Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

V. GENERAL REMARKS AND CONCLUSIONS

The Explosion. — The evidence in regard to the origin of this explosion is so clear as to make superfluous the discussion of any other possible causes. It was due to the firing of a shot in contravention of the provisions of Clause 6(d) of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order of 1st September, 1913, as amended March 30th, 1915; November 14th, 1919; August 31st, 1922; September 1st, 1924; and November 10th, 1926, which reads as follows :—

(d) Every shot shall be charged and stemmed by or under the supervision of a shotfirer. Before the hole is charged a shotfirer shall examine it for breaks running along or across, and if any such break is found, the hole shall not be charged, except in stone drifts if special permission has been given in writing by the manager or under-manager.

Whether or not James Cunliffe, the fireman who fired the shot, made an examination for breaks in the shot hole I do not know, but that he had knowledge of the presence of a break in it cannot, in my opinion, be disputed. Unfortunately, and to my own personal regret, Cunliffe was killed and has had, therefore, no chance to defend himself. In order, however, to avoid the possibility of doing an injustice to a deceased person, I quote below portions of the evidence of the manager, Harold Whitehead, and of the fireman, Spurgeon Green, relating to a oonversation between the former and Albert Page, upon which this opinion is founded.

Albert Page was the contractor who bored or supervised the boring of shot holes in the canch and who in this instance, as the evidence will show, had actually bored the shot-hole in question. It is a matter for regret that Page's death has rendered unavailable first-hand evidence on this crucial point. There is, however, no reason to think that he would not have confirmed the very circumstantial account of the conversation as given by these two witnesses.

Under examination by Mr. Charlton in reference to events following the explosion, Spurgeon Green said

3963. Q. Mr. Charlton: We will go back to where you had gone to the face with Mr. Whitehead, and you saw him test for gas? — A. Yes.

3964. Q. What happened then ? — A. Mr. Whitehead, after he had examined for gas, looked underneath the canch, and I assume he saw some wires hanging down.

3965. Q. You had seen them before ? — A. Yes. Mr. Whitehead said to me, "Now then, this is not fair, Spurge," and then all at once a voice replied. "It was a straight in shot he fired, Mr. Whitehead."

3966. Q. How could you connect that remark from this unknown voice with what Mr. Whitehead said? Mr. Whitehead said, "This is not fair, Spurge," and this voice said, "It was a straight in shot he fired, Mr. Whitehead?" — A. Yes. On looking round we saw this Albert Page laid up against the face.

3967. Q. Under the canch ? — A. Yes, near to the face.

3968. Q. It was Albert Page who made this remark ? — A. We found out it was Albert Page when we saw the man.

3969. Q. Could you conceive what Albert Page meant when he said, "It was a straight in shot, Mr. Whitehead?" — A. When we heard this voice we looked round and we saw where it came from, and we found out the voice had come from the man of the name Albert Page, so Mr. Whitehead said to him, "Now then Page, what are you doing here?" He said, "I couldn't get out." Parr had gone for some more assistance to get him out. So Page said "I drilled through a break, Mr. Whitehead." Mr. Whitehead asked him had he informed the fireman. He replied "Yes." Then Mr. Whitehead asked him if it had been stonedusted and the man replied "No."

3970. Q. Mr. Whitehead having arrived there, had seen something which made him say to you "This is not fair, Spurge?" A. Yes.

3971. Q. Did you know what Mr. Whitehead meant when he said that? — A. I had an idea.

3972. Q. What was your idea as to what he meant when he said that ? — A. That Mr. Whitehead had informed both shot-firers and firemen that they must not ram more than one shot at a time.

3973. Q. And what was there to be seen? How many shots were there already there? — A. We found four.

3974. Q. Four with wires hanging down ? — A. Yes.

3975. Q. Did you come to the conclusion a shot had been fired? — A. Well, we had been already told a shot had been fired.

3976. Q. Who told you that ? — A. Page.

3977. Q. He said, "I drilled into a break?" — A. Yes.

3978. Q. So that you knew five shots had been charged before one was fired? — A. Evidently they must have been.

3979. Q. You say you knowing, and everybody knowing, Mr. Whitehead had told you and everyone concerned that shots should never be charged before one is fired, he said to you, "This is not fair, Spurge" and you thought what he meant was that he had been let down? — A. Yes, that they had disregarded the rule.

3980. Q. So that he proceeded further to ask about the thing that was in his mind. Knowing a shot had been fired there, he was full of anxiety to know whether everything had been done that might have been done, and he asked the men, "Did they stonedust?" — A. Yes.

3981. Q. And he said "No"? — A. Yes.

3982. Q. I am still rather puzzled as to why Page should have said, when he heard Mr. Whitehead's remark, which presumably he did, "It was a straight in shot, Mr. Whitehead?" — A. Yes.

3983. Q. What did you conceive that he meant by that ? — A. After we heard the voice and looked round and examined and found how it was, then we came to the conclusion that it must have been a horizontal shot he must have fired, according to Albert Page's evidence, according to what he said.

3984. Q. What you think now is this, that Page had some reason why he wanted to assure Mr. Whitehead that it was a straight in shot ? — A. Oh, Yes.

Under examination by Mr. McGurk, Harold Whitehead, the manager, said —

5910. Q. Mr. McGurk: . . . . Now you say you saw Page before he was taken out of the pit ? — A. Yes.

5911. Q. Can you tell us what conversation you had with him? — A. I met Page about 70 yards from the face. That is the first time I saw Page.

5912. Q. The Commissioner: Which Page is that? There were two ? — A. A. Page he means, Albert Page. I met Albert Page, as I say, about 70 yards from the face.

5913. Q. Mr. McGurk: That is on the slant? — A. Yes. Spurgeon Green and Parr were busy with artificial respiration with a man, and I saw a man sitting down beside them. I said "Who is that?" Either he said or one of the others said "It is Page," and I said "How are you? or something like that, I cannot exactly remember now. He said "I am not so grand, but I can walk out." You are asking me now to repeat all I said at the Inquest?

5914. Q. Yes, I am asking that. — A. Yes, that is right. That is all I said to Page then.

5915. Q. What did you say to him afterwards ? — A. After what?

5916. Q. You said "That is all I said to Page then?" — A. Yes, it is. It is all I did say to Page.

5917. Q. Did you speak to him afterwards ? — A. Yes, I did.

5918. Q. Will you tell us what you said to him then ? — A. Certainly. The next time I came in contact with Page was when he spoke to me in reply to a remark I made to Spurgeon on the face of the slant. He heard me say to Spurgeon Green "This is not fair, Spurgeon," and Page replied — I did not know Page was there at the time — "The hole that was bored (I am not quite sure whether he said the hole that was fired) was a straight in one." I said "Oh," and he said, "Yes." He said "Yes, I bored into a break with it." I said "Did you tell the fireman?" He said "Yes." I said "Was it stonedusted?" He said "No." That is all the remark I had with Page.

Shot firing practice. — It having been so clearly demonstrated that shot-firing was at the root of the matter, it was only natural that a good deal of evidence was led to ascertain whether the shotfiring practice at the colliery was in accordance with statutory requirements. Three firemen were closely examined in this respect but they stoutly maintained that as far as they knew no irregularities occurred. I should have been glad for Cunliffe's sake if I could have come to the same conclusion in regard to him and to have been able to suggest that this was an isolated instance of neglect of statutory requirements on his part. I regret however, that in view of the evidence I am unable to do so. It was definitely established that both the agent and manager had gone to considerable lengths to warn the fireman and shot-firers about their duties generally, but specially and particularly on two points connected with shot-firing, viz. —

(a) against charging more than one shot at a time, and

(b) against firing shots in holes bored vertically, (vertically being used apparently in the sense of vertically upwards in the roof). And yet, in the coal roof under the canch there were four vertical holes positioned roughly at the corners of a four foot square, and every one of these holes was charged and ready for firing. In addition, two further vertical holes were found uncharged, one in the roof a few feet outbye of the canch and another in the coal a few inches from the edge of the canch.

An attempt was made by the representatives of the Firemens' Association to gloss over the charging of five holes at once by suggesting that Clause 6 (g) (ii) of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order, as amended 1st September, 1924, leaves it to the shotfirer to decide whether or not the firing of one shot would be liable to relieve any part of the work to be done by another, and that Cunliffe had exercised the discretion allowed him. This might have told in Cunliffe's favour were it not for the very definite instruction that had been given to all the firemen and shot-firers on this point.

Cunliffe's competence as a fireman and shotfirer was not questioned and those who were in a position to speak on the subject gave him an excellent character, and I cannot believe that he charged and fired the hole without any regard for the possible consequences. In fairness to him it is, I think, reasonable to suggest that his sense of danger was lulled by the freedom of the air in the vicinity of the canch from detectable firedamp.

As regards firing shots in vertical holes it was clear from the evidence that the injunction or prohibition referred to above was not a general prohibition. It arose out of special circumstances and was intended apparently to apply only to those special circumstances. These bear no relation to the cause of this explosion and I do not propose therefore to deal with them.

Shot-firing in canches. — In general, there can be little doubt that greater risk attends the firing of shots in canches in long-wall workings than in any other situations, since breaks are more likely to be formed in the roof strata there. For this reason the fewer the number of shots fired in such canches the better.

It must be admitted that ripping in certain classes of rock can hardly be undertaken economically without the use of explosives. There are many rippings, however, in which, although explosives are extensively used, it is a moot question whether any advantage is derived therefrom. After personal observation, I suggest that the strata forming the roof of the Wigan Four Feet seam comes within the latter category and that the firing of shots in such strata could be reduced almost, if not quite, to vanishing point. It was stated in evidence at the Inquiry that for some time prior to the explosion shot-firing had been discontinued at the canch in the Conveyor Level and it is a matter for regret that it was not discontinued in the Main Slant at the same time. I am glad to record, however, that shot-firing in the canches was not resorted to after the explosion.

Firemen's Work. — A sustained effort was made, especially by the representatives of the Firemen's Associations, to establish a case that the district allotted to the fireman on the afternoon shift was too large for him properly to carry out his statutory duties, and that owing to anxiety to get through his work he was harried and possibly did things in a hurry that he would not have done with plenty of time on his hands.

It is true that in addition to the inspections required by Section 65 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, to be made in No. 1 District he had also to visit a gang of rippers in No. 2 District, The length of roadways to be travelled in order to carry out these inspections was gone into in great detail, but in my opinion no case of overburdening the fireman was made out.

Support of roof in roadways. — I have already mentioned that steel arch girders were used extensively for supporting the roof in the roadways. I believe that owing to the use of this form of support the effects of the explosion were minimised, and I venture to suggest that if props and bars only had been used falls would have occurred and created difficulties of escape and rescue which might have added seriously to the toll of dead and injured. It is safe to say that ingress to and egress from the affected area was practically as easy immediately after the explosion as it was immediately before it; and that is saying a great deal.

Supervision. — In an early section of this report I mentioned that during the afternoon and night shifts supervision was normally exercised only by the fireman or firemen who happened to be on duty. No official superior to a fireman visited the workings during these shifts.

Mechanisation and the modern intensive methods of mining, in my opinion, call for a review of the arrangements for supervision. In many instances the day shift is no longer the shift in which the great majority of the workers are engaged, nor is it the shift in which the most important and dangerous operations are carried on. It is just as important for supervision by an official superior to the fireman to be exercised on the back shifts, when the operations of cutting and breaking out are performed, as it is on the day shift, when the only work is the simple operation of filling but the coal which has been got ready on the previous shifts.

I feel confident that if visits to the workings by superior officials during the afternoon and night shifts had been the custom in this mine, better discipline would have been maintained and the probability of detection would have kept the fireman from disobeying the very definite orders that he had received.

In conclusion, I desire to place on record my appreciation of the very able assistance afforded me in elucidating the circumstances of this disaster by the different parties mentioned at the opening of this report. They were animated by one motive only, and that was to make the Inquiry as thorough as it was possible to make it.

My thanks are also due to Professor R. V. Wheeler for the trouble he took in investigating the large number of dust samples submitted to him. His report and evidence were most valuable in showing that, thanks to the preventive measures adopted, the explosion did not develop into a coal dust explosion.

It may not perhaps be out of place here to mention the firemen and workmen witnesses who gave evidence at this Inquiry. Speaking from a fairly wide experience I can say that, generally, the manner in which they approached the questions put to them and gave their answers was most impressive. They exhibited a degree of intelligence considerably above the average and seemed not only to know exactly what they wanted to say, but also how to say it.

I have the honour to be,

Sir,

Your obedient Servant,

F. H. Wynne.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z