Remarks And Conclusion.
There are one or two facts which appear to upset the opinion that firedamp was rapidly evolved from the mushy coal in the "slip-fault". According to the evidence of Mr. N. C. Ebray, Surveyor, who made a Section from actual measurements of the position at the "slip-fault" where Samuel Wright had set an eight feet bar, the stamp or needle hole made for the face end of that bar had in fact passed through the clay, which was immediately in front of the mushy ground, and even through the mushy ground, yet firedamp, according to the evidence of the deputy, Yorke, who made tests, was not present. This seems contrary to the expectation of Mr. Graham who said that if Wright had pierced the clay, the firedamp would have come off at once.
Again, according to the evidence of Mr. Smith, there was in the No. 2 West face, of which inspection was made on 3rd November (when the barometer was as low as it was on 3rd September, the day of the explosion) a length, some 35 to 40 yards long, of mushy coal similar to that found in the slip-fault in No. 6's face, and yet tests made next to that mushy coal showed less firedamp to be present in the air than at other points on the face where such mushy coal was not present.
Mr. Smith also said that although similar slips were encountered from time to time, he had never seen any firedamp come from them.
Further, if the firedamp had been rapidly evolved from the mushy coal in the "slip-fault" in 6's face, as adumbrated by Mr. Graham, its first effect would have been to extinguish the flame lamp being used by Samuel Wright who, at the moment of the explosion, was kneeling sawing a tree, his lamp being alight and hung on a prop about 4½ ft. from the face and 18 inches to 2 feet above the floor, opposite the "slip-fault". According to Wright's evidence, the first he knew of the explosion was a terrific bang, and not that the light of his lamp was extinguished.
I am in agreement with Mr. McCallum and Mr. Rowley that firedamp would be given off due to the heavy weighting over the whole length of 6's face and with Mr. Rowley that it would also be given off at the "slip-fault" and, on account of the low barometer, issue freely from the wastes. But there is no evidence that the ventilation was not capable of diluting such firedamp as did issue due to these causes; on the contrary when the deputy, Yorke, made tests within an hour of the occurrence of the explosion, he did not detect the presence of firedamp. Moreover after the explosion had occurred, access to 6's face was not impeded by firedamp; there was firedamp in the wastes but not on the face.
At first, I considered the fall over the coal cutter was the most significant happening in that, if firedamp filled the cavity left by that fall, it might find its way into the top end and, in time, form an explosive mixture which would be ignited at the plug of the conveyor motor.
By the courtesy of Messrs. T. Wragg and Sons, experiments were carried out in their mine at Loxley by Mr. H. J. Humphrys, Senior Inspector, Yorkshire Division, and Dr. H. F. Coward and Mr. F. J. Hartwell of the Safety in Mines Research Board and Mr. G. A. Cutler of the Mines Department Testing Station, to ascertain if firedamp when issuing next the roof would form an explosive mixture in a fast end such as the top end of 6's face. The result of the experiments showed that, with an issue of firedamp at the rate of 4 to 8 cubic feet per minute, it was not possible under similar conditions of height, width, and ventilation as existed in 6's face at the time of the explosion, to obtain an explosive mixture more than 18 inches from the roof in the fast end. It would appear that to fill a fast end such as the top end of 6's face, one of two things is necessary; either a feeder of fired amp in that fast end, of which there was no evidence in this case, or a sudden emission of a fairly large volume of firedamp as a body and not as a stream.
It would appear therefore that the firedamp in the explosion had come into the face due to some sudden cause and was not due to a continuous feeder, and that that sudden cause was most probably, as suggested by Dr. Coward, a fall in the waste.
It is true that Mr. Graham said that, in his experience, there is comparatively little firedamp in the wastes in the Newdigate and neighbouring collieries: that experience, however, is not consonant with the evidence given at the Inquiry in respect of the waste next 6's face and in which Mr. Graham said he did not make a test.
As to the means of ignition, on the evidence of Captain Platt alone, it could not have been the damaged electric lamp No. 348. That evidence, the gist of which has already been given, was based on his own observations as well as on those of other investigators, in particular the investigations by Mr. W. C. F. Shepherd and Professor Wheeler as set out in the Safety in Mines Research Board Paper No. 36, entitled "The Ignition of Gases by Hot Wires".
Captain Platt's evidence as to the thinning of the ends of a filament broken by burning in air or a mixture of firedamp and air, was supported to a great extent by Mr. Graham who explained that he had carried out a number of tests to ascertain, if possible, the behaviour of a lighted electric bulb when broken in an explosive atmosphere, and he had found that by breaking such a bulb of the type used at the time of the accident, it was perfectly possible to explode a mixture of firedamp and air, provided the firedamp was "somewhere in the neighbourhood of 9 per cent. After ignition; the filament was broken and in most of his tests there was a tendency for the broken ends to be thinned at the end, just as happens when a filament is burned in air, but on two occasions he found that the ends appeared to him to be due to rather a sharp break.
There are other circumstances which make it difficult to agree to this damaged electric lamp being the means of ignition, namely
If, as suggested, this lamp was hanging near J. W. Morris as he was working at the knob of coal and was broken by him by a stroke of his pick or other tool, it is curious that he was not severely burnt by flame. According to the evidence of Dr. A. F. Wright, Morris, although he had a hairy chest and the skin was burnt by nascent steam or other hot product of the explosion, had not been exposed to flame for the hair in the area burnt was not singed.
Further, if this lamp was hanging opposite the knob of coal at the time of the explosion and firedamp became ignited by it after it was damaged, the three men, Wright, Byard and Marston, would it is certain have seen some lighting up of the face, if indeed they would not also have been enveloped in flame. Wright certainly was burned but Byard and Marston were not and none of the three saw any lighting up of any sort.
There is also the statement Hayward was heard by Cowell to make to Marsden: "Pity help those poor devils working in the top end" which seems to suggest that the explosion came from some point beyond the coal cutter where they were working.
The only other means of ignition suggested was arcing in the plug connector of the conveyor motor. This was the suggestion of Mr., Rowley, and on examination of this connector by Mr. Horsley on the day following the explosion it was plain to him that arcing had been taking place between the top pin and its socket. The effect of this arcing was also seen at a later date by Mr. Mackay, the maker's representative, who said no claim was made that the connector was flameproof.
Having considered the whole of the evidence, I have come to the conclusion that firedamp was suddenly ejected from the waste by a heavy fall and that an explosive mixture was formed in the top end of 6's face and there ignited by arcing in the plug connector of the conveyor motor.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.