8. Irregularities As Regards Statutory Reports On The Condition Of The Mine.
On the 26th April a spontaneous combustion report was made and signed by the Manager and Under-manager and also by J. E. Leader (the Deputy) that gob-stink was being emitted from the Low East return airway. But after that date until the 26th July no reports were made by the responsible official appointed to supervise the affected area. No. 9 (i) of the General Regulations of 30th July, 1920, requires such reports to be posted up at the pit-head at the end of each shift for the information of the workmen. No explanation why this requirement had not been observed was mentioned at the Inquiry.
On the 2nd May, after the ventilation had been re-arranged, a joint report was made by the Manager, a Deputy, and two workmen's representatives, in accordance with General Regulation 9 of 30th July, 1920, to the effect that all reasonable precautions for safety had been taken and in their opinion work could be resumed in 21's district, it having been made a separate ventilating district. Following this, coal-getting continued in the unaffected parts of the mine and gob fire operations went on throughout May and the following month. No further joint report appears to have been made or deemed to have been necessary.
Following the explosions which had occurred on the night of the 16th July, the manager reported in the Danger book — which, by the way, was not in the exact form prescribed by the Coal Mines Act, 1911 — that he had "at once cleared the whole pit until it had been investigated," meaning that he had withdrawn all the workers out of the mine.
The evidence showed that the reports by the Deputies required by Sections 64 and 65 of the Coal Mines Act were duly made, but it transpired that in some instances, when the same report had been signed by two Deputies, the Deputies had not together inspected the whole district. This was out of order and not in conformity with requirements. Each Deputy should have reported only upon that part of the workings assigned to him for inspection, and signed a separate report for that part only; and only when both Deputies had inspected the whole district together should the report have been a joint one.
On and after the 26th July, spontaneous combustion reports were made daily on the form prescribed under the General Regulations, but an examination of these reports showed that, while some of them described the state of the area at the end of the period covered by the report, others did not, but simply mentioned the kind of work that had been in progress. It may have been thought unnecessary to mention the state .of the area since Deputies were continuously in charge and reporting upon the state of the workings, or the omission may have been an oversight on the part of the Official making the report. In any case, if the reports are to be of use from a safety point of view the state of the workings should be reported upon on every occasion.