70. I conclude that:
| | (i) |
the disaster was caused by the complete failure of the mechanical brake of the winding engine because the spring nest centre rod which was a single line' component, broke. The design of the trunnion did not take account of the high pressures due to the spring nest, and the main lever could not rotate freely about the trunnion axle which had no practicable means of lubrication. Consequently, operation of the brake produced bending forces and induced fluctuating stresses in the rod which it could not sustain. Cracks developed in the rod and one of them extended until failure occurred;
|
| | (ii) |
the cracks which were present in the rod could have been detected before it broke by the magnetic particle method of non-destructive testing;
|
| | (iii) |
there can be no criticism of R. W. Kennan, the winding engineman who, as a last resort, attempted to stop the engine by pressing the emergency stop button provided for this purpose;
|
| | (iv) |
it was always necessary to apply the mechanical brake to stop the engine but, had regenerative braking been available after the emergency stop button was pressed, there is little doubt that the speed of the cages at the end of the wind could have been significantly reduced;
|
| | (v) |
the fatal or serious injuries received by the men in the descending cage were caused by it crashing on to the wooden baulks at the bottom of the shaft. The accident would not have been so serious if, instead of landing baulks, an arresting device had been installed below the lowest winding level.
|