|
General RemarksFiredamp Determination and Layering 71. This explosion focuses attention on two closely related subjects, firstly, the emission of firedamp, from a source other than the seam being worked into a face return roadway, as a factor to be taken properly into account in assessing the ventilation situation and, secondly, the propensity for firedamp to form roof layers, particularly where the ventilation velocity is low. The firedamp determination in the general body of the air taken at the statutory sampling point ten yards outbye the P. 26 face was less than 0.4 per cent when coaling was in progress and was 01 per cent when it was not. By reference to this data alone, it is reasonable to presume that the management concluded that there was no real firedamp problem. But in the event, such a conclusion must have been wholly false for, whilst the "make" inbye of the statutory sampling point was low, about 20 cubic feet per minute of firedamp were being emitted into the return, well outbye the statutory sampling point. As I have recounted, S.M.R.E. scientists and inspectors demonstrated that this firedamp, because of defective ventilation, formed a layer of dangerous proportions which backed uphill against the sluggish air current, and eventually led to a disastrous situation. 72. Whenever firedamp emission into a roadway occurs well outbye from the face there is always the possibility of a dangerous situation developing if there is any marked reduction in air speed. The emission into the P. 26 Return Gate could have been recognised, and evaluated, by a simple determination of the firedamp content in the general body of the air at the outbye end of the return. It seems to me, therefore, that there is much to be said for making it a statutory requirement that firedamp determinations be made at the end of face return roadways as nearly as possible at the same time as the present statutory determination, and this I recommend should be done. With the knowledge of an increase in the firedamp content, it is a relatively easy matter to seek out the point or points of emission and to take such precautions as may be necessary. Pending the making of the statutory provisions, I should like the National Coal Board to arrange administratively for such determinations to be made and recorded. 73. It should be remembered that layers may move against the ventilating current even when the inclination of the roadway is slight. This is being recognised more and more as a phenomenon which is by no means a rare occurrence. The likelihood of layering depends on three factors, namely, the rate of emission of the firedamp, the cross-sectional area of the road and the velocity of the ventilating current. 74. The S.M.R.E. have carried out a great deal of research into layering and have published conclusions, which are, broadly, that the risk of layering can be determined mathematically by reference to the three factors mentioned above. They have also arrived at a formula which, utilising the statutory firedamp determination as the first factor, gives a figure which is an indication of the probability of layering taking place. This figure, termed the "layering index", has been described and discussed in the Establishment's Annual Report for 1963, and in an article entitled "Firedamp Roof Layers" by S. J. Leach and A. Slack* 75. The application of the formula is based on the presumption that, in any given situation, an indication of whether or not a risk of layering exists will hold good both inbye and outbye the measuring point. This is probably quite reasonable in the great majority of cases, but it could well be otherwise in a wholly unusual situation, such as developed in P. 26 District, where the return roadway emission was independent of the district "make" and as great as that of the rest of the district, while the ventilation velocity was at times sluggish in the extreme. A more realistic appraisal of the position could have been derived from a calculation of the layering index using a determination of firedamp content taken at the outbye end of the return roadway in accordance with my recommendation above. Firedamp Detection and Monitoring 76. In the course of submissions, reference was made to the shortcomings of the flame safety lamp in the detection of thin layers of firedamp; however, the National Coal Board has proposals for the introduction of lamps of the Garforth type or lamps modified to accept a probe. 77. It was also put to me that there was a need for instruments which would continuously monitor the firedamp situation in a district. I quite agree with this view for this explosion has shown that the time is now overdue for a reappraisal of the methods used in mines today to detect firedamp. I certainly do not envisage the use of instruments which have to be carried in and out of a district every shift. I have more in mind the kind of instrument to which I referred in my recent Annual Report, namely a methanometer designed to operate a suitable alarm system and to isolate automatically the electricity supply into a district. So far as I am aware there is nothing to prevent a further development of this so that a number of such instruments are installed at potentially vulnerable points in a ventilating district and then coupled together to provide continuous monitoring of the firedamp conditions there. 78. I am aware that, apart from the instrumentation of automated faces, research and development is proceeding in this matter; I most earnestly recommend that it be accorded a high degree of priority. The Testing of Flameproof Apparatus 79. The front cover plate of the gate-end switch involved in this explosion was secured by ten bolts. To ensure that a flameproof enclosure is in fact flameproof it is essential that all cover bolts are in position and properly tightened whenever the power is applied. Thus electricians wishing to gain access to the interior for any purpose are faced with the prospect every time of removing ten bolts and replacing them before applying power. When repeated adjustments have to be made, this procedure would have to be followed many times. 80. One can, therefore, understand, but not excuse, electricians who are tempted to avoid this tedious process by not always replacing bolts before applying power. But it is imperative that they recognise the danger and do not default in this respect. What can be done to give them practical assistance in this matter is to provide adequate means for testing the operation of the switchgear and suitable instruments for tracing external faults. There may well be an advantage also in the use of gate-end switches having covers which are secured or locked by single bolts and are thus much easier to remove and replace. 81. Many types of gate-end switches are designed with integral testing facilities which enable an electrician to determine whether a fault exists in the control circuits within the switch itself or whether the fault is external to the switch. An alternative device for this purpose is a test plug which simulates an external control circuit and so assists in checking the operation of a switch. In this instance the switch being tested was not equipped with integrated testing facilities but a test plug was available in the district. This, however, was over 400 yards away at the face end of the other gate and one must, I think, recognise that not only was distance a major consideration, but that the plug itself was awkward to carry. In the circumstances, the electricians probably adopted the expedient of using a rectifier, a procedure to be deprecated. 82. I consider that, as an immediate measure in places where firedamp is a hazard, existing gate-end switches or banks of such switches not having integral testing facilities should be provided with a test plug. The ultimate must, however, surely be the provision of testing facilities as an integral part of all gate-end switches and I recommend accordingly. Further, so that faults in control circuits external to the switchgear may be more readily traced, I recommend that test instruments designed for this purpose should be developed. * Published in Colliery Engineering, May, 1964.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||