Conclusions And Remarks.
As a result of my investigations, I have come to the following conclusions :—
(1) The explosion was one of firedamp, the part played by coal dust being relatively small.
(2) The presence of firedamp was due to the normal bleeding from the strata combined with an emission from the extension of 328's level beyond the engine.
(3) The firedamp accumulated through the ventilating current on the coal face being too weak to remove it.
(4) The weakness of the ventilating current was due partly to leakage through stoppings and sheets, some of which was allowed in order to ventilate the pillar workings, and partly to some derangement of the sheets or doors, of which it was not possible to get evidence.
(5) The means of ignition was an electric spark caused through the ringing of the signal bell at the engine in 328's level, but there is no evidence to show what caused the bell to ring.
(6) The bell was not of a type certified by the Mines Department, but was believed by the Colliery officials to have been wound with a protective winding, and to have been incapable of igniting firedamp.
In conclusion I desire to mention the work of the eight rescue teams who assisted in the recovery operations after the explosion.
A team was at the Hednesford Rescue Station preparing for a practice when the call for assistance was received, and the Superintendent of the Station, Mr. J. Payton, at once took this team to the Colliery, arriving there only a few minutes after the call had come through.
All the teams carried out their duties quickly and well, and their reports as to the conditions of the workings were clear and accurate; their work was very creditable both to themselves and to the officials of the Rescue Station responsible for their training.
Excellent arrangements were made at the Colliery for the treatment of the injured, and special reference is necessary to the use that was made of Oxygen. Dr. S. W. Fisher, who was present, has referred to this matter in the following terms
As usual, I went carefully into the treatment, by the First Aid personnel of the mine, of the men involved in the explosion, and I found that every man was taken to the surface ambulance room and effectively given oxygen from three or four Novita Apparatus by the man in charge of the room, and also by Mr. Payton, the Superintendent of Hednesford Rescue Station, who in fact supervised the whole organization. All the men I spoke to in the accident home (except the three very serious cases) told me in no uncertain manner that the oxygen did them good.
The slight cases were made to rest before proceeding home.
I do not wish to exaggerate, but in my opinion the prompt and effective administration of oxygen (in some cases against the will of the patient) probably averted very serious consequences, if not actual collapse and death, and credit is due to Mr. Payton and those working with him for their grasp of the situation and efficient manner of dealing with it."
Belowground I found that oxygen was being administered freely to anyone who showed signs of being affected by carbon monoxide gas, with equally good results.
A number of the slighter cases of carbon monoxide poisoning were probably due to the men coming out of the workings by way of the main return airway. This road was the usual travelling road, and the men used it automatically in spite of the fact that the afterdamp had to travel up it.
The Overman, William Challoner, and the men I have referred to earlier in this Report as assisting him, deserve credit for their actions immediately after the explosion. Challoner, in particular, acted very well under trying circumstances. In the saving of the two ponies under very difficult conditions, Reynolds and Parton showed courage of a high order.
I have the honour to be, Sir,
Your obedient Servant,
Walter E. T. Hartley.