VII. — Remarks On The Accident.
There can be no doubt that the cause of the accident was an explosion of firedamp initiated by the firing of a charge of eight ounces of Samsonite No. 3, a permitted explosive, in proximity to fissures or breaks which contained firedamp.
There was no evidence that coal dust had played any part in the explosion.
It may be conceded that the shotfirer carried out all the statutory requirements prior to the firing of the shot, but in as much as (1) he did not make an examination for firedamp immediately before firing but relied on the result of the examination he made prior to beginning to charge the shot, and (2) did not remove the hurdle screen to ascertain if firedamp was in fact issuing from the break at the ripping lip, he did not show that sagacity which a man occupying such an important position as that a shotfirer should possess.
It is, however, only right to add, firstly, that the shotfirer had only been in the 320's level section from Monday (18th February), five days prior to the date of the accident, and was unaware of, and did not read the deputies' reports to ascertain, the fact that firedamp had been issuing from the break in 93's gateroad for several consecutive days; and, secondly, that whilst he agreed that, as the result of the presence of the hurdle sheet, any firedamp that was issuing from the break was being diluted and could not be detected, he contended that the necessity for the presence of the hurdle sheet had disappeared, and that this sheet was not required at the time the shot was fired. This contention confirms me in my opinion that he did not possess the acuteness which a shotfirer should possess, for it is not possible to say what the condition would have been had the hurdle sheet been removed.
It seems to me quite evident that the firing of shots in circumstances such as existed in this case is attended with grave risk. I take the view that, with the knowledge gained from the reports and with the known existence of breaks from which firedamp had been issuing, it was entirely wrong, irrespective altogether of the possibility of the existence of further concealed breaks, to allow a shot to be fired or to fire a shot; and I was astounded by the evidence of the shotfirer and the three deputies to the effect that, notwithstanding the occurrence of this accident in their own mine, they would under similar conditions again fire a shot, and by the evidence of the Manager (Mr. Michael MacDermott) to the effect that in his opinion they would be justified in doing so.
To understand this attitude of the Manager correctly it is necessary to quote from the evidence given by him at the Inquiry. Referring to Figure 2 on Plate 2, Mr. Lowenthal asked :—
1399. Q. Taking the section on the line AB, what are the two triangular lines shown in black between the end of the shot hole and the break? What are they intended to denote? . They are intended to denote a subsidiary break to the main break which was visible before the shot was fired.
1400. Q. Wait a moment; let me be clear. The main break is the break that the witnesses have said was 9 to 10 inches away from the end of the shot hole ? — A. Yes.
1401. Q. That is what you call the main break? — A. Yes.
1402. Q. We have heard that was the only break visible before the shot was fired ? — A. Yes.
1403. Q. The triangular lines on the end of the shot hole and communicating with that break are intended to denote another break ? — A. Yes.
1404. Q. Was that visible before the shot was fired? — A. I should say not.
1405. Q. It could not have been discovered at all? — A. I do not think so.
1406. Q. How did you ascertain, from your subsequent examination, that there was such a subsidiary break? How did you satisfy yourself there was such a subsidiary break? — A. The shot had removed part of the stone and made this break visible.
1407. Q. Was there a lump of stone on the ground? — A. The lump of stone was on the ground, yes.
1408. Q. And you were able to see from that stone that there had been a fissure there which was unaffected by the explosion of the cartridge ? — A. Yes.
1409. Q. And in your opinion how far would that subsidiary break be from the end of the shot hole ? — A. I should judge about two inches, probably.
1410. Q. If there was a subsidiary break two inches from the end of the shot hole, communicating with a break that is supposed to be 10 inches away, would that account, in your opinion, for this accident ? — A. Undoubtedly.
1411. Q. Supposing that break — what you call the main break — had been, as everybody supposed it to be, 10 inches away and no break connecting it or bringing it nearer to the shot hole, in your opinion would there have been any accident, even if there had been gas in the main break ? — A. None at all, in my opinion.
1412. Q. When these deputies and shot firers say they would have fired under similar circumstances to that accident, you think their opinion is right ? — A. Entirely.
1413. Q. Of course, not if they had known there was a subsidiary break connecting the main break with the shot hole. Two inches away is not a safe distance ? — A. I do not think so, no.
1414. Q. The explosion would blow the flame into that subsidiary break ? — A. It depends upon the nature of the substance.
1415. Q. It may have done? — A. It may have done.
Examined by Mr. Wynne.
1452. Q. You know, Mr. MacDermott, exactly, I think, to what extent these persons were injured ? — A. Yes.
1453. Q. They were, I think, badly burned, most of them ? — A. Yes, that is correct.
1454. Q. Which rather indicates that there was a big quantity of gas? — A. Quite.
1455. Q. Burning for an appreciable period? — A. Yes.
1456. Q. It is hardly possible for that gas to have been in the air current ? — A. No, I do not think it was.
1457. Q. Had it been there it would have been detected, you would think ? — A. I should think so.
1458. Q. Therefore we must conclude that it was in these breaks? — A. Probably, yes — in the breaks or the goafs.
1459. Q. In the breaks and cavities? — A. Yes.
1460. Q. Can you suggest any means by which we could become aware of such accumulations of gas ? — A. No, not in inaccessible places.
1461. Q. Of course, you see, as well as everybody else here, how important it is for us to be able to detect it if we possibly can ? — A. Oh, yes, unquestionably.
1462. Q. From what you know from your own investigations on the spot, from what you have seen and from what you have heard said, do you agree with the deputies who have said that they would fire a shot themselves in similar circumstances 2- — A. It must be borne in mind, Mr Wynne, that the deputies are speaking after the accident, and if there had been a socket 8 or 10 inches —
1463. Q. I want you, if you please, to speak in the same way as they did — not necessarily use the same words, but from the same point of view ? — A. Assuming there was 8 or 10 inches of socket at the back of that hole, they are perfectly justified in firing that shot.
1464. Q. You think so? — A. I do, undoubtedly.
Examined by Mr. Herbert Smith.
1544. Q. Did I understand you to say, Mr. MacDermott, that with the conditions as they were on the 23rd of February before this explosion, if similar conditions were existing to-morrow, you would say the deputies were justified in firing shots when they have told you they could not examine those cavities ? — A. If they did not know that that subsidiary break existed, certainly.
1545. Q. Although they could not examine those cavities? — A. Certainly.
1546. Q. So do I take it from you as a mine manager that you say, break or no break, if we cannot examine it we are going to risk it and fire a shot ? — A. Quite.
1547. Q. That is what you are going to say? — A. Certainly, yes.
1548. Q. I am very sorry, because we have not much to expect from you if that is your opinion. I put that seriously to you ? — A. I hold to my point, Mr. Smith. Anyway, it is a matter of opinion, you know.
1549. Q. I put it again to you; would you let your deputies fire a shot under similar conditions to what were reported by the night deputy and the fireman before he fired that shot; would you let them fire another to-morrow ? — A. Yes, certainly.
Re-examined by Mr. Lowenthal.
1573. Q. One other question. Assuming that there had been no subsidiary break, and 9 to 10 inches or anything like that of rock between the end of the shothole and this break, the first visible break; in your opinion would there have been any risk whatever in firing that shot ? — A. None at all.
1574. Q. And is that opinion of yours confirmed by the opinion of very well-known engineers? — A. Yes.
1575. Q. With more experience than yours ? — A. Quite.
The Manager produced in evidence figures to show that during the period he had been Manager of this mine, namely, from 1913 to 1923, 262,013 shots had been fired and 177,000 lbs. of explosives consumed without accident.
I do not share the satisfaction which he derived from these figures seeing that on the average for these years over the whole of the country 3,257,358 shots and 1,509,002 lbs. of permitted explosives were fired for every person killed by explosion of firedamp or coal dust caused by shotfiring.
It is right that I should say that since this accident an attempt has been made to reduce the number of shots fired whilst the workmen are at the face. During the month of May last in the 320's level section of the mine 121 shots were fired between 5 and 6.30 a.m. when the men were not in the working faces and 14 when they were.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.