The Shifts Before The Explosion
14th-17th May
23. The last coaling shift before that on which the explosion occurred was the afternoon of Friday, 14th May. The deputy in charge, B. Pyne, who was a substitute for the regular shift deputy, said that the shift was normal and that he did not detect firedamp in the course of his inspections. He recalled that sometime during the shift the access holes in the air bridge were open for the passage of materials, but he did not observe any adverse effect on the ventilation.
24. The next shift to which I need to refer is that of the night shift of 16th/17th May. The deputy, C. Evans, had in his charge a few men who were engaged in changing props on the face. He said that supplies were not brought into the district during the night shift and that the shift was normal in all respects.
The Morning Shift of 17th May
25. The day shift of 17th May went underground at the usual time and arrived in the district at about 7.30 a.m. H. Pope was the district overman and T. E. Davies was the deputy in charge. Apart from work on the face that morning, there was a considerable amount of other activity in the district. Two major operations were in progress, firstly, the transport and erection of a belt conveyor in the intake gate to replace one of the existing chain conveyors and, secondly, the extension of a rope haulage system m the return gate. As a consequence of these activities the number of men in the district was greatly in excess of the normal complement.
26. A. Richards and P. Best, two repairers, who spent the whole of the shift at or near the air bridge, were engaged in getting parts for the conveyor drive head up through the larger of the two access holes from the Maindy Heading Return for D. Bessant and E. L. T. Jones, fitters, who, with others, were erecting the conveyor. They removed the boards covering the larger opening at about 8.30 a.m., but shortly afterwards Overman Pope visited them and noted that, although the access hole was open, the materials to be passed through were not there. He gave instructions for the hole to be closed until the materials were on the spot, and the men replaced the boards while they went along the Maindy Heading Return to load machinery parts into trains. This probably took one-half to three-quarters of an hour, but it seems clear that, from the time the material reached the air bridge until the explosion, the larger access hole remained open. According to Richards, the other access hole, the smaller one equipped with a ladder, remained open throughout the shift and other witnesses confirmed this.
27. The day shift pit overman, G. Price, said that it was normal practice for the smaller of the two access holes to be open throughout the coaling shift and his understanding was that the other access hole would have been open for at least half of the shift that morning. The deputy, Davies, said that he found the larger access hole open and the two men engaged in raising machinery through it when he returned to the air bridge on the completion of his first inspection at 10.20 a.m. He said he was satisfied with the state of the ventilation throughout the whole of his shift. Other persons who passed by way of the air bridge during the morning had varying recollections about the openings, but they were generally consistent with those of the men primarily concerned.
28. The extension of the rope haulage in the return gate involved the transfer of a number of sheave wheels from one side of the gate to the other. R. C. Jones, sheavesman for the mine, who was supervising this work, was in the roadway for nearly three hours from 9.30 a.m. and thought the ventilation satisfactory. As he was coming out of the road at about 12.15 p.m., two electricians passed him going inbye.
29. Another item of work which had a bearing on the subsequent events was the completion of the door and stopping in the P. 11 connection. This, as I have already recounted, was effected at 11.15 a.m.
30. Although coaling commenced normally, it was interrupted at about 9.00 a.m. by the breaking of the plough chain, which seems to have coincided with a failure of the face telephone circuit. The chain was repaired by about 11.00 a.m. and coaling recommenced after food time, the telephone circuit in the meantime having been repaired by electricians. At some time, possibly just before 12 noon, a shot was fired in the return stable and the coal filled out.
31. According to Overman Price, who had spent over an hour supervising the repair of the plough chain, signalling trouble developed on the face at about 11.50 a.m. and ploughing was again interrupted. The fault on the signalling system either cleared itself or was rectified by someone unknown. There was some contradiction in the evidence about whether or not ploughing recommenced but, if it did, it could only have been for a few minutes because at about 12.15 p.m. an electrical fault developed at the return end plough motor. The overman telephoned K. Davies, the plough operator at the return end, who told him that the electricians were working on the switches in the return gate with one panel open but that the fault had not been located. Price then gave instructions for the plough to be brought down the face by the motor at the intake end; this was done but attempts to plough back up the face were unsuccessful.
32. When the electrical fault developed the deputy was on his way along the face towards the intake end, and at about 12.40 p.m., when some 40 yards from the intake gate, he encountered the Manager and the Under-Manager. They told him that Overman Price was attending to the electrical fault, but after a few minutes the Manager instructed the deputy to go and find out what was happening. Davies went to the telephone at the intake end of the face and spoke to the plough operator at the return end, who said he would go and make enquiries. While the deputy was waiting at the telephone, the explosion occurred.