V. — Point Of Origin And Cause Of The Explosion.
The point of origin of the explosion was undoubtedly near the cavity containing firedamp on the B conveyor face, and the surrounding atmosphere containing an explosive mixture of firedamp and air. The capacity of the cavity was approximately six hundred cubic feet, but as the area through which the flame passed amounted in capacity to some twenty thousand cubic feet, it is evident that, as the volume of flame produced is three to six times that of the mixture exploded, there must have been a considerable volume of explosive atmosphere in the neighbourhood of, in addition to that actually contained in, the cavity. The movement of the air tended towards the workings of Mapstone's and so carried the explosive mixture over and past the electric coal-cutting machine into those workings.
The Manager, Mr. Lewison, advanced three theories to account for the explosion, and gave evidence upon them, as follows :—
Theory 1. — Ignition by means of sparks produced by striking a pick on a rail which was being erected for the purpose of a haulage post for the coal cutter.
Q. . . . Now Mr. Lewison, we have got the presence of gas; we have got your theory as to how the gas got to be there. We have to carry it further and we want your assistance as to what view you formed as to how the gas became ignited ? — A. Well, there are three theories. At least I have thought of three theories. I may say they are possible theories. One is the mandril (pick) striking the rail which was held against the roof.
Q. Is that rail which you have dealt with the one spoken of as being found between the bodies of Howells and Edmunds? — A. Yes.
Q. And is that rail in Court? — A. Yes.
Q. As to the head of the rail my friends will want to see it, are there marks on the head of the rail indicating it received a glancing blow from a mandril or some other sharp instrument ? — A. Yes.
Q. Assuming that to be so, would you expect sparks from a contact of that kind, steel upon steel? — A. Yes, but I am not prepared to say what temperature it was.
Q. You will not give an opinion yourself, but that of the expert chemist? — A. If there was not sufficient temperature then this theory falls to the ground.
Theory 2.
Q. That is a matter for the expert chemist. That is one possibility. What is your alternative theory? — A. The machine itself.
Q. You are speaking of the cutter machine as reported by the Electrical Engineer, Mr. Horsley? — A. Yes.
Q. You have said in your inspection there were three bolts missing? — A. I was informed.
Q. And you understand that Mr. Horsley has expressed a view that there is a possibility of that being the cause of the ignition. You are not prepared to put your opinion against Mr. Horsley as that being the possible cause? — A. No.
Q. In addition, have you a third alternative theory which may possibly be the cause? — A. Yes.
Theory 3.
Q. What is it? — A. That the machine was running; when I say that I mean the cutting picks were revolving.
Q. Is that your view that the picks turning would be wearing against the Warwicks and causing a spark by that means? — A. Yes.
Whilst it is agreed that the explosive mixture was ignited in the neighbourhood of the cavity on B conveyor, two reasons for its presence have been suggested. One, and in the light of all the circumstances, the most probable reason, is that a blower of gas was present within the cavity, being given off from the Horn Coal, a small seam some seven or eight feet above the Black Vein, which had been exposed at the apex of the cavity. The other, and more unlikely reason, especially when it is remembered that gas was constantly being given off by the blower after the explosion, was that a fall had occurred within the open spaces of the waste and forced out a body of gas which became lodged in the cavity some time after Morgan, the night fireman, had examined and left the place at about 6.40 a.m. on the 10th July. The possibility of such a thing having occurred was put to Mr. D. L. Davies in cross-examination by Mr. Prosser, but he could not accept it. I agree with Mr. Davies that on this occasion the possibility was remote. Nevertheless, the point is worthy of consideration as pointing to the desirability of ensuring the closing, by tight packs, of all wastes in the Black Vein so as to avoid the possibility of accumulations of gas forming and being suddenly thrust into the working faces in the manner suggested by Mr. Prosser.
Dealing with Mr. Lewison's first theory in which he suggests that a spark of sufficient intensity to ignite an explosive mixture was produced by the men Howells and Edmunds, during the erection of a haulage post at the face in Mapstone's Level, by the striking of the point of a pick (found near these two deceased men) against the steel rail which they proposed to use as a haulage post for the coal-cutting machine, I believe this to be an unlikely possibility. In the first place, no difficulty need be experienced in the erection of such a prop in a seam of this sort the roof of which is moderately soft, thus requiring no great physical exertion to force the props into a safe position, and so eliminating the necessity for such violent blows being struck as to produce sparks of the nature suggested.
Experiments have proved it to be difficult to ignite firedamp or methane by means of frictional sparks. On page 3 of Paper No. 9 of the Safety in Mines Research Board the following statement will be found
"The ignition of a mixture of firedamp and air does not necessarily follow when a source of heat the temperature of which is higher than the ignition temperature of the mixture is introduced into it. An essential condition for ignition is that the source of heat, besides being of sufficient temperature, shall remain in contact with the mixture to which it is imparting heat during a sufficient length of time."
"The reason far this is that there is a 'lag' on the ignition of firedamp (methane). There is, indeed, a lag on the ignition of all inflammable gases, but it is more marked with methane than with some other gases; hydrogen, for example."
Again from page 16 of Paper No. 8 of the same Board I take the following quotation which was used in evidence
"More recently the ignition of firedamp by frictional sparks has been obtained during experimental work. A steel locomotive wheel was caused to rotate about a stationary axis and a steel rail was held against the rim of the wheel with considerable pressure. With a pressure equal to the weight of one ton, a speed of wheel of 1,120 revolutions per minute, and with frequent sanding of the contacts to produce brilliant sparking, an 8 per cent. firedamp air mixture was not ignited during a trial lasting 20 minutes although the rail became red hot at the point of contact. With half the pressure, however, but with a shield (metal, firebrick, wood or paper) to concentrate the sparks, ignition was obtained."
Again, on page 25 of this Paper the following paragraph is found
"When we turn to consider the incendivity of the various means by which ignition may be effected, we find it impossible to make exact comparisons. It may be said, however, that any ordinary sustained flame (such as that of a lamp) will certainly ignite all inflammable firedamp-air mixtures, for the temperature of a flame is sufficiently high, and its volume is sufficiently great, to fulfil amply the conditions necessary for ignition. Heated surfaces are relatively less dangerous than lamp-flames unless their temperature is unusually high; and since the extent of surface is the important factor in determining the time during which gas in their neighbourhood may remain boated, a body possessing large surface is more dangerous than a wire of the same temperature, and a wire is in turn more dangerous than a frictional spark of equal temperature."
On page 7 of Paper No. 46 of the same Board, Messrs. Burgess and Wheeler say
"It is comparatively easy, under laboratory conditions, to ignite firedamp by the friction between certain kinds of sandstone rocks. It is easier to ignite firedamp in this way than when a steel tool is pressed against a sandstone wheel, the reason being that the ignition of the firedamp is not by the sparks produced but by the glowing surface at the point of contact between the rock and the wheel. The brilliant showers of sparks that can be produced from steel and carborundum do not ignite firedamp because of the long 'lag' on ignition of methane. The small transitory sparks are not in contact with a given portion of the methane-air mixture for a sufficiently long time to cause it to ignite. When, however, a bright heated area is formed at the point of contact of the wheel and the rock, this heated area, which often appears to be brighter than the sparks streaming from it, can beat the gas mixture around it to its ignition-temperature. It is more difficult, and perhaps impossible, to produce a heated area that can ignite firedamp by pressing a steel tool against a sandstone wheel than by pressing a rock, because the steel conducts the heat away more rapidly."
With regard to Mr. Lewison's third theory, I think that, owing to the fact that the coal-cutting machine was running light at the time, the haulage arrangement being out of gear so that the picks were revolving loosely within the cut, this theory might be dismissed as a probable cause, especially when it is remembered that Mr. D. L. Davies in his evidence states that he collected some of the nodules of ironstone — referred to as "Warwicks" — from the neighbourhood of the machine and could find no signs of abrasion or friction thereon.
With regard to the second theory, the theory which I accept as being in every way the most feasible, it depends largely for its justification upon the evidence of Mr. Horsley, who is quite definite in his statement that the condition of the coal-cutting machine at the time of the explosion was such that it could emit flame or heated gases from its interior into the outer atmosphere.
The state of the machine is indicated in the following conclusion formed by Mr. Horsley after his examination of the coal-cutting machine
(1) that firedamp could enter the enclosure along almost the whole length of the flanged joint between the upper and lower halves of the machine frame, and could also enter readily by the widely open joint between the semi-circular cover and the frame of the machine.
(2) that if firedamp accumulated in explosive proportions within the enclosure, it would be immediately ignited by sparking at the switch contacts.
(3) that if such gas was so ignited the flame or heated gases would pass out through the gap between the flanges at. a temperature sufficient to ignite firedamp present in explosive proportions in the surrounding atmosphere.
Mr. Horsley's views are supported by Mr. Morris Hughes, H.M. Junior Inspector, and Mr. D. L. Davies, who, in evidence, stated
Mr. Morris Hughes.
Q. You said, I think, that the cause was the electrical coal cutter. Will you please tell us what occurred when the ignition occurred ? — A. The coal cutter was working probably before it reached the top of Mapstone's coming into contact with a mixture of gas, the gas found access to the internal parts of the machine and formed an explosive mixture in the machine, this becoming ignited. From the casing it passed through the gap in the flanges. The flanges had not been bolted tightly and closed to prevent it from passing.
Mr. D. L. Davies.
Q. You were present when the coal cutter was examined at the surface by Mr. Horsley ? — A. Yes, I was.
Q. What conclusion did you come to? — A. I thought it (the state of the coal-cutting machine) was sufficient to ignite firedamp and that it ignited the explosive mixture outside the cutter.
Q. And that in your view caused the explosion ? — A. Yes.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.