Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

IV. Investigations After The Explosion

The manager, Mr. Horton, was discussing his Transport Rules with Mr. L. L. Edwards, H.M. District Inspector of Mines and Quarries, in the office on the surface when the alarm was given. They immediately went below ground and reached the pit bottom when James Hill, the medical room attendant, was treating three burnt men. Mr. Horton and Mr. Edwards, together with W. Pickering, the deputy, made their way carefully into the tunnel. The atmosphere in the pit bottom was clear; there was a slight haze in the tunnel inbye of the air crossing, with a visibility of about 15 yards; these conditions were found to persist right up to the tunnel face. At a point 43 yards outbye of the firing station a piece of sacking and the wooden sleeper on which it was lying were found to be smouldering and were extinguished (see Plate II). Just inbye of the firing station a man's smouldering coat was extinguished. The notices at the firing station were seen to be badly scorched whilst excess shot firing cable which hung in loops from the arches outbye the firing station was affected by heat, some of the bitumen coating having melted and run (see Plate III). The cable was found to be similarly affected up to a point about 14 yards outbye the forcing fan. The fan itself was still running but the ducting had become disconnected about 10 yards from the fan. The manager climbed up and re-connected the tubes. The ducting terminated about 20 yards from the last arch at the tunnel face, where there was a pile of debris from the firing of the shots.

An extinctive mixture of firedamp and air was found at the face of the tunnel and for some distance outbye, near the roof.

Soon afterwards a rescue team arrived and made an inspection, and at 1 p.m., i.e., about an hour and three-quarters after the explosion, the compressed air forcing fan was stopped on account of the presence of gas. Immediately afterwards under the supervision of J. Dawber of the Boothstown Rescue Station, a series of samples was taken by rescue men, at 20 yard intervals, from the atmosphere at the crown of the steel arch supports. The results are given below:—

Distance from face of tunnel in yards1030507090110130150170190210230250270
Percentage Methane2.11.982.127.5011.012.015.133.05.51.984.142.100.80.2

The return tubes ended 47 yards from the face of the tunnel and the firing station was 223 yards away.

Although no measurements of the thickness of the layer of gas were made, the percentages suggest that there was a thin layer near the roof at the face of the tunnel, that the layer began to increase about 70 yards outbye, reached a peak 150 yards outbye and then diminished fairly rapidly.

About eight hours after the fan had been stopped, an inspection by Messrs. Benson and Dobson, H.M. Senior District Inspectors of Mines and Quarries, showed that an extinctive atmosphere of firedamp and air extended from the tunnel face outbye to the firing station; the thickness of the layer was 30 inches at the face, decreasing gradually to 6 inches at the firing station. This pattern of the presence of gas was confirmed by Mr. L. Beck, H.M. Inspector of Mines and Quarries, who inspected on the next shift.

After the fan had been standing about 24 hours, the greatest concentration of gas was again found in the length of tunnel between the open end of the return tubes and the face, where the extinctive layer was at least 4 feet thick. Outbye of the open end of the tubes the extinctive layer tapered evenly, as far as could be estimated, from a thickness of 2 feet at the end of the tubes to 1 foot at the firing station. There was no peak at 150 yards from the tunnel face as was suggested by the samples taken by the rescue men soon after the explosion.

The same afternoon, i.e., on Sunday, 8th December, a measurement of the air passing into the inbye end of the steel return tubes was made by Mr. Dobson, H.M. Senior District Inspector of Mines and Quarries, and Mr. Albert Allan, colliery ventilation officer; a figure of 2,512 cubic feet per minute was obtained. At the discharge end of the tubes in the return the quantity was 8,200; it was observed that a number of a certain type of joints in the tubes near the air crossing (where the suction would be considerable) were leaking badly and that air was drawing inwards.

A steel flap, or regulator, in the 3 feet return tubes near the air crossing was found to be in its correct position of fully open.

A detailed examination of the shot firing apparatus and its cables was made by Mr. E. J. Platts, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines and Quarries. The exploder was found on the floor with the charging handle inserted. A length of old insulated detonator lead about 6 inches long was attached to one of the terminals and a 15 inch length of similar wire was found attached to the prepared end of the core of one of the two shot firing cables. It was apparent that the two short lengths of old detonator lead had been used to facilitate connection between the exploder and the ends of the two armoured shot firing cables.

Close observation of these short pieces of detonator leads showed that it appeared unlikely that they could have made electrical contact with the armouring of the firing cables when the shot was fired.

Just outbye the firing station excess shot firing cable was coiled up and hung at the side of the roadway, but nearer the face the two shot firing cables were laid out on opposite sides of the roadway. The cable on the right hand side facing inbye was found to have two taped up joints in its length and there was another place where the conductor was joined together but was not taped up and was thus left exposed; the armour wires at this joint were roughly twisted together, were separated from the conductor and were well clear of both the roadway sides and its supports. This cable was suspended from the sides of the roadway at heights up to 7 feet from the floor near the firing station but lay on the floor for the last 20 yards or so near the face. When tested the cable showed good insulation resistance between conductor and armour wires. The cable on the left hand side of the roadway was suspended about 9 feet from the floor near the firing station, where it appeared to be in good condition, but much of it lay on the floor further inbye. There were six taped up joints in the run of the cable; the armour wires were not continuous electrically at two of these joints, whilst at two other places joints in the conductor had been made but had not been taped. When the cable was tested with a 500 volt insulation tester after the breaks in the armouring had been bridged, a resistance between conductor and armouring of 80,000 to 90,000 ohms was indicated; after several such tests had been made over a period of some minutes the insulation resistance broke down to zero.

At the tunnel face the ends of the cables had been prepared by turning back the armour wires and binding them to the outside of the cable with old detonator wire, leaving some 1½ inches of insulated conductor exposed. When the round of shots had exploded the ends of both cables had been thrown back into the roadway.

Careful examination of the tunnel (supplemented by a study of certain samples taken by members of the Flame Section of the Safety in Mines Research Establishment later) showed that the length of roadway visibly seen to have been traversed by flame was of the order of 263 yards, starting from a point 44 yards outbye of the tunnel face, the most pronounced effects being near the firing station, 223 yards from the face. Microscopical examination of certain specimens showed that there had been weak flame right up to the last arch nearest to the face. In addition to the effects already mentioned there were few plain indications of the effect of flame, the chief of these being the charring of certain random pieces of wood, the burning of scattered pieces of paper and a slight singeing of some of the canvas ducting (see Plate II). The signs of burning were thus far from extensive and there was no evidence at all of blast in the tunnel. At the time of the explosion, three doors leading into a locomotive garage direct from the return had been blown open by pressure presumably transmitted through the return tubes.

There were no indications that coal dust had taken part in the explosion, as indeed was to be expected since practically all the work carried out in the tunnel had been connected with material other than coal and no coal dust was present.

Considerable trouble was experienced later in moving the gas which was present some distance back from the tunnel face; it was found necessary to install three forcing fans near the entrance to the tunnel, delivering at different points along the length of the tunnel. An interesting observation was that some of the air from the two furthest outbye deliveries returned back along the body of the tunnel to the air crossing, a natural result of the inability of the return tubes to carry the amount of air then being supplied.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z