making electrical braking available after the initiation of an emergency or automatic trip at least until the application of the mechanical brake has been proved;
|
| | (vi) |
all solid landings in shafts be replaced by suitable arresting devices below the lowest winding level as soon as possible;
|
| | (vii) |
an operating manual be prepared for each winding engine and the training and examination of winding enginemen be reviewed;
|
| | (viii) |
every winding engine which can attain a speed in excess of seven feet per second be provided with a rope speed indicator; and
|
| | (ix) |
The Coal and Other Mines (Shafts, Outlets and Roads) Regulations 1960 be revised to include additional statutory requirements for the safe winding of persons through shafts and unwalkable outlets.
|