Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

VI. Recommendations

Ventilation

The first and foremost safeguard against the ignition of gas in a mine is efficient ventilation. It is plain as a result of this explosion that in the large tunnels now being driven the standards of ventilation hitherto accepted as satisfactory must be raised if adequate ventilation over the whole area and length of the tunnel is to be obtained constantly. If it is assumed that the tunnel does not suffer much from squeeze outbye the face, the fact that ventilation at the rate of 25 cubic feet per minute per square foot of cross sectional area is provided at the tunnel face means that the average velocity of the air in the tunnel outbye is little more than 25 feet per minute. It is not difficult to envisage cases where such a velocity is insufficient to remove a layer of gas near the roof, should the circumstances (for instance the exposure of a coal seam in the side or roof) be such as to pre-dispose towards the presence of gas. In many tunnels the ventilation tubes are 30 inches or even 3 feet in diameter and I recommend that in circumstances such as prevailed at Golborne nothing less than 3 feet diameter tubes (which have an area more than twice that of 24 inches tubes) should be provided, and that the aim should be the provision of such a quantity of air as will ensure that the air has adequate velocity over the whole of the cross sectional area of the tunnel.

As regards the actual methods of ventilation in most general use, there is, firstly, the method adopted here, i.e., the provision of a range of steel tubes exhausting from near the tunnel face into the return, together with the installation of a forcing fan on the intake side of the inbye end of the return tubes with separate ducting leading to the tunnel face. Inasmuch as the main range of tubes is subjected to the pull of the surface fan, this method may be described as that of exhaust ventilation. Secondly, there is the use of a forcing fan on the intake side of the entrance to the tunnel with a range of tubes which provides fresh air to within 5 yards of the tunnel face; this method may be described as that of forcing ventilation. The first method has the advantage of removing dust and fumes produced by shot firing (and also any gas which may be made at the face) out of the tunnel quickly, whereas with forcing ventilation such products are pushed out along the tunnel itself at the rate of the slowly moving air, exposing to their ill effects for some time any men working in the tunnel. I feel that this may not be so important a matter nowadays since with improvements in wet drilling machines the problem of dust production during drilling is almost solved; as regards the fumes produced by shot firing, I feel that if an intensive effort were made to improve the design of mist sprays or water curtains the problem of the elimination of such fumes need not arise.

There has also to be considered the position which arises when an increase in the water gauge is required, through the extension of the tunnel. With forcing ventilation the water gauge can be increased by the provision of another fan in series with the first. With exhaust ventilation, such a fan would be situated in return air. The drive, of course, could be compressed air, or in certain circumstances an external electric drive; other risks, such as sparking at the blades and, with compressed air drive, electrostatic sparking, could arise, however, unless maintenance was of a high standard. This, of course, should be a sine qua non but unfortunately the human element intrudes into the working of mines rather considerably.

A difficulty with a forcing fan is the objection of the tunnellers to a strong current of air blowing on to them; if this is a real difficulty it should not be impossible to devise a suitable diffuser. Temperature issues may also arise. With exhaust ventilation there would appear to be a tendency for the cold air entering the tunnel to flow near the floor and allow the air near the roof to become stagnant, whereas with forcing ventilation, the higher temperature of the return air passing along the tunnel might have a tendency to cause the air to rise nearer the roof and prevent layering of firedamp.

On balance, therefore, unless other important factors intrude, I would prefer the use of forcing ventilation. No matter what method of ventilation is produced, however, if feeders of gas occur or accumulations develop, some means of producing local turbulence, such as the provision of small branch pipes from the main ventilation tubes, or the setting of inclined sheets on frames in the upper part of the roadway may have to be considered.

When arrangements for adequate ventilation have been provided, there remains the problem of checking its efficiency. There need be no trouble at or near the face since either equipment or tunnel dirt or a ladder is available, so that an official can test against the roof. For the testing of the general ventilation outbye, difficulties arise when roads are of the order of 10 and 12 feet high. These outbye stretches of road are almost invariably within the orbit of a deputy's district so the first line of defence must be regular testing by these officials. Thought should be given to the devising of an efficient and convenient method of testing with a flame safety lamp at such high points.

An analysis of the problem of the occurrence of gas in tunnels outbye of the face suggests, however, that such appearances are not likely to be in the nature of sudden outburst (unless open old workings have been crossed) and I think that a most useful check on the position would be the taking of periodic air samples at suitable intervals in both time and space.

I strongly condemn the practice of removing the innermost length of canvas ducting from the range of tan tubes, thus leaving the delivery end of the tubes 20 yards from the face of a tunnel, particularly when this is done some 20 minutes before a round of shots is to be fired at the tunnel face; during this time gas may accumulate in the unventilated end.

Finally, I recommend that in the interests of accuracy there should be greater adoption of more up-to-date ways of measuring the amount of air flowing in tubes. The quantity of air passing into ventilation tubes installed in tunnels usually results in high velocities occurring in the tubes. The standard type of anemometer is not suitable for measuring such high velocities, apart from the difficulty of obtaining an average value for the air speed. One method of measurement is by means of the Pitot tube which, inserted into the air duct where the air flow is constant, can be used to obtain an accurate air velocity. Other instruments, such as the velometer, can be used for the same purpose.

Shot firing apparatus and practice

(a) Exploder. The Beethoven exploder was designed, I understand, as an apparatus for use on the surface and it is known that it does not meet the requirements of the Ministry's Testing Officers for exploders intended to be used where firedamp may occur. Risks arising from use of the exploder have been touched on already. One risk difficult to overcome is that dangerous sparking may occur within the exploder itself. A greater risk, however, is that the exploder condenser does not necessarily discharge completely on firing. Out of this there arises the possibility that post-firing contact in the shot firing circuit may cause sparking which could ignite gas already present or, in certain circumstances, gas liberated by rock movement caused by the firing of the round. There is also the possibility that a capacity charge of electricity developed in the shot firing cable may be increased by the still partially charged condenser, leading again to dangerous sparking. These risks could be eliminated if a device for automatically limiting the duration of the flow of current to a figure of the order of four milliseconds were incorporated in the exploder and care was taken to see that no instantaneous detonators were used in the shot firing circuit. Time-limited exploders are already available and the issue of bringing the Beethoven in line with these or of removing it from the pit altogether should be clearly faced.

It is desirable, whatever type of exploder is used, that an examination of its firing characteristics should be made at regular intervals by qualified electricians. This could be done at the same time as the statutory weekly test of firing efficiency which is made in accordance with Regulation 21(b) of the Coal Mines (Explosives) Regulations, 1956.

(b) Cables. Although there was some doubt as to the part played by the cable (in conjunction of course with the exploder) in the explosion, the tests carried out at Sheffield indicated clearly that damage of a certain type to the cable could lead to the formation of sparks capable of igniting gas. In order to avoid such a situation it is necessary in the first place to use cables of a suitable type and secondly to see that they are very carefully maintained. There may be scope for argument about the best type of cable to be used but there is no doubt it is essential to ensure that any joints are mechanically sound and electrically efficient and, most important of all, that they are suitably insulated, bearing in mind that high voltage may be applied to the circuit.

The prevention of damage to shot firing cables is a matter which requires greater consideration. Damage occurs through two main causes: in the length nearest to the tunnel face it is generally caused by material projected from the shots and it is not unusual for a length of 15—20 yards of the inbye end of the cable to have to be replaced after every round or at most every two or three rounds. This may involve the making of another joint, with its attendant risk of open sparking. Damage is also caused, chiefly to the main length of the cable outbye, by such mechanical means as the movement of tubs, the placing of material adjacent to the cable and so on; cables should be suspended, so as to be efficiently protected from such damage. Where this is difficult, I think that consideration should be given to the idea of normally keeping the cable wound up on a suitable reel and pulling it off only when it is intended to fire a round.

It is worth while considering, too, whether, should the cable be wound on a reel after shot firing, it is necessary or desirable to use two single-core cables, or whether, with the higher standard of maintenance proposed, a twin-core cable with highly insulated conductors provided with a strong protective sheath would not be more satisfactory.

I recommend that these matters should be carefully considered with a view to the institution of trials embodying the suggestions.

The experimental work carried out at Sheffield showed that the use of armouring increases the capacity effect on a shot firing cable and hence is a potential cause of increased danger. There is the further disadvantage that the detection of conductor faults is rendered difficult and I accordingly recommend that the use of armoured cables for shot firing, particularly with high voltage exploders, should not be approved.

Whatever the kind of cable finally adopted and in whatever way it is used, a higher standard of maintenance is most important; as a check on the condition of the cables I recommend that they be taken to the surface for examination and if necessary repair, by qualified electricians, weekly.

VII. Acknowledgments

I would like to express my sincere thanks to the representatives of all organisations who assisted in the investigation of this explosion; in particular, thanks are due to Mr. E. R. Hassall, Surveyor of No. 1 Group of No. 3 (St. Helens) Area, and his staff for preliminary work in the preparation of the plans. Special thanks are due also to the Technical Information Section of the Safety in Mines Research Establishment who arranged the final presentation of the illustrations.

I have the honour to be, my Lord,

Your Lordship's obedient servant,

G. Hoyle.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z