VIII. — General Remarks.
1. Shot firing in proximity to breaks.
There is no explosive — "permitted" or otherwise — which sooner or later would not have ignited firedamp in such circumstances as those which existed at the Birley East Pit, and have existed in other pits where firedamp has been ignited by shotfiring. Apart from the possibility of ignition by the flame of the explosive — and there is no flameless explosive — it is quite possible for the firedamp-air mixture to be ignited by sudden compression alone; and it should be realised therefore that there is little hope that an explosive will be evolved which cannot in any circumstances ignite firedamp. From the evidence given at the inquiry it is quite plain that official reports in regard to explosions due to the firing of shots do not reach those persons whom it is very important they should reach. I therefore recommend that a short epitome of every official report made in connection with the ignition of firedamp by the firing of explosives should be issued by the Mines Department to colliery managers. These short reports should be illustrated by sketches when necessary and should be posted up by the managers in suitable places including the cabins and report boxes frequented and used by deputies and shot firers.
A review of the causes of ignitions of firedamp set up by shotfiring with "permitted" explosives shows that the large majority are in all probability due to a shot having been fired into a break or cavity containing gas. In some mines this risk is obviated by eliminating shotfiring altogether where such circumstances exist, and it is a risk which, in the present state of knowledge at any rate, cannot be altogether obviated in any other way.
But, while I recommend that shotfiring in the proximity of breaks should be avoided wherever practicable in mines where danger from inflammable gas exists, I am bound to face the fact that it is to some extent necessary if some of the mines are to be carried on at all. At such mines, since the risk of explosion cannot be eliminated, it should be reduced to a minimum by taking the most scrupulous precautions in all matters relating to shotfiring, and the number of persons exposed to risk should be reduced to a minimum by firing the shots at times when the only persons in the ventilating district are the shot firers themselves.
2. Deputy should fire all shots in his district.
I have already said that the shotfirer was new to the section, and was unaware of the fact that firedamp had been issuing for several consecutive days from the break in 93's gateroad. I do not think if he had been aware of this fact that it would have made any difference nor, in view of the statements of the three deputies that in similar circumstances in the future they would fire a shot, that the following suggestion would have altered the course of events in this instance, but I consider that in general all shots in the district allotted to a deputy should be fired by that deputy, he being the person who has the most intimate knowledge of the condition of his district.
3. Qualifications of shot firers and deputies.
I consider that before any person is appointed to fire shots in a mine to which Part II of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order applies, that person should have received instruction, not only in the mine from a person who is or has been a shotfirer, but also should have attended for at least six months a school where he would be taught simple facts in reference to mine gases, ventilation, explosives and coal dust. Similar instruction should be given to persons wishing to become deputies, and, as a natural corollary, the requirements of Section 15 (1) (b) should be amended to extend the character of the examination to be passed before a certificate may be issued enabling any person to act as a deputy or as a shotfirer under Part II of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order of 1st September, 1913.
In conclusion, I desire to acknowledge the assistance given to me by the representatives of the various parties present at the Inquiry.
I have the honour to be,
Sir,
Your obedient Servant,
H. Walker.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.