IV. THE CAUSE OF THE EXPLOSION
There has been no doubt or difference of opinion at any time either as to the point at which this explosion originated or as to its cause. It was caused by the firing of a charge of Polar Viking Powder (a permitted Explosive) in a shot, hole in the canch of the so-called Main Slant which was, in fact, the return airway from the conveyor face. This is proved by the evidence of James Clarke, a coal cutting machine attendant, who was present with the deputy, James Cunliffe, when the shot was fired. Clarke said in evidence —
"2635. Q. Where did you stay when he (i.e., Cunliffe) fired the shot ? — A. We sat beside him.
"2636. Q. Will you tell us now what happened? — A. He fired the shot. We saw him turn the handle.
"2637. Q. And that was followed by what? — A. An explosion by fire."
By "we" Clarke meant himself and two other coal cutter men, namely, T. Clarke and J. Brown.
Clarke's evidence, I think, is quite conclusive in itself, but it is corroborated by what was found after the explosion: the positions of the shot firing cable and battery, the rammer and the handle of the battery and the body of the dead fireman; and the signs of force and coking.
Details of all these are given in Plan 2 and the case being so clear, I need hardly discuss them in detail.
It is so rarely that men who have seen an extensive pit explosion survive to tell the tale and the evidence of Clarke and of another man named Ernest Pilling, a fitter, is so graphic and interesting that I have thought it well worth while to include a rather lengthy quotation from it as an appendix to this Report. (See Appendix III.)
An important point established by the evidence of these two men is that there was a small initial explosion immediately the shot was fired, followed after an interval of a few seconds, by a bigger explosion. I think the first explosion caused a large volume of firedamp to be sucked into the slant from crevices in the strata and from cavities in the goaf and that this firedamp was ignited by the flame of firedamp left burning after the first explosion.
Examination of the canch after the explosion revealed that the shot hole, bored horizontally, had penetrated a break which crossed the roadway diagonally and extended over the dip side pack towards the waste or goaf below, In the shale roof outbye of the canch several more breaks existed which were easily to be seen. There was a further break crossing the roadway practically at right angles in the top coal inbye of the canch. These breaks are shown in plan and section on Plan No. 2.
It is more than probable that these breaks were interoonnected with each other and also with further breaks and cavities in the roof over the goaf on the dip side and over the pack on the rise side of the slant. And that firedamp was present in these breaks and cavities goes without saying. After the explosion a number of samples of gas were drawn from some of these breaks at depths varying between 12 inches and 4 feet 6 inches by means of a copper tube with an aspirator attached. Whilst the firedamp content in some instances was small and almost negligible in others it was present in proportions exceeding the lower explosive limit of a mixture of firedamp and air.
It is, of course, because firedamp is so likely to be lurking in breaks that the charging of a shot hole in which a break has been detected is strictly prohibited.
I am of opinion that coal dust played little or no part in the explosion. I base this conclusion on (1) the small extent to which coked dust could be observed afterwards, and also by the absence, in any part of the workings traversed by the explosion, of any indications of that sooty deposit which appears to be one of the characteristics of an explosion of coal dust; (2) the result of a minute investigation, carried out ‘by Professor R. V. Wheeler at the Safety in Mines Research Laboratories at Sheffield, of a large number of samples of dust which were collected more or less systematically in the face and roadways after the explosion. (Professor Wheeler's report is given in full in Appendix IV of this report and Plan No. 3 is a diagram showing the localities from which the samples were taken); and (3) the absence of carbon monoxide in the afterdamp. As far as is known neither those killed nor the injured showed any of the symptoms usually associated with the inhalation of this gas.
But for the presence of inert dust in ample quantity in the roadways there is little doubt, I think, that the explosion would have extended throughout the workings of the mine, instead of being confined, as in fact it was, to a comparatively small portion thereof..