Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Scientific Experiments

85. At the Inquiry D. G. Wilde, a Principal Scientific Officer in the Safety in Mines Research Establishment of the Ministry of Power, described a series of experiments which had been carried out at the Establishment's Buxton Station to obtain information about the behaviour of polyurethane foam when subjected to igniting agents of different intensity.

The Locus of the Experiments

86. The experiments were carried out in an arched roadway, 240 yards long, seven feet high and seven feet wide, ventilated by a fan which was so adjusted that the airspeed in the roadway was 200 feet per minute, In the first three experiments, the roof and sides of the roadway were lined with a two inch layer of polyurethane foam for a distance of 23 yards; the area so covered was 134 square yards. The thickness of two inches was chosen because at that time the information was that this had been the thickness of the foam lining in the Loader Mine although subsequent evidence indicated that the lining was only one inch thick. In the fourth experiment the foam was applied to the inside surfaces of a steel duct 75 feet long, four feet high and four feet wide. The fifth experiment was a variation of the first three in that the foam in the roadway was coated with a fire-retardant material.

The Experiments

The first experiment

87. The purpose of this experiment was to test the inflammability and combustibility of the foam lining when it was ignited at the upwind end and to compare the result with that observed in an earlier series of experiments in which timber lining was used. The igniting agent was a stack of timber and a roadway lining of untreated timber which together weighed about 860 pounds. This timber was sited in the roadway just upwind of the foam; the igniting agent occupied a five yard length of the roadway and had a peak output of four megawatts, and an average of two megawatts over one hour.

88. Within two minutes of ignition flame developed over the whole area of the roadway and large volumes of dense black smoke, having temperatures in excess of 1,000 degrees centigrade, were produced. The initial rate of flame spread across the foam was observed as being between 120 and 150 feet per minute; burning of the foam lasted for 90 seconds at any given point. This rate of propagation compared with a rate of one foot per minute observed in other experiments in which the roadway was lined only with untreated timber. Although instrumentation was made difficult by heavy deposits of solids, it was found that the oxygen content of the atmosphere fell to seven per cent, the carbon dioxide concentration rose to 13 per cent, and the carbon monoxide concentration exceeded one per cent. The rate of evolution and colour of the fumes emitted were of a kind never experienced in timber fires. Examination of the roadway showed that virtually all the foam had been burned away and that the fire had increased in intensity as it moved away from the igniter.

The second experiment

89. This experiment was designed to test the inflammability and combustibility of the foam lining when ignited at the centre of the lined area, to obtain information on the risk of the burning foam igniting fire-retardant treated timber downwind, and to observe to what extent flame would propagate against the ventilation. The igniter on this occasion was capable of developing 2.4 megawatts and of lasting six minutes. The timber downwind was composed of 150 treated boards weighing about 850 pounds forming a roadway lining.

90. Within 90 seconds of ignition, flame spread with the ventilation at 78 feet per minute and against it at 90 feet per minute. Smoke travelled with the ventilation at about 230 feet per minute and backed up against it at 160 feet per minute. The general character of the smoke was similar to that observed in the first experiment. Examination of the roadway after the fire showed that all the foam downwind of the midpoint had been consumed, but upwind patches of partly burned foam remained. The treated timber downwind had been charred to a depth of about ten per cent of its thickness. Other work at the Establishment suggested that untreated timber, subjected to the heat developed by the polyurethane foam, would have burned fiercely producing very hot fumes containing almost no oxygen and high concentrations of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide.

The third experiment

91. The purpose of this experiment was to determine the order of the power required to ignite a foam lining. The capacity of the igniting agent was stepped up in stages from a small paraffin wick developing 40 watts to an oil burning igniter of 2,000 watts (in all of which cases there was no sign of general ignition) and, finally, to an igniter which burned three-quarter ounce of mineral hydraulic oil per minute providing an output of 20 kilowatts. In all cases, the igniters were so placed that the flames from them made contact with the foam lining. The 20 kilowatt igniter was placed at floor level eight yards from the downwind end of the foam lining. Immediately after the igniter was fired, flames spread up the roadway wall to a height of about five feet and 70 seconds after ignition a cloud of vapour was suddenly generated on the crown of the roadway. This cloud ignited and a violent fire ensued. Within nine minutes the fire was over and the smoke had cleared away. While alight, the fire seemed to fluctuate and this suggests that in some conditions the foam will burn in such a way as to consume most of the available oxygen; the flame is therefore temporarily quenched until fresh supplies of oxygen are available when the conflagration is resumed.

The fourth experiment

92. This experiment with foam applied to the inner surface of a steel duct, was set up to determine whether a fire could be propagated in the foam lining by a mass of glowing and flaming solid fuel falling into the duct. The igniter in this case consisted of a 2: 1 coke/coal mixture contained in a steel box sited centrally over the top of the duct. The mixture and the siting of the igniter and the lining of the duct with foam was intended to simulate the situation which might occur when hot burning coal from a gob fire is discharged into a foam lined roadway. The fire was given its own air supply and when it was judged to be sufficiently developed the burning coke/coal mixture was discharged into the duct by way of an opening in the top.

93. Examination of the duct after the fire had gone out showed that all the foam had been consumed and, although the experiment was on a smaller scale than the others and the airspeed higher, the fire in the duct had features very much in common with those in the earlier experiments.

The fifth experiment

94. This experiment was designed to test the effect of applying an igniter to foam which had been coated. The igniter was of the type used in the first experiment and was sited at the centre of the lined area. Downwind of the foam. five yards of the roadway was lined with timber treated with a fire-retardant When the fire was ignited, it burned more fiercely than had been expected, developing a power of seven megawatts and the roadway lining was subjected to a fire of great intensity, greater indeed than had been used against the uncoated foam in earlier experiments. There was no indication of flame other than from the igniter and the experiment was stopped after an hour. The oxygen concentration never fell below 14 per cent and was usually above 18 per cent.

95. Visual inspection of the roadway afterwards disclosed that none of the lining had been burned or affected with the exception of a small area which had been scorched. The fire-retardant coating had separated from the foam in places. the separation in some instances being in the form of bulges. Cracks had appeared in some of the bulges and the mechanical strength of the coating appeared to have been reduced by the fire. The lining timber downwind was not even charred, although the surface had become rather brittle and some resinous substance had exuded.

An Appreciation of the Experiments

96. Wilde advanced the view that the experiments demonstrated the hazards of uncoated foam in conditions which were designed to resemble, but not exactly reproduce, those which obtained in the Loader Mine. He saw no reason to suppose that a fire in the Loader Mine would not have had the same general characteristics as the fire experimentally produced at Buxton. He would have expected all the polyurethane lining the Loader Mine, with the exception of patches, to have been burnt in the same way as was found to be the case in the fourth experiment. He accepted that the lining in the Loader Mine was thinner than that used in the experiments but he thought that the difference in the behaviour of the fire would have been significant only in regard to its duration.

97. It was his opinion that foam uncoated with a fire-retardant material was highly inflammable material with a low fire resistance; provided flames from the source of ignition made contact with foam, the heat output of the source itself need not be large to start a fire. If a fire behind a lining of foam heated the foam to a temperature of between 150 and 200 degrees centigrade, the fire would break through. Before the break-through, however, the foam lining masked the heat behind and prevented the issue of the gaseous products of combustion, and the smell therefrom. Once the foam was burning neither the speed of the air in the vicinity nor the thickness of the lining would have much influence on the rate of spread of flame.

98. There seemed little doubt, given the intensity of the fires generated experimentally, that a P.V.C. belt within the range of the fire would have been consumed by it. Both foam and P.V.C. belting produce thick black smoke, the particulate content of which is fundamentally carbon, and fumes which contain carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide. In addition, the polyurethane would produce other and more complex gases, and the P.V.C. would produce gases containing chlorine. Wilde was, however, unable to explain why black smoke persisted for so long in the fire at the colliery; he could not say whether temperatures of the order of 1,000 degrees centigrade would have penetrated cracks between fireboards and concrete lining slabs and ignited coal and wood behind them.

99. Pressed to give some indication on likely concentrations of gases from the fire which would have been produced at various times and places, such as the Sea Mine, Wilde explained that, although he had considered the matter, he had been unable to reach a reliable conclusion.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z