Research into outbursts
66. Despite a considerable amount of research work in many countries the way in which the gas is contained in the coal, both in free and adsorbed form, and the mechanism of its sudden release accompanied by large quantities of powdered coal are still not fully understood. Experience in this country has shown that outbursts do not usually occur at depths of less than about 300 yards (270 metres); it is thus presumed that mechanical stress plays a part. The stress conditions within a coal seam result from the geological structures and the strata movement associated with the mining process. The factors are difficult to quantify, but it is desirable for the workings to be so arranged that concentrations of stress are minimised.
67. Since the formation of the Joint Advisory Committee on Outbursts of Coal and Gas in 1945 there has been a steadily increasing amount of research into many aspects of the problem. In 1951 the National Coal Board appointed a full time investigator to co-ordinate and extend the work previously done on a part-time basis. This appointment has been maintained and in 1961 an Outburst Research Centre was set up at Tumble which has recently been transferred to premises on the surface adjacent to Cynheidre No. 3 and No. 4 Shafts. The work is directed by well-qualified persons.
68. The centre has a well-equipped laboratory where the routine work is carried out on the samples of coal obtained from advance boring to determine the 'desorption ratio' and thus obtain a measure of its susceptibility to outburst. The laboratory also undertakes more fundamental research into the causes of outbursts and possible methods of early detection of impending outbursts by the measurement of seam stress vibrations, using sophisticated scientific instruments for recording and analysing sound and vibrations. A programme of work has also been commenced on rates of firedamp emission during working.
69. In 1968, the Department of Mineral Exploitation at University College, Cardiff was commissioned by the National Coal Board to study the structures of normal anthracite and coal which is considered to be of a type giving a risk of outburst. This investigation includes the use of modern techniques of microscopy for the examination of samples and is still in progress.
70. Close liaison has been maintained over many years between the staff of the Outburst Research Centre and similar organisations in other countries with coalfields subject to outbursts of a comparable nature. Considerable experience has been gained in Belgium, Canada, France, Japan, Poland, USSR and other countries where the phenomenon is broadly similar, except that in some instances the gas emitted is carbon dioxide or a mixture of that gas and firedamp. Many technical papers have been published recording the experiments and research programmes carried out and the various procedures adopted to reduce the occurrence of outbursts and to minimise their consequences. These include inducer (volley) firing, working a 'reliever' seam first to reduce the stresses, drilling boreholes of various diameters into and ahead of coal faces and in some cases injecting water at high pressure into these holes. The behaviour of gas in coal seams has also been investigated in an endeavour to determine the basic causes of outbursts and the sudden release of gas. Some of these investigations have included the use of seismic equipment and apparatus to determine the mechanical strength of the coal. This information has been available from international sources and has been taken into consideration in the study of the phenomenon and the development of preventive and precautionary measures in this country.
71. Clearly, this research work should be continued energetically because the application of existing knowledge has not given complete control over outbursts or protection against them.
Recommendations
72. I recommend that in respect of mines working seams liable to outbursts of coal and firedamp:
| | (i) |
where narrow headings in coal are driven every endeavour should be made to arrange the general layout and coursing of the ventilation so that, in the event of an outburst in the heading, the gas would pass directly to the main return;
|
| | (ii) |
advance boring, sampling and determination of the desorption ratio of the coal should be adopted in all coal headings;
|
| | (iii) |
having regard to the fact that, in this case, all six persons died from shortage of oxygen, careful consideration should be given to the provision of breathing aids to sustain the life of persons caught in the gas from an outburst. This might include the use of compressed air lines with frequent breathing points similar to those which are used on faces in the Silkstone Seam at certain mines in Yorkshire (Ref. page 29 of Report for 1970 HM Divisional Inspector of Mines and Quarries for the North-Eastern and Western Division by Mr R T Purvis). Consideration should also be given to the development of specially designed breathing apparatus to be carried by the individual;
|
| | (iv) |
loudspeaker communications should be installed throughout the workings of each main ventilation section. Any such communications system should have an independent power supply so that it will remain in operation if the colliery mains electricity supply has to be switched off. When satisfactory automatic firedamp alarms are developed they should be coupled to the system.
|
73. I am pleased to record that the Joint Advisory Committee on Outbursts of Coal and Firedamp has been enlarged to include additional members with special scientific and engineering expertise and further recommend that the Committee carry out a thorough review of inducer firing techniques for use both in headings and on longwall faces and that the Code of Precautions be revised as necessary.
Acknowledgements
74. I wish to thank all those persons who have helped in the collection, preparation and presentation of the material for this report. I am grateful to Mr G S Lewis, Area Chief Surveyor, and his staff for the preparation of the plans and Mr J Thomas for the excellent photographs.
I have the honour to be, Sir,
Your obedient Servant,
J S Marshall
HM Divisional Inspector of
Mines and Quarries