Account Of Events On Friday, 22nd January, And Thereafter.
On Friday morning, 22nd January, about half-past twelve o’clock, a joint of the compressed air main laid in Cooper’s failed, with the result that the conveyor in George Rees’ conveyor face could not be worked until it had been repaired, and the coal got after that hour had in consequence to be turned back from the face by hand. The coal so turned back, enough to fill nearly six trains, remained stacked in George Rees’ conveyor face until Sunday, 24th January, when two men, Edward Henry Charles Bulgin and Edward Davies, went in at 6 p.m. to fill it away, one filling it on to the conveyor and the other into the trains on its being dumped at the delivery end. According to the evidence of these two men, the afternoon shift fireman (Richard Cheney) who was killed in the explosion, told them not to go beyond the loose coal which had been turned back on the Friday, and that he would send in some brattice, which one of them (Edward Bulgin) agreed to put up.
This fireman (Cheney) made an inspection between 9.30 and 10.30 on this Sunday night preparatory to the night shift men coming to work at 11, and his report of that inspection showed that he had found firedamp in George Rees’ conveyor face but at what particular part there was no evidence to show.
From the instruction given by Cheney to Edward Bulgin and Davies not to go beyond the loose coal and his request to them to put up brattice which he would send in, it would appear that the firedamp he had found was in the face of this place and was still present at the time he allowed them to go to work. The evidence of the night shift fireman, Gordon Hughes, who descended the pit at 10.45 p.m. on Sunday, 24th January, was that he was told by Cheney that he (Cheney) had found gas in George Rees’ place at the beginning of the shift and that everything was all right now — that is just before 11 p.m. The statement "that everything was all right now" attributed to Cheney by Hughes is inconsistent with the report made by Cheney following his inspection between 9.30 p.m. and 10.30 p.m. This report, in reference to the finding of noxious or inflammable gases, was as follows: "Blower on St. (straight) of Brown and gate, Geo. Rees Con. Face, and Bulgin Old Road (Diluted)."
Hughes said that during the night shift of Sunday, 24th January, he visited George Rees’ conveyor face twice, once just after 1 a.m. on the 25th January and the second time at 6.15 a.m. after the two men Edward Bulgin and Davies had gone up the pit, and that on neither occasion did he find gas.
There were discrepancies in the evidence given by Hughes and that previously given by the two men Edward Bulgin and Davies, both as to the time he visited them and as to the direction from which he came. I was not impressed with Hughes as a witness; there were many discrepancies in the evidence which he gave.
The fireman of the day shift, Reginald Shipp Camm, descended the pit at 6.45 a.m. on Monday, 25th January, and conferred with the outgoing fireman Hughes, who, he said, told him that everything "was pretty fair, only there was a blockage in George Rees’ airway." Camm had this blockage removed by a collier, Charles Bulgin, who stated in evidence that it amounted to "just a few stones which I shoved on one side." Camm said that during this shift everything was normal; that he had never at any time found gas in George Rees’ conveyor face; that he had found gas in the rippings of George Rees’ road on 7th, 8th, and 10th January and his reports showed that he had also found it on 11th January; that he had erected a "fly" sheet to turn the air coming along Squints airway into the rippings and, by this means, had diluted this gas; and that this "fly" sheet remained in position thereafter "as a precautionary measure."
On the completion of his shift shortly before 3 p.m. Camm saw the on-coming fireman, Richard Cheney, of the afternoon shift but had nothing whatever to report to him.
On this afternoon shift of 25th January, two men, Thomas Cryer and Herbert Evans, were to work in George Rees’ conveyor face — Cryer presumably at the actual face getting coal and filling it on to the conveyor and Evans at the delivery end filling the coal dumped on to the ground by the conveyor into the trains standing on George Rees’ road.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.